Voice Compare » Super Mario Bros. » Princess Peach

I actually quite like Kozuki's portrayal. Engrish aside, I find it to be unique (and oddly cute).

On a completely different note, does anyone else get a "she's-totally-going-to-murder-me-in-my-sleep" vibe from the "Mario is Missing" Peach?

1. Samantha Kelly
2. Leslie Swan
3. Tracey Moore
4. Asako Kozuki
5. Jeannie Elias (her acting is a lot to be desired for me)
6. Jocelyn Benford (same thing as Jeannie but didn't sound annoying or wierd like the last 3)
7. Nicolle Mills
8. Jen Taylor
9. Unknown voice actress

Wow, this is a big comparison, but I'll do my best:


1. Samantha Kelly

This is probably the only high-pitched Peach voice that doesn't sound annoying. Samantha pretty much nails Peach's personality, but also has some fun with it too. So she deserves my vote.


2. Jeannie Elias

Her voice is my favorite of the cartoon series, as it sounds very cute and innocent. Her pitch isn't overly high like most of the recent voices are, which is a plus for me. Overall, a pleasure to listen to.


3. Jen Taylor

While Jen did sound like she inhaled helium to do the voice at times, I still liked the enthusiasm she provided. I kinda missed her when she left voicing for the Mario Franchise in 2006.


4. Tracey Moore

This voice is okay, but to me it's not quite as likable as the voice Jeannie provided. Still, it's suitable for how the character was like in the cartoons.


5. Leslie Swan

Her voice may not be high pitched, but that doesn't mean it sounds bad. But since Leslie Swan is not really a voice actress (she's actually a localization manager for Nintendo) she probably isn't properly cut for the job anyway.


6. Unknown

This voice is actually okay, but it's way too young for Peach. If Peach were a little girl, this might have been more suitable.


7. Nicole Mills

Sounds like Nicole was trying to imitate Jen Taylor's Peach voice, and partially failed at doing that. It's rather annoying for the most part.


8. Jocelyn Benford

Ugh...Jocelyn sounded like she was reading directly from a script, with a painfully wooden performance to go with it. The voice itself sounds a bit too old for Peach also.


Asako Kozuki shouldn't even be in this comparison as she's Japanese-born and English is clearly not her native language. It doesn't help that her attempt at voicing the character was painful to listen to...


Anyways, overall, there were a few good voices and a few...not so good voices. Samantha Kelly is the winner for me.

After M64 her voice became SO HIGH! Taylor's voice, for example sounds like a little girl.

Overall, I'm going with Lesile Swan

To be honest I dislike Peach ever since Mario Party 4. She seems a lot ditzier than her N64 days but let's get started

1 Leslie Swan-Other than Mario 64 I think she sounds really good
2 Tracey Moore
3 Jeannie Elias
4 Samantha Kelly-She got a few good lines but really now
5 Jen Taylor-Minnie Mouse... I don't like Minnie Mouse but...
6 Jocelyn Benford
7 Asako-I normally can't stand Japanese voices
8 Unkown
9 Nicole Mills- Oh looooord a cheap Jen Taylor

In Mario is Missing, dear lawd her face... my goodness. And the voice is actually kinda cute but sounds too young.

Oddly, it sounds roughly the same as all the other in-game voices excluding Mario 64, which is SO off.

The rest sound similar but the one in Mario Golf sounds like Cream the rabbit the most while the rest were just EAR RAPE! I mean, in Brawl it was still annoying but the least annoying of that group.

The cartoon voices sound fine and a lot like each other but I don't get that "Peach" vibe.

And Hotel Mario just sounded weird.

1. Sam - Just right
2. Leslie
3. Tracy - Nice TV voice.
4. Jeannie
5. Jen
6. Nicole - Sounds like a cheap imitation of Jen's
7. Asuko - Far too foreign
8. Jocelyn - Bland and forgettable
9. Unkown - SWEET FRICKIN' JESUS!

Samantha Kelly get Peach's voice down perfectly right. Nicole Mills tried but isn't quite as good, Jen Taylor went TOO overboard with the "Minnie Mouse" high pitched voice, Leslie Swan actually got better in other games but that clip from Super Mario 64 is really wooden and boring, Asako Kozuki is too foreign sounding, Jocelyn Benford sucked, and the Unknown Voice Actor sounds creepy. Jeannie Ellis and Tracey Moore do great but they weren't playing the canon version of the character.

I'm gonna go with Tracy Moore, since she doesn't make her sound like a ditz and acts to a proficient degree.

Samantha for me!

Mills, Kelly, and Taylor are all top-notch, but I give my vote to Jen Taylor, since I'm more used to her Melee voice...

Jen and Samantha are cute! Asako is cute too! Nicole, don't know. Leslie, "Listen everybody!" LOL! xD The TV cartoon people are kind of okay. Jocelyn, dunno either.

Here is my Top 4:

1. Samantha Kelly
2. Leslie Swan
3. Jen Taylor
4. Asako Kozuki

I'd say Leslie Swan sounds the least annoying out of all the VG Peaches.

1. A tie between original Leslie Swan "Princess Toadstool; Peach" and Jen Taylor "Ooooh, did I win??"
2. Samantha Kelly
3. Nicole Mills
4. Asako Kozuki
5. Tracey Moore
6. Jeannie Elias
7. Jocelyn Benford

VERY tough decision because I personally am not fond of ANY of her voice actresses. However, Samantha is definitely the smoothest of the bunch.

Samantha and Jen sound basically the same, but Samantha sounds a bit less "forced high".

1. swan
2. kelly
3. elias
4. moore
5. taylor
6. mills
7.kosuki
8. benford

Hmmm This is a tough one There are a few I like a lot but I'm not sure I'm not gonna vote just yet But for now Here's my order

1) Tracy Moore (Favourites)
2) Samantha Kelly (Favourites)
3) Jeannie Elias (Favourites)
4) Jen Taylor
5) Nicole Mills
6) Leslie Swan
7) Jocelyn Benford
8) Asako Kozuki

I Like the First 3 on my list more :)

I won't vote yet though I might change my mind later on...

THe last 3 are the ones I'd prefer