4th Annual BTVA Voice Acting Awards - Movies
Browse VOICE COMPARE
#ABCDEF
GHIJKLM
NOPQRST
UVWXYZ
OTHER SPONGEBOB SQUAREPANTS COMPARES
SpongeBob SquarePants

Voice Compare » SpongeBob SquarePants » Mermaid Man

Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Mermaid Man with sound clips and images.
Mermaid Man is a retired superhero who lives in the Shady Shoals retirement home. In his younger days, he appeared on an old TV show with his young ward Barnacle Boy. SpongeBob and Patrick are huge fans of this show, and consider the two heroes their idols. In his old age, Mermaid Man is rather slow-witted and laidback, though the slightest mention of evil sends him off the wall. His cynical, more intelligent partner Barnacle Boy is pretty much all that's keeping him in check. He's also ornery when his nap is disturbed.

Created by NCZ on Mon Jul 9 2012, 70 Comments, Add Comment
Share/Save/Bookmark
SpongeBob SquarePants (1999)
Mermaid ManErnest Borgnine
Ernest Borgnine
SpongeBob SquarePants: Battle for Bikini Bottom (2003)
Mermaid ManJoe Whyte
Joe Whyte
SpongeBob SquarePants: Lights, Camera, Pants! (2005)
Mermaid ManJoe Alaskey
Joe Alaskey

EDITOR'S OPINION

I've can't not give this to Ernest Borgnine. His aged voice and withered-yet-enthusiastic delivery matched the character perfectly. I do appreciate that Joe Whyte and Joe Alaskey brought slightly different interpretations to the table, though Joe Whyte doesn't sound quite aged enough IMO. It's also kind of cool that Joe Alaskey is basically using a lower version of his Grandpa Pickles voice. When all is said and done, Ernest is the clear winner.


NCZ

Latest Comments

Add a Comment

HienFan
said at 3:27 AM on Wed Feb 4 2015
Sooo Joe Whyte replaced Ernest after the latter's death...

Was Nicktoons high when they chose him when they have a far better alternative?(Alaskey)
Slick
said at 5:29 PM on Tue Oct 21 2014
It would be pretty good if Jeff Bennett became Ernest Borgnine's successor.
myopinion1
said at 5:24 PM on Thu Aug 14 2014
SPINOFF. Like the Lights Camera Pants cutscenes.

Joe Alaskey as Mermaid Man.
Coleiosis123
said at 9:43 AM on Wed Jul 30 2014
My bro made me change the vote from Joe to Ernest.
Slick
said at 5:28 PM on Tue Oct 21 2014
Whyte or Alskey?
Metabad
said at 11:46 PM on Fri Jun 27 2014
Ernest Borgnine is definitely the best, he gave Mermaid Man his old kooky craziness that everybody loved so much!

I'm a bit mixed on the other two...like others have said, Joe Whyte sounds WAY too young, but I think he gets the voice itself down fairly well. It's not a perfect impression by any means but he seems to capture some of Mermaid Man's craziness in his performance, which is fine and all, it's just the young light sound of his voice that's admittedly a pretty major issue. His voice also sounds a little too high at times.

Joe Alaskey gets Mermaid Man's old age down MUCH better than Whyte does, but I don't hear Mermaid Man's quirky craziness at all in that clip. Maybe that was just a bad example of his work as the character, but either way he definitely seems like he needed to work on it.

If Joe Whyte took some cues from Alaskey's aged sounding voice, or better yet Joe Alaskey took cues from Whyte's crazy sounding voice, we'd probably have the perfect successor to Ernest Borgnine. But as it stands Ernest Borgnine originated the voice and made the character who he is and given his unfortunate death I doubt Mermaid Man is coming back any time soon. Although considering what I've heard about the quality of the recent episodes of the show, then maybe that's for the best.

So yeah, Ernest Borgnine is of course the best Mermaid Man, I'm incredibly mixed on the other two as I don't even know how to rank them alongside him.
HienFan
said at 8:03 AM on Sat Jan 24 2015
@Metabad That's not the best clip, the ones you see at the end of a sucessful audition are much funnier
HienFan
said at 5:05 AM on Sun Jun 15 2014
I kinda like Joe Alaskey the most.

Joe Whyte sounds very meh
ryanruff13
said at 6:15 PM on Sat Feb 8 2014
1. Ernest Borgnine: I'm going to have to side with the majority here and vote for Ernest; his voice is simply great for the character, and manages to match his personality very well.

2. Joe Alaskey: He provides a pretty decent take as well. Impression-wise, it sounds quite different from Ernest - slightly more so than Whyte does - but by it's own merits, it's a different take that still sounds expressive and suits the character.

3. Joe Whyte: For a replacement, admittedly I didn't think Whyte was THAT bad. At least he has the weary line delivery down. Still, he's not nearly as easy on the ears as the other two are, and I don't think that he would be a suitable replacement for a larger role than he has in the Battle for Bikini Bottom video game. If there's ever another game or something that has Mermaid Man in it in the future, I feel that Alaskey would be a better choice for the role than Whyte would be.
TehRoblobsta
said at 9:43 AM on Sun Dec 15 2013
I prefer Joe Alaskey because of his voice and tone.

Joe Whyte voice doesn't convince me that it's Mermaid Man. It's a very poor impression.

My vote goes to Ernest.

R.I.P Ernest, Mermaid Man will never be the same without you.
DVJ
said at 4:37 AM on Sat Dec 14 2013
 4 Shout Outs! [?]
Joe Alaskey while not perfet suprisingly sounds a lot like Ernest Borgnine,he only need to put on a bit nore of the `frail,senile oldman` tone that Borgnine gave to the character.

Joe Whyte,falls flat,not only does he sound decades younger,but just listening to his voice out of contexst would you ever guess that was mermaid man

Acording to the wiki Whytes gonna voice mermaid man in future episodes of the show,and i really hope that was false informacion,they need to get Joe Alaskey back!
Ross123
said at 12:52 PM on Tue Jan 27 2015
@DVJ I'm surprised at what I'm hearing from you considering you don't even like the show anymore and just complain about how it sucks nowadays and so on.

Nevertheless, I agree with what you said about them getting Joe Alaskey back as Mermaid Man.
BlankSlate
said at 4:47 PM on Fri Mar 13 2015
@DVJ Uhhhh. It's like the Rudiger Evers/Tobias Lelle situation, but in America and for Mermaid Man!
Dogman15
said at 10:44 PM on Wed Dec 11 2013
Whyte is doing his voice in the show now, right? I haven't seen any of the new episodes.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 12:29 AM on Thu Dec 12 2013
@Dogman15 As far as I know, Mermaid Man hasn't appeared since Ernest Borgnine's death.
GothamRed
said at 9:13 AM on Sat Dec 14 2013
@NCZ Well he did, but Borgnine had already recorded those episodes beforehand.
Dogman15
said at 11:53 AM on Sat Dec 14 2013
@NCZ The only reason I ask is because the wiki reports that Joe Whyte has voiced him in the series in 2012 onward. http://spongebob.wikia.com/wiki/Mermaid_Man
Ross123
said at 8:10 AM on Mon Dec 23 2013
@Dogman15 I don't get it. Why are we being told information that's not exactly true? If Mermaid Man has not appeared at all since Ernest's death then they can't just say some1 else is currently voicing him when it's not even happening.
lnytune1
said at 3:26 PM on Fri Nov 15 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Ernest- EEEVVVVVVVIIIIILLLLLLYYY awesome!

Joe Alaskey- Great impression, but a little too deep.

Joe Whyte- No no no no no no no non on on on on no no on on on on on on on no non on ono no no no no non no no no no no no no no no no no non on no no. I so messed up on all my nos. Anyway, Mermaid Man is OLD, you know that right, Joe?!?!?!?!?
lnytune1
said at 3:28 PM on Fri Nov 15 2013
@lnytune1 Oh..... and RIP.
DreamMaster08X (Moderator)
said at 1:37 PM on Fri Nov 15 2013
 5 Shout Outs! [?]
I'm mildly disappointed here. Not because there's no good performance here (my vote's on Borgnine, BTW), but because they didn't use a scene for Borgnine's sound clip to where he says his most epic line of all:

EEEEEEEEEEVIIIIIIIIIIIILLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
lnytune1
said at 3:23 PM on Fri Nov 15 2013
@DreamMaster08X AGREED!!!
Galactic_Cyrus
said at 10:32 AM on Mon Oct 7 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
OK, there's no contest here. Ernest WAS Mermaid Man. The two imitators don't even come close.
Ross123
said at 11:41 AM on Tue Oct 15 2013
@Galactic_Cyrus personally I think Joe Alaskey did not bad at impersonating Ernest. I know u say he doesn't come close but at least he did his best.
Galactic_Cyrus
said at 9:40 PM on Wed Oct 16 2013
@Ross123 Joe's definitely the better imitator here. Joe Whyte didn't sound like an old man at all.
Ross123
said at 5:06 AM on Fri Oct 18 2013
@Galactic_Cyrus I totally agree.
Galactic_Cyrus
said at 7:10 PM on Mon Oct 21 2013
@Ross123 Totally!
Ross123
said at 4:50 PM on Mon Jul 15 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Ernest was and always will be Mermaid Man but last year he sadly died at the grand age of 95.

Joe Whyte however is not and never will be Mermaid Man even if he is Borgnine's replacement in which should have gone 2 Joe Alaskey cause he sounds more like Ernest.

Most of you say they should just retire Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy but that wouldn't be fair on Tim Conaway so that is way they got a replacement.
HienFan
said at 8:02 AM on Sat Jan 24 2015
@Ross123 Try the game Alaskey voiced Mermaidman, it's hilarious(Well the PS2/XBOX/Gamecube version not so much the PC or handhelds) and shows how good Joe Alaskey is at the character
Ross123
said at 12:54 PM on Tue Jan 27 2015
@HienFan If you read closely, you'll see that I liked Joe Alaskey's performance and think that he should take over the role instead of Joe Whyte.
HienFan
said at 9:03 PM on Tue Jan 27 2015
@Ross123 I know you said that but I just suggest trying the game if you like party games since watching the footages you get when you complete auditions are hilarious and similar to the cartoons
Ross123
said at 9:48 AM on Wed Jan 28 2015
@HienFan Oh, I suppose I might check the game out. Though it's very unlikely as I rarely buy old games on previous systems anymore.

And I like Joe Alaskey's performance regardless so I might just check a YouTube vid instead.
HienFan
said at 11:20 PM on Thu Jan 29 2015
@Ross123 If you can cause I have a hard time finding a video myself, I guess I should record the entire footage someday with all of the possible auditions since I have the 100% complete data(And let me tell you it is HARD to get past gold auditions)

I still have to wonder why did they hire Joe Whyte for two games for... since Ernest voiced him on the first game but after that... though they got Ernest before he died at least
Ross123
said at 11:59 AM on Tue Feb 3 2015
@HienFan You don't have to record footage for the game. I'm not gonna put through playing it just to do something for me. Unless you really want to.

Besides, I liked Joe's voice as I said before. So there's really nothing that's gonna make me think better or worse about him.

Didn't know Ernest voiced Mermaid Man in one of the games since I never saw it on his page.
HienFan
said at 8:12 PM on Tue Feb 3 2015
@Ross123 There's an unlockable where you can see those footage without playing the game when you have everything, that's the best thing for me cause I don't care for Sandy Cheeks to finish the game as her

But... 'SWEET MERCIFUL NEPTUNE WHAT IS THAT SMEEELLLL!?' that is the most hilarious thing Alaskey ever said (and my main reason for my vote)

But there's that other Joe... I had the computer game(no sample here) he voiced Mermaidman but I didn't judge because Mermaidman is delirious with cola in that game but jesus in the clip... he sounds too weak and I can't chalk that as sickness
HienFan
said at 3:18 AM on Wed Feb 4 2015
@Ross123 On that note the best thing Joe Alaskey can do is ridiculously overblown reactions, they sound so funny when he does it
HienFan
said at 3:21 AM on Wed Feb 4 2015
@Ross123 And I could joke that they chose Whyte to replace Mermaidman is because he's younger so they can have him longer(I have to question Nicktoons sometimes)
Ross123
said at 6:35 AM on Sat Feb 7 2015
@HienFan Well I'll think about whether or not I should check the cut scenes from the game out if you say they're worth checking out.

Also, it's believed that Nicktoons retired Mermaid Man & Barnicle Boy since they have not appeared on the show since Borgnine's death, RIP to him.
HienFan
said at 5:16 AM on Wed Feb 11 2015
@Ross123 Considering I have the weirdest taste ever, you might have to think about it very carefully though on the other hand we are 2/3rd of the people who prefer Hope Levy as that Melvin dude in Invader Zim

One thing for suuuure

If Nicktoon is never hiring Joe Alaskey, retire Mermaid and Barnacle boy I am not listening to Mermaid Man sounding like a 20 year old with Asthma
Ross123
said at 8:46 AM on Wed Feb 11 2015
@HienFan I'm with you on that cause I sure don't want to hear Joe Whyte as Mermaid Man for the rest of the show's run.

And quick question, what does us voting for Hope Levy as Melvin got to do with this?
HienFan
said at 11:31 PM on Thu Feb 12 2015
@Ross123 I meant our weird taste as a whole, that is just one sample I wanted to say a long time ago but anyways Mermaid Man, if the retired him eventually great
HienFan
said at 6:10 AM on Sun Feb 15 2015
@Ross123 I guess I will say this we're 2/3rd of the people who didn't want Melvin to have the voice he have now and for this case no one wants Joe Whyte as Mermaid Man either(I think considering no one voted for him yet)
Ross123
said at 12:26 PM on Sun Feb 15 2015
@HienFan Ok, we have weird tastes but so what. I don't see anything wrong with that.

Now back on topic, no1 wants Joe Whyte because, well I'm sure you already know why. By the way, in my original comment I mention why it would be unfair if they retired Mermaid Man & Barnicle Boy.
HienFan
said at 1:33 AM on Tue Feb 17 2015
@Ross123 Unless you are a hardcore fan of MAINSTREAM(cough certain Funimation fans but it's another story)

Too bad Nicktoon must have liked Joe Whyte's voice since they probably thought a weak voice would be better for a senile old man I guess, I noted that Joe sounds a LOT more energetic than Ernest
HienFan
said at 1:48 AM on Tue Feb 17 2015
@Ross123 CRAP I MEANT JOE ALASKEY SOUNDS MORE ENERGETIC

Also on the mainstream stuff I was refering to how in some pages there's sometimes someone saying stuff like how can you not vote for *insert winner if the winner has an overwhelming number of votes*/list winner so low or vote for the choice almost everyone hates stuff, that's why I listen before I vote then I can tell if this so called good person is good on my ears or the so called bad person is as bad as the majority makes out
Ross123
said at 2:13 PM on Tue Feb 17 2015
@HienFan Calm down now, I know which Joe you're talking about. Don't want you to go crazy over a little accidental mistake.

I'm the same, I listen then vote.
HienFan
said at 10:16 PM on Sat Mar 21 2015
@Ross123 Considering Joe Whyte only has two episodes so far who knows they might get him replaced with Joe Alaskey, Whyte is better as younger characters
HienFan
said at 10:47 PM on Sat Mar 21 2015
@Ross123 Scratch that found out those eps are recorded when Ernest was still alive, they just released it after he died.

Where did this Joe Whyte replacing Ernest came from anyway? There's no listed appearance of the character post Ernest so for all we know Mermaidman could be gone
Ross123
said at 12:34 PM on Tue Mar 24 2015
@HienFan Don't worry, I was already scratching it out as I knew Mermaid Man & Barnicle Boy hadn't appeared since Ernest's passing in 2012 and that those episodes were released after his death.

I'm just as confused as you are with the whole Joe Whyte as Mermaid Man permanently thing. I almost forgot about it until you mentioned it.
HienFan
said at 11:36 PM on Tue Mar 24 2015
@Ross123 Heard it's common to record long before release, so he might have a few episodes done and they could have retired him after all his episodes are done
Ross123
said at 10:19 AM on Thu Apr 2 2015
@HienFan I forgot about that they record before release. Good point by the way.

So sadly, we will never see Mermaid Man again.
SuperSaiyanBillCosby
said at 6:13 PM on Fri Apr 26 2013
Joe Whyte doesn't sound like an old man, he doesn't fit the character, Mermaid Man is an old retired super hero but Joe sounds young the voice just doesn't match they should find someone like Ernest but Joe Alaskey sounded better then Joe W and nice coincidence for both having the same names lol
Moossey
said at 10:24 PM on Tue Sep 11 2012
Ernest was definitely the best.
curtis13
said at 2:09 AM on Wed Jul 18 2012
 4 Shout Outs! [?]
Ernest Borgnine forever RIP Love him in Airwolf that was my favorite show.
MatthewC17
said at 8:55 PM on Wed Jul 11 2012
 7 Shout Outs! [?]
Ernest Borgnine FTW! may he Rest in Peace
thomwim
said at 6:31 PM on Tue Jul 10 2012
Nothing better than the real thing, honey!
Cartoon_fan87
said at 5:17 PM on Tue Jul 10 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Ernest all the way may he rest in piece now he was a great character actor, Whyte is terrible he doesn't even sound like an old man he just sounds like a wacky character.
JayGirl10
said at 3:11 PM on Tue Jul 10 2012
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Yeah, Ernest all the way!! Joe A was pretty good though. I wonder who will replace Ernest voicing MM...or will the SB people retire the character or just forget about him (and Barnacle Boy) as they do on lots of cartoons? We'll see. RIP Ernest.
Red524
said at 12:33 PM on Tue Jul 10 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Sometimes you find a voice actor who delivers a performance that fits a character like a glove. Here, Ernest Borgnine did that voice. While Joe Alaskey did an adequate job for what it was, I felt Joe Whyte sounded like an obviously younger man trying to sound aged and it just came off as awkward.
MaryKosmos
said at 10:48 AM on Tue Jul 10 2012
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Borgnine. He IS Mermaid Man.

RIP Ernest Borgnine...
TheVengeanceKnight
said at 8:30 AM on Tue Jul 10 2012
 5 Shout Outs! [?]
"YOU MAY KISS THE BRIDE!!!"

Dear God, that clip was hilarious. XD
pete
said at 1:06 AM on Tue Jul 10 2012
Is Adam West's take not included since he played a younger version?
NCZ (Admin)
said at 8:51 AM on Tue Jul 10 2012
@pete Young Mermaid Man would have his own VC because he has more than one actor.
pete
said at 1:05 AM on Tue Jul 10 2012
 3 Shout Outs! [?]
RIP Ernest Borgnine
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 12:41 AM on Tue Jul 10 2012
Joe Whyte kinda sounds like MasakoX
SparklyShake12
said at 8:36 PM on Mon Jul 9 2012
 3 Shout Outs! [?]
Ernest Borgnine is absolutely classic! Joe Alaskey was pretty good as well, but I think Joe Whyte really missed the mark. His tone is too high and has no edge or gruffness to it. Doesn't even come close to the others.


A favorite Voice Compare
for 6 members.
BTVA POLL
Who do you think has been the best from these Mermaid Man voice actors?
Ernest Borgnine
Joe Whyte
Joe Alaskey