EDITOR'S OPINIONChuck Huber's the voice actor who's played Pilaf lonest (in English), so he's the one who's pretty much got to go with him and flesh him out from beginning to end. His screechy but raspy voice is a natural fit for the diminutive dictator... wannabe, and is very reminiscent of Shigeru Chiba's original take. Dean Galloway's played him the second longest and his take is pretty different, going for a more gravelly voice that makes the comedy more understated. I kinda wish Don Brown got more to do with him - his take has some pretty obvious potential to it. Dave Mallow's voice plays up more of the lighthearted aspects and McFarland's fairly similar to Chuck Huber, but didn't get as much to do, what with being a one-off and all.
Overall, I give my vote to Chuck Huber.