Super Mario Bros. Super Mario Bros.


Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Toadette with sound clips and images.
Franchise: Super Mario Bros.

Toadette is a character from the Super Mario Bros series in which she made her debut in Mario Kart Double Dash for the Gamecube. Toadette is simply known as a female counterpart to Toad (however unlike Toad the games do make it clear that Toadette is a unique character and not just Toads whom happen to be girls). The relationship with Toadette and Toad is a bit inconsistent as they are sometimes referred to as siblings and sometimes they are referred to as friends. However Toadette does aid Mario and has mainly appeared in the Mario Spin-Offs
Created by Pokejedservo on Sep 1 2011
Mario Kart: Double Dash!! (2003)
ToadetteJen Taylor
Jen Taylor
Mario Party 8 (2007)
ToadetteSamantha Kelly
Samantha Kelly


Today on the Super Mario Bros. VC section we have a little something for this cutesy little female counterpart of Toad... TOADETTE! We shall begin with Toadette's initial appearance as Toad's partner in the Race where she was voiced by Jen Taylor. Jen is of course no stranger in doing cutesy higher voices for Nintendo games however I do think that this is one of her better ones though. While Jen's voice for Toadette is suitably cute but it also came off kind of natural to me as well. So in other words Jen's work as Toadette is a good example of her work in the Mario Franchise.

While Jen did reprise her role as Toadette in the Mario Party games it was until Mario Party 8 in which Samantha Kelly took over the role here. While yes Samantha did take over all of Jen Taylor's roles in the Mario series ever since the late 2000's but unlike her work such as Peach and Toad, Samantha's Toadette voice does sound a bit different compared to Jen's. (Not necessarily complaining mind you, just an observation.) Though it seems like Samantha's Toadette sounds like her Toad voice but remove the rasp but add in a little bit of femininity to which does work with the role fairly well. Overall I am not entirely sure who to go with as both of these gals did OK with this role.



Add a Comment

said at 7:31 PM on Thu Aug 10 2017
Jen Taylor and Samantha Kelly both work as Toadette, but I think I might go with Taylor just a bit more.
said at 8:38 PM on Tue Feb 13 2018
@greenman26 Just like with Bowser Jr, I could honestly go with either voice as Toadette.
Ed Red
said at 7:37 PM on Thu Jun 22 2017
said at 7:50 AM on Sun Aug 28 2016
Gave my vote to Samantha.
said at 6:36 PM on Sun May 29 2016
jen because toadette's scream is hilarious in mp6
Joel the Pokekid
said at 2:05 PM on Wed Mar 23 2016
I pick Samantha Kelly. Jen Taylor sounds too much like a guy to me.
Swiftie Muggle
said at 11:05 AM on Mon Mar 9 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
Jen Taylor Obviously. Samantha may have an identical Peach and Toad's voice to make up for her , but her Toadette sounds too much like Toad , even in Mario Golf WT Toadette voice is raspy! lol . Jen never messed up her characters , all of them sounded clearly different.
said at 7:01 AM on Fri Feb 6 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
1) Jen Taylor
2) Samantha Kelly
said at 10:05 AM on Thu Jul 10 2014
I pick samantha.
said at 4:04 AM on Thu Jun 5 2014
They sound very similar but there is a bit of difference and I find Jen is better
said at 8:57 AM on Tue Jun 3 2014
 1 Shout Out!
Jen's Toadette sounds so adorable that I can't help but vore for it.

Don't get me wrong, Samantha did a really great job but I just love the sound of cute voices from cute characters. Ah music to my ears.
said at 8:57 AM on Tue Jun 3 2014
said at 12:08 AM on Thu Oct 23 2014
@Ross123 And it sounds different from her Toad, I notice from Sam's clip it sounds like her Toad
said at 8:41 AM on Thu Oct 23 2014
@HienFan I think Jen's Toadette sounds better than her Toad. And yes, I noticed that Sam's does sound just like her Toad.
said at 5:03 AM on Fri Oct 24 2014
@Ross123 She is much cuter than Toad certainly, just because she's a female counterpart doesn't mean she has to sound like Toad

Though Jen's Toad is waaaaay better than her Peach(she sounds like she's on helium on the late N64/Gamecube days ack)
said at 11:52 AM on Sat Oct 25 2014
@HienFan I never said that she has to sound like Toad. I said Jen does a better job here than voicing Toad and Sam sounding just like her Toad. Those statements don't necessarily mean they have to sound alike.

And I agree, Jen's Toad is better than her Peach as I found her annoying to listen to.
said at 2:06 AM on Tue Jan 13 2015
@Ross123 I meant that Toadette didn't need to sound like Toad himself so therefore I think Jen is better as this character

Jen's a great actress as Toad, Toadette and Daisy but as Peach err wut...
said at 3:27 PM on Thu Jan 15 2015
@HienFan Ok that makes sense and I agree with on Jen anyway.

As for Jen as Peach, it's just an opinion. If you disagree with it that's fine.
said at 3:54 PM on Thu Jan 15 2015
@HienFan I just realised I didn't like Jen as Peach. I completely forgot about my comments on the Peach compare. Probably because it was a while ago so just ignore that last comment.
said at 12:36 AM on Thu Apr 9 2015
@Ross123 As I said on Peach's page she could sound okay)that clip on this site was absolutely horrible(though her screams as Peach could get really ugly) and while Samantha got less irritating as Toadette this is a case I feel like Jen's departure of Nintendo is badly missed on my side, she's so cuuuute as Toadette
said at 9:30 AM on Mon Apr 13 2015
@HienFan I agree. Like we both said, Jen's Toadette sounds cute & adorable so changing it was a bit of a bad move, for us anyway.

The majority of people prefer Samantha so we'll just have to accept that. I know I do because she's pretty good in her own right.
said at 9:54 PM on Mon Apr 13 2015
@Ross123 I think that's because Jen quit voicing Nintendo projects on her own is why almost all her remaining roles save for Daisy is voiced by Samantha Kelly
said at 1:19 PM on Wed Apr 15 2015
@HienFan Oh I didn't know that. I was thinking it was because Nintendo replaced her but I was wrong.
said at 9:48 PM on Wed Apr 15 2015
@Ross123 At least they didn't hire Nicole Mills for Toadette at that brief period Jen left but Samantha wasn't hired yet
said at 12:14 PM on Mon Apr 20 2015
@HienFan I've only ever heard Nicole as Peach, to which I did not enjoy.

Can't really say anything bad about her since I've only heard 1 role from her. And I don't plan on it either, doesn't interest me enough.
said at 9:11 PM on Wed Sep 16 2015
@Ross123 NOw that I think about it Sam got a bit better after Toadette got a hiatus(though that scream stuck...) but Jen is still cuter
said at 6:27 AM on Sun Dec 27 2015
@Ross123 Looked up Youtube scratch that they sound identical except for a minor thing that was a reverse of Peach for those two actresses, Samantha has a weird scream as Toadetter wher else for Peach it was Jen who had a weird scream
said at 6:37 PM on Sun May 29 2016
@Ross123 i find toadette's scream hilarious in mario party 6.
said at 6:39 PM on Sun Dec 1 2013
 1 Shout Out!
#1. Samantha Kelly
#2. Jen Taylor
said at 12:08 PM on Mon Oct 7 2013
Samantha, hands down!
said at 9:26 PM on Thu Oct 3 2013
Well, both voices sound a little nasally, but maybe that was the point. I don't know, their voices sound similar to me.
said at 7:59 PM on Mon Sep 5 2011
Both were fantastic (not to mention a whole lot better than their Toad voices), bringing out Toadette's joyness and vitality, but I slightly prefer Samantha's; her performance has more emotion and liveliness to it.
Faved by 8 BTVA Members

Support Behind The Voice Actors on Patreon
What is Patreon?
Who do you think has been the best from these Toadette voice actors?
Jen Taylor
Samantha Kelly