EDITOR'S OPINIONAlright folks today on the Rankin Bass Classics VC section we take a look at this cranky old elf... FOREMAN ELF! Let us begin...
Carl Banas- Carl's voice felt rather natural for the role as a cantakerous old-fashioned elf as his performance does suit the Foreman Elf's authoritative nature rather well. So in other words its a fine example of Carl's work and a good example of the voice work in that classic specuial.
Peter Kelamis- While this movie contained some very good to exceptionnal cases of vocal mimicry this example of vocal mimicry on the other hand was pretty good at best. While Peter's voice for the role does have a similar sense of gruffness that Carl's did but I do think that Peter's voice for the role is a bit too high. But to be fair Peter's performance does suit the Foreman Elf's hot-tempered nature pretty well. So in other words while its not one of the better performances in that movie its still a pretty good example nevertheless.
Overall I will go with Carl as his work is rather classic but Peter's work on the role is pretty good too.