Clumsy Smurf
Smurfs Smurfs

Clumsy Smurf

Comparison of the voice actors who have been the voice of Clumsy Smurf with sound clips and images.

Number of Comparisons: 2
Franchise: Smurfs

Clumsy Smurf is the Smurf-villager that always seems to be tumbling around, yet laughing at it!

Created by solidejake on Aug 24 2015

EDITOR'S OPINION

Good evening Smurfs and Smurfettes! Welcome to another day of Hanna-Barbera Month (Still going strong). Today, we are going to be looking at a quick mash-up of both of Clumsy Smurf (originally known as Dimwitted Smurf)'s English actors. Come check it out.

Bill Callaway - As the original actor from The Smurfs, Bill is a lot more true to the origins of "Dimwitted Smurf" by portraying more than just clumsiness, but absent-mindedness as well. It always seems that Clumsy is tumbling over things, but at least he gets a good laugh at it while he's at it.

Anton Yelchin - Now for the more-recent movie adaptation of The Smurfs, Clumsy is played a lot more light-hearted. Anton portrays a version of the character that kind of seems to trip every once in a while and seems embarrassed by it. He also seems a tad brighter. While the more cinematic approach is understandable, and not bad by any means, I don't think that it lives up to the original.

To straighten things out, I have to give my vote to the original voice, Bill Callaway, as he made the character far more iconic. While Anton was good in his own right, I found the character to be far more "Generic Smurf" rather than a specific one.


solidejake

Comments

Add a Comment

Faved by 2 BTVA Members
Share/Save/Bookmark
BTVA POLL
Who do you think has been the best from these Clumsy Smurf voice actors?
Bill Callaway
Anton Yelchin