Created by OptimusSolo on Jun 29 2010
Special thanks to AMT, Music Meister, TylerMirage for additional sound clips.
EDITOR'S OPINIONI have to say the voices are so distinctly different in this compare that it is really hard to determine my favorite. Let me attempt to break it down.
I definitely do not like the Next Mutation version by Mendel or the Turtles 3 version by Murray. I will easily put those two at the bottom.
I also don't like Dunstan's take very much from the 2003 cartoon. I realize he was trying to sound deep and spiritual like Splinter should but you can tell that he is a younger voice actor in that making Splinter sound 'old' comes across as fake.
I was very surprised that I actually like the Video Game voice by Scammel and the 87 Turtles Forever voice by Wills. They both do a good job getting that deep tone that we love from Splinter. I like Scammel slightly more than Wills here though.
Of course Reneday is the classic voice I remember but I must say that he sounds the least 'sensei' like out of the top voices here.
At the top i have Mako from the CGI Movie and Kevin Clash from the first two live action movies.
In the end when I think of Splinter I hear Kevin Clash, so he is the winner for me: 1st: Clash, 2nd: Mako, 3rd: Reneday, 4th: Scammel, 5th: Wills, 6th: Dunstan, 7th: Murray, 8th: Mendel