Remember Me?

Don't have an account? Join BTVA

Browse VOICE COMPARE

#	A	B	C	D	E	F
G	H	I	J	K	L	M
N	O	P	Q	R	S	T
U	V	W	X	Y	Z

LATEST COMMENT

"Menville's performance feels genuinely, and his voice really fits Lloyd's character. On the flip side, Beacock's performances in both DotNW and RM feel forced and I feel his voice doesn't mesh well with the character. Scott Menville all the way. Hope he comes back if they remake Symphonia."

By Dimentionalist at 11:38 AM on Sat Mar 30 2013

Read All Add Comment

OTHER TALES COMPARES

CHECK OUT MORE »

Lloyd Irving

Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Lloyd Irving with sound clips and images.

Created by CatsTuxedo on Sat Aug 21 2010, 7 Comments, Add Comment

Tales of Symphonia (2004)

Scott Menville

Tales of Symphonia: Dawn of the New World (2008)

Brian Beacock

EDITOR'S OPINION

Scott easily has my vote. It's much more distinctive and feels more "real" than Brian.

CatsTuxedo

Latest Comments

Add a Comment

Dimentionalist
said at 11:38 AM on Sat Mar 30 2013

Menville's performance feels genuinely, and his voice really fits Lloyd's character. On the flip side, Beacock's performances in both DotNW and RM feel forced and I feel his voice doesn't mesh well with the character. Scott Menville all the way. Hope he comes back if they remake Symphonia.

VanOsdel 0123
said at 1:24 PM on Tue Apr 3 2012

I also prefer Scott M., maybe they should redub Dawn of The New World.
Besides, Brian B. is not my vote. What do you think?

ConfusedPhantom
said at 3:18 AM on Thu Mar 22 2012

Gonna go with Scott Menville. His acting's great, and he fit the character to a tea. It's a darn shame he didn't reprise. Beacock isn't terrible, though. He probably sounds closer to the Japanese VA, but Menville was still the more enjoyable performance.

JTurner
said at 11:20 AM on Sat Mar 5 2011

I dunno, I kinda like both for different reasons. Scott does a great job of making Lloyd exuberant and youthful, while Brian effectively makes Lloyd sound experienced and even a bit shadowy. Both are very good in the role, although Scott definitely gets my vote.

Sonic_Blaze
said at 12:07 AM on Thu Feb 10 2011

Lloyd grew up so a change in voice was a way of showing that. Plus Lloyd sounded more cool minded and grown up more.

twye (Guest)
said at 7:48 PM on Sun Dec 19 2010

I agree with the comment before me. Scott all the way man. I still don't get why they changed his voice. I was PO'd when I noticed it. If ToS II was focused on Lloyd I wouldn't have played it. Emil/Ratatosk and Marta made the game for me.

briancurtis (Guest)
said at 1:23 PM on Wed Dec 1 2010

Beacock makes my soul weep... Scott feels much more natural, his acting's better, and Beacock's performance was incredibly forced. What an awful change!