EDITOR'S OPINIONMerry Chirstmas everyone! Here is a little present from BTVA and its a VC for the most famous Snowman of all... FROSTY THE SNOW MAN! Let us begin...
Jackie Vernon- Jackie's work as Frosty is easily one of the biggest reasons why the original Frosty special is such a classic. Jackie's voice and performance suit the role's friendly and enderingly child-like nature very well.
John Goodman- John is quite a natural choice for this role I will say this much. However while John's performance does suit Frosty's friendly nature well John does seem to be playing the role somewhat differently though. (Namely playing Frosty as a more friendly smooth-talker like Baloo than the more child-like being he is traditionally known as.) But rest assured this is no complaint as John does a fine job in making it work and its a good example of his voice work.
Bill Faggerbakke- Bill is also a VERY natural choice for the role as he does a fine job in playing Frosty as a lovable oaf with a slight mischeivous side to him. While Bill does play the role of Frosty with a child-like glee like what the late Jackie did but Bill does in a way make the role his own as well. So in other words Bill's take on the role is very solid and is another fine example of his work.
Overall I am basically going with a tie here as while Jackie's work is very classic but John and Bill also do a very fine job as well.