Created by Foxwolf on Mar 28 2009
Special thanks to Jackson_H, Pokejedservo, CatsTuxedo, NCZ, TylerMirage, UltimateCharm, solidejake, Music Meister for additional sound clips.
Comments
Add a Comment
said at 9:18 AM on Fri Jun 22 2018
It was difficult choosing between either George Newbern or Tim Daly. Both have a similar vocal quality in my opinion, and they contrast well when paired alongside Kevin Conroy's Batman voice. Ultimately, I went with Newbern because he nailed heroic and hopeful in JL/JLU and then he nailed angry and tormented in Injustice 1 & 2. I still love Tim Daly's voice though, especially in the Batman/Superman films.
Replysaid at 11:24 AM on Mon May 21 2018
I think one thing that I really love about Tim Daly and George Newbern's renditions is how their voices are light. Sure, Superman with a deeper voice can work well (hence why I think Brian Bloom would be excellent in the part), but I love how their lighter voices contrast against Kevin Conroy's much deeper Batman voice.
Replysaid at 4:25 PM on Fri Apr 6 2018
This is going to sound pretty heretical, but does anyone else feel like George Newbern was a little... Off in Injustice 2?
Don't get me wrong, I love Newbern as Superman in everything else he's voiced him in, but he had some moments of weird delivery in Injustice 2. Maybe it has something to do with Supes' characterisation in the game, since I thought George was perfectly fine in the few lighter moments he had in the story mode.
Oh well, I still rank him right up there with Tim Daly, though my vote's sticking with the latter. I can't think of any other Superman VA's I love at the moment other than those two, but I definitely wouldn't mind seeing Travis Willingham or Matthew Mercer reprise the role for a more serious adaptation.
ReplyDon't get me wrong, I love Newbern as Superman in everything else he's voiced him in, but he had some moments of weird delivery in Injustice 2. Maybe it has something to do with Supes' characterisation in the game, since I thought George was perfectly fine in the few lighter moments he had in the story mode.
Oh well, I still rank him right up there with Tim Daly, though my vote's sticking with the latter. I can't think of any other Superman VA's I love at the moment other than those two, but I definitely wouldn't mind seeing Travis Willingham or Matthew Mercer reprise the role for a more serious adaptation.
said at 7:22 PM on Fri Apr 6 2018
@TheGreenSpeedster Sort of. I think Batman sounds way off in Injustice 2. Like he sounds quite flat in his delivery.
Replysaid at 4:02 PM on Mon May 21 2018
@TheGreenSpeedster
There were some moments that sounded a little off, I agree.
It was still a very good performance, just a little less polished. But when he nailed a line, he really nailed it.
ReplyThere were some moments that sounded a little off, I agree.
It was still a very good performance, just a little less polished. But when he nailed a line, he really nailed it.
said at 10:56 PM on Mon May 21 2018
@TheGreenSpeedster Yeah, but that's probably more of a voice direction problem.
Replysaid at 6:42 AM on Sun Apr 1 2018
1. Tim Daly
2. George Newbern
3. Bud Collyer
4. James Denton
5. Adam Baldwin
6. Nolan North
7. Matt Bomer
8. Jerry O'Connell
9. Jason J. Lewis
10. Mark Harmon
Reply2. George Newbern
3. Bud Collyer
4. James Denton
5. Adam Baldwin
6. Nolan North
7. Matt Bomer
8. Jerry O'Connell
9. Jason J. Lewis
10. Mark Harmon
said at 9:04 PM on Thu Mar 29 2018
If I had to rank them all:
1. George Newbern/Tim Daly (TIE)
2. Jason J. Lewis
3. Nolan North
4. Travis Willingham
5. David Kaye
6. Michael Daingerfield Hall
7. Beau Weaver
8. Danny Dark
9. Bud Collyer
10. Christopher MacDonald
11. Crispin Freeman
12. Roger Rose
13. Peter Jessop
14. Mark Harmon
15. Jerry O'Connell
16. Adam Baldwin
17. Mark Valley
18. Troy Baker
19. Matthew Mercer
20. Patrick Warburton
21. Yuri Lowenthal
22. Alan Tudyk
23. James Denton
24. Matt Bomer
25. Sam Daly
26. Keith Ferguson
27. David Lodge
28. Kyle MacLachlan
29. Christopher Corey Smith
30. Joseph May
31. Marc Silk
32. Channing Tatum
33. Brandon Routh
34. Jeff Kramer
35. Armin Shimmerman
Reply1. George Newbern/Tim Daly (TIE)
2. Jason J. Lewis
3. Nolan North
4. Travis Willingham
5. David Kaye
6. Michael Daingerfield Hall
7. Beau Weaver
8. Danny Dark
9. Bud Collyer
10. Christopher MacDonald
11. Crispin Freeman
12. Roger Rose
13. Peter Jessop
14. Mark Harmon
15. Jerry O'Connell
16. Adam Baldwin
17. Mark Valley
18. Troy Baker
19. Matthew Mercer
20. Patrick Warburton
21. Yuri Lowenthal
22. Alan Tudyk
23. James Denton
24. Matt Bomer
25. Sam Daly
26. Keith Ferguson
27. David Lodge
28. Kyle MacLachlan
29. Christopher Corey Smith
30. Joseph May
31. Marc Silk
32. Channing Tatum
33. Brandon Routh
34. Jeff Kramer
35. Armin Shimmerman
said at 11:05 AM on Sun Mar 25 2018
It's an obvious casting choice, but Brian Bloom needs to voice Superman someday. Roger Craig Smith would also work.
Replysaid at 10:08 AM on Wed Mar 21 2018
1. Newbern
2. Tim Daly
3. Sam Daly
4. North (YJ > Lego stuff)
5. Baldwin
Reply2. Tim Daly
3. Sam Daly
4. North (YJ > Lego stuff)
5. Baldwin
said at 1:57 PM on Mon Oct 16 2017
I don't know if this is common knowledge to everyone but there's something interesting that I want to bring up regarding Nolan North as Lego Superman. In a interview regarding the LEGO DC movie with Bizarro, he said his Superman voice in that movie is based off of The Super Friends era of Superman.
Replysaid at 3:03 PM on Mon Oct 16 2017
@Shaun Ince Yeah, I actually do get a Danny Dark vibe out of Nolan's performance in that movie.
Replysaid at 3:23 PM on Mon Oct 16 2017
@Starscreamsfan Yeah. He did say that he grew up with that show back when he was a kid, so he wanted to do something similar to what Danny Dark did.
Now that I think about it, those Lego DC Movies are very reminiscent of the Super Friends era of DC cartoons. Which does explain why I like it so much.
ReplyNow that I think about it, those Lego DC Movies are very reminiscent of the Super Friends era of DC cartoons. Which does explain why I like it so much.
said at 3:35 PM on Mon Oct 16 2017
@Shaun Ince I agree. The tone is pretty similar to the SuperFriends cartoons that came out before the Super Powers line.
Replysaid at 9:28 PM on Mon Aug 21 2017
1) Tim Daly
2)George Newborn (he and Daly are both excellent and are probably about the same objectively, but I watched STAS a lot more than JL when I was a kid so I prefer Daly)
3)Nolan North
4)Adam Baldwin
The others aren't super impressive IMO
Reply2)George Newborn (he and Daly are both excellent and are probably about the same objectively, but I watched STAS a lot more than JL when I was a kid so I prefer Daly)
3)Nolan North
4)Adam Baldwin
The others aren't super impressive IMO
said at 2:32 PM on Wed May 31 2017
1. George Newbern
2. Tim Daly
3. James Denton
4. Travis Willingham
5. Nolan North
6. Jason J. Lewis
7. Mark Harmon
8. Adam Baldwin
9. David Kaye
10. Crispin Freeman
11. Michael Daingerfield
Reply2. Tim Daly
3. James Denton
4. Travis Willingham
5. Nolan North
6. Jason J. Lewis
7. Mark Harmon
8. Adam Baldwin
9. David Kaye
10. Crispin Freeman
11. Michael Daingerfield
said at 11:23 PM on Sat May 20 2017
Travis could be perfect if he got to voice him in something non-Lego, his Brotherhood Roy Mustang voice would work well in the role.
I mean, Troy's gotten his shot at a darker Batman and he was amazing there. Why not give Travis a similar opportunity?
ReplyI mean, Troy's gotten his shot at a darker Batman and he was amazing there. Why not give Travis a similar opportunity?
said at 12:15 PM on Fri Jul 28 2017
@GreenGoblin75 I agree. I also feel Nolan North works much better as Lego Superman than Travis Willingham does. He also got to voice a more serious Superman in Young Justice but he wasn't in it a whole lot. If there is a Telltale Superman game, hopefully Travis gets another opportunity to reprise.
Replysaid at 3:27 PM on Sun Apr 30 2017
Wonder why they kept recasting LEGO Superman, they kept Troy's Bruce outside the theatrical movies so I'm not sure why they didn't keep Travis? I mean Nolan already did YJ Supes, & LEGO tries to differentiate most of the characters from their more mainstream versions.
On another related note, I'm not sure why they recast so much of the Justice League for the New 52 OVAs, when they bring back so many of the Teen Titans from Young Justice. It's weird.
ReplyOn another related note, I'm not sure why they recast so much of the Justice League for the New 52 OVAs, when they bring back so many of the Teen Titans from Young Justice. It's weird.
said at 3:39 PM on Sun Apr 30 2017
@huzaifa_ahmed The Lego DC animated movies are directed by Brandon Vietti. That's why he picked Nolan North to voice Superman in that section of Lego material. Because of Young Justice. The Lego games aren't directed by Vietti so they bring Travis Willingham instead.
As for why they keep recasting for New 52, some voice directors want new people while at the same time doing cross casting from other series. It's inconsistent, but as far as voice compare's go, it's another addition to the VC's themselves when they get someone new to voice these characters.
ReplyAs for why they keep recasting for New 52, some voice directors want new people while at the same time doing cross casting from other series. It's inconsistent, but as far as voice compare's go, it's another addition to the VC's themselves when they get someone new to voice these characters.
said at 7:10 PM on Sun Apr 30 2017
@Shaun Ince I know as much, I suppose; still I figure casting a story's something that should be handled prior to the story moving forward; you dont want randomly different voices halfway through a story. As for Nolan's reasoning, that makes sense but I feel they'd've brought make more of em in general; I dont see many YJ reprisals in LEGO; in fact, YJ *avoids* the 03 Titans whereas LEGO embraces them.
Replysaid at 1:37 PM on Sun Mar 12 2017
The great thing about George Newbern's Superman is that he's able to play so many different versions.
In most appearances, he gets to play the traditional personification of truth, justice, and the American way, portraying a superhero of such great character phenomenally.
Which makes his performance in Injustice and Injustice 2 all the more frightening. There, he gets to play the Superman who is a fallen hero. A man with unlimited powers manipulated into killing his own family, who then becomes so traumatized that he turns into the exact monster he used to fight. Terrifying.
And then my favorite performance of his. Admittedly, for the longest time I only remembered Newbern's evil Superman and had trouble imagining him as a traditional version.
But then I watched the episode of JLU called For The Man Who Has Everything. George Newbern was absolutely fantastic in that episode. Amazing work. Due to tampering by Mongul, Superman is trapped in his vision of a perfect world: A simple life with a wife and son on a farm. He slowly realizes that it isn't real, and has to tear himself away from everything he's ever wanted: https://youtube.com/watch?v=qTcIgyNAwmw
George Newbern has, in my mind, easily become the best voice of Superman and the voice I imagine when reading the comics. In fact, I think George even surpasses most, if not all, of the live-action actors.
In my mind, George IS the Man of Steel.
ReplyIn most appearances, he gets to play the traditional personification of truth, justice, and the American way, portraying a superhero of such great character phenomenally.
Which makes his performance in Injustice and Injustice 2 all the more frightening. There, he gets to play the Superman who is a fallen hero. A man with unlimited powers manipulated into killing his own family, who then becomes so traumatized that he turns into the exact monster he used to fight. Terrifying.
And then my favorite performance of his. Admittedly, for the longest time I only remembered Newbern's evil Superman and had trouble imagining him as a traditional version.
But then I watched the episode of JLU called For The Man Who Has Everything. George Newbern was absolutely fantastic in that episode. Amazing work. Due to tampering by Mongul, Superman is trapped in his vision of a perfect world: A simple life with a wife and son on a farm. He slowly realizes that it isn't real, and has to tear himself away from everything he's ever wanted: https://youtube.com/watch?v=qTcIgyNAwmw
George Newbern has, in my mind, easily become the best voice of Superman and the voice I imagine when reading the comics. In fact, I think George even surpasses most, if not all, of the live-action actors.
In my mind, George IS the Man of Steel.
said at 1:42 PM on Sun Mar 12 2017
@GreenGoblin75
The video clip I referred to starts at 1:02 of the link, my apologies.
ReplyThe video clip I referred to starts at 1:02 of the link, my apologies.
said at 1:55 PM on Sun Mar 12 2017
@GreenGoblin75 What do You Think Of James Denton's Portrayal of Superman?
Replysaid at 2:01 PM on Sun Mar 12 2017
@EPA Deane
He did a fantastic job judging off the clip. I still need to see the movie to fully judge, but I thought he was pretty underrated.
ReplyHe did a fantastic job judging off the clip. I still need to see the movie to fully judge, but I thought he was pretty underrated.
said at 6:00 PM on Sat Mar 18 2017
@GreenGoblin75 Couldnt agreee with you more and to think he was only brought in to subsititute Daly and now he outperforms the guy as the years go by Newburn improves with age with performances in elite and Injustice showcasing how great he is gotten.
The words he uses as Superman are great and some goods morals also wether good superman or evil superman he just convinces you that his way is the right way
ReplyThe words he uses as Superman are great and some goods morals also wether good superman or evil superman he just convinces you that his way is the right way
said at 4:23 AM on Fri Mar 10 2017
Newbern is my fave with Daly as a close second.
Replysaid at 10:16 PM on Sun Feb 5 2017
George newbern has been able to play several versions of the character seamlessly, that's what makes him stand out above all the others for me. What started as a weak Tim Daly impression has gradually improved and is the definite voice of Superman for me.
Replysaid at 12:54 AM on Wed Jan 18 2017
What many people like about Lewis- him sounding a lot like Daly & Newbern- is actually my biggest turn off about him. If you're going to bring back Conroy, and have Lewis do an impression of those two, why not just bring one of those two on instead? As is, he doesn't really bring anything new to the role, and every time he and Conroy speak, I get this strange dissonance where it feels like it should be Newbern, especially because Lewis lacks Newbern's experienced sound while Conroy sounds as much of a veteran as ever. I'd have much preferred them either bringing back all three DCAU actors (Daly/Newbern,Conroy, and Eisenberg)i or three new actors doing something new than this strange in between of WW being a pretty new take, Superman trying to be the two most acclaimed ones, and Conroy being the same Bats as ever.
Replysaid at 9:10 AM on Wed Jan 18 2017
@Bookman230 - If I had to make a guess, maybe Daly and Newbern were either too busy with other projects or they just didn't want to come back.
Replysaid at 1:51 PM on Wed Jan 18 2017
@HyperVoiceActing Possibly, though Newbern returning for Injustice 2 makes me doubt that. Even if they didn't want to return, I would've preferred Lewis or some other VA doing a new take with a new Batman.
Replysaid at 4:08 PM on Wed Jan 18 2017
@Bookman230 - Newbern working on Injustice 2 doesn't disprove that he wasn't too busy to work on Action.
Also, I don't really see what's so horrible about having newcomers working alongside reprisals.
ReplyAlso, I don't really see what's so horrible about having newcomers working alongside reprisals.
said at 10:17 PM on Wed Jan 18 2017
@HyperVoiceActing Nothing inheretly, but when Lewis is clearly strongly emulating Newbern and Daly right alongside the Batman VA who worked along them the most, it just makes me wish one of them was there instead. Lewis doesn't feel like his own Superman take, he feels like Newbern/Daly-lite,and being paired with Conroy only highlights that, for me. I didn't mind, say, Newbern and Rino Romano in The Batman, because Romano's Batman was a clearly different take that resulted in a different feel to their dynamic. Lewis and Conroy feel like echoes of past stuff, and so I just can't hear it as it's own thing. But that's just me.
Replysaid at 9:52 AM on Thu Jan 19 2017
@Bookman230 Actually the answer to your question is pretty simple. Depending on the voice director they either want to try something new instead of relying on reprisals for the show. Some of them don't want what other cast members did years ago, som of them want something new. It's the whole reason why all these characters especially DC characters have over 20 voices on their voice compare page. It'd be like asking why Mark Hildreth was brought back for Wolverine & The X Men & have him not reprise Angel from the previous X-Men show he worked on.
Finally the reason why voice actors like Nolan North & Steve Blum reprise Wolverine & Deadpool so often is, despite the different voice directors on some projects, they like what they hear based off of past work in other roles. For example, Jamie Simone who worked on Wolverine & The X-Men picked Nolan North for Deadpool in the Hulk vs Wolverine movie because he liked what he did previously. Which is why that casting choice has sticked through various incarnations.
My comment is a bit long winded but you get what I'm saying.
ReplyFinally the reason why voice actors like Nolan North & Steve Blum reprise Wolverine & Deadpool so often is, despite the different voice directors on some projects, they like what they hear based off of past work in other roles. For example, Jamie Simone who worked on Wolverine & The X-Men picked Nolan North for Deadpool in the Hulk vs Wolverine movie because he liked what he did previously. Which is why that casting choice has sticked through various incarnations.
My comment is a bit long winded but you get what I'm saying.
said at 4:38 PM on Sun Jan 29 2017
@Shaun Ince Right, but my problem is that Lewis _doesn't_ do anything new. He doesn't do anything that Newbern and Daly didn't already do. He's an impression, basically, and for a show that's already trying to get noticed as it's own thing separate from the previous JL cartoons, I think having him impersonate them and getting Conroy back was a mistake, because it just echoes those previous shows. But that's just my view.
Replysaid at 5:54 PM on Sun Jan 29 2017
@Bookman230 Maybe Jason J Lewis wasn't given a whole lot of creative choice? And he just decided to play it safe and try and channel the two most iconic Superman voices into his portrayal. Also considering Superman has 36 entries on this page, it gets harder to find a more unique take.
Replysaid at 11:53 PM on Sun Jan 29 2017
@Shaun Ince Hey, I don't hate the guy or anything. It's true, maybe he didn't have a lot of creative choice or tried to play it safe. And maybe Blum's darkseid would be a lot better without the effects, but that's still not one of my favorite Darkseid takes. We rarely know all that goes into a voice, all we can do is judge the voice we have.
You have a good point with the difficulty of finding an unique take, but my view is I can at least respect a take that tries something new even if it's lacking. An impression is usually middling unless at some point, it finds unique notes for itself, like Baker's Joker (even if it's still not quite on the level of Hamill, I found that his subtle touch of aimlessness pre-Bats and manic purpose after meeting him helps differentiate him). Or heck, Newbern himself, who started off as a Daly voice match but evolved into his own. Maybe all Lewis needs is time himself. For now, though, he's still a middle of the road Supes for me. Not at all bad, but nothing outstanding.
ReplyYou have a good point with the difficulty of finding an unique take, but my view is I can at least respect a take that tries something new even if it's lacking. An impression is usually middling unless at some point, it finds unique notes for itself, like Baker's Joker (even if it's still not quite on the level of Hamill, I found that his subtle touch of aimlessness pre-Bats and manic purpose after meeting him helps differentiate him). Or heck, Newbern himself, who started off as a Daly voice match but evolved into his own. Maybe all Lewis needs is time himself. For now, though, he's still a middle of the road Supes for me. Not at all bad, but nothing outstanding.
said at 7:27 AM on Tue Jan 31 2017
@Bookman230 Don't worry about it. You never gave off the impression that you hated the guy. You're also right. If someone does an impression of a former actor but doesn't evolve it to where he makes it his own, it remains as an impression & nothing more. Looney Tunes voices for example fall into this category, but you have rare circumstances where the VA imitating them not only makes the role their own, but also does it better than the original did(e.g Bob Bergen as Porky Pig, Joe Alaskey as Marvin the Martian, Jim Cummings as Tazamanian Devil)
Replysaid at 6:42 PM on Mon Jan 16 2017
Jason I'd actually put as my second favorite, with Tim and George tied for first. It's also scary how spot on Jason's impression of them is
Replysaid at 6:07 PM on Mon Jan 16 2017
I'm still surprised on how much Jason sounds like Tim Daly and George Newbern. He's proving to be pretty good at impressions.
Although part of me wanted his Superman to be an Eddie Murphy impression for no real good reason.
ReplyAlthough part of me wanted his Superman to be an Eddie Murphy impression for no real good reason.
said at 6:42 PM on Mon Jan 16 2017
@Music Meister - I don't get the Eddie Murphy thing, but otherwise I totally agree
Replysaid at 6:52 PM on Mon Jan 16 2017
@HyperVoiceActing
Well mostly a reference that his first role on the site was his impression of Eddie Murphy as Donkey. It was just me making a dumb joke.
ReplyWell mostly a reference that his first role on the site was his impression of Eddie Murphy as Donkey. It was just me making a dumb joke.
said at 9:50 AM on Tue Jan 17 2017
@Music Meister I was actually waiting for someone to make that Eddie Murphy reference on this compare when Jason was added.
Replysaid at 1:41 PM on Mon Jan 16 2017
Alright; Up, up, and away we go!
Tim Daly and George Newbern - They are both tied for the best voice of Superman; not only do they sound-alike but they both convey the tone, emotion, spirit, and charisma of what Superman stands for. And I think they both play the role best with the character of Clark Kent, I mean let's face it Superman is just what Superman can do, it's Clark Kent that makes Superman the hero. (or at least that's how I see it)
Mark Hammon - Not bad, but he does sound a little too off the edge sometimes. He's got the right speaking voice for the character, but he still sounds kind of aggressive with what he's given.
Michael Daingerfield - Michael does a good impression of Tim and George to some extent, if they ever make a Vancouver based Superman project, I'd love to hear him reprise.
David Kaye - Another good choice for Superman that I actually really liked. I don't know why though, but maybe it's that Optimus Prime voice from Transformers Animated that really works to it's advantage.
James Denton - All-Star Superman has to be one of my favorite Superman stories, if only because of how wonderfully it interperpates what makes Superman such a good hero, and James definitely conveys the more soft spoken, open minded, clarifying morality of Superman's character. ^^
Alan Tudyk - While not the worst Superman, and even having a decent speaking voice for the character, I'm afraid Alan's performance just didn't sit well for me; if only because of how naive and callous the character was made to be.
Jerry O'Connell - Definitely better than Alan's performance, not only in terms of acting out the tone for the hero but also in terms of conveying the character of Clark Kent, subtle and clear.
Roger Rose - Definitely works for a Golden/Silver Age interpretation of the character, and the way he portrays Superman under the influence of Red Kryptonite is actually a delight to watch.
Peter Jessop - While he may sound a little authoritarian, Peter still did good with Superman, since he still acts out the character's collective tone and decency.
Nolan North - Somewhat similar to David Kaye, if not a little bit lighter; basically just a more mature sounding Superboy voice. I guess it makes sense since the latter is a clone of the character... I don't know, but for what it is, Nolan did alright.
Troy Baker - Troy is a good choice for Superman (or just about any superhero) but I don't know, the way he acts sounds a bit forced or even over the top; the character sounds kind'a pompous even more so than Alan Tudyk's. I don't know if it's the direction or indeed the actor himself, but if Troy did something similar in tone to Nolan North, I think he'd make some improvement.
Crispen Freeman - It's good... not great, but still good; certainly has it's charm and charisma, that much I'll give.
Travis Willingham - Works for a more comedic take on the character, just like with Hulk, but I'd like to hear him voice a more subtle interpretation of Superman to.
Matthew Mercer - This is what Troy Baker's Superman should have been, not too forced or pompous with the tone and speech for the character. It's not exactly right up with some other choices, but it's still decent.
Matt Bomer - Matt was alright with what he's given, mind you I thought the character did have moments where he was kind of a jerk and maybe a bit too brusk, but I still thought it was okay.
Sam Daly - I honestly had no idea at first, that Tim Daly had a son, and they got him to follow in his footsteps; and low and behold he actually did a pretty dang good job! Talk about a legacy role!
Yuri Lowenthal - For a younger sounding Superman, Yuri was okay with what he's given. Nothing great, but it's passable.
Mark Valley - While maybe a bit too low, I still think Mark did good with Superman, properly emulating the character's tone when he's still trying to be reasonable and decent even if the character portrayed is still a tool for the government. Despite whatever rift there is between Supes and Batman, the two are still friends and even if Superman is on the wrong side, his attitude still justify's his position (to an extent) and Mark's performance certainly more than made up for it.
Keith Ferguson - Once again, another unexpected casting that actually work's to it's advantage, in both conveying the character's tone and playing a little to the comedic side with the slapstick. A subtle balance to be certain, and all the same I'd definitely wanna hear him play Supes again.
Jason J. Lewis - Jason definitely conveys the charm, decency, and spirit of both Tim Daly and George Newbern, while still having a little fun with the performance. Not much to say, but I will admit, Jason does a legitimately good job as Superman.
ReplyTim Daly and George Newbern - They are both tied for the best voice of Superman; not only do they sound-alike but they both convey the tone, emotion, spirit, and charisma of what Superman stands for. And I think they both play the role best with the character of Clark Kent, I mean let's face it Superman is just what Superman can do, it's Clark Kent that makes Superman the hero. (or at least that's how I see it)
Mark Hammon - Not bad, but he does sound a little too off the edge sometimes. He's got the right speaking voice for the character, but he still sounds kind of aggressive with what he's given.
Michael Daingerfield - Michael does a good impression of Tim and George to some extent, if they ever make a Vancouver based Superman project, I'd love to hear him reprise.
David Kaye - Another good choice for Superman that I actually really liked. I don't know why though, but maybe it's that Optimus Prime voice from Transformers Animated that really works to it's advantage.
James Denton - All-Star Superman has to be one of my favorite Superman stories, if only because of how wonderfully it interperpates what makes Superman such a good hero, and James definitely conveys the more soft spoken, open minded, clarifying morality of Superman's character. ^^
Alan Tudyk - While not the worst Superman, and even having a decent speaking voice for the character, I'm afraid Alan's performance just didn't sit well for me; if only because of how naive and callous the character was made to be.
Jerry O'Connell - Definitely better than Alan's performance, not only in terms of acting out the tone for the hero but also in terms of conveying the character of Clark Kent, subtle and clear.
Roger Rose - Definitely works for a Golden/Silver Age interpretation of the character, and the way he portrays Superman under the influence of Red Kryptonite is actually a delight to watch.
Peter Jessop - While he may sound a little authoritarian, Peter still did good with Superman, since he still acts out the character's collective tone and decency.
Nolan North - Somewhat similar to David Kaye, if not a little bit lighter; basically just a more mature sounding Superboy voice. I guess it makes sense since the latter is a clone of the character... I don't know, but for what it is, Nolan did alright.
Troy Baker - Troy is a good choice for Superman (or just about any superhero) but I don't know, the way he acts sounds a bit forced or even over the top; the character sounds kind'a pompous even more so than Alan Tudyk's. I don't know if it's the direction or indeed the actor himself, but if Troy did something similar in tone to Nolan North, I think he'd make some improvement.
Crispen Freeman - It's good... not great, but still good; certainly has it's charm and charisma, that much I'll give.
Travis Willingham - Works for a more comedic take on the character, just like with Hulk, but I'd like to hear him voice a more subtle interpretation of Superman to.
Matthew Mercer - This is what Troy Baker's Superman should have been, not too forced or pompous with the tone and speech for the character. It's not exactly right up with some other choices, but it's still decent.
Matt Bomer - Matt was alright with what he's given, mind you I thought the character did have moments where he was kind of a jerk and maybe a bit too brusk, but I still thought it was okay.
Sam Daly - I honestly had no idea at first, that Tim Daly had a son, and they got him to follow in his footsteps; and low and behold he actually did a pretty dang good job! Talk about a legacy role!
Yuri Lowenthal - For a younger sounding Superman, Yuri was okay with what he's given. Nothing great, but it's passable.
Mark Valley - While maybe a bit too low, I still think Mark did good with Superman, properly emulating the character's tone when he's still trying to be reasonable and decent even if the character portrayed is still a tool for the government. Despite whatever rift there is between Supes and Batman, the two are still friends and even if Superman is on the wrong side, his attitude still justify's his position (to an extent) and Mark's performance certainly more than made up for it.
Keith Ferguson - Once again, another unexpected casting that actually work's to it's advantage, in both conveying the character's tone and playing a little to the comedic side with the slapstick. A subtle balance to be certain, and all the same I'd definitely wanna hear him play Supes again.
Jason J. Lewis - Jason definitely conveys the charm, decency, and spirit of both Tim Daly and George Newbern, while still having a little fun with the performance. Not much to say, but I will admit, Jason does a legitimately good job as Superman.
said at 1:42 PM on Mon Jan 16 2017
@Troodon2
BONUS: I can see Brian Bloom, Robin Atkin Downes, or even Fred Tatasciore making a Superman, sure Fred may be a tad deep or gruff for the tone of the character, and probably better suited for Batman, but given his range he'd make for a good Superman too, though there's always Neil Kaplan for someone similar but a little lighter.
I think some more good candidates would be Liam O'Brien, Imari Williams, Michael Gough, Michael Dobson, Roger Craig Smith, and even Maurice LaMarche using his Charlie Burns voice from Transformers Rescue Bots.
And I don't know why though, but I actually think Dwayne Johnson make a good Superman to. ^^;
ReplyBONUS: I can see Brian Bloom, Robin Atkin Downes, or even Fred Tatasciore making a Superman, sure Fred may be a tad deep or gruff for the tone of the character, and probably better suited for Batman, but given his range he'd make for a good Superman too, though there's always Neil Kaplan for someone similar but a little lighter.
I think some more good candidates would be Liam O'Brien, Imari Williams, Michael Gough, Michael Dobson, Roger Craig Smith, and even Maurice LaMarche using his Charlie Burns voice from Transformers Rescue Bots.
And I don't know why though, but I actually think Dwayne Johnson make a good Superman to. ^^;
said at 10:56 AM on Wed Feb 1 2017
@Troodon2 I think Neil Kaplan would be much more suited for Lex Luthor tbh.
Replysaid at 9:47 AM on Mon Jan 16 2017
Jason J. Lewis sounds like a combination of George Newbern & Tim Daly. Pretty good.
Replysaid at 9:30 AM on Mon Jan 16 2017
Sticking with Tim Daly, but Jason J. Lewis was also good.
Replysaid at 3:16 PM on Mon Jan 2 2017
For This Voice Comparison I'm going to do
Two Separate Top Five Lists for Superman Voices:
Gold-Bronze Age Inspired Superman:
5. Michael Dangerfield
4. Danny Dark
3. Kyle MacLachlan
2. Bud Colleyer
1. Roger Rose
Post 'Crisis on Infinite Earths' Superman:
5. Matt Bomer
4. Adam Baldwin
3. George Newbern
2. James Denton
1. Tim Daly
Tim Daly Earns My Vote.
Future Voice Actor Suggestions:
Vic Mignogna is my main suggestion since feel he would be a great fit for either a comedic or Dramatic Superman..... That and I think Caitlin Glass would be great as Lois Lane....hint hint...
I would Really like to hear Lee Pace voicing Superman, as his voice has a Soothing resonance that would suit the Man of Steel quite nicely.
I can also recommend Joseph Gordon Levitt, James Arnold Taylor, Bruno Campos, Sean Schemmel and Eric Stuart.
ReplyTwo Separate Top Five Lists for Superman Voices:
Gold-Bronze Age Inspired Superman:
5. Michael Dangerfield
4. Danny Dark
3. Kyle MacLachlan
2. Bud Colleyer
1. Roger Rose
Post 'Crisis on Infinite Earths' Superman:
5. Matt Bomer
4. Adam Baldwin
3. George Newbern
2. James Denton
1. Tim Daly
Tim Daly Earns My Vote.
Future Voice Actor Suggestions:
Vic Mignogna is my main suggestion since feel he would be a great fit for either a comedic or Dramatic Superman..... That and I think Caitlin Glass would be great as Lois Lane....hint hint...
I would Really like to hear Lee Pace voicing Superman, as his voice has a Soothing resonance that would suit the Man of Steel quite nicely.
I can also recommend Joseph Gordon Levitt, James Arnold Taylor, Bruno Campos, Sean Schemmel and Eric Stuart.
said at 1:58 AM on Tue Apr 3 2018
@EPA Deane Sean Schemmel as Superman, eh? I see what you did there.
Replysaid at 9:34 AM on Mon Jan 2 2017
VC thoughts update
I personally think Bud Collyer's performance as Superman still holds up to this day. Bud just brought charisma, presence and power to Superman, yet he also nailed Clark Kent as well. In the radio show, Clark was a timid yet strong and authoritative character, who wasn't afraid to take reasonable risks. Bud also differentiated his Clark Kent voice from his Superman voice quite well, making Superman's voice lower and stronger and Clark's voice lighter and meeker. It's a trick that I really miss nowadays. I was born in the 90's, but for me, Superman will always be either Bud Collyer in voice performances and George Reeves in live action.
Danny Dark also delivers a great performance. It could be extremely corny at first (especially in the first two SuperFriends shows), but it gets better later on (especially in the Super Powers tie-in cartoons). A take filled with charm and you can tell Danny is having fun with the role.
Beau Weaver would be tied with Dark if it weren't for the fact that his Clark Kent was too much of a total bungler. I've always liked a stronger Clark, so it is kinda unfortunate. However, Beau makes up for it with a very strong and authoritative Superman.
I've heard a little bit of Jason J. Lewis' take, and it really is nice. He sounds warm and confident, and is what I really think the DCAU Superman should have been.
Out of the DCAU ones (I never was a fan of the DCAU interpretation of the character), I like Christopher McDonald the most. He just has a nice delivery and he does sound pretty authoritative. However, the material he was given was a little bit meh, but I really think he could do a more standard take.
I also enjoyed George Newbern, Michael Daingerfield, Brandon Routh, Yuri Lowenthal, Crispin Freeman, Adam Baldwin, Roger Rose, Joseph May, Christopher Smith, David Lodge, Nolan North, David Kaye, Travis Willingham, Mark Valley, Channing Tatum, Peter Jessop, Troy Baker, Jerry O'Connell, Matthew Mercer and Keith Ferguson in the role.
Tim Daly, Jeff Kramer, Kyle MacLachlan, Mark Harmon, James Denton, Marc Silk, Matt Bomer, Sam Daly, Alan Tudyk, Patrick Warburton and Armin Shimerman just don't leave an impact on me.
Honorable mentions: Michael Fitzmaurice (Superman radio show), Stuart Milligan (BBC DC radio dramas)
ReplyI personally think Bud Collyer's performance as Superman still holds up to this day. Bud just brought charisma, presence and power to Superman, yet he also nailed Clark Kent as well. In the radio show, Clark was a timid yet strong and authoritative character, who wasn't afraid to take reasonable risks. Bud also differentiated his Clark Kent voice from his Superman voice quite well, making Superman's voice lower and stronger and Clark's voice lighter and meeker. It's a trick that I really miss nowadays. I was born in the 90's, but for me, Superman will always be either Bud Collyer in voice performances and George Reeves in live action.
Danny Dark also delivers a great performance. It could be extremely corny at first (especially in the first two SuperFriends shows), but it gets better later on (especially in the Super Powers tie-in cartoons). A take filled with charm and you can tell Danny is having fun with the role.
Beau Weaver would be tied with Dark if it weren't for the fact that his Clark Kent was too much of a total bungler. I've always liked a stronger Clark, so it is kinda unfortunate. However, Beau makes up for it with a very strong and authoritative Superman.
I've heard a little bit of Jason J. Lewis' take, and it really is nice. He sounds warm and confident, and is what I really think the DCAU Superman should have been.
Out of the DCAU ones (I never was a fan of the DCAU interpretation of the character), I like Christopher McDonald the most. He just has a nice delivery and he does sound pretty authoritative. However, the material he was given was a little bit meh, but I really think he could do a more standard take.
I also enjoyed George Newbern, Michael Daingerfield, Brandon Routh, Yuri Lowenthal, Crispin Freeman, Adam Baldwin, Roger Rose, Joseph May, Christopher Smith, David Lodge, Nolan North, David Kaye, Travis Willingham, Mark Valley, Channing Tatum, Peter Jessop, Troy Baker, Jerry O'Connell, Matthew Mercer and Keith Ferguson in the role.
Tim Daly, Jeff Kramer, Kyle MacLachlan, Mark Harmon, James Denton, Marc Silk, Matt Bomer, Sam Daly, Alan Tudyk, Patrick Warburton and Armin Shimerman just don't leave an impact on me.
Honorable mentions: Michael Fitzmaurice (Superman radio show), Stuart Milligan (BBC DC radio dramas)
said at 10:33 AM on Mon Jan 2 2017
And I forgot Sam Parker in the last four Famous Studios Superman shorts. Just as Daly, Kramer, MacLachlan, Harmon, Denton, Silk, Bomer, Daly, Tudyk, Warburton and Shimerman, he just doesn't leave a big impression on me. His acting is a little bit wooden too.
Replysaid at 2:02 PM on Mon Jan 2 2017
@Starscreamsfan Why did you dislike the DCAU version of Superman?
Replysaid at 4:06 PM on Mon Jan 2 2017
@EPA Deane It just didn't sit right with me. It lacked the charisma and presence that my favorite versions of Superman had and it was kinda boring.
Plus, the DCAU cartoon relied too much on Superman to tell it's story, whereas I always preferred stories like in the radio show and the 1950's live-action show in which Clark Kent has to help others with their troubles and only becomes Superman when he has to. The Kent identity is criminally underused nowadays, which is sad, 'cause in the right hands, Kent can be his own character separate from Superman without any problem.
ReplyPlus, the DCAU cartoon relied too much on Superman to tell it's story, whereas I always preferred stories like in the radio show and the 1950's live-action show in which Clark Kent has to help others with their troubles and only becomes Superman when he has to. The Kent identity is criminally underused nowadays, which is sad, 'cause in the right hands, Kent can be his own character separate from Superman without any problem.
said at 5:14 AM on Wed Mar 1 2017
Recently rewatched the Seinfeld/Superman American Express commercials and I must say that Patrick Warburton is a much better Superman than most of the modern actors (though Jason J. Lewis and Christopher McDonald are still better than him IMO). He doesn't quite make it to my top 5, but he's really that close. I think he should reprise the role someday.
Replysaid at 10:44 AM on Wed Mar 1 2017
@GreenGoblin75 Because some of the others kinda lack sense of humor or play the part too seriously. IMO Superman should be warm, charismatic, authoritative and friendly at the same time, and I honestly feel that the modern versions don't really manage to display all of these traits, whereas the radio show and the 50's TV show gives us a Superman that is more down-to-earth, relatable as well as funny.
Replysaid at 5:52 PM on Fri Dec 9 2016
Tim Daly gets my vote always gonna love his take on the Man of Steel and if there ever a Superman video game they should bring him back along with some of the original cast of Superman TAS
Also like Nolan north, George newborn, and Adam Baldwin
ReplyAlso like Nolan north, George newborn, and Adam Baldwin
said at 8:03 PM on Fri Oct 28 2016
Starting from the top right and going down the list, my opinions would be:
- Matthew Mercer's actually pretty good as Superman: I'd like to hear more from him in the role, but he doesn't leave much of a lasting impression with his performance.
- Patrick Warburton is way too goofy and hard to take seriously as Superman, enough said: definitely a miscast.
- Bud Collyer was a pretty solid fit for the character, but came off as a little flat at times.
- Armin Shimerman sounds way too old in the role.
- Keith Ferguson's take is a bit too bland and generic here.
- Danny Dark is also pretty good, emoting well to boot, though his screams got a bit forced at times.
- Beau Weaver is in a similar boat to Danny Dark, only a bit more flat, but his screams are also much stronger.
- For the most part, Tim Daly was excellent, really bringing out Superman's character with his performance, if a bit limited in expressing emotion at times.
- Christopher McDonald worked well enough for the elderly Superman, but his delivery got a bit too flat at times.
- Jeff Kramer is okay, if a bit bland at times.
- George Newbern is also excellent, even managing to emote a little better than Tim Daly, so I'm probably going with him.
- Michael Daingerfield is actually pretty good, if a bit different from the others.
- Brandon Routh's voice is fitting, but his delivery is very flat and poor at times.
- Yuri Lowenthal sounds like a more positive Sasuke from Naruto as Superman: the voice is a bit awkward to listen to on Superman, but his acting's really natural, if nothing else.
- Crispin Freeman is pretty generic in this role.
- Adam Baldwin's a bit too deep and flat.
- Roger Rose is OK, if a bit bland and generic.
- Joseph May is good, if a bit rough at times.
- Kyle MacLachan is pretty solid, but a little dull.
- Christopher Corey Smith sounds a bit too old in the part & his delivery seems a bit forced.
- David Lodge sounds a lot like Jiraiya from Naruto with a Russian accent as Superman, so I can't say I entirely agree with the voice he went with, but I do think he brings a certain depth and presence to the role, so I'm OK with it.
- Nolan North is pretty good, though I feel he sounds fairly generic and bland at times.
- Mark Harmon's voice is a bit rough, but his acting's very good.
- I can barely hear David Kaye in that clip, but he seems pretty decent, if a little dull.
- James Denton is really, really great, bringing a lot of presence and warmth to the part: I really like his take.
- Mark Silk is incredibly generic and sounds too smug for Superman.
- Travis Willingham is funny, but is very hard to take seriously as the character.
- Mark Valley is a bit too low pitched and slightly gruff, but his acting's good.
- Matt Bomer's good, but a bit generic.
- Sam Daly's OK, but a bit low pitched.
- Channing Tatum's too loud and shout-y in the role.
- Peter Jessop's pretty good, but is a bit flat.
- Alan Tudyk sounds a bit too aggressive and ruthless.
- Troy Baker is a bit too smug and flat in the part for me.
- Jerry O'Connell is OK, but a bit too low and gruff at times.
Overall, My Top 5 would be:
1. George Newbern
2. Tim Daly
3. James Denton
4. Nolan North
5. Beau Weaver
Reply- Matthew Mercer's actually pretty good as Superman: I'd like to hear more from him in the role, but he doesn't leave much of a lasting impression with his performance.
- Patrick Warburton is way too goofy and hard to take seriously as Superman, enough said: definitely a miscast.
- Bud Collyer was a pretty solid fit for the character, but came off as a little flat at times.
- Armin Shimerman sounds way too old in the role.
- Keith Ferguson's take is a bit too bland and generic here.
- Danny Dark is also pretty good, emoting well to boot, though his screams got a bit forced at times.
- Beau Weaver is in a similar boat to Danny Dark, only a bit more flat, but his screams are also much stronger.
- For the most part, Tim Daly was excellent, really bringing out Superman's character with his performance, if a bit limited in expressing emotion at times.
- Christopher McDonald worked well enough for the elderly Superman, but his delivery got a bit too flat at times.
- Jeff Kramer is okay, if a bit bland at times.
- George Newbern is also excellent, even managing to emote a little better than Tim Daly, so I'm probably going with him.
- Michael Daingerfield is actually pretty good, if a bit different from the others.
- Brandon Routh's voice is fitting, but his delivery is very flat and poor at times.
- Yuri Lowenthal sounds like a more positive Sasuke from Naruto as Superman: the voice is a bit awkward to listen to on Superman, but his acting's really natural, if nothing else.
- Crispin Freeman is pretty generic in this role.
- Adam Baldwin's a bit too deep and flat.
- Roger Rose is OK, if a bit bland and generic.
- Joseph May is good, if a bit rough at times.
- Kyle MacLachan is pretty solid, but a little dull.
- Christopher Corey Smith sounds a bit too old in the part & his delivery seems a bit forced.
- David Lodge sounds a lot like Jiraiya from Naruto with a Russian accent as Superman, so I can't say I entirely agree with the voice he went with, but I do think he brings a certain depth and presence to the role, so I'm OK with it.
- Nolan North is pretty good, though I feel he sounds fairly generic and bland at times.
- Mark Harmon's voice is a bit rough, but his acting's very good.
- I can barely hear David Kaye in that clip, but he seems pretty decent, if a little dull.
- James Denton is really, really great, bringing a lot of presence and warmth to the part: I really like his take.
- Mark Silk is incredibly generic and sounds too smug for Superman.
- Travis Willingham is funny, but is very hard to take seriously as the character.
- Mark Valley is a bit too low pitched and slightly gruff, but his acting's good.
- Matt Bomer's good, but a bit generic.
- Sam Daly's OK, but a bit low pitched.
- Channing Tatum's too loud and shout-y in the role.
- Peter Jessop's pretty good, but is a bit flat.
- Alan Tudyk sounds a bit too aggressive and ruthless.
- Troy Baker is a bit too smug and flat in the part for me.
- Jerry O'Connell is OK, but a bit too low and gruff at times.
Overall, My Top 5 would be:
1. George Newbern
2. Tim Daly
3. James Denton
4. Nolan North
5. Beau Weaver
said at 5:45 PM on Thu Oct 6 2016
Don't kill me, but (only going off clips here) I don't think The Lego Movie did a great job with casting this character. Channing Tatum ironically would be much better in live-action; here, he doesn't seem to do even the parody/lighthearted Superman justice.
I know that animated features are cast as showcases for celebrities, but I really think that Tatum's performance doesn't do respect for Willingham's, or the character in general. Will Arnett was a hilariously good Lego Batman.
Ton of these that others have already covered, so aside from George & Tim being faves, I'll add what hasnt been said.
Michael Daingerfield Hall's take is interesting - he plays him softer than his voice double David Kaye, kinda sounds like Crispin actually.
Both are good.
Interestingly, Nolan North wasn't originally going to play Supes in YJ - Crispin was. I prefer him as Red Arrow, but I did like his Superman & I'd like to hear more of it. Nolan kinda sounds a little old for this character tbh.
David Lodge, Chris Smith, Troy Baker, & Matthew Mercer are all natural fits that simply weren't given proper direction (Lodge is playing Jiraiya, Troy is reading a script) &/or were doing a low-budget production.
I like Matt's chibi Superman, but he has potential to do a more serious version as well (as does Travis, incidentally).
Other VA's I want to play this guy? Robin Atkin Downes, Jamieson Price, JAT, Scott Porter, DC Douglas, David Matranga, Cam Clarke, the Dobson Bros.
ReplyI know that animated features are cast as showcases for celebrities, but I really think that Tatum's performance doesn't do respect for Willingham's, or the character in general. Will Arnett was a hilariously good Lego Batman.
Ton of these that others have already covered, so aside from George & Tim being faves, I'll add what hasnt been said.
Michael Daingerfield Hall's take is interesting - he plays him softer than his voice double David Kaye, kinda sounds like Crispin actually.
Both are good.
Interestingly, Nolan North wasn't originally going to play Supes in YJ - Crispin was. I prefer him as Red Arrow, but I did like his Superman & I'd like to hear more of it. Nolan kinda sounds a little old for this character tbh.
David Lodge, Chris Smith, Troy Baker, & Matthew Mercer are all natural fits that simply weren't given proper direction (Lodge is playing Jiraiya, Troy is reading a script) &/or were doing a low-budget production.
I like Matt's chibi Superman, but he has potential to do a more serious version as well (as does Travis, incidentally).
Other VA's I want to play this guy? Robin Atkin Downes, Jamieson Price, JAT, Scott Porter, DC Douglas, David Matranga, Cam Clarke, the Dobson Bros.
said at 8:52 PM on Thu Oct 6 2016
@huzaifa_ahmed Evidently enough, DC Douglas technically did voice Superman in a Family Guy/American Dad episode.
Replysaid at 11:47 PM on Fri Oct 7 2016
@Troodon2 I also kinda think Ian Sinclair & Patrick Seitz would make great Supermen. Especially after hearing Travis's take.
Replysaid at 10:29 AM on Fri Oct 28 2016
@huzaifa_ahmed Now I can only hear Superman shouting "ZA WARUDO!", Engrish. and lots of hammy lines.
Replysaid at 9:51 AM on Mon Jan 16 2017
@huzaifa_ahmed Most of the casting in the Lego movie as the DC characters was dissapointing.
Batman was an exception to this rule.
Nolan North sounds much better in the Lego DC movies. At least to me anyway.
ReplyBatman was an exception to this rule.
Nolan North sounds much better in the Lego DC movies. At least to me anyway.
said at 2:26 PM on Mon Jan 16 2017
@Shaun Ince Haven't seen them. Did they have Nolan do Channing Tatum, ala the new Lego Batman stuff?
Replysaid at 7:06 AM on Tue Jan 17 2017
@huzaifa_ahmed In the case of Superman, not really. He does sound more chipper & energetic, which I believe that was missing from his Young Justice performance. But the writing of Superman in the show was also to blame as well. He didn't show up a whole lot so he didn't have a whole lot of time to improve it in the show.
Replysaid at 5:55 PM on Tue Jul 26 2016
Now that I think about it perhaps I was a little too harsh on Jerry O'Connell as Superman. In the Justice League vs Teen Titans movie he does sound better. It's just that his take in the Throne of Atlantis movie doesn't sit right with me.
Replysaid at 5:41 PM on Sun Apr 10 2016
Patrick Warburton could literally play any character and I'd be totally fine with it.
Replysaid at 1:03 PM on Sat Apr 2 2016
1. George Newbern
2. Tim Daly
3. Mark Harmon
4. Matt Bomer
5. Peter Jessop
Reply2. Tim Daly
3. Mark Harmon
4. Matt Bomer
5. Peter Jessop
said at 3:48 AM on Sun Jan 31 2016
George Newbern: primarly because of his work in Superman vs The Elite. When Superman finally gave us the speech about what made an hero, about what he stand for... that is exactly why George is the best Superman.
Replysaid at 7:43 AM on Mon Jan 25 2016
Yeah, I've officially been won over by George Newbern, he really nailed it after seeing more Justice League episodes. He plays off Kevin Conroy as Batman very nicely, actually, they had a fun dynamic going there.
I still like Tim Daly though, he did a very good job, but George has a bit more emotion and range in his take.
No one else is bad, but I just don't care much for them. Well, I laughed hearing Patrick Warburton using his Joe Swanson voice from Family Guy, though I don't think it fits very well.
ReplyI still like Tim Daly though, he did a very good job, but George has a bit more emotion and range in his take.
No one else is bad, but I just don't care much for them. Well, I laughed hearing Patrick Warburton using his Joe Swanson voice from Family Guy, though I don't think it fits very well.
said at 10:55 PM on Sat Jan 30 2016
@Dr.Who "Well, I laughed hearing Patrick Warburton using his Joe Swanson voice from Family Guy, though I don't think it fits very well."
Patrick Warburton really sounds like that, he doesn't normally do a different voice in his voice acting roles.
ReplyPatrick Warburton really sounds like that, he doesn't normally do a different voice in his voice acting roles.
said at 7:20 AM on Sun Jan 31 2016
@Jacob M. Keene
Yes, but his delivery is very goofy and silly here compared to how he voices other characters he does like Buzz Lightyear, for example.
ReplyYes, but his delivery is very goofy and silly here compared to how he voices other characters he does like Buzz Lightyear, for example.
said at 12:38 PM on Sun Jan 31 2016
@Dr.Who I don't think delivery of lines on a character is equal to doing the same voice for the other character, but that's just me.
Replysaid at 7:16 AM on Fri Jan 1 2016
I'm finally going to start commenting on voice compares so I might as well will start with Superman.
Superman is a iconic character that sadly a lot of folks nowadays think is a boring over powered mary-sue that I can't relate with...which I think is balderdash. I do think that a lot of writers don't know how to utilize him but when they do, I think Superman is a excellent classic hero and in this day and age that is something we definitely need. anyways on to the voice compare.
My personal favourite voice here is George Newbern, he did well at voice matching Tim Daly for the Justice League cartoons but I think its his performance in Superman vs. The Elite that really won me over as him as The Man of Steel. He's strong, dutiful, capable of compassion and mercy, sounds like he came from a "Smallville USA", pulls off all the personas well and can even be terrifying for his more darker depiction.
I also like Tim Daly but I think George honestly surpassed his take with ease. I don't think he's bad but I just prefer Newbern is all.
I think the other stand outs here are Travis Willingham, David Kaye, Michael Daingerfield Hall, Peter Jessop, Beau Weaver, Danny Dark, Nolan North, Mark Harmon and Jerry O'Connell.
I also give some credit also to Bud Collyer for being the first ever voice of Superman from the old radio shows and original shorts.
The rest aren't bad but they just don't hold my attention is all.
Overall my vote goes to George Newbern.
BONUS: Throwing in my two cents on people that I would love to see voice Superman in the future. I think both Ian Sinclair and Marc Diraison would make excellent voices for Superman/Kal-El/Clark Kent.
ReplySuperman is a iconic character that sadly a lot of folks nowadays think is a boring over powered mary-sue that I can't relate with...which I think is balderdash. I do think that a lot of writers don't know how to utilize him but when they do, I think Superman is a excellent classic hero and in this day and age that is something we definitely need. anyways on to the voice compare.
My personal favourite voice here is George Newbern, he did well at voice matching Tim Daly for the Justice League cartoons but I think its his performance in Superman vs. The Elite that really won me over as him as The Man of Steel. He's strong, dutiful, capable of compassion and mercy, sounds like he came from a "Smallville USA", pulls off all the personas well and can even be terrifying for his more darker depiction.
I also like Tim Daly but I think George honestly surpassed his take with ease. I don't think he's bad but I just prefer Newbern is all.
I think the other stand outs here are Travis Willingham, David Kaye, Michael Daingerfield Hall, Peter Jessop, Beau Weaver, Danny Dark, Nolan North, Mark Harmon and Jerry O'Connell.
I also give some credit also to Bud Collyer for being the first ever voice of Superman from the old radio shows and original shorts.
The rest aren't bad but they just don't hold my attention is all.
Overall my vote goes to George Newbern.
BONUS: Throwing in my two cents on people that I would love to see voice Superman in the future. I think both Ian Sinclair and Marc Diraison would make excellent voices for Superman/Kal-El/Clark Kent.
said at 12:38 PM on Fri Nov 20 2015
For a lighthearted portrayal, Peter Jessop and Matthew Mercer. for serious portrayals, Jerry O'Connell and Mark Harmon.
Replysaid at 12:06 PM on Sat Oct 24 2015
It's a really tough choice to make for me between Tim Daly and George Newbern, but Daly had something about his take that stuck with me.
Replysaid at 10:51 PM on Mon Sep 21 2015
Matt Mercer sounds really good as Superman. I hope he gets more chances to be him
Replysaid at 8:30 PM on Tue Sep 8 2015
You know hearinnthek side by side, you can really hear how similar Matthew, Crispin and Troy are.
Replysaid at 11:24 PM on Mon Sep 7 2015
Sticking with Tim Daly was Matthew Mercer was also good. Channing Tatum was okay.
Replysaid at 7:41 PM on Mon Sep 7 2015
Jerry is okay, needs to be a little smoother.
I can actually hear some potential with Channing but as is he's pretty funny.
Matthew is pretty good if a bit young sounding
ReplyI can actually hear some potential with Channing but as is he's pretty funny.
Matthew is pretty good if a bit young sounding
said at 5:29 PM on Fri Sep 30 2016
@Music Meister "Matthew is pretty good if a bit young sounding"
Keep in mind DC Super Friends is the "chibi" edition of DC, the way that Super Squad was for Marvel.
ReplyKeep in mind DC Super Friends is the "chibi" edition of DC, the way that Super Squad was for Marvel.
said at 6:14 PM on Mon Sep 7 2015
Bud Collyer was the one with whom I'm most familiar with thanks to the Superman radio show, though I also enjoyed Michael Fitzmaurice's take. Danny Dark and Beau Weaver were also good. Stuart Milligan was also pretty good as BBC Radio's Superman. Most of the other guys do well, but my favorite out of all the modern voices is, oddly enough, Christopher McDonald!!! Though I also enjoyed Channing Tatum, Troy Baker (raises shield to protect from an angry mob), Travis Willingham and George Newbern.
1) Bud Collyer
2) Michael Fitzmaurice (Superman radio show)
3) Danny Dark
4) Beau Weaver
5) Stuart Milligan (BBC DC radio dramas)
6) Christopher McDonald
7) Channing Tatum
8) Troy Baker
9) Travis Willingham
10) George Newbern
11) Christopher Smith
12) Mark Valley
13) Nolan North
14) Crispin Freeman
15) Patrick Warburton
16) Roger Rose
17) Keith Ferguson
18) Kyle MacLachlan
19) Tim Daly
20) Mark Harmon
21) James Denton
22) Michael Daingerfield
23) Yuri Lowenthal
24) Adam Baldwin
25) Joseph May
26) David Lodge
27) David Kaye
28) Peter Jessop
29) Jerry O'Connell
30) Matthew Mercer
31) Brandon Routh
32) Jeff Kramer
33) Marc Silk
34) Matt Bomer
35) Sam Daly
36) Alan Tudyk
37) Sam Parker (last four Famous Studios Superman cartoons)
38) Armin Shimerman
Reply1) Bud Collyer
2) Michael Fitzmaurice (Superman radio show)
3) Danny Dark
4) Beau Weaver
5) Stuart Milligan (BBC DC radio dramas)
6) Christopher McDonald
7) Channing Tatum
8) Troy Baker
9) Travis Willingham
10) George Newbern
11) Christopher Smith
12) Mark Valley
13) Nolan North
14) Crispin Freeman
15) Patrick Warburton
16) Roger Rose
17) Keith Ferguson
18) Kyle MacLachlan
19) Tim Daly
20) Mark Harmon
21) James Denton
22) Michael Daingerfield
23) Yuri Lowenthal
24) Adam Baldwin
25) Joseph May
26) David Lodge
27) David Kaye
28) Peter Jessop
29) Jerry O'Connell
30) Matthew Mercer
31) Brandon Routh
32) Jeff Kramer
33) Marc Silk
34) Matt Bomer
35) Sam Daly
36) Alan Tudyk
37) Sam Parker (last four Famous Studios Superman cartoons)
38) Armin Shimerman
said at 5:33 PM on Mon Sep 7 2015
Matthew Mercer is expectedly similar to Troy Baker's take in Infinite Crisis. Anyone find this anything other than coincidental?
Replysaid at 5:36 PM on Mon Sep 7 2015
@Troodon2 Considering he voiced Tim Drake in Arkham Knight which was formerly voiced by Baker in the previous movie it's anything but coincidental.
Replysaid at 6:32 PM on Mon Sep 7 2015
@Troodon2 I mean Mercer's voice sounds similar to Troy's in some retrospect. It's probably why they had him voice Kanji in Persona for that reason.
Replysaid at 5:33 PM on Fri Sep 30 2016
@Troodon2 Matt playing Supes here is a definite hearkening to Troy. Considering that Troy also played Two-Face & Matt does that character in Super Friends as well.
Matt often sounds like a warmer, friendlier version of Troy so it makes sense that he'd sub for him in Super Friends.
Beyond that, Troy cut off working with dubbing studios around this time, & Michael Sinterniklaas directed Super Friends...So they weren't exactly on friendly terms...
All in all, I do think this was a "Matt subs for Troy" situation as is often the case.
ReplyMatt often sounds like a warmer, friendlier version of Troy so it makes sense that he'd sub for him in Super Friends.
Beyond that, Troy cut off working with dubbing studios around this time, & Michael Sinterniklaas directed Super Friends...So they weren't exactly on friendly terms...
All in all, I do think this was a "Matt subs for Troy" situation as is often the case.
said at 10:06 PM on Fri Sep 4 2015
I honestly can't decide between Tim and George. Leaning toward Tim, who sounds a TAD more heroic and mature. George is a very close second though. Because there's so many others, I'll just say that my other favorites are Adam Baldwin, Chris Smith, Danny Dark, Nolan North, Roger Rose, Travis Willingham, and Bud Collyer is classic. They captured the heroic aspects of the characters of the best, while still sounding well-rounded to me. Some of the others sounded either boring or too young/old. Honestly, most of these sounded the same. There's really no reason for Superman to have so many voices!
Replysaid at 8:05 PM on Fri Sep 4 2015
I had no clue Shooter Mcgavin did a Superman character lol
Replysaid at 5:40 PM on Mon Aug 31 2015
I think that both Tim Daly and George Newbern sound a lot a like
Replysaid at 6:10 AM on Sat Aug 29 2015
Jerry O'Connell is good, though it also helps that Superman in ToA was more in-line with what Superman should be that War, but that isn't Tudyk's fault.
Sorry to sound fickle again, but I'm changing my vote back to Tim Daly. I'm really sorry if I'm getting on people's nerves with this.
ReplySorry to sound fickle again, but I'm changing my vote back to Tim Daly. I'm really sorry if I'm getting on people's nerves with this.
said at 9:13 AM on Tue Nov 3 2015
@Anicomicgeek Come on, opinions change all the time. and so do yours, there's nothing for me to be personally angry about.
Replysaid at 11:36 PM on Wed Nov 4 2015
@Netherman14
Yeah, but I also admit I'm pretty self-conscious.
ReplyYeah, but I also admit I'm pretty self-conscious.
said at 6:29 PM on Fri Aug 28 2015
Jerry sounds sweat at times, as Superman should sound, similar to George Newbern to stand with.
Replysaid at 1:56 PM on Fri Aug 28 2015
Jerry O'Connell sounds a bit too rapsy.
Replysaid at 9:23 PM on Fri Aug 28 2015
@Shaun Ince Do you mind explaining how? because I hear none of the aforementioned rasp.
Replysaid at 6:51 AM on Sat Aug 29 2015
@Netherman14 Maybe that's the wrong word to describe it. Brooding sounds more appropriate. Also there's nothing about that voice that really stands out either. Going off the sound clip at least.
Replysaid at 6:37 PM on Mon Aug 31 2015
@Shaun Ince
It does lack a certain smooth-ness that Supes is known for.
ReplyIt does lack a certain smooth-ness that Supes is known for.
said at 6:50 AM on Thu Aug 27 2015
Troy sounds like he'd make a better Captain America.
Replysaid at 2:20 PM on Wed Aug 26 2015
I think Nolan sounds better as the Lego version of Superman rather than the regular Superman. Granted, his performance in Young Justice isn't bad, but it's a tad bit on the bland side. However, Alan Tudyk & Troy Baker are really bland & generic.
Replysaid at 2:30 PM on Wed Aug 26 2015
@Shaun Ince
I agree that Nolan is fantastic Superman in the Lego movies but I think he's bland in Young Justice because of the script and/or direction.
ReplyI agree that Nolan is fantastic Superman in the Lego movies but I think he's bland in Young Justice because of the script and/or direction.
said at 2:43 PM on Wed Aug 26 2015
@Music Meister Yeah. Probably the voice direction.
Replysaid at 7:01 AM on Sun Feb 22 2015
George Newbern is my favorite, both for nostalgic reasons (the DCAU Justice League show was my introduction to the character) and because he perfectly captures the gentle authority that defines Superman. If you want to see what's probably his best performance as the character, go watch 2012's Superman vs. The Elite, which is based on the classic comic storyline "What's So Funny About Truth, Justice, and the American Way?".
Tim Daly is nearly as good, though he's got a bit more of an edge to his voice that I don't like quite as much. Still very close second, as George Newbern was originally selected for the Justice League show because his voice sounded very similar to Daly's.
Adam Baldwin is a good choice for a somewhat older, somewhat darker Superman, which is fitting for a film based off of a storyline titled "The Death of Superman". I wouldn't want him all the time, but he does a perfectly good job.
Kyle MacLachlan does a very good job as well. As "Hollywood" voices for Superman go, he's one of the best, and his high, energetic voice helps contrast him with New Frontier's incredibly gritty and noir-sounding Batman, Jeremy Sisto.
Nolan North has a decent voice for the character, although he's obviously more known for Superboy on Young Justice than the rarely seen Superman. His main probably is his recognizability, because we've all heard his Nathan Drake voice a thousand times, and his Superman voice is barely any different.
Mark Harmon has it even worse in that respect, because while Nolan North has a voice that's recognizable for the huge amount of characters he's played, these days Harmon is instantly recognizable for a single character on a single, live-action show: Gibbs on NCIS. Crisis on Two Earths is barely watchable for me, not because it's a bad film, but because all I can hear is Gibbs in a Superman outfit. It's impossible to hear anything else.
I actually really liked James Denton in All-Star Superman. Would I have preferred Newbern or Daly to lend their voice to the adaptation of arguably the greatest Superman story ever written? Undoubtedly. But Denton did a perfectly respectable job of conveying the emotion of the piece, and his voice didn't seem unfitting at all.
Mark Valley did a fine job contrasting with the booming voice of Peter Weller in Dark Knight Returns. I'd welcome another film with him in the role.
Sam Daly sounds like his dad. Not a bad choice, not anything super amazing. He didn't have much meaningful dialogue in the film anyway, so it's hard to judge.
Haven't watched Unbound yet, so I'll reserve judgement on Matt Bomer.
Alan Tudyk wasn't BAD, really, but I definitely think a better choice could have been made. I get that they didn't want to use any of the DCAU cast, but still, I wasn't enthralled by his performance. Maybe it's just because Superman's kind of an ass in Justice League: War.
Point obviously goes to George Newbern, in my opinion, the true voice of Superman, and the only actor other than Christopher Reeve that I'd place on the pedestal of being the true Man of Tomorrow.
ReplyTim Daly is nearly as good, though he's got a bit more of an edge to his voice that I don't like quite as much. Still very close second, as George Newbern was originally selected for the Justice League show because his voice sounded very similar to Daly's.
Adam Baldwin is a good choice for a somewhat older, somewhat darker Superman, which is fitting for a film based off of a storyline titled "The Death of Superman". I wouldn't want him all the time, but he does a perfectly good job.
Kyle MacLachlan does a very good job as well. As "Hollywood" voices for Superman go, he's one of the best, and his high, energetic voice helps contrast him with New Frontier's incredibly gritty and noir-sounding Batman, Jeremy Sisto.
Nolan North has a decent voice for the character, although he's obviously more known for Superboy on Young Justice than the rarely seen Superman. His main probably is his recognizability, because we've all heard his Nathan Drake voice a thousand times, and his Superman voice is barely any different.
Mark Harmon has it even worse in that respect, because while Nolan North has a voice that's recognizable for the huge amount of characters he's played, these days Harmon is instantly recognizable for a single character on a single, live-action show: Gibbs on NCIS. Crisis on Two Earths is barely watchable for me, not because it's a bad film, but because all I can hear is Gibbs in a Superman outfit. It's impossible to hear anything else.
I actually really liked James Denton in All-Star Superman. Would I have preferred Newbern or Daly to lend their voice to the adaptation of arguably the greatest Superman story ever written? Undoubtedly. But Denton did a perfectly respectable job of conveying the emotion of the piece, and his voice didn't seem unfitting at all.
Mark Valley did a fine job contrasting with the booming voice of Peter Weller in Dark Knight Returns. I'd welcome another film with him in the role.
Sam Daly sounds like his dad. Not a bad choice, not anything super amazing. He didn't have much meaningful dialogue in the film anyway, so it's hard to judge.
Haven't watched Unbound yet, so I'll reserve judgement on Matt Bomer.
Alan Tudyk wasn't BAD, really, but I definitely think a better choice could have been made. I get that they didn't want to use any of the DCAU cast, but still, I wasn't enthralled by his performance. Maybe it's just because Superman's kind of an ass in Justice League: War.
Point obviously goes to George Newbern, in my opinion, the true voice of Superman, and the only actor other than Christopher Reeve that I'd place on the pedestal of being the true Man of Tomorrow.
said at 6:58 PM on Wed Feb 18 2015
I just want to point out that in Troy Baker's sample, the line "Let's make them fear the survivors of the Atom" is not Superman. It's actually Nolan North as Atomic Green Lantern. Which is a shame, because it's the most emotional line out of all of them.
Yeah, I really like Superman in Infinite Crisis, but now that I'm comparing his voice side-by-side with people like George Newbern, it sounds like Troy just really wanted to play it safe and not try to be creative with the voice.
However, there are a few lines in the game that sound great and show Troy had the potential to do more. Because it's Superman, he tends to remain calm, even while fighting, but every now and then, his voice will raise and it's got a great impact.
On the other hand, it may just because Superman's playstyle makes him a big deal whenever he steps it up, and that's usually the points when his voice gets bigger, so maybe that's kind of tricking me into thinking the voice has more going for it.
Anyway, my vote stays with George.
ReplyYeah, I really like Superman in Infinite Crisis, but now that I'm comparing his voice side-by-side with people like George Newbern, it sounds like Troy just really wanted to play it safe and not try to be creative with the voice.
However, there are a few lines in the game that sound great and show Troy had the potential to do more. Because it's Superman, he tends to remain calm, even while fighting, but every now and then, his voice will raise and it's got a great impact.
On the other hand, it may just because Superman's playstyle makes him a big deal whenever he steps it up, and that's usually the points when his voice gets bigger, so maybe that's kind of tricking me into thinking the voice has more going for it.
Anyway, my vote stays with George.
said at 9:29 AM on Tue Feb 10 2015
Tim Daly and George Newbern aside as the obvious top two, I really like Mark Harmon's take on Superman.
He sounds like an older, wiser and wearier kind of Superman who has been at his job for a while. And the accent makes it sound like he actually grew up on a farm in Kansas, which is something no one else adds to the character.
ReplyHe sounds like an older, wiser and wearier kind of Superman who has been at his job for a while. And the accent makes it sound like he actually grew up on a farm in Kansas, which is something no one else adds to the character.
said at 7:28 PM on Wed Feb 4 2015
On that note of Troy Baker, yeesh his voice is ridiculously generic here, his Ryu Hayabusa, Espio the Charmelion and Hanzo Hattori are not super original either but here he doesn't even sounds like he's trying
Replysaid at 7:24 PM on Wed Feb 4 2015
It probably doesn't help my vote that the first show I saw with Superman is Justice League so...
Replysaid at 5:35 AM on Sun Jan 18 2015
Tim Daly is the perfect Superman voice to me, with George Newbern being a close second.
Replysaid at 11:32 AM on Sun Jan 11 2015
Can't beleive I forgot to talk about Marc Silk, but he was good, too. That said, yeah, Troy Baker's Superman sounds a little bland and like TylerMirage said, he sounds like a *parody* of Superman.
Replysaid at 7:58 AM on Sun Jan 11 2015
Not to knock Troy, but yeah... the voice is almost *too* "heroic". Comes off as cliche, or like he's doing a parody of the strong, heroic voice of a god-like superhero.
Replysaid at 1:17 PM on Fri Jan 9 2015
Yeah, as everyone else has mentioned, Troy is just okay. It just sounds like a by the numbers performance, rather than creating something unique.
Replysaid at 2:59 PM on Thu Jan 8 2015
Troy is just okay, he doesn't do much to make it distinct. I'd say its a stronger performance than his Joker but not on the same level as his Batman
Replysaid at 6:18 PM on Thu Jan 8 2015
@Music Meister I don't know, at least with his Joker it sounded like he was trying despite sounding kinda forced, but his Superman here just sounds phoned-in and boring.
Replysaid at 6:31 PM on Thu Jan 8 2015
@PsychicVoiceSpy
I guess that's true
ReplyI guess that's true
said at 12:33 PM on Thu Jan 8 2015
Troy sounds alright. So therefore my vote doesn't change a bit.
Replysaid at 7:33 PM on Wed Feb 4 2015
@Ross123 Didn't care for it now that I heard, it sounds far too generic for me, his Espio is not the most original but he actually put effort there, here he's not even trying which is sad because his Joker is surprisingly dead on and his Loki's great too and I love his Yuri Lowell(the last one at least put something more original than the Japanese voice as well so he wasn't the king of generic voices)
Still the first two choices, Tim and George are the best choices
ReplyStill the first two choices, Tim and George are the best choices
said at 6:54 AM on Sat Feb 7 2015
@HienFan When you're 1 of over 30 people who voiced a character, I'm sure it can be pretty hard to stand out from the rest.
Troy (like most of the others on this compare) just comes off as alright to me. He's not bad but he's not good either.
ReplyTroy (like most of the others on this compare) just comes off as alright to me. He's not bad but he's not good either.
said at 11:07 PM on Fri Feb 13 2015
@Ross123 Unfortunately when a compare have over 4 it can be hard to swim through everyone as well to find who sticks out the most never mind 30
Replysaid at 11:43 AM on Thu Jan 8 2015
It's official, Troy can play any DC superhero or supervillain he wants.
Replysaid at 10:07 AM on Thu Jan 8 2015
Troy is fine, he's kinda just doing Troy Baker voice but with mildly more oomph. He also sounds a bit too threatening in his delivery near the end there.
Replysaid at 12:47 PM on Sat Jan 10 2015
@GothamRed I believe Clark should sound somewhat threatening, especially when he's angry.
Replysaid at 11:54 PM on Tue Jan 6 2015
Armin Shimerman was decent, but Peter Jessop was pretty good. I don't like Alan Tudyk's Superman, but that's more the writing and general disdain for the New 52 version of Superman than Tudyk's acting.
That said, after rewatching Superman vs. The Elite and playing Injustice, I'm gonna change my vote back to George Newbern.
ReplyThat said, after rewatching Superman vs. The Elite and playing Injustice, I'm gonna change my vote back to George Newbern.
said at 10:21 AM on Tue Jan 20 2015
@Anicomicgeek
Sorry if I'm fickle, but if it's possible to edit, could someone edit out that part of me changing my vote; I'm changing it back to Tim Daly.
ReplySorry if I'm fickle, but if it's possible to edit, could someone edit out that part of me changing my vote; I'm changing it back to Tim Daly.
said at 11:07 PM on Sat Aug 22 2015
@Anicomicgeek
Sorry and thanks in advance, but could someone delete that last post? I'm going back to George Newbern.
ReplySorry and thanks in advance, but could someone delete that last post? I'm going back to George Newbern.
said at 3:32 PM on Tue Nov 25 2014
Both Tim and George give fantastic performances and each sound eerily similar, but with who is better, I honestly think it depends on which version you prefer.
Daly's superman is much more get the job done, and has the mild mannered personality of Clark Kent down to a T, while Newbern is the much more emotionally driven superman.
Daly did get a good amount of time with the character having both the animated series and a couple animated films, but Newbern has had so much more time to flesh out the character and make it his own role having two TV series, appearing in two others, as well as a film and a video game to perfect the character.
Again I like both performances very well, but if I had to pick I'd say Newbern, just due to the fact he has had so much more to work with over the years and his Superman I feel has had much more development (JLU and Superman Vs. The Elite are great examples of this).
If I could pick someone instead of either George or Tim I'd go for Nolan North. While he didn't have a whole lot to work with, he had enough for all the episodes he appeared in and nailed the authoritative side of Superman.
If not Nolan than Travis Willingham for his great comedic portrayal of Superman.
ReplyDaly's superman is much more get the job done, and has the mild mannered personality of Clark Kent down to a T, while Newbern is the much more emotionally driven superman.
Daly did get a good amount of time with the character having both the animated series and a couple animated films, but Newbern has had so much more time to flesh out the character and make it his own role having two TV series, appearing in two others, as well as a film and a video game to perfect the character.
Again I like both performances very well, but if I had to pick I'd say Newbern, just due to the fact he has had so much more to work with over the years and his Superman I feel has had much more development (JLU and Superman Vs. The Elite are great examples of this).
If I could pick someone instead of either George or Tim I'd go for Nolan North. While he didn't have a whole lot to work with, he had enough for all the episodes he appeared in and nailed the authoritative side of Superman.
If not Nolan than Travis Willingham for his great comedic portrayal of Superman.
said at 6:26 PM on Sun Sep 14 2014
I don't know who to pick between Tim Daly and George Newbern, honestly: they both fit Superman so well and also sound so similar...it's really tough to choose between the two, but I'm going to vote for George as I feel like he brought more emotion to the role.
Replysaid at 10:38 AM on Tue Aug 26 2014
Oh wow, so it looks like Tim Daly and George Newbern are tied in this comparison now.
Replysaid at 1:36 PM on Thu Oct 2 2014
@Zillah - Well it's not that surprising considering they're basically the same voice
Replysaid at 4:35 PM on Tue Jul 1 2014
George Newburn is the best superman, he has this don't worry it's going to be ok tone, these two are post-crisis superman. Roger Rose is pre-crisis hands down, captures Newburn's voice but puts on a side of ham.
Replysaid at 12:06 PM on Sat Jun 21 2014
Not that into making lists but I'll make one for this.
1. George Newbern- He has every quality that Superman needs. He's heroic, friendly, and (when he needs to be) threatening. All in all the perfect Superman voice.
2.Tim Daly- The crazy thing is I watched the Superman TAS and didn't notice he didn't reprise his role in JLA. That being said, he's very similar to Newbern (after all Newbern was a replacement, makes sense that he would) but the one thing Newbern does to beat out Daly is the emotion. Tim is great, but he falls flat occasionally. Still really good however.
3. Mark Harmon- A lot of really good qualities to this performance. Not much to say, it's good but not my favorite.
4. Mark Valley- Pretty good choice, a voice that stands out, decent performance.
5.Peter Jessop- If there's one thing I'd critique, it's that he sounds a little too big and mighty. But it suits this particular version.
6.Keith Ferguson- Surprisingly good, sounds a bit like Newbern to me. Not bad.
7.Alan Tudyk- Has potential, but he barely had anything to say in this movie.
8.Matt Bomer- Aside from some awkward delivery here and there he's decent.
9.Roger Rose- As a somewhat comedic version it fits, and I'd like to hear him get another crack at it under different direction.
10.Nolan North- It's a little bland, but again, I'd like to see him have another shot.
Reply1. George Newbern- He has every quality that Superman needs. He's heroic, friendly, and (when he needs to be) threatening. All in all the perfect Superman voice.
2.Tim Daly- The crazy thing is I watched the Superman TAS and didn't notice he didn't reprise his role in JLA. That being said, he's very similar to Newbern (after all Newbern was a replacement, makes sense that he would) but the one thing Newbern does to beat out Daly is the emotion. Tim is great, but he falls flat occasionally. Still really good however.
3. Mark Harmon- A lot of really good qualities to this performance. Not much to say, it's good but not my favorite.
4. Mark Valley- Pretty good choice, a voice that stands out, decent performance.
5.Peter Jessop- If there's one thing I'd critique, it's that he sounds a little too big and mighty. But it suits this particular version.
6.Keith Ferguson- Surprisingly good, sounds a bit like Newbern to me. Not bad.
7.Alan Tudyk- Has potential, but he barely had anything to say in this movie.
8.Matt Bomer- Aside from some awkward delivery here and there he's decent.
9.Roger Rose- As a somewhat comedic version it fits, and I'd like to hear him get another crack at it under different direction.
10.Nolan North- It's a little bland, but again, I'd like to see him have another shot.
said at 1:51 AM on Sat Jun 21 2014
You know, I've realized something, in Justice League: The Flashpoint Paradox, Superman is voiced by Sam Daly, but in Justice League: War he is voiced by Alan Tudyk, and so I wonder, why not simply bring back Sam Daly for Justice League: War as well? a little consistency with Superman's voice, for these two films, I mean, they exist in the same universe.
Replysaid at 7:08 PM on Tue Jun 3 2014
I originally picked Tim Daly, but after watching JL episodes like Twilight and The Man Who Has Everything, my vote goes to George Newbern!!! I still like Tim of course, as well as Adam, Travis, Keith, Matt, Peter, Mark, and Michael.
Replysaid at 8:17 PM on Sun Jun 15 2014
@DravenRoth994 "For The Man Who Has Everything", my bad. I also forgot to mention his performance in Injustice, another highlight.
Replysaid at 10:55 AM on Sat May 17 2014
Superman is a really hard compare. Not just because there's to many voices but also because a lot of them blend together.
Now that's NOT a bad thing, it just shows that DC has done a good job at casting Superman because there are a lot more good voices than bad ones here.
Yes there are bad voices, especially the ones before the 90s but that gets outshadowed by too many good ones.
But I'm still not a fan of the constant recasting, you know like with Batman.
I suppose my vote goes to Tim since he was the one to open up the amazing voice for Superman which it seems a lot of these people followed.
I'll consider George a close 2nd though because there was something special about his take on the role.
ReplyNow that's NOT a bad thing, it just shows that DC has done a good job at casting Superman because there are a lot more good voices than bad ones here.
Yes there are bad voices, especially the ones before the 90s but that gets outshadowed by too many good ones.
But I'm still not a fan of the constant recasting, you know like with Batman.
I suppose my vote goes to Tim since he was the one to open up the amazing voice for Superman which it seems a lot of these people followed.
I'll consider George a close 2nd though because there was something special about his take on the role.
said at 10:47 PM on Sat Apr 26 2014
Armin Shimerman and Alan Tudyk are two of the last people I'd think of as Superman. They don't do awful, but just...really?
But Peter Jessop as Superman = HECK YEAH!
ReplyBut Peter Jessop as Superman = HECK YEAH!
said at 10:17 AM on Sun Apr 27 2014
@Galactic_Cyrus So you're not saying that they're awful, you're just surprised at their casting? Implying that choosing them was a bad move?
Replysaid at 12:29 PM on Sun Apr 27 2014
@TylerMirage Not "bad" casting, just outside the box casting. It's like the casting director wanted to try something really different from what most would do.
Replysaid at 1:00 PM on Sun Apr 27 2014
@Galactic_Cyrus Gotcha'. I wasn't sure if you were implying that they were poor choices or just expressing general surprise. :)
I'm all for outside-the-box casting. Lots of great performances have sprung from those. ;)
ReplyI'm all for outside-the-box casting. Lots of great performances have sprung from those. ;)
said at 1:41 PM on Wed Apr 30 2014
@TylerMirage Tudyk in particular actually does well there. Still weirded out by Principal Snyder as Superman, but that was a comical version of the character he voiced, so it's not so bad.
Replysaid at 12:13 AM on Sat Apr 26 2014
I've come to like George Newbern the best. I like Tim Daly and it was a little odd hearing George voice him at first, but I've just really come to hear George's voice when I see or think of Superman.
I'd like to hear Nolan North take another crack at him. He didn't get much play on Young Justice. He was great as Superboy, but I want to hear more of him as Superman.
ReplyI'd like to hear Nolan North take another crack at him. He didn't get much play on Young Justice. He was great as Superboy, but I want to hear more of him as Superman.
said at 8:27 PM on Tue Jan 28 2014
While I like Alan's voice for New-52 Kal, I would have liked Matt Boomer in the role better.
Replysaid at 11:50 AM on Wed Jan 29 2014
@Netherman14 Adam Baldwin, one of the few guys who can argue with himself.
Replysaid at 9:26 AM on Tue Jan 28 2014
I love Alan, I love him to death, but based on this clip in not loving him as Supes here
Replysaid at 6:07 PM on Sun Jun 22 2014
@WoodstockProd I know he voiced Green Arrow in YJ, but Superman in that movie sounds too much like him..but that's just me.
Replysaid at 8:18 PM on Mon Jan 27 2014
George Newbern is my favourite, and "Superman vs. The Elite" is my reason why. Definitely a powerhouse performer as the Man of Steel, and makes him sound so damn likeable. But he's done great in all his pieces of work. Close second, for me, is probably... either Travis Willingham or Matt Bomer. I like 'em both equally for the different versions they portrayed.
Alan Tudyk... could do well as Superman, but he needs a better-written version of the character for me to judge. New 52-Superman is a jerk.
Also... while he has played Batman already... what would people say to the idea of Roger Craig Smith as Superman? Something inspired by his Captain America, but a little older and more experienced-sounding, would work really well for a traditional Superman.
ReplyAlan Tudyk... could do well as Superman, but he needs a better-written version of the character for me to judge. New 52-Superman is a jerk.
Also... while he has played Batman already... what would people say to the idea of Roger Craig Smith as Superman? Something inspired by his Captain America, but a little older and more experienced-sounding, would work really well for a traditional Superman.
said at 8:53 PM on Mon Jan 27 2014
@Lion's Edge
It'll work better for Superman than Cap.
ReplyIt'll work better for Superman than Cap.
said at 8:58 PM on Mon Jan 27 2014
@TheVengeanceKnight Admittedly, RCS is my favourite Cap... but I do think it works really well for Superman as well.
Replysaid at 7:44 AM on Mon Jan 27 2014
Gonna change my vote to George Newbern, because of his most recent works like Injustice for example. I mean, Tim Daly would make a good Clark Kent, but in my opinion, George Newbern gives Superman some personality and power as a leader of the Justice League. Loved his Injustice performance though. I still like both voices, but Newbern has the edge in this one.
Replysaid at 7:45 AM on Mon Jan 27 2014
@llawliet159 Oh, and I disliked Alan's take on Superman, I really hated New 52 Superman in the film LOL
Replysaid at 5:38 PM on Sun Jan 26 2014
Armin's fine. Loved Peter Jessop's take. Haven't heard much of Alan's take besides this one...but this Superman sounds like a jerk.
Replysaid at 2:05 PM on Sun Jan 26 2014
Armin is alright. Alan was good too. I don't care for Superman's characterization in JL War. Peter Jessop did great as well. I'm sticking with Gearge Newbern though.
Replysaid at 1:13 PM on Sun Jan 26 2014
Peter and Alan were a bit underwhelming to me, but Peter was the better of the two.
Replysaid at 11:54 AM on Sun Jan 26 2014
Mark Silk- Meh, I'm not impressed. Not terrible, but not very good. 6.4/10
Armin Shimerman- Generic, but not bad. Not bad at all. 7.2/10
Peter Jessop- Wow! I'm impressed! He's probably my 3rd or maybe 4th favorite of all the ones here. 8.9/10
Alan Tudyk- Good for "New 52!" Superman, but unfortunately the writing makes him dislikeable.
I do think he should be aloud to come back to the role, to see how he does with better writing. 7.6/10
ReplyArmin Shimerman- Generic, but not bad. Not bad at all. 7.2/10
Peter Jessop- Wow! I'm impressed! He's probably my 3rd or maybe 4th favorite of all the ones here. 8.9/10
Alan Tudyk- Good for "New 52!" Superman, but unfortunately the writing makes him dislikeable.
I do think he should be aloud to come back to the role, to see how he does with better writing. 7.6/10
said at 11:11 AM on Sun Jan 26 2014
Peter Jessop is a fantastic Superman. The other two new additions here are don't leave much of an impression on me, although Alan is better than Armin.
Replysaid at 10:53 AM on Sun Jan 26 2014
Armin was alright, he sounds a little like David Kaye and I could see it fitting if given more dialog.
Peter was awesome in the role, his deep voice was commanding yet kind. He was able to make Supes sound strong yet kind and caring. Hope he gets more chances.
Alan was...again, I have to blame the truly awful version of Supes he got. He played Supes as a total douche bag but that's how Supes was portrayed so I can't fault him. I really hope he gets to play an actual version of Superman instead of...THAT.
ReplyPeter was awesome in the role, his deep voice was commanding yet kind. He was able to make Supes sound strong yet kind and caring. Hope he gets more chances.
Alan was...again, I have to blame the truly awful version of Supes he got. He played Supes as a total douche bag but that's how Supes was portrayed so I can't fault him. I really hope he gets to play an actual version of Superman instead of...THAT.
said at 11:05 AM on Sun Jan 26 2014
@Music Meister A shame... I do think Tudyk could work well as a more traditional take at Superman... It is just... well...
This is New 52!Superman. And New 52!Superman is FAR from well-written, disappointingly.
ReplyThis is New 52!Superman. And New 52!Superman is FAR from well-written, disappointingly.
said at 11:15 AM on Sun Jan 26 2014
@Music Meister Even with the awful version of all the characters in War, I still think Alan was inconsistent in the role. Sometimes he hit the right point and others he was a bit too high and/or nasally.
Replysaid at 2:07 PM on Sun Jan 26 2014
@GothamRed You have a point but I think Alan could do better if given a second chance
Replysaid at 8:30 PM on Thu Mar 6 2014
@Music Meister Strangely enough, what I've read of New52 Supe actually acts pretty consistently with other versions, just more stoic, I just don't like Justice League War's take on him.
Replysaid at 8:19 AM on Sun Jan 26 2014
Says the guy who kills if he has no choice. (I'm referring to the Mark Harmon clip.)
Replysaid at 6:42 PM on Sat Jan 25 2014
Honestly, I'm going to go with George Newbern as #1, and Tim Daly as a close second. Tim was a better Supes voice at first, but I think that in more recent things such as "Superman vs the Elite" and "Injustice" George has really proven himself and shown his emotional range. I'd like to see him play the Clark Kent- side of the character more often though, to see how he does.
Replysaid at 2:25 PM on Fri Jan 24 2014
What about peter jessop, I want to here what he sounds like as Supes!
Replysaid at 2:46 PM on Fri Jan 24 2014
@CLG stay calm, you can expect a lot of DC compares updated this weekend
Replysaid at 11:44 AM on Fri Jan 24 2014
Wow, was not expecting Marc Silk
Replysaid at 12:26 PM on Fri Jan 24 2014
Marc reminds me of JAT, anyone else?
Replysaid at 8:24 AM on Mon Jan 20 2014
Who thinks Keith Ferguson is underrated just because of the show...?
Replysaid at 9:54 AM on Tue Jan 7 2014
I can see why everyone likes Tim Daly. Everything's there that Superman is, but George Newbern delivered a little something extra; a Superman that had seen dark times and continued to face them. He made him seem like a man with a heavy burden, but he wanted to carry that burden and see it through to the end.
Having said all that, though, my personal favourite is Mark Harmon, just because he makes Superman sound like he's been around the block a few times and is still the good guy he is. Not a lot of actors here actually make Superman sound as experienced as he would be.
ReplyHaving said all that, though, my personal favourite is Mark Harmon, just because he makes Superman sound like he's been around the block a few times and is still the good guy he is. Not a lot of actors here actually make Superman sound as experienced as he would be.
said at 7:12 PM on Tue Nov 26 2013
I went with Newbern. While his voice is very Similar to Tim Daly, I feel like he just gives a better performance. So for me Newbern at 1 and Daly at a photo finish 2nd..
Replysaid at 10:59 PM on Thu Oct 31 2013
Danny Dark is , was and always will be the voice of Superman to me. I grew up with him doing the voice.
Replysaid at 9:19 PM on Sat Oct 19 2013
In the end, I went with Tim Daly, but i was surprised by Travis Willingham and I would love to see him do a more serious take on the role.
Replysaid at 7:02 PM on Tue Oct 22 2013
@Comicfan117 I think he'd be great as a serious, comic-accurate incarnation too, or maybe even a live-action one.
Replysaid at 4:16 PM on Sat Oct 12 2013
This is a pretty good Voice Compare, the only VA'S I don't really like Michael Hall, Matt Boomer, and Sam Daly. I also feel Adam Baldwin is a bit miscasted, but that's just me. It's tough to choose between Tim Daly and George Newbern, but George is the voice I have the most memories of, so he gets my vote.
Replysaid at 8:08 AM on Sat Oct 12 2013
Whenever I read the comics and I see Superman, George Newbern comes in my head, whenever i see Clark Kent, Tim Daly comes in my head
Replysaid at 2:14 PM on Tue Oct 8 2013
Tim Daly, George Newbern, Sam Daly, James Denton, Michael Dangerfield Hall, Crispin Freeman, Brandon Routh, Beau Weaver, David Kaye, Nolan North, Roger Rose, Patrick Warburton, and Travis Willingham are the standouts here. The rest are all either unfit or bland as heck.
Replysaid at 2:41 AM on Sat Oct 26 2013
@Galactic_Cyrus Although, in the case of Yuri Lowenthal, he was a younger incarnation of Superman so... I'm not really SURE how you would grade that...
...
Which makes me wonder why Yuri wasn't casted as Superboy. As much as I love Nolan North.
Reply...
Which makes me wonder why Yuri wasn't casted as Superboy. As much as I love Nolan North.
said at 7:23 AM on Sat Oct 26 2013
@Comicfan117 ...Fair enough... but I think Yuri would also make a good Superboy. If ever they brought him into a series where Superman was being played by someone like George Newbern, who wouldn't be able to do a younger voice like Nolan does...
Replysaid at 4:10 AM on Sat Aug 22 2015
@Lion's Edge
Mostly because of legal issues at the time, because technically, in Season 1, he *was* Superboy in all but name.
ReplyMostly because of legal issues at the time, because technically, in Season 1, he *was* Superboy in all but name.
said at 9:40 AM on Mon Oct 7 2013
Tim Daly 1st
George Newbern 2nd...because he's a successor if Daly ever gave up the mantle of voicing Superman
Nolan North 3rd because of his Young Justice performance
ReplyGeorge Newbern 2nd...because he's a successor if Daly ever gave up the mantle of voicing Superman
Nolan North 3rd because of his Young Justice performance
said at 8:59 PM on Mon Oct 28 2013
@llawliet159 on top of that, Mark Harmon and Mark Valley were great too.
Replysaid at 2:15 PM on Tue Sep 24 2013
Well I like Tim Daly and George Newbern, but Adam Baldwin makes a good mmo superman from dcuo, its a very commanding voice, even though a bit quiter than Newbern or Daly. Why didnt anyone pick Yuri as Superboy though? I liked Legion of Superheroes
Replysaid at 7:19 PM on Fri Sep 13 2013
I feel that George Newbern is the only actor to convey that while Superman is a symbol of hope and justice he still has the powers of a god and could destroy the world just as easily as he could save it if he went over the edge.
Replysaid at 3:25 AM on Sat Sep 7 2013
My favourite here is George Newbern.
However, if he had the chance to play out more of Superman's personality, I think I would actually change my vote for Travis Willingham. I thought he did a wonderful job with what he had in the game.
ReplyHowever, if he had the chance to play out more of Superman's personality, I think I would actually change my vote for Travis Willingham. I thought he did a wonderful job with what he had in the game.
said at 11:50 AM on Wed Aug 7 2013
I'm putting my vote on Travis Willingham; while he doesn't get to perform an especially wide range of emotions, his inflections make him seem really invested in what he's doing, and the voice itself is really close to what I would consider the definitive "Superman" sound that allows me to hear the character rather than the actor behind the character.
Replysaid at 9:17 PM on Sun Aug 18 2013
@CatsTuxedo Travis really is a perfect match for Superman. I would love to see him portray the broader scope of Superman's personality and emotions. If he did I would very easily consider changing my vote to him.
Replysaid at 10:58 PM on Sun Aug 18 2013
@PsychicVoiceSpy Well, to be fair on Travis. His last name isn't Willing-HAM for nothing, now, is it?
Replysaid at 8:36 PM on Sun Aug 4 2013
Sam didn't bring much, but he's OK. Maybe with more material he'd be better. Plus, he wasn't really playing Superman as we know him.
Replysaid at 9:31 AM on Mon Aug 5 2013
@VctrBnsn His clip is from the traditional Superman.
Replysaid at 12:06 PM on Sat Aug 3 2013
Tim Daly and George Newbern are the best. As Kevin Conroy is the voice for Batman, Tim and George are the voices for Superman. If one can't voice him pick the other.
Replysaid at 11:01 AM on Fri Aug 2 2013
My favorite is George Newbern for his Superman vs The Elite performance, where he got to sound more heroic and likable than what I saw from his other appearances.
Matt Bomer has a nice voice for the part and good acting with personality from what I've heard, so he's my second place.
My third place is James Denton because I felt he captured his kind and gentle side the best out of all of them.
I also liked Mark Valley too.
And on another note... I may get a few disapproving looks for saying this, but every time I've heard Tim Daly he sounded too much like a generic tough-guy with little personality. I don't feel he sounds heroic or likeable enough, his voice and performance for the character has never sounded fully appropriate for Superman, in my honest opinion. I think he's far from the definitive Superman, but I may change my opinion later.
ReplyMatt Bomer has a nice voice for the part and good acting with personality from what I've heard, so he's my second place.
My third place is James Denton because I felt he captured his kind and gentle side the best out of all of them.
I also liked Mark Valley too.
And on another note... I may get a few disapproving looks for saying this, but every time I've heard Tim Daly he sounded too much like a generic tough-guy with little personality. I don't feel he sounds heroic or likeable enough, his voice and performance for the character has never sounded fully appropriate for Superman, in my honest opinion. I think he's far from the definitive Superman, but I may change my opinion later.
said at 3:02 PM on Sun Aug 4 2013
@Silence Heh, and I was having doubts anyone would publicly agree with me. Kudos. :)
Replysaid at 3:46 PM on Sat Sep 21 2013
@Comicfan117 - I kinda agree. I'd like to see Tim have a chance to really convey a more emotional Superman performance
Replysaid at 12:22 PM on Sun Sep 22 2013
@Comicfan117 - I think if they make a movie based on the Injustice prequel, they'll just bring back Newbern for consistency's sake.
The others though, yeah that'd be great
ReplyThe others though, yeah that'd be great
said at 4:22 PM on Tue Jul 9 2013
Again, I know I don't normally make posts like these, but we could use Paul Dobson as Superman; he can definitely pull off the "tough, mature and powerful paragon of masculinity" aspect while also getting the "humble, idealistic and responsible hero" character across.
Replysaid at 6:26 PM on Wed Jul 24 2013
@CatsTuxedo Maybe if Ocean dubs over a Superman motion comic we'll have a chance at seeing that.
Replysaid at 3:40 PM on Mon Sep 9 2013
@CatsTuxedo Hmmm...he'd definitely have the power in his voice, though I think he's a bit too deep and/or gridmark for Superman. Paul would be an awesome (if not a bit typecast) Lex though.
Replysaid at 1:17 PM on Thu Oct 3 2013
@LordofEvil96 True. Unfortunately, given DC's track record, it doesn't seem like that'll ever happen.
However, if someone were to twist my arm and force me to select an LA-based actor, I'd go with Fred Tatasciore since he can capture a similar "strong, humble hero" quality to what Dobson can.
ReplyHowever, if someone were to twist my arm and force me to select an LA-based actor, I'd go with Fred Tatasciore since he can capture a similar "strong, humble hero" quality to what Dobson can.
said at 1:11 AM on Fri Jul 5 2013
Similar to my comment in the Spider-Man VC, this is one of the voice compares where I feel that every single actor did well. Some better than others, yes, but none that really stand out as "poor".
Overall, my top picks are:
1.) Matt Bomer
2.) Mark Valley
3.) George Newbern
4.) Tim Daly
5.) Mark Harmon
ReplyOverall, my top picks are:
1.) Matt Bomer
2.) Mark Valley
3.) George Newbern
4.) Tim Daly
5.) Mark Harmon
said at 4:00 PM on Fri Jun 7 2013
Newborn perfectly encapsulates everything that i loove about superman. Tim Daly is a very close second, and Bomer and Baldwin are third.
Replysaid at 6:21 PM on Sun May 26 2013
All of these guys do really great jobs protraying Superman of different styles. However, if I had to choose.. I'd either go with Tim Daly, or Matt Bomer with George Being my final. If I had to choose a second set of 3 it'd be Mark Valley, Mark Harmon, and James Denton - simply because of acting ability. I can believe they're Superman.
Replysaid at 2:05 PM on Sat May 25 2013
Gotta stick with George Newbern, especially after Injustice!
But does anyone elsse find it ironic that Matt Bomer looks suspiciously like Henry Cavill here???
ReplyBut does anyone elsse find it ironic that Matt Bomer looks suspiciously like Henry Cavill here???
said at 8:42 PM on Sat May 25 2013
@AMT Apparently Matt was originally up for the role in Man Of Steel but got rejected
Replysaid at 4:12 PM on Tue Jun 18 2013
@TheGreenSpeedster actually he was up for the role in a film called "Superman vs Batman" set to be directed by Brett Ratner, but the project never got off the ground for whatever reason
Replysaid at 1:38 PM on Fri May 24 2013
Gotta say, really digged Mark and Matt's performances as the man of steel this year, i'm interested to hear what Sam Daly can bring to the role
Replysaid at 2:49 AM on Wed May 22 2013
Originally, Tim Daly was my favourite but after playing Injustice, I just had to vote for George Newbern
Replysaid at 7:16 PM on Sun Jun 23 2013
@TheGreenSpeedster On second thought, while I still love George Newbern, I'm changing my vote to Tim Daly.
Replysaid at 10:03 AM on Fri May 17 2013
Matt Bomer is surly one of the better newer voices. I would love to see him as Superman in future projects. Tim and George are still my favs though.
Replysaid at 12:50 AM on Fri May 17 2013
I'm gonna stick with Tim Daly, but Matt Bomer was better than I'd thought he'd be.
Replysaid at 9:36 PM on Sun Aug 4 2013
@Anicomicgeek
Sam Daly was okay, but I think his dad's better, so I'll stick with Tim.
ReplySam Daly was okay, but I think his dad's better, so I'll stick with Tim.
said at 12:36 AM on Fri May 17 2013
I think most of these VA'a are doing an awesome job, but i really like Tim Daly being Superman.
Replysaid at 1:17 PM on Sun May 12 2013
I say the best modern ones are Tim Daly, George Newbern, Mark Harnon, Mark Valley, and Nolan North though Nolan's was kind of a jerk to Superboy compared to the Kents he definitely could go into Superman's angry moments well if he got the chance. Out of the classic ones Bud sounds the most convincing.
Replysaid at 8:57 PM on Thu May 16 2013
@pete In Superman Unbound I really enjoyed Matt Bomer, he's one of the stronger new voices.
Replysaid at 12:15 AM on Fri May 17 2013
@pete I excluded since he's not on here yet but I put him after Tim and George. He has the same aspects they do. I also put James Denton at 7. making it Tim, George, Matt, Mark H, Mark V, Nolan then James in that order.
Replysaid at 1:51 PM on Thu May 9 2013
I think Travis Willingham does a great job as a smug, full-of-himself Superman, but I think Mark Valley does the best job overall.
Replysaid at 6:02 PM on Sat May 4 2013
I know a lot of modern DC fans won't agree with me, but for me, Bud Collyer is and always will be Superman!!!! Mainly thanks to his ability to lower the pitch of his voice whenever Clark Kent became Superman.
Replysaid at 10:32 PM on Mon May 6 2013
@Starscreamsfan Bud Collyer is one of the most fantastic classic performances of any superhero. He was the first, and still one of the best.
Replysaid at 1:07 PM on Sun May 12 2013
@Starscreamsfan As someone who enjoys the voices in the old DC cartoons I actually don't have a problem with that but I do say since Bud's Superman isn't the emotional 3 dimensional hero who goes on about truth, justice, and morality then I say he is the best of the classic voices and Tim and George are the best modern ones.
Replysaid at 8:51 PM on Thu May 16 2013
@pete I think I'll have to agree and disagree with that last aspect. The Fleischer Cartoons really didn't used Collyer that much, so Superman simply rescues people and the fact that he doesn't even have lines in some shorts, doesn't give Collyer any justice. But if we talk about the old time radio show, Collyer delivers very powerful acting both as Clark Kent and as Superman.
Replysaid at 8:52 PM on Thu May 16 2013
@VctrBnsn Yep, but Danny Dark was pretty cool too.
Replysaid at 8:55 PM on Thu May 16 2013
@Starscreamsfan So, what do you think of fan favorites Tim Daly and George Newborn?
Replysaid at 8:30 PM on Fri May 17 2013
@VctrBnsn Ehhh, I don't know what to say. They are too generic sounding for my taste. Sorry. :/
Replysaid at 9:46 PM on Fri May 17 2013
@Starscreamsfan Glad to see someone willing to voice there opinion even if it isn't the norm. I respect that.
Replysaid at 5:41 PM on Thu May 23 2013
@Starscreamsfan I think a variety of different opinions is good for this sight. From what I could gather, most of the members hear (including me) prefer post 90's voices in superheroes (Tim Daly as Superman, Kevin Conroy as Batman, Mark Hamill as Joker). But then I saw your comments and though "wait this guy is picking Superfriends voices." I thought it was a refreshing change of pace. The more opinions we see, the more we fully understand peoples views on these actors, instead of a bunch of us kids just voting for the newest guy. Although I listen to every voice clip, I'm afraid some people disregard the older voices just because they are old. Come on guys, a lot of these actors did great work. Even if they aren't your favorite, they deserve the option to be acknowleged.
Replysaid at 8:39 AM on Mon May 27 2013
@VctrBnsn That's right. I respect the modern Super Hero VAs, but since my childhood was mainly reruns of classic shows and short subjects, I will always stick with classic performances.
Replysaid at 10:46 PM on Fri Apr 26 2013
George Newbern had greater emotional range and put an undercurrent of pathos and subtle danger into Superman. Tim Daly had pretty much one setting, which was Tim Daly. Both of them are miles above anyone else who DC/WB has tapped for the role in any other adaptation, however.
Replysaid at 3:50 PM on Tue Apr 23 2013
I'm going with George Newbern. Tim Daly is my second favorite.
Replysaid at 1:28 PM on Wed Apr 17 2013
Tim Daly's son Sam Daly will voice Superman in the Flashpoint adaptation. I wonder how he will do.....
Replysaid at 7:21 PM on Mon May 6 2013
@VctrBnsn Interesting change of pace. I wonder how well the son will do in comparison to the father.
Replysaid at 9:46 AM on Thu Mar 21 2013
James Denton. Don't ask me why, everyone else sounded either too sissy or reminded me too much of their performances in other media. I know Denton's known for other things but his voice isn't as recognisable to me as other 'celebrity' Supermans (Supermen?) and I really felt like a man with that voice could lift a car without breaking a sweat, whereas the others didn't sell it for me quite as well.
Now here come the haters.
ReplyNow here come the haters.
said at 8:59 PM on Mon Mar 18 2013
After much thought, I'm changing my vote to George Newbern, because I believe he gives Superman more of a human side at times than Tim Daly. but they are both good. in fact I think George proved that point in the JLU episode "for the man who has everything"
Replysaid at 11:26 PM on Sat Feb 23 2013
Tim Daily/George Newborn - Tie. They are awesome.
Adam Baldwin - Good.
Crispin Freeman - Different, but likable.
Kyle MacLachlan - OK, nothing special.
CCS - A little bland, but fine.
Michael Dangerfield - I thought it was George in that cartoon. I`m impressed.
Jeff Kramer - For lack of a better word, too superheroy.
Mark Harmon - He would of bean better as an aged Superman.
David Kaye - I think he can do a serious Superman if he toned down the camp.
Nolan North - Not bad, but not outstanding. Still one of the better ones.
James Denton - I like it.
Roger Rose - Worked for what the show was going for.
Patrick Warburton - I thought parodies weren't aloud in VCs.
Keith Ferguson - He's a good cartoon voice but I can still take him seriously. He doesn't go for that stereotypical superhero voice.
Travis Willingham - Although he does go fore that stereotypical Superman voice, he does it better than others.
Mark Valley - One of the better ones here, I would listen to him more.
ReplyAdam Baldwin - Good.
Crispin Freeman - Different, but likable.
Kyle MacLachlan - OK, nothing special.
CCS - A little bland, but fine.
Michael Dangerfield - I thought it was George in that cartoon. I`m impressed.
Jeff Kramer - For lack of a better word, too superheroy.
Mark Harmon - He would of bean better as an aged Superman.
David Kaye - I think he can do a serious Superman if he toned down the camp.
Nolan North - Not bad, but not outstanding. Still one of the better ones.
James Denton - I like it.
Roger Rose - Worked for what the show was going for.
Patrick Warburton - I thought parodies weren't aloud in VCs.
Keith Ferguson - He's a good cartoon voice but I can still take him seriously. He doesn't go for that stereotypical superhero voice.
Travis Willingham - Although he does go fore that stereotypical Superman voice, he does it better than others.
Mark Valley - One of the better ones here, I would listen to him more.
said at 2:55 PM on Wed Feb 27 2013
@VctrBnsn Are these your favorites because you forgot like 5. Also I think Patrick is counted an official version since it wasn't on Robot Chicken, Family Guy, South Park, MAD etc.
Replysaid at 10:20 AM on Fri Mar 1 2013
@pete Those were the only actors I felt like talking about at the time. Here is my opinion on the others.
Christopher McDonald - Didn't really count him because he's an older version (but for some reason that didn't stop me from doing Mark Valley) but he's OK.
Yuri Lowenthal - Younger version, I watched that show a bit and I liked him in it.
Danny Dark - OK
Beau Weaver - Better than Danny
Brandon Routh - Like his movie performance, a little dull.
Bud Collyer - Awesome as the first Superman voice.
Joseph May - Surprisingly good.
David Lodge - A different version, but good for what they were going for.
ReplyChristopher McDonald - Didn't really count him because he's an older version (but for some reason that didn't stop me from doing Mark Valley) but he's OK.
Yuri Lowenthal - Younger version, I watched that show a bit and I liked him in it.
Danny Dark - OK
Beau Weaver - Better than Danny
Brandon Routh - Like his movie performance, a little dull.
Bud Collyer - Awesome as the first Superman voice.
Joseph May - Surprisingly good.
David Lodge - A different version, but good for what they were going for.
said at 2:58 AM on Sat Feb 16 2013
I've only seen a few clips of the movie, but Mark Valley was pretty good.
Replysaid at 8:25 PM on Fri Feb 15 2013
Mark Valley is how Christopher Macdonald should have sounded in Batman Beyond an older version of Tim Daly/George Newbern.
Replysaid at 12:05 AM on Fri Feb 15 2013
Travis Willingham was okay as Superman. Having said that, Mark Valy was pretty good as the DKReturns version of Superman.
Replysaid at 10:27 PM on Thu Feb 14 2013
Mark Valley's isn't that bad. It's pretty good actually.
Replysaid at 6:59 PM on Thu Feb 14 2013
My issue with Mark is two things, one he sounds too young for the superman he's playing. Two, his voice is too...modern for lack of a better term for something like the dark knight rises (which apparently is set in the future and the 80s at the same time)
Replysaid at 4:25 PM on Thu Feb 14 2013
Mark doesn't have the strength in the voice that some of the others had
Replysaid at 12:33 AM on Sat Feb 9 2013
George Newbern or Tim Daly? Decisions... Decisions...
Replysaid at 8:35 PM on Mon Jan 7 2013
I'm not sure, I want to say Tim Daly because he's the first superman and he sounds patriotic which is great for Clark, but then there's George Newbern and he gives Superman an edge. he makes him more human by giving him anger during some episodes of Justice League and Superman vs. the Elite. in fact when I try to mimic Tim's voice in comic books I keep getting George instead.
Replysaid at 2:18 PM on Mon Feb 11 2013
@ZangetzuBLK I want to see Daly do more dramatic scenes. There are scenes in Superman The Animated Series, but not to the magnitude of what Newbern gets.
Replysaid at 3:12 AM on Thu Jan 3 2013
Travis Willingham as Superman reminds me that he should voice Aquaman.
Replysaid at 8:55 PM on Mon Jan 7 2013
@Mr.Fennoy93 You know what? that is a great idea! in fact it can work for serious moments and humor! if anyone can pull that off it's Travis.
Replysaid at 11:23 PM on Fri Jan 18 2013
@Mr.Fennoy93 That'd better not be a slant against Travis, considering how much you hate Aquaman.
Replysaid at 11:28 PM on Fri Jan 18 2013
@TheVengeanceKnight I Like Aquaman. My Brother does Not.
What's Intresting though he's the first to portray Hulk, Thor & Superman together. When Aquaman joins, Mindblown Awesomeness. He should star in the Next Superman animated Film.
ReplyWhat's Intresting though he's the first to portray Hulk, Thor & Superman together. When Aquaman joins, Mindblown Awesomeness. He should star in the Next Superman animated Film.
said at 8:54 PM on Fri Apr 19 2013
@Mr.Fennoy93 He would be an awesome Aquaman
Replysaid at 12:44 PM on Wed Dec 5 2012
My 4 favorites
1. Tim Daly
2. George Newbern
3. Nolan North
4. Adam Baldwin
Reply1. Tim Daly
2. George Newbern
3. Nolan North
4. Adam Baldwin
said at 7:32 AM on Sat Nov 17 2012
George Newbern
Tim Daly
Travis Willingham
Yuri Lowenthal
ReplyTim Daly
Travis Willingham
Yuri Lowenthal
said at 6:16 AM on Sun Nov 11 2012
I've been catching episodes of Superman TAS on The Hub lately and after hearing Tim Daly as Clark, I'm going to give my vote to him.
That said, after Tim, my new rankings are:
George Newbern
Mark Harmon
Nolan North
David Kaye
ReplyThat said, after Tim, my new rankings are:
George Newbern
Mark Harmon
Nolan North
David Kaye
said at 5:02 PM on Tue Sep 18 2012
top three for me would have to be
1Tim Daly
2George Newbern
3Mark Harmon
Reply1Tim Daly
2George Newbern
3Mark Harmon
said at 1:11 PM on Mon Jul 23 2012
Sticking with Tim Daly though I like hearing the Superman theme in Travis Willingham's clip.
Replysaid at 12:26 AM on Tue Jul 17 2012
Tim Daly is probably my overall favorite, with Nolan North as least favorite. George Newbern started off a bit shaky but he improved a lot over the years, as evidenced by "Superman Vs. The Elite".
Replysaid at 8:22 PM on Wed Jun 27 2012
George and Tim are the best. I think I slightly prefer George, but Tim's great too!
Replysaid at 11:21 PM on Tue Jun 26 2012
After having watched Superman VS. The Elite, I'm gonna change my vote to George Newbern. Yeah, he was good before, but that was one of his best performaces as Superman (if not THE best) and I think he might've outdone Daly there.
Replysaid at 11:45 PM on Thu Jun 28 2012
@Anicomicgeek On second thought, while George Newbern was good, I prefer prefer Tim Daly more, so I'm gonna change my vote back to him.
Replysaid at 12:48 PM on Fri Jun 29 2012
@Anicomicgeek I meant to say "I still prefer Tim Daly more."^^;
Replysaid at 1:13 PM on Mon Jul 23 2012
@Anicomicgeek Yeah i know right? I think that in the DCAU Tim was the better of the two but in Superman VS. The Elite Newbern no doubt out did Dal. His performance there had stuff his DCAU performance and all others lacked.
Replysaid at 2:22 PM on Mon Jul 23 2012
@pete No offense, but I did post a retraction before you replied, so I no longer stand by that statement.
Replysaid at 8:14 PM on Tue Jun 12 2012
There were a few stinkers, but I have a top 4 ( not in any particular order):
George Newborn
Tim Daly
James Denton
Yuri Lowenthal
Which is my number one?... I guess George Newborn.
ReplyGeorge Newborn
Tim Daly
James Denton
Yuri Lowenthal
Which is my number one?... I guess George Newborn.
said at 8:18 PM on Sun May 20 2012
1. George Newbern
2. Tim Daly
3. Mark Harmon
4. Michael Daingerfield Hall
5. Christopher Corey Smith
Reply2. Tim Daly
3. Mark Harmon
4. Michael Daingerfield Hall
5. Christopher Corey Smith
said at 3:30 AM on Sun May 6 2012
It's official Tim Daly was is the better voice George sounds like a lighter version and well some of his emotion was good Daly could have been better in JL/JLU. A shame he let for a show that bombed.
Replysaid at 9:23 PM on Tue May 8 2012
@SLEDGERAID It was a remake of the original 60's version of the The Fugitive. That show was later made into a 1993 movie with Harrison Ford. The remake series however was canceled after 1 season of 22 episodes and ended in 2001 so bad decision TIm Daly's part which is probably the main reason. why he reprised his role for Brainiac Attacks and Superman/Batman Public Enemies and Superman/Batman Apocalypse.
Replysaid at 2:44 AM on Wed May 9 2012
@pete The Fugitive that sounds familiar, and well that sux at least Daly is reprising every so often
Replysaid at 10:54 PM on Thu May 3 2012
Did George Newbern do a Tim Daly impression when he took over or was it an original voice?
Replysaid at 12:58 PM on Fri May 4 2012
@pete It's an original voice, Pete. :)
I'm updating my top picks for Clark now;
Tim Daly
George Newbern
David Kaye
James Denton
Mark Harmon
Crispin Freeman
Yuri Lowenthal
Brandon Routh
and now adding Keith Ferguson. :)
ReplyI'm updating my top picks for Clark now;
Tim Daly
George Newbern
David Kaye
James Denton
Mark Harmon
Crispin Freeman
Yuri Lowenthal
Brandon Routh
and now adding Keith Ferguson. :)
said at 7:51 PM on Fri May 4 2012
@BigBDawg Tim is the better of the two because George sounds too light and Tim was deep with his voice and more emotional. For some version George's voice sounds distortred in his clip. This is the only way to tell the difference between the two.
Replysaid at 11:06 PM on Wed May 2 2012
Was Warburton doing a Seinfeld parody in his clip?
Replysaid at 10:23 PM on Wed May 2 2012
THAT'S Keith Ferguson?! O_O WOAH. I would have never guessed it's him.
Him, Newbern, and Daly are my favorites. Nolan North needs to do more stuff with him, but I like his Superman too.
ReplyHim, Newbern, and Daly are my favorites. Nolan North needs to do more stuff with him, but I like his Superman too.
said at 10:10 PM on Wed May 2 2012
Keith Ferguson was pretty good as the SBFF version of Superman. That said, I'm sticking with Tim Daly.
Replysaid at 9:57 PM on Wed May 2 2012
"You're not my dad!"
"No, but I AM Superman."
Best comeback ever.
Reply"No, but I AM Superman."
Best comeback ever.
said at 6:02 AM on Thu May 3 2012
@NCZ "MOOOOOOOOOM!!!"
Wow, what a way to ruin an awesome moment.
ReplyWow, what a way to ruin an awesome moment.
said at 9:22 PM on Thu May 3 2012
@TheVengeanceKnight She gave him a wedie, the moment was ruined
Replysaid at 9:48 PM on Wed May 2 2012
George Newbern was my favorite, and Tim Daly was good too. Keith Ferguson, wow, I wouldnt have guessed that was him, he does a pretty good job!
Replysaid at 7:34 PM on Thu Apr 12 2012
My top picks for Kal/Clark;
Tim Daly
George Newbern
David Kaye
James Denton
Mark Harmon
Crispin Freeman
Yuri Lowenthal
and Brandon Routh
ReplyTim Daly
George Newbern
David Kaye
James Denton
Mark Harmon
Crispin Freeman
Yuri Lowenthal
and Brandon Routh
said at 6:46 PM on Tue Apr 3 2012
Roger Rose definitely sounds like his Kent Powers' voice
Replysaid at 4:21 PM on Tue Apr 3 2012
My faves are definitely
Tim Daly
George Newbern
Adam Baldwin
Nolan North (I didn't like his portrayal of Father, but his voice grew on me)
Christopher Corey Smith
Patrick Warburton?! - LOL Kronk as Superman?
ReplyTim Daly
George Newbern
Adam Baldwin
Nolan North (I didn't like his portrayal of Father, but his voice grew on me)
Christopher Corey Smith
Patrick Warburton?! - LOL Kronk as Superman?
said at 12:32 PM on Tue Apr 3 2012
Wow; Jethro Gibbs and Mike Delfino have both been Superman!
Replysaid at 9:05 AM on Sun Feb 26 2012
My vote went to Newbern but they're all good. There are a few guys that I feel don't fit the character very well (Adam Baldwin, Crispin Freeman & David Lodge) but I didn't think they were HORRIBLE either, just miscast. This is a tough one, they're all so good.
Replysaid at 5:40 PM on Wed Feb 8 2012
My favorite Superman voices for years were Tim Daly and Beau Weaver. But I was surprised at how well David Kaye works for me as Superman. That's pretty much the Superman voice I've always had in my head: the kind of voice that makes you immediately picture a square jaw, but with the kind of personality that would make him a relatable guy.
Replysaid at 12:32 AM on Sun Feb 5 2012
So from what it looks like on the page the American Express commercial was making fun of Seinfeld and Warburton was cast because of his role as Puddy.
Replysaid at 3:53 AM on Wed Jan 25 2012
My favorite is George Newbern, Tim Daly was like the one that nailed it yea but George Newbern Grew into me like crazy hell I did not even notice that it was a diffrent actor wen justice League came on, Nolan North is cool as Superboy but as Superman I wish Daly or newbern reprised there roles in Young Justice.
Replysaid at 11:49 PM on Sat Oct 29 2011
Really can't decide between Daly and Newbern. I guess I'll go with Newbern, since he doesn't get as much love, and his clip is AWESOME.
Replysaid at 8:43 PM on Wed Oct 19 2011
I like Tim Daly, George Newbern, Nolan North,
James Denton and Kyle MacLachlan.
ReplyJames Denton and Kyle MacLachlan.
said at 12:33 PM on Tue Oct 18 2011
Tim Daly is my personal favorite as Superman. I felt he really nailed the character, though George Newbern is a worthy successor. Christopher McDonald also worked as an older Superman. Mark Harmon does sound like a good middle ground between Daly and Newbern, IMO.
Yuri Lowenthal also worked pretty well as a younger Superman/Superboy. I'd like to see him played either a Superboy or Superman again. Adam Baldwin also works well as Superman, as does Crispin Freeman.
James Denton works well as Superman in All-Star Superman. Kyle MacLachlan also worked pretty well as Superman in TNF and Rgoer Rsoe nailed the Silver Age Superman on B: TBatB. David Kaye's Superman also seems inspired by the Silver Age and It hink he works well for that version.
IMO, Nolan North is miscast as both Superman AND Superboy. Hisperformance doesn't work for either of them and it doesn't help that YJ made Superman an uncharacteristic jerk and Superboy a quick to angry emo.
ReplyYuri Lowenthal also worked pretty well as a younger Superman/Superboy. I'd like to see him played either a Superboy or Superman again. Adam Baldwin also works well as Superman, as does Crispin Freeman.
James Denton works well as Superman in All-Star Superman. Kyle MacLachlan also worked pretty well as Superman in TNF and Rgoer Rsoe nailed the Silver Age Superman on B: TBatB. David Kaye's Superman also seems inspired by the Silver Age and It hink he works well for that version.
IMO, Nolan North is miscast as both Superman AND Superboy. Hisperformance doesn't work for either of them and it doesn't help that YJ made Superman an uncharacteristic jerk and Superboy a quick to angry emo.
said at 8:59 PM on Fri Apr 19 2013
@Anicomicgeek I'm inclined to agree. I've enjoyed Nolan North in other stuff he's done (Ultimate Avengers, Hulk Vs., Crisis on 2 Earths, TMNT) but his voice was a poor fit for Superman, lacking the warmth, power and nobility we expect from Superman. Maybe that isn't fair since the show wrote Superman as a jerk and never gave him or his relationship with Superboy any proper development (and I don't really care about Superboy in any incarnation). I also felt North was miscast as Cyclops as well (who also got written badly on W&TXM). But North will always be an awesome Deadpool. :)
Replysaid at 9:10 PM on Tue May 21 2013
@Anicomicgeek If Johnathan and Martha knew how he treated Superboy they would probably have something to say about that. Especially Johnathan since he accepted Superboy as "one of his boys".
Replysaid at 3:58 PM on Sun Oct 16 2011
Well, so many good ones, it's hard to decide. Just from doing the voices, they're all tied at first place.
Also, what RabidSonicFan said.
ReplyAlso, what RabidSonicFan said.
said at 12:59 PM on Mon Oct 10 2011
Kyle and Mark are pretty great. Mark is famous for playing a badass boss/ hero, so that makes him perfect.
Replysaid at 7:54 PM on Sat Sep 24 2011
Woah, Denton's clip sounds like it has a major spoiler in it
Replysaid at 9:40 AM on Mon Sep 5 2011
I honestly can't pick *one* voice, most of them are excellent in their own way. Some of my favorites:
Tim Daly and George Newbern- They honestly sound kind of similar in terms of their "hero voice", but Daly and Newbern do a great job in their respective series. Newbern also gets to play around a little more with Superman's anger issues on Justice League/JLU.
Adam Baldwin-For a rougher Superman, Baldwin's voice is a great fit, and he also does a wonderful job of differentiating the original and clone Superman in his acting without really changing the voice.
Kyle MacLachlan- He's got that strange, 50s quality to his voice, which works perfectly for a period piece like New Frontier.
James Denton-Denton has a softer voice than we're used to from Superman, but that fits the more introspective qualities of All-Star Superman, and he still has plenty of authority in it.
ReplyTim Daly and George Newbern- They honestly sound kind of similar in terms of their "hero voice", but Daly and Newbern do a great job in their respective series. Newbern also gets to play around a little more with Superman's anger issues on Justice League/JLU.
Adam Baldwin-For a rougher Superman, Baldwin's voice is a great fit, and he also does a wonderful job of differentiating the original and clone Superman in his acting without really changing the voice.
Kyle MacLachlan- He's got that strange, 50s quality to his voice, which works perfectly for a period piece like New Frontier.
James Denton-Denton has a softer voice than we're used to from Superman, but that fits the more introspective qualities of All-Star Superman, and he still has plenty of authority in it.
said at 3:11 PM on Wed Aug 3 2011
Patrick Warburton as Superman? That's... interesting... XD
Replysaid at 5:43 PM on Fri Jun 17 2011
For all these years I thought the voice for STAS and JLU were the same person. They sound so much alike.
Replysaid at 4:06 AM on Sun Dec 20 2009
Yeah I remember the fugiive TV series Daly also starred opposite his mother Tyne Daly in Jusging Amy on CBS ... honestly like I said for the DCAU Superman voices Daly and Newbern are best ever. Adam Baldwin was a joke in Superman Doomsday. then again if I had huge cracks in my face I'd be funny. (Superman Doomsday model)
Replysaid at 4:37 PM on Sun Nov 29 2009
actually, Daly starred in the lead role of short lived "The Fugitive" series, based off the Harrison Ford movie.
Replysaid at 6:14 AM on Tue Mar 25 2014
@Foxwolf which itself was based off the 1960's series with David Jansen
Replysaid at 12:18 PM on Sat Nov 28 2009
I think Daly was suppose to reprise his role for Justice League/Justice League Unlimited but also had the chance to star in a TV series (Private Practice - spinoff of Grey's Anatomy). He would get more $ and overall better exposure for his career so he took it. Then George Newbern auditioned and got the role for Superman.
Replysaid at 7:28 AM on Sat Nov 28 2009
the JL Crisis On Two Earths movie voice will be Mark Harmon of NCIS.
I never got the change from Daly to Newbern so I think of the,m both as the #1 superman animated voice.
ReplyI never got the change from Daly to Newbern so I think of the,m both as the #1 superman animated voice.
said at 12:41 PM on Wed Nov 11 2009
ALL SUPERMAN VA NOW ADDED!
Just added Michael Daingerfield Hall and Bud Collyer.
Now we just wait until Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths for a new one. :)
ReplyJust added Michael Daingerfield Hall and Bud Collyer.
Now we just wait until Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths for a new one. :)
said at 3:38 PM on Thu Aug 6 2009
preferably with him saying:
"This is a job... For SUPERMAN."
Reply"This is a job... For SUPERMAN."
said at 4:06 PM on Sun Jun 28 2009
that daly clip has too much luthor and not enough daly...
Replysaid at 4:01 PM on Sun Jun 28 2009
Glad you stopped by Chris let us know if we can do anything to make the site better!
Replysaid at 3:22 AM on Sun May 24 2009
Thanks Christopher!
Hope u keep coming back, we'll be adding forums and many other features to expand the site.
ReplyHope u keep coming back, we'll be adding forums and many other features to expand the site.
said at 12:43 AM on Sun May 24 2009
Wow, its an honor to have a celebrity visit our site :)
And with that, u r now part of the gang :P Though I've had a little trouble finding a photo of you.
Any chance you could post us a photo link of u to add?
ReplyAnd with that, u r now part of the gang :P Though I've had a little trouble finding a photo of you.
Any chance you could post us a photo link of u to add?
said at 9:18 PM on Wed Apr 22 2009
You forgot to add:
Bud Collyer (Fleischer Superman, 60s Superman)
Danny Dark (Superfriends)
Beau Weaver (Ruby-Spears Superman)
ReplyBud Collyer (Fleischer Superman, 60s Superman)
Danny Dark (Superfriends)
Beau Weaver (Ruby-Spears Superman)
said at 5:40 AM on Fri Jul 13 2018