EDITOR'S OPINIONLadies and gentlemen we know look at the other aunt, Hilda!
Jane Webb: Jane gives a good "typical witch" kind of voice but she did well to give Hilda a sense of humor and did sound like she was enjoying herself.
Caroline Rhea: Comedian and actor, Caroline Rhea was another actor from the original sitcom to reprise their role in this game. Caroline has had plenty of energy and comedic timing to really make this version of Hilda sound like the scattered brain that she is and sound like she's having fun. This is a good example of Caroline's voice acting.
Melissa Joan Hart: Melissa does a higher voice for Hilda (to contrast with the lower voice she gave Zelda) and does fit for the more party girl version of Hilda. However, sometimes her voice didn't come off as natural and (like I mentioned in the Zelda compare) she would slip in and out of her Hilda and Zelda voices and this would be confusing when the two argued. Still, it is an enjoyable performance and is a good example of Melissa Joan Hart's voice acting.
Moneca Stori: Much like all of the cast from the animated series, Hilda was recasted after DiC was no longer apart of Disney. That said, Meneca was a natural in the role. She also gave a pretty high voice for Hilda but she came off as more natural and had a good amount of energy. This is a good example of Moneca's voice work and Friends Forever (and Secret Life's) casting .
In the end each of these ladies did a very good job but my personal favorites are Moneca and Carline but Melissa and Jane are very close seconds.