EDITOR'S OPINIONToday on the Silent Hill VC section we take a look at this big guy from SH2... EDDIE DOMBROWSKI! Let us begin...
David Schaufele- David's voice for the role is not really bad but I do think it is a bit too high. But David's performance was pretty good as a young man who seemed to be normal at first but becomes increasingly insane. So in other words its a somewhat above average example of his work and a good example of the voice work in the original release of Silent Hill 2.
Liam O'Brien- First of all I will say that this is a rather interesting change of pace for Liam here. Liam's somewhat rougher voice works pretty well for the role and his performance suits Eddie's persona really well. While Liam does a fine job in playying Eddie a somewhat oafish nice guy I really liked Liam's performance when Eddie is getting crazier and crazier as it feels suitably intense and even at times chilling. So basically Liam's work as Eddie is a great example of his work and of the voice work in the HD Collection version of the game.
Overall while neither one are bad I am clearly going with Liam here.