Created by Pokejedservo on Mar 15 2011
EDITOR'S OPINION
Today on the Spider Man VC section we shall revisit the Robertson family, a while back there was a VC for Joe "Robbie" Robertson so today we have a VC for Robbie's son... RANDY ROBERTSON! Now unlike Randy's father we shall begin this with the 94 Spiderman series in which Randy appeared for a couple of episodes voiced by Alfonso Ribeiro. Now in the 94 Spider Man series Randy was depicted as how he traditionally was in the comics namely a hot-tempered young punk with angst issues. Alfonso's voice and performance did work with Randy well as Alfonso delivered a suitably emotional performance as it suited Randy on how he can go from a cocky punk to a teen whom is not a bad kid at heart but had some issues to work out. While Randy Robertson was only in a couple of episodes Alfonso did make a fairly memorable performance for Randy and is a good example of the voice work in the show.In Spectacular Spider Man, while Phil LaMarr voice Robbie Robertson he also voiced Randy Robertson as well. Unlike his 90's counterpart Randy is a lot more mellow as he is one of the jocks who hangs out with Flash Thompson (though is easily the nicest of the jocks, heck he has actually occasionally helped the likes of Peter Parker.) While the idea of Phil LaMarr doing a slightly more mellow version of John Stewart/Green Lantern voice for Randy Robertson might seem a little strange but to be fair Spectacular Spiderman does make it work as while Randy is a bit more mellow he is also a bit bigger as well. But still Phil's performance certainly worked with what the series was going for in Randy's characterization here. However the only problem I have is that while Randy is a recurring character in the series when he is in a episode he seems to normally have only a line or few but I suppose I can't really fault Phil LaMarr here. Overall I liked them both as they both did well for the role in their own way.
Pokejedservo
Comments
Add a Comment
said at 7:08 PM on Mon Nov 21 2016
Alfonso get my vote i like the more rebellious Randy and he nailed it
Side note Bryton James would make a good Randy
ReplySide note Bryton James would make a good Randy
said at 9:31 AM on Sat Jan 16 2016
They both work well as Randy, Phil is a lot more chill and likeable but Alfonso Riberio fits the character so much more.
I think I'll give to Carlton on this one. *does the Carlton dance*
BONUS: I could see Khary Payton, Bryton James, Bumper Robinson, Ogie Banks or Dexter Bell fitting well as Randy.
ReplyI think I'll give to Carlton on this one. *does the Carlton dance*
BONUS: I could see Khary Payton, Bryton James, Bumper Robinson, Ogie Banks or Dexter Bell fitting well as Randy.
said at 4:37 AM on Thu Jun 5 2014
I don't really like how deep Phil sounds in the role. But as a different take on the character, I thinks it forks well.
I personally prefer Alfonso. IMO, Alfonso's performance was one of the more memorable ones in the 90s cartoon.
ReplyI personally prefer Alfonso. IMO, Alfonso's performance was one of the more memorable ones in the 90s cartoon.
said at 7:16 PM on Thu May 1 2014
While I voted for Phil, I also like Alfonzo's take on the character. Both are good performances, but are both entirely different takes on the character and I just really liked Randy better in Spectacular.
Replysaid at 11:18 AM on Tue Oct 8 2013
Alfonso fits the character from the comic better, but Phil LaMarr was way more likable.
Replysaid at 1:48 PM on Fri Jul 19 2013
Phil is the man while Alfonso makes Randy sound younger than what he's supposed 2 be.
Replysaid at 8:50 PM on Fri Nov 2 2012
I'm voting for Phil LaMarr but Alfonso Ribiero is also good.
Replysaid at 5:10 PM on Fri Jun 29 2012
I'm goin' with phil, but I can't help but laugh when carlton says," Spiderman? Pfft, he's nothing but wimp in red and blue spandex."
Replysaid at 2:04 AM on Thu Apr 26 2012
Both are good as Randy, but I'm gonna go with Phil LaMarr for this one.
Reply
said at 1:19 PM on Mon May 29 2017