Created by NCZ on Feb 15 2019
Well... I'll do my best.
Andrew Chaikin: Andrew goes for a more subdued take on Dio, which fits the OVA's overall darker tone than the series. I actually have a soft spot for his performance, it's one of the most memorable from the OVA's dub. I think the direction clearly shows the crew and cast were new to dubbing anime, but Andrew still turns in as good work as possible with those conditions.
Patrick Seitz: Patrick hams it up far more. He's better in Stardust Crusaders when they don't make everybody do those ridiculous accents. Despite Patrick being more experienced in dubbing, I just can't shake that he doesn't quite click with me as "Dio" rather than "Patrick as Dio". Despite all that he's probably about as good as a non-union Dio in 2017 could've been.
Overall: Takehito Koyasu. (And Isshin Chiba.)