Browse VOICE COMPARE
#ABCDEF
GHIJKLM
NOPQRST
UVWXYZ
OTHER SONIC THE HEDGEHOG COMPARES
Sonic the Hedgehog

Voice Compare » Sonic the Hedgehog » Amy Rose

Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Amy Rose with sound clips and images.

Amy Rose is the leader of Team Rose and has a huge crush on Sonic. Even though she has a small stature, Amy can wield an enormous hammer and can be easily angered.
Created by Pokejedservo on Sun Oct 4 2009, 277 Comments, Add Comment
Special thanks to NCZ for additional sound clips.
Share/Save/Bookmark
Sonic Adventure (1999)
Amy RoseJennifer Douillard
Jennifer Douillard
Sonic X (2003)
Amy RoseLisa Ortiz
Lisa Ortiz
Sonic Free Riders (2010)
Amy RoseCindy Robinson
Cindy Robinson

EDITOR'S OPINION

Amy Rose, whom is supposed to be the original love interest for Sonic (well in the games if that matters to you).

Her modern English voice acting debut came in the late 90's Sonic Adventure where she was voiced by Jennifer Douillard. Jen is certainly not bad as she does do a fairly high cutesy voice that is suiting for the role, not one of my fave performances at the time but certainly not bad.

Jennifer has been voicing the character until 2005 when 4Kids got to dub Sonic X in which was voiced by Lisa Ortiz. While I did like Jennifer's handiwork in the games when it comes to New York VA talent, Lisa was pretty much perfect for the role all things considered. Lisa Ortiz is well known for doing cutesy fairly higher voices well and this is no exception as her work did certainly fit Amy rather well.

I know that VA comparisons are a bit of a touchy subject in Sonic's fandom (thought to be fair its certainly not the only fandom with a problem like that). But while I certainly did like both I am going with Lisa Ortiz a bit more here.

Pokejedservo

Latest Comments

Add a Comment

Truesonic
said at 5:37 PM on Fri Nov 21 2014
 3 Shout Outs! [?]
Now that Cindy isn't being directed to sound like Minnie Mouse as she mentioned during FTA's Boom charity stream, she sounds more tolerable which is a relief. She has definitely improved which has really surprised me.

The only criticism I can give is that she sounds quite generic at some parts. I've also noticed that she occasionally switches back to the high pitched voice but pushing that aside, this is the best she has ever sounded as Amy.

My only worry is that they may push her back to high pitched voice for the main series. I hope they stick with the direction she got in Boom for the main series.
ConfusedPhantom
said at 2:54 PM on Sun Nov 16 2014
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
My favorite is still Lisa Ortiz, but Cindy Robinson has improved a lot in Boom. Hope she sticks with that voice.
DravenRoth994
said at 11:30 PM on Sat Nov 15 2014
Cindy improved A LOT in Sonic Boom!!! That Italian accent she did was actually pretty funny!!! She now comes in second for me, beaten only by Lisa Ortiz.
mdalsted
said at 9:41 AM on Mon Nov 10 2014
I've heard her performance in Sonic Boom, and it's actually different from her performance in the previous games. O.o
Slick
said at 11:16 AM on Sun Nov 2 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Grey Delisle and Lacey Chabert would be great as Amy.
Gatch
said at 7:06 AM on Sat Nov 1 2014
Lynn Harris also did the voice of Amy in the US version of Sonic CD. I don't think she did much VA in the game, probably only screamed? Taeko Kawata did the JP version, and has been voicing amy since 1998. Although was replaced in 2000 for a brief period by Emi.

http://sonic.wikia.com/wiki/Lynn_Harris
NCZ (Admin)
said at 7:30 AM on Sat Nov 1 2014
@Gatch No, she didn't. That's a common rumour that's been going around for what feels like ages, but there are no sources that actually confirm it. There's a lot of fake info and credits about Lynn Harris circulating the web for some reason. It doesn't make sense for them to hire a whole new VA just for one scream, so the most likely assumption is that it was a sound designer at Sega who could jump into the booth quickly at no extra cost.
Gatch
said at 10:05 PM on Sun Nov 23 2014
@NCZ

Wow really they should remove that >_
Gatch
said at 10:08 PM on Sun Nov 23 2014
@NCZ

That means Amy's voice in Sonic CD is just Taeko Kawata. Taeko Kawata has been doing Amy's voice for quite a long time, Japanese VA work differently from English ones. I think Taeko got replaced once... by another Japanese woman, but still voices Amy on occasions.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 5:32 AM on Mon Nov 24 2014
@Gatch Taeko Kawata only began voicing Amy in Adventure; it's not her in CD. Emi Motoi voiced her as a one-off in Shuffle and then they went back to Kawata for Adventure 2 onward.

The only line Amy had in CD was a short scream which if anything, would have probably been recorded by a sound designer from Sega.
rosebr10
said at 5:57 AM on Mon Nov 24 2014
@NCZ
Correction: A yelp and a sigh of infatuation. Its occurrence is random for the most part.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfiEO4fOrPU#t=10m10s

I actually managed to find a way to contact Phase 1 earlier this month. Here's their bottom line, even after I presented some of the contradictory evidence, such as the case of Nina Williams:

"So, just assume that if it says that she was in it, she WAS"

"We do not randomly upload anything. All that is uploaded has some proof submitted to the authorities."

(just to note, I had initially inquired about false entries that could have been detrimental to Harris' credibility and included a list of suspect credit that I had hoped they could alleviate, and one of them was one that did not exist before my influence: Tillis from Burning Rangers)

Well they've reaped what they've sewn, alright.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 1:45 PM on Mon Nov 24 2014
@NCZ Do you suppose it could just be Keiko Utoku? It would have made sense to use her when she was already there to record Sonic.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 2:50 PM on Mon Nov 24 2014
@Nightmare Crusher That is a suggestion that's crossed my mind a fair few times. I'm not totally sure on it, though.
DVJ
said at 12:32 PM on Tue Sep 23 2014
Lisa Ortiz is one of the stronger voice actors in the 4kids dub,she gives Amy a lot of personality and does a decent job emoting the characters cutesy side as well as her more fierce side.

Jennifer Douillard is just meh.

Cindy Robinson....yeah I`d be lying if I said that I didn't understand why she is the most despised out of the casts LA voice actors.Better luck in Sonic Boom.
HyperVoiceActing
said at 10:27 AM on Sat Sep 20 2014
Cindy REALLY improved in Boom. She just may be the only Amy voice I can tolerate.
HienFan
said at 1:14 AM on Wed Sep 3 2014
After listening to Sonic Boom

Congrats Cindy you are now 2nd place after Liza, Jennifer is decent but she has a tendency to sound monotone
CuriousUserX90
said at 1:29 AM on Fri Aug 22 2014
To all those who believe Robinson's take on Amy is a Minnie Mouse Rip off, why not contact the Voicer of Minnie Mouse, Russi Taylor. Ask her what she thinks of Amy's voice.
TrueMyriad
said at 11:20 AM on Tue Jul 22 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Christine Marie Cabanos as Amy. Who else asks for that? I think maybe if SEGA chooses Bang Zoom in the future.
Shiny Raticate
said at 9:56 PM on Wed Jul 30 2014
@TrueMyriad I've always wanted to hear Veronica Taylor voice Amy using her May voice. :)
SteelEthlan
said at 11:22 AM on Wed Aug 6 2014
@TrueMyriad I did i'm the one who had an idea that Christine Marie Cabanos should to an great Amy cause this came to me.
TrueMyriad
said at 8:26 PM on Wed Aug 6 2014
@SteelEthlan and I think that your idea is one of the best ones, if not the best on this topic for sure.
TrueMyriad
said at 7:58 PM on Sat Jul 12 2014
I think Amy should at least be voiced a teen actor to make her sound more natural, and considering how many talented child/teen actors exist today, I say Darcy Rose Byrnes or Ariel Winter would make a more natural Amy
Element Riser
said at 12:48 PM on Sun Jun 22 2014
#1: Lisa Ortiz - Not much to say, she's the best for this character.
#2: Jennifer Douillard - Not that bad, just a bit dull.
#3: Cindy Robinson - Sounds more like a Cream impression than Amy Rose.
superwplf
said at 7:19 PM on Wed Jun 11 2014
 3 Shout Outs! [?]
Cindy robinson is sounding better in sonic boom^^
TrueMyriad
said at 5:46 PM on Thu Jun 12 2014
@superwplf yeah, I watched the Sonic Boom trailer and I want to see more Sonic Boom to see if that will be the official voice Cindy is using
TrueMyriad
said at 3:47 PM on Fri Jun 13 2014
@TrueMyriad I think Cindy is using her Makoto Nanaya voice for Amy this time. But I guess that's just me.
SteelEthlan
said at 6:23 PM on Mon Jun 23 2014
@TrueMyriad Maybe she's using her own tone of voice impression rather than makoto nanaya last time i check she doesn't sound similar what amy is speaking.
TrueMyriad
said at 7:34 PM on Fri Apr 18 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
If anyone should voice Amy Rose, I suggest Cristina Valenzuela. Not only does she improve on Lisa Ortiz's Amy Rose Voice, but that's also Cristina's natural voice, so she can display as much emotion and material without straining her voice too much. The best examples are Louise from Familliar of Zero, Noel from Blazblue, Alisa Askinovich from Tekken, Riven from League of Legends, and Cerebella from Skullgirls.
TrueMyriad
said at 5:26 AM on Mon May 26 2014
@TrueMyriad Kira Buckland and Cristina Valenzuela are the best options I can think of for Amy Rose.
SteelEthlan
said at 3:50 PM on Sun Jun 1 2014
@TrueMyriad how about Christine Marie Cabanos?
TrueMyriad
said at 11:33 AM on Tue Jun 10 2014
@SteelEthlan and Christine Marie Cabanos too:-)
TheSonicFanGirl
said at 1:25 AM on Wed Mar 19 2014
I never found Amy's voice to be annoying. I don't know why people dislike her so much. She's actually my favorite character in the franchise
HyperVoiceActing
said at 10:29 AM on Sat Sep 20 2014
@TheSonicFanGirl - It's mainly because of her Sonic obsession, which is basically the entirety of her personality at that point.
Heyhell
said at 2:52 PM on Sun Jan 19 2014
Jennifer Douillard:I LOVE this voice,its my favorite one,I just think that she shold put more emotion in her acting.

Lisa Otriz:I like it.She can act and her voice remember a little Jenn.In Sonic X she was annoying,but in the games she was PERFECT.


Cindy:She can act and she is doing a good work,but the voice dont fit Amy.
"Dont look so sad...after..."
BUT
When she say "Half bad?Are you kidding?He was all great!" in Sonic Generations 12th cutscene,it wasent bad.I think she shold try sounding like that.
austinslashlavaboy
said at 4:07 PM on Wed Dec 4 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Jennifer Douillard: She doesn't put emphasis on Amy (especially screaming), but nice start.

Lisa Ortiz: I might love the current voice actors, but I'll say this: Lisa Ortiz is the Perfect voice actress. She puts actual emphasis with her emotions and it fits perfectly

So I've already chosen the perfect voice actress, so you might know what I think about....
Cindy Robinson: Ohhhh
Cindy
Cindy
Cindy.
She give Amy a cute high pitch voice that I kind of like (only a tiny bit), but it sounds more like Minnie Mouse. She did improve In generations, but I'll say this now: I think that Cindy is both the WORST voice actress for Amy and the worst thing to come out of the 2010 cast, and it's all Sonic lost world's fault

So I'm voting for Ortiz. There's no way I'm choosing someone that makes Amy sound like Minnie
austinslashlavaboy
said at 8:36 AM on Mon Jun 23 2014
@austinslashlavaboy UPDATE: can someone record Cindy's voice from the sonic boom footage for amy and replace the voice clip we already have?
NCZ (Admin)
said at 8:55 AM on Mon Jun 23 2014
@austinslashlavaboy I'd rather wait until the show itself airs so we can properly analyse the material she's given.
SteelEthlan
said at 6:23 PM on Mon Jun 23 2014
@austinslashlavaboy At least at the end of sonic boom trailer she sounds much better.
TrueMyriad
said at 4:04 PM on Fri Nov 22 2013
 4 Shout Outs! [?]
Cristina Vee would be perfect as Amy Rose. I love her singing and I especially love her voice acting, especially in Magi the Labyrinth of Magic and Skullgirls.
IceElvenPrincess
said at 9:44 PM on Tue Nov 12 2013
I don't really like Cindy's take on Amy. she needs a better person to voice her. either bring back one of the people that did her voice before Cindy or hire someone like Jennifer Hale or someone similar to her.
TrueMyriad
said at 5:20 PM on Fri Nov 15 2013
@IceElvenPrincess exactly what I have been saying.
Here are my options:
Lisa Ortiz, Cristina Valenzuela, Jennifer Hale, Kira Buckland, Ali Hillis, Mae Whitman, and Wendee Lee.
TrueMyriad
said at 6:05 AM on Fri Dec 6 2013
@TrueMyriad it's official, I think Cristina Vee would be the best Amy Rose.
IceElvenPrincess
said at 1:24 AM on Fri Feb 7 2014
@TrueMyriad those are excellent options you have chosen. at least we are on the exact same page here when it comes to that.
SteelEthlan
said at 3:49 PM on Sun Jun 1 2014
@TrueMyriad or how about Christine Marie Cabanos? I bet she'll do an excellent Amy Rose.
SteelEthlan
said at 6:24 PM on Mon Jun 23 2014
@TrueMyriad Jennifer Hale pretty doubtful.
chaosincarnate
said at 8:49 PM on Tue Nov 12 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I'm really disappointed by Cindy Robinson continuing the Minnie Mouse voice in Sonic:Lost World. She even sounded a little deeper in Generations, I thought she would have improved by now. I know she can do better if she uses a different voice, Cindy is very talented. I hope she does a good job in that new Sonic Boom cartoon.

Still sticking with Lisa Ortiz.
TrueMyriad
said at 2:17 PM on Wed Dec 4 2013
@chaosincarnate what bothers me most about Cindy Robinson is that she recently did the voice of Sicily from the new Disgaea game and she sounds perfect, in fact, she sounds nothing like her other roles at all either.
SteelEthlan
said at 6:24 PM on Mon Jun 23 2014
@chaosincarnate Which got your wish at the end of sonic boom trailer.
chaosincarnate
said at 6:18 PM on Sat Jun 28 2014
@SteelEthlan Yeah, she's sounding miles better, going by the game footage. Anyone betting that since she'll be playing one of the more bearable versions of the character, and her voice doesn't sound nearly as obnoxious, she'll end up rising to the top of the poll?
SteelEthlan
said at 6:29 PM on Sat Jun 28 2014
@chaosincarnate If that's an option then yes.

And yeah i'm in a same boat as you buddy lisa ortiz is still without a doubt the better voice actress.
chaosincarnate
said at 8:20 PM on Sat Jun 28 2014
@SteelEthlan Haven't heard enough of Lisa's work to make that judgement, but I can't wait for Cindy to improve. I sincerely hope that squeaky falsetto doesn't continue into the main series though, that would be a serious buzzkill. :/
SteelEthlan
said at 8:54 PM on Sat Jun 28 2014
@chaosincarnate I did but hey that's ok (Wow that kinda rhymed) and so do i.
Blaze
said at 4:17 PM on Mon Nov 4 2013
Two words: Lisa Ortiz!
I liked Jennifer but she couldn't beat LISA ORTIZ!
Cindy scares me.I'm sure she's nice and all but... As an Amy voice she is just...Urgh!And now she'll be in a T.V. show?!Hopefully she can do better.

said at 12:42 PM on Sat Nov 2 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Lisa Ortiz all the way, she IS Amy!!
Jennifer did alright for us first va
But Cindy.... Bad..just bad..
Adjeras
said at 5:39 PM on Mon Dec 16 2013
@Leetastic3 Agreed.
Zekewars010
said at 7:30 AM on Wed Oct 30 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1. Ortiz

2. Robinson

3. Douillard
Bluzziku
said at 4:27 AM on Tue Oct 22 2013
I'm going with Lisa Ortiz surprisingly despite not liking most of the 4Kid's cast. I felt her voice was perfect and she emoted well and I'm quite partial to her voice so hearing her was a treat. Jennifer Douillard was just OK. She has the right kind of voice but lacks a lot of emotion and her crying in that one scene of SA2 was just.... Yeah.... Don't want to go there. As for Cindy Robinson... She could be doing so much BETTER its not even funny first she tried doing an Minnie Mouse impression what was flat out bad and now she's showing slow signs of improvement but I can't recall the name of the character but that voice would be perfect for Amy so I don't know why she doesn't use that.
Adjeras
said at 5:39 PM on Mon Dec 16 2013
@Bluzziku I so agree. I'm glad I'm not the only one who noticed Jennifer's poor acting.
Adjeras
said at 5:50 AM on Sun Oct 20 2013
Jennifer: Easilly my least favorite SA voice. Would it kill her to show SOME emotion.
Lisa: Easilly the best.
Cindy: Too far.
OldSchoolFTW
said at 8:56 PM on Thu Oct 10 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Lisa Ortiz shined in this role.
TrueMyriad
said at 4:47 PM on Wed Oct 9 2013
Cindy Robinson really improved, but if she sounded more like Princess Bloom, Makoto Nanaya, and Labrys, then she would be set.
ConfusedPhantom
said at 2:38 PM on Wed Oct 9 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
I'm going with Lisa Ortiz. She fits perfectly and she does her personality well without her being too annoying.
Galactic_Cyrus
said at 9:56 AM on Mon Oct 7 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Lisa Ortiz OWNS the competition! Jennifer was just okay, and Cindy is a bad Minnie Mouse imitation.
MatthewC17
said at 10:28 AM on Thu Oct 3 2013
Cindy sounds like Prairie Dawn
Definitely going with Lisa Ortiz here
Soldierkei
said at 11:48 AM on Fri Sep 27 2013
Giving it to Jennifer. Just something about her voice is more tolerable. Probably because its the least girly out of the 3.
Adjeras
said at 10:02 AM on Sun Oct 20 2013
@Soldierkei But girliness is what Amy Rose is about, and besides, Jen was a TERRIBLE choice. It seems as though she doesn't know about human emotion.
Soldierkei
said at 7:44 PM on Mon Jan 20 2014
@Adjeras I think that's more so because of the directing. Can't forget, these game were Sega Dreamcast games. Wasn't exactly in the age of "we need to actually act for vid-ya games" yet. When I say least girl, I mean its the least typical girls sounding voice. Cindy's take for example is more Minnie Mouse like. I don't really dig that. Now I'm only commenting on the voice, not the acting, because again, I think with better directions Jen would be fine, but I think voice-wise she was just the best.
Adjeras
said at 2:23 PM on Fri Jan 24 2014
@Soldierkei Meh, you can like it, but the acting with Jen always gets to me. I can't like the voice because the acting is hard to get over.
HyperVoiceActing
said at 12:08 PM on Wed Sep 11 2013
Out of the three, I think Jennifer is the only tolerable Amy voice over. Lisa, while at times is real good, can get real annoying at others. And Cindy is just Minnie Mouse.

What I would love to see, if they can't bring back Jennifer, is maybe Grey DeLisle taking the helm. I think she can do Amy very well without making her sound annoying
Adjeras
said at 2:24 PM on Fri Jan 24 2014
@HyperVoiceActing I disagree. Lisa, while kinda annoying, fit Amy better because she's supposed to be annoying. Jen didn't really feel that tolerable. Even if the directions is to blame, I'm sorry, but that doesn't excuse an otherwise bland and unappealing performance.
E_Granderson37
said at 3:15 PM on Sat Aug 31 2013
I'll say Cindy I'm Glad she Improved in Generations
rosebr10
said at 7:56 AM on Thu Aug 15 2013
You know it's strange. I actually think Robinson would be the definitive Classic Amy if such a thing came to pass (I have the same opinion for Higgins and Willingham for their characters as well [Higgins using her Modern voice for Classic, not her Classic for Classic])

Yeah, I'm a Douillard fan, but having heard her as Kunoichi I feel that GK Bowes would be a worthy successor.
TrueMyriad
said at 6:18 AM on Sun Aug 4 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
We need Lisa Ortiz back, if Mike Pollock can stay, why couldn't Lisa?
SpongeBat1
said at 11:43 AM on Thu Aug 8 2013
@TrueMyriad The only reason Mike stayed is because they couldn't find anyone who did the voice as well as him.

Cindy playing Amy raises questions as to what Sega considers good imitations.
TrueMyriad
said at 12:31 PM on Sun Aug 11 2013
@SpongeBat1 I completey agree, which is why Lisa Ortiz must come back.
HyperVoiceActing
said at 6:03 PM on Tue Oct 1 2013
@TrueMyriad - Nah I'm fine with Lisa being gone. She was good but got real annoying sometimes.
Adjeras
said at 5:48 AM on Sun Oct 20 2013
@HyperVoiceActing But that was the point. It was in her character. Besides, do you really want Jen back? She was just awful.
HyperVoiceActing
said at 10:51 AM on Sun Oct 20 2013
@Adjeras - That's moreso a fault of the voice direction, not the actress herself. I think Jen is most tolerable of the voices, but the direction is what ruined her.
Adjeras
said at 11:41 AM on Sun Oct 20 2013
@HyperVoiceActing I guess. But in my opinion, Lisa is the better actress. Direction or no, Lisa had more experience, whereas the Sonic games were all Jen had.
TrueMyriad
said at 7:39 AM on Fri Jul 19 2013
Either bring back Lisa Ortiz,
Or hire Jennifer Hale, Ali Hillis, or Mae Whitman.
Mephilesthelight358
said at 11:18 AM on Fri Jul 19 2013
@TrueMyriad What's wrong with Jennifer Douilard? I mean, I get your take on Cindy. I totally agree with you on that, but what was so bad about Jennifer? She did pretty well as Amy.
TrueMyriad
said at 9:34 AM on Sun Jul 21 2013
@Mephilesthelight358 I guess all I am looking for in Amy is a voice that is not only fitting and sincere for the character, but also extremely well at changing moods and keeping the same voice. Besides, I think she retired voice acting.
Adjeras
said at 5:49 AM on Sun Oct 20 2013
@Mephilesthelight358 No she didn't. She was emotionless and an overall horrible actress. I'm glad she's gone. We need more capable actors anyways.
HyperVoiceActing
said at 6:14 AM on Mon Oct 21 2013
@Adjeras - At least her voice didn't get as irritating as Lisa's sometimes did
Adjeras
said at 11:21 AM on Mon Oct 21 2013
@HyperVoiceActing Yeah, well even with the annoying tone, it was clear that Lisa was in tune with the role. I feel that Jen took it for granted.
TrueMyriad
said at 5:40 PM on Fri Nov 15 2013
@Adjeras well we will have a poll as to which actress of the folowing I will list that needs to replace Cindy, or you would want to voice Amy:
Lisa Ortiz
Cristina Valenzuela
Jennifer Hale
Kira Buckland
Ali Hillis
Mae Whitman
Wendee Lee.
Adjeras
said at 4:09 PM on Mon Dec 16 2013
@TrueMyriad: Lisa Ortiz since we already know how she'd do the role.
Ross123
said at 3:19 PM on Wed Jul 17 2013
Lisa & Jennifer are my favs but i'm going for Lisa as she sounds a bit better.

Cindy is really really annoying.
Shiny Raticate
said at 2:53 AM on Fri Jul 12 2013
Lisa Ortiz all the way. She was the spunky and happy Amy that I knew and loved.
TrueMyriad
said at 6:43 PM on Fri Jun 28 2013
Lisa Ortiz by a long shot. In my opinion, if anyone should voice Amy as a replacement for Lisa Ortiz, it should be Ali Hillis(Lightning Ferron).Listen to her Demo Reel and your mind will be blown. Tell me your thoughts if you agree/disagree about Ali Hillis being the best option for Amy.
pokemastanumba1
said at 6:35 PM on Fri Jun 28 2013
 4 Shout Outs! [?]
Even though the 4Kids Sonic cast is mediocre at best overall (at least IMO), I have to give this one to Lisa; she really brings out the personality, her performance had a lot of liveliness to it. Of course she sounds really bratty and/or over-the-top at times, but considering the nature of the franchise as a whole, it makes sense at least. Overall, while her voice takes at least some time to get used to, she certainly pulled it off in the end. Shame she didn't get to stick around.

Jennifer's acting is pretty wooden, and her voice is a bit weird, but she did fine with what she had to work with.

Cindy Robinson was off to a horrible start, and while she has improved at least a bit in Generations, I just don't care for her take on the character at all. When I hear her voice, I just can't get Minnie Mouse out of my head. Granted, while Amy and Minnie share some striking similarities between each other, I don't think Amy should sound like Minnie Mouse. X(
chaosincarnate
said at 1:38 PM on Thu Jun 20 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
To be fair, I think Cindy Robinson improved a bit in Sonic Generations.
Rabindranith
said at 5:09 PM on Sun Jun 2 2013
Despite Amy having an annoying personality, I do like her Ortiz voice. It's the least annoying one. Or maybe I'm just used to Lisa's voice.
Robinson's voice kind of sounds like she's squealing. But, she isn't bad at all, really.

Jennifer's voice actually sounds like an Amy voice!
Mephilesthelight358
said at 8:49 PM on Tue Jun 4 2013
@Rabindranith Same opinion.
Adjeras
said at 10:03 AM on Sun Oct 20 2013
@Rabindranith But Amy Rose isn't an emotionless character. People seem to ignore this factor.
Rabindranith
said at 3:00 PM on Mon Nov 11 2013
@Adjeras Well, true. I'm just not too much of a fan, is all
Adjeras
said at 4:08 PM on Mon Dec 16 2013
@Rabindranith I jaust think Jennifer is overrated.
FireGamer1992
said at 11:15 PM on Tue Apr 30 2013
The only great voice who did a great job as Amy Rose is Lisa Ortiz. The new voice actress SUCKS! Need between hire Hynden Walch or better yet bring back Lisa as Amy Rose.
Bombermanp
said at 1:53 PM on Mon Apr 22 2013
one of my favorite sonic character ^^.. lisa Amazing! jenifer also good...
*hears Cindy*
.......................
*gives self a Lobotomy*
ok seriously i like cindies other roll BUT how the heck did she even get the roll as amy with that voice!?! WENDEE LEE should have got this roll.. hell STEPHANIE SHEH should have given this a shot. or maybe cindy COULD keep this roll BUT STOP USING THAT VOICE
Fulgore2005
said at 5:14 AM on Sat May 11 2013
@Bombermanp You know, I think Stephanie would have been an excellent choice as Amy.
Ratchetjak
said at 5:02 PM on Sun Mar 31 2013
Jennifer wins my vote hands down. True she isn't an amazing voice but I just thought it fit her perfectly. Lisa is meh... I mean, she's not bad but I just didn't care for it. Plus, since Amy had much more screentime on Sonic X, you had to hear her more and honestly (no offense to the VA), I thought she sounded annoying, especially when she yelled. But like I said, Lisa isn't bad, I really enjoyed her work in Pokemon but I just didn't like her voice for Amy.

However, Cindy's is much worse... She sounds way too high. She sounds like a Minnie Mouse clone. So uh... Yeah, I'll take Lisa over Cindy.

1. Jennifer
2. Lisa
3. Cindy

Amy is a character I have a like/hate relationship. Like because she is fierce, strong, and deep down has a good heart but hate or rather, dislike because I don't like how overboard she goes over Sonic. If she lightened up some, maybe Sonic would stick around and possibly date her haha. But yeah, she is an okay character. :)
coolgeek176
said at 9:48 PM on Tue Mar 26 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I normally don't go for 4Kids actors but I think Lisa did the best.
VctrBnsn
said at 2:29 PM on Fri Mar 22 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
I like most of the new Sonic cast, but man, CINDY SUCKS. She's like a bad Minnie Mouse impression. Lisa gets my vote for sure.

Candi Milo for Amy.
chaosincarnate
said at 10:03 PM on Wed Mar 20 2013
Jennifer got my vote. Even though her acting isn't as great as it could be, she offered the perfect voice. Lisa is close, but her voice is a tad bit too high for my liking. Cindy... just ugh.
chaosincarnate
said at 1:52 AM on Fri Jun 7 2013
@chaosincarnate On second thought, I've changed my vote to Lisa Ortiz. Jennifer's acting isn't all that great, but her voice is alright. I originally complained about Lisa's voice being high, but it fits, seeing as how Amy as 12, and her acting was the best out of the three. Cindy is far too high pitched, sounding like minnie mouse. She improved slightly in Generations, so perhaps her performance will improve in future games.
Toady_12
said at 8:52 PM on Sat Mar 16 2013
I think Cindy would be great if she used a voice similar to her Zero III voice for Amy
SpongeBat1
said at 6:56 PM on Tue Feb 5 2013
Lisa was great at making Amy sound both sweet and insane at the same time. Jennifer sounded a little ditzy, and Cindy sounds too kiddy and annoying.
Nirvana
said at 5:36 PM on Mon Jan 7 2013
Jenny from the block!

The high piched cutesy voices Lisa and Cindy have are ok (I always found Lisa's lisp pretty cute), I just find Jennifer's natural approach more likable.
LJ7117
said at 3:12 PM on Sun Jan 6 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
1. Lisa Ortiz-Surprised I'm going with 4Kids on this one, considering how much I despise them, but Lisa did well with capturing Amy's personality and really caught her flirty side.
2. Jennifer Douillard-Though not really great with VAing, she was a lot of fun to listen to and got Amy's spirited side quite well
3. Cindy Robinson-.....Do I even need to say anything? She sucks. No better way to put it. That voice REALLY gets on my nerves.
TheTrueYuma
said at 1:38 AM on Sat Jan 5 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1. Jennifer Douillard - She did give Amy a perfectly suiting voice that covered all of her personality.
2. Lisa Ortiz - She was really only good for Amy's "PMS" moments.
3. Cindy Robinson - Yeah, not going there.
TheTrueYuma
said at 1:37 AM on Sat Jan 5 2013
Why does Lynn Harris not have a clip?
BlueSkySlash
said at 11:38 AM on Thu Jan 10 2013
@TheTrueYuma Because she only uttered a simple laugh and a gasp in Sonic CD. It's really not enough to put her in this comparison.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 11:56 AM on Thu Jan 10 2013
@TheTrueYuma Also because I don't think it's Lynn Harris. There's a lot of false info about her online and I doubt they'd go to the trouble of hiring someone for a laugh and a gasp. If anything, it's more likely to be Keiko Utoku.
rosebr10
said at 12:44 PM on Sun May 26 2013
@NCZ
While the chances of it being Lynn have been greatly thinned out, it wasn't without the benefit of linking similar roles to a common name. It just wasn't the right one.

Claris and Amy seem to have the same voice, and given her known voice and singing roles, the voice of both is in all likelihood Tomoko Sasaki.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 12:48 PM on Sun May 26 2013
@rosebr10 Yeah, my theory was that it was a Sega employee if not Utoku, so Tomoko Sasaki seems plausible.
Bryton
said at 12:25 AM on Fri Nov 23 2012
Jen's voice sounds the most natural and I like the "flighty valley girl" portrayal she gives, but I think Lisa was just hilarious! Almost every time her Amy was on scene a smile would just appear on my face. Definitely one of the few casting decisions 4kids didn't manage to screw up. Cindy I gotta hear more from but it sounds like she's improving.
Lisa FTW!
CrazyNoods
said at 11:47 PM on Mon Nov 19 2012
Lisa Ortiz. All the way.

Cindy is ruining my perfect image of Sonamy with that squeaky, mouse-like voice!
Edork42
said at 3:44 AM on Fri Sep 28 2012
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
I'm so in between Lisa and Jennifer for my favorite Amy because both were so good in their own ways. Jennifer sounds more natural and very much so like a city girl, even though her acting was iffy at times like in SA2. Heroes I thought she was perfect, really giving Amy more of an energetic, determined edge and no longer making her come off as an annoying third wheel or a dumbass in distress.

While Lisa really doesn't have much range in terms of acting for other things like Pokemon and Ratatoing, I think Amy is her best role. No matter how dull the 4kids cast were in the anime or games like Riders and Sonic 06, you could always bet she'd be the only thing to look forward to seeing because she was so funny and could breath life into any boring, tedious scene she was in (character, personality, words that the rest of the cast must have never learned). I'm really upset Sega didn't decide to renew her contract along with Mike; to this day she's the only 4kids actor I miss.

Cindy's acting is good, but her voice is way to high and cartoonish for me to get into. She's getting better so I'll give her some more time and who knows, maybe by the next game she'll finally have Amy's voice down to a T.
Animefan98
said at 7:22 PM on Mon Sep 24 2012
Lisa Ortiz sounded clear, non-compressed, and perfect in every way. It's a shame her contract won't let her voice Amy anymore in the games. :(
Jennifer did a good job as the starter, but her voice seemed a little flat. And as for Cindy, even a 7-year old girl could do a better job.
MrParadox
said at 1:25 AM on Tue Sep 18 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Jennifer does a good job as Amy, she gives out one of the most emotional performance of any of the original Sonic cast. A pity she doesn't do any more voice overs as I feel that she would make an excellent career as a voice actress.

Lisa is one of my favorite NY based voice actors out there and Amy is a prime example of her talent as a voice actress. She has a high pitch which fits for Amy and for a pitch like that, she was able to bring in a surprising amount of emotion for Amy.

Cindy sounds way too much like Minnie Mouse, in fact, I first thought they hired the voice actress of Minnie to do Amy when I first heard her in Free Riders. I will say that she has greatly improved in Sonic Generations but still has a long ways to go.
MilanTheVillain01
said at 11:58 PM on Tue Sep 11 2012
My ranks for Amy....

# 1 - Lisa Ortiz.
# 2 - Jennifer Douillard.
# 3 - Cindy Robinson.
munsonx4
said at 12:42 PM on Tue Aug 21 2012
Gonna go with Jennifer. Her performance as Amy in SA and SA2 were quite good in my opinion!
JDFlame20222
said at 4:11 PM on Thu Aug 2 2012
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Lisa Ortiz was the best voice for Amy Rose to me.
AJW98productions
said at 10:21 AM on Mon Jul 16 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1. Lisa Ortiz she captures the character perfectly in my opinion and situationally the writers put her in the best spots
2. I'm tied Amy's adventure series and hereos voice I found to be just plain annoying and her new voice sounds like minnie mouse as with knuckles and shadow, I want her 4kids voice back
Mrguy22594
said at 9:20 PM on Mon Jul 9 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
As much as I don't like the 4kids cast I miss Lisa Ortiz as Amy but at some point Cindy needs to get better.
Zylphia
said at 9:11 PM on Sat Jun 30 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I love Lisa! Jennifer has to come in second, though I love this game. But Cindy's wasn't grabbing me unfortunately.
Mickwhitefire28
said at 6:09 PM on Sat Jun 9 2012
 3 Shout Outs! [?]
Lisa. Hands down! Jennifer, not bad. Cindy is minnie mouse. I know a ton of fans are asking Cindy to be compared to someone else, but.... WHO ELSE TALKS LIKE THAT?!
Fulgore2005
said at 4:39 PM on Fri Apr 20 2012
 5 Shout Outs! [?]
I think Monica Rial would have been a better placement than Cindy Robinson:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xA_PNfdLkMQ
NCZ (Admin)
said at 6:02 PM on Fri Apr 20 2012
@Fulgore2005 If Funimation or Sentai ever got ahold of Sonic, I agree that Monica would be a good choice for Amy.
AMT
said at 10:49 PM on Mon Apr 23 2012
@NCZ Yeah shes not bad! Id take her over Cindy. I also think Cristina Vee would have been a good choice

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8HGG5j9o9cc&t=21s
Fulgore2005
said at 6:21 AM on Thu Apr 26 2012
@AMT Cristina Vee would definitely be another good choice for Amy too.
pokemastanumba1
said at 9:26 PM on Tue Aug 21 2012
Another FUNi VA I'd pick for Amy would have to be Luci Christian. Though since they're currently using a Studiopolis cast, what about Tara Platt?
NCZ (Admin)
said at 12:44 AM on Wed Aug 22 2012
@pokemastanumba1 Tara's voice is a little too low for Amy, but she could surely work as Rouge, Wave, or Blaze. I'm thinking Amanda Winn-Lee could have potential.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 1:03 AM on Wed Aug 22 2012
@NCZ Or Melissa Fahn.
pokemastanumba1
said at 9:32 PM on Wed Aug 22 2012
@NCZ About Tara Platt, I was thinking her Tron Bonne voice would fit Amy much better:
http://www.behindthevoiceactors.com/voice-compare/Mega-Man/Tron-Bonne/

@JSD Pokemon has nothing to do with this. And FYI, both of the changes of cast with Sonic were NOT handled any more professionally or respectfully; all VAs have been abruptly replaced without warning, nor is there any chance of any of the previous VAs coming back.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 9:44 PM on Wed Aug 22 2012
@pokemastanumba1 Hmm, that voice could actually work pretty well. It's nice to hear Tara do something different than her usual roles.
pokemastanumba1
said at 10:18 PM on Wed Aug 22 2012
@NCZ Yeah, she's a LOT more versatile than I realized. But for Rouge, Wave, or Blaze, something much closer to her Temari voice would be better.
LivChan45
said at 4:42 PM on Tue Apr 17 2012
I grew up hearing Jennifer Douillard, but when I heard Liza Ortiz I thought she was better. I do not really like Cindy Robinson and her voice for Amy. It's too...cheesy...no that's not it...I don't want to say she sounds like Minnie Mouse cause someone already said that...
bwaffles9
said at 3:25 PM on Fri Apr 13 2012
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
People stop saying that Cindy Robinson sounds like Minnie Mouse!!!! I DO NOT care if sounds like Minnie Mouse.
Marzy97
said at 9:10 PM on Thu Apr 12 2012
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Amy sounds alot like Minnie Mouse... :/
bwaffles9
said at 3:25 PM on Fri Apr 13 2012
@Marzy97 ya right like lots of people say that.
witswithme
said at 10:28 AM on Thu Mar 15 2012
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
No offense, but...
The current Amy voice sounds (creepily) like Minnie Mouse...
bwaffles9
said at 3:26 PM on Fri Apr 13 2012
@witswithme What else besides Minnie Mouse!!!! Can people say something ELSE!!!!
IblisAngel
said at 2:42 PM on Sun Oct 21 2012
@bwaffles9 Fine then we'll say she sucks

said at 11:43 AM on Wed Feb 29 2012
Amy sounds like Spice from Batman X when Lisa Ortiz voices her! :p
So I like Jen and Cindy here. (why I like Cindy's voice here is because she sounds like Peach in Mario!)
Sonamyfan666
said at 9:54 PM on Sun Feb 12 2012
1.Lisa
2.SonicSong182 on YouTube
3.Jennifer
1Googleplace behind other fan voice actors.
Minnie Mouse
Torak
said at 10:49 AM on Sun Jan 22 2012
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Lisa was perfect as Amy, the other too I don't really like.
XxDream
said at 11:35 PM on Mon Jan 9 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1.Lisa:her voice was very suiting for amy's personality.
2.Jennifer:good but it made Amy sound a little too old for her age.
3.Cindy:too minnie mouse-ish!DX

said at 9:23 AM on Sat Dec 10 2011
Jennifer:SO CUTE!
Lisa:Ok
Cindy:Cute ,but not as cute as Jennifer and Lisa
Mandie_Marley
said at 12:33 PM on Sat Dec 3 2011
Cindy sounds like Minnie Mouse haha
Mephilez
said at 6:35 PM on Thu Nov 24 2011
1 Jennifer
2 Lisa/Cindy

If Jennifer added more... emotion to it rather than *script reading... with little effort* then it would have been better

Lisa made Amy annoying and you wanted to hit her, and Cindy makes her sound like Minny Mouse
I hope Cindy can improve.........
NCZ (Admin)
said at 9:57 PM on Mon Nov 7 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Cindy's improved a good deal in Generations. Sounds much more fitting.

See guys? With time, everything works out.
AMT
said at 10:34 PM on Mon Nov 7 2011
@NCZ She was better, but still not fitting for me. There are parts in the game where her free riders voice still kinda slipped in.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 10:40 PM on Mon Nov 7 2011
@AMT Well, a slight improvement is a good sign. It means she'll probably improve even more in further games.
Ninjaman15
said at 7:49 PM on Wed Nov 9 2011
@NCZ Will Cindy's clip be updated soon enough?
NCZ (Admin)
said at 9:33 PM on Wed Nov 9 2011
@Ninjaman15 Generations clip is on her page for now. I won't add a new one to the VC unless the voice becomes significantly different.
Belial Edge
said at 2:38 AM on Sun Nov 20 2011
@NCZ Sad that almost EVERYONE said Cindy Robinson makes her sound like Minnie Mouse.
That made me even think Robinson actually did voice Minnie for a sec back then. XPXP
pokemastanumba1
said at 1:38 PM on Fri Dec 2 2011
@AMT She does sound a LOT better than she did in Free Riders though. Yeah, it's not so much of an improvement but she's at least nowhere near as horrible.

@NCZ Still, she's one of the worst Studiopolis VAs and stands to replaced or even fired. Danielle Judovits, Tara Platt or Stephanie Sheh would have been much more suitable. Cindy should just stick with...well, who cares about her? :P

@Belial Edge She must've somehow confused Amy with Minnie Mouse...
NCZ (Admin)
said at 4:03 PM on Fri Dec 2 2011
@pokemastanumba1 That comment you made about Cindy was so rude, I'm not going to bother responding to it.
Ninjaman15
said at 10:47 AM on Sat Dec 17 2011
@NCZ I think saying something bad about a VA is just.... d-d-dude! Who really wants to fly off the handle that far? The way I see is this: it if has something to do with the Japan-residing English VAs, then I'll let it slide...

A member months ago said something else about Roger Craig Smith on Sonic's own voice compare. It was moreso negative if anything... :P
PusoPimp
said at 10:24 AM on Fri Nov 4 2011
One more top 3 today.

1. Lisa Ortiz- Lisa perfected the role of Amy, both her voice and her acting were perfect here. They should have kept her as Amy, personally I think they didn't because it would have been inconvenient for Lisa since she works mainly in New York City and Studiopolis is in Los Angeles.

2. Cindy Robison- Her acting seems great, but the voice she puts out simly isn't as good as Lisa's, so I guess the tie breaker goes to her. A very good replacement on Studiopolis' part though.

3. Jennifer Douillard- Mediocre voice, mediocre acting, over all mediocre performance. Still, mediocre's good for dead last.
Ninjaman15
said at 4:47 PM on Mon Oct 31 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
You know what? After hearing a few of Cindy's lines for Amy in Generations, she seems to have improved. Granted, I still prefer Jennifer and Lisa over her, but hey... definitely not as annoying as it was in Free Riders. In fact, Amy sounds more like Betty Boop now, which isn't too suprising since Cindy also voices that character as of right now.

1. Lisa Ortiz
2. Cindy Robinson (Sonic Generations)
3. Jennifer Douillard
4. Cindy Robinson (Sonic Free Riders/Colors)

That's my opinion as a whole, folks.
Hazeleyed487
said at 5:50 PM on Wed Aug 31 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Okay, let me restart. Cindy makes her sound like minnie mouse** Which I really don't like.
Downloadsbacon
said at 1:51 AM on Sun Jul 31 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
LISA ORTIZ GETS MY VOTE.
Other sound good too but not as good as lisa
Aurora
said at 8:45 PM on Sat Jul 30 2011
Cindy's voice for Amy almost sounds like Princess Peach!
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 1:58 PM on Fri Jul 22 2011
#1- Lisa Ortiz: PERFECT FIT!!!

#2- Jennifer Douillard: No emotion when screaming for help, but pretty good.

#3- Cindy Robinson: TERRIBLE!!! Not only does it sound like Minnie Mouse, but there's another issue I have: Amy is supposed to be 17 years old! DOES THAT SOUND 17 TO YOU??!!!!!!
NCZ (Admin)
said at 5:20 PM on Fri Jul 22 2011
@TheUltimatePhantom1 I have no idea where you're getting 17 from. Amy is 12 years old.
AMT
said at 2:28 AM on Tue Aug 9 2011
@NCZ He's confusing her age from the comics. Biologically, amy is 17 years old in the comics, though chronologically, she's about 11-12 years old.
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 12:15 PM on Fri Aug 19 2011
@NCZ I read her bio on "Sonic Free Riders", and I looked at the character's ages. When I looked at Amy's, it said 17.
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 12:15 PM on Fri Aug 19 2011
@AMT I read her bio on "Sonic Free Riders", and I looked at the character's ages. When I looked at Amy's, it said 17.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 2:34 PM on Mon Aug 22 2011
@TheUltimatePhantom1 That's probably a typo. According to Sonic Channel (the official Sonic website) and the manual for Sonic Heroes, she is 12.
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 11:23 PM on Fri Aug 26 2011
@NCZ Then every other character's ages are typos, because I looked at the other ages as well:

Sonic= 19/20

Tails= 12

Knuckles= 21

Cream= 8

Vector= 24

Shadow=???

Rouge= 22

Jet= 16

Wave=21

Storm= 26

Dr. Robotnik=???
AMT
said at 11:51 PM on Fri Aug 26 2011
@TheUltimatePhantom1 Wow, you're right, they ALL are typos... these ages are just wayyyy off...
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 10:55 PM on Sat Aug 27 2011
@AMT You really believe that they just stay the same age?! Sonic's 20 now (As proven in a Sonic Generations plot interview). And Sonic can't be the ONLY character in the ENTIRE SERIES that can age! I take it you've never seen their bios either. Ever read the instruction manual for it?
NCZ (Admin)
said at 12:50 PM on Sun Aug 28 2011
@TheUltimatePhantom1 The sources I found for Sonic being 20 in Generations were from random gaming sites and not from Sega themselves, so I'm taking "Generations is five years later" rumour with a grain of salt.

Besides, aging is inconsistent in Sonic anyway. Between Sonic and Knuckles and Adventure, Amy aged four years, Knuckles aged one year, and Sonic went down a year.
Truesonic
said at 9:43 AM on Tue Aug 30 2011
@NCZ

I'm getting a little confused now...after hearing the plot of Generations...everyone is taking a picnic in honour of Sonic's 20th then a dark force starts I believe Sonic is still 15 in the games but in reality he is 20 He's not 20 in the games we just celebrate the years since his first game

I believe they never age

Sonic - 15
Tails -8
Knuckles - 16
Amy - 12
Cream - 6
Big - 18
Shadow - N/A (50 but 15?)
Rouge - 17
Vector - 20
Espio - 16
Charmy - 6
Blaze - 14
Jet - 14
Silver -14
Marine -7
Eggman - N/A

But now after being told the plot I'm now a bit confused...
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 8:10 PM on Tue Oct 18 2011
@NCZ How do the Sonic characters have a picnic celebration Sonic's 20th Anniversary, and he's still 15? That makes no sense..
NCZ (Admin)
said at 6:28 AM on Wed Oct 19 2011
@TheUltimatePhantom1 Considering that it's the Sonic Colours writers, it's probably a meta thing. He might not literally be twenty.
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 8:26 PM on Thu Oct 20 2011
@NCZ What "Meta Thing", exactly are you driving at?
NCZ (Admin)
said at 11:10 PM on Sat Nov 12 2011
@TheUltimatePhantom1 Now that Generations is out, I can confirm that the rumour about Sonic turning 20 (and thus, everyone else aging five years) is false. They're just celebrating Sonic's birthday. They don't give a specific age. Considering how everybody looks about the same, it definitely isn't his 20th.
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 9:49 PM on Mon Nov 14 2011
@NCZ In DBZ, some of the characters also look the same, and it's been like, 13 years..
GameMaster8229
said at 9:51 PM on Wed Apr 4 2012
@TheUltimatePhantom1 How about we all just say that he's 16. Due to the fact that he just had his birthday in Sonic Generations.
pokemastanumba1
said at 10:38 PM on Tue Jul 19 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
#1 Jennifer Douillard
The original Adventure voice cast was (at least in most cases) the best, and Jennifer was no exception. She did an excellent job, bringing lots of love and energy to her performance. She also sounds the most natural and realistic, originally leading me to forget it wasn't actually done by a teenager! Most importantly, you can feel the nice chemistry between her Amy and Ryan's Sonic. Plus, hers stands out even more as Amy's the only VA role she's done.

#2 Lisa Ortiz
I love her voice a lot too, almost as much as Jennifer's. She wasn't too distinctive in the role, but her voice definitely worked out very well nontheless. My main criticisms are just her relative lack of originality and her monotone temper tantrum. Amy sounded upset or frustrated pretty much all the time, but then again, that IS the way character has been in her modern depictions and at least Lisa delivered on that. All in all, a great voice, and definitely one of the best of the 4Kids cast. She will be greatly missed indeed, and as you will know how I feel about the new voice in a moment, you'll understand why.

#3 Cindy Robinson
I'm very sure everyone would be in agreement here. Cindy was horribly miscast in this role. Apparently someone at Studiopolis forgot to remind her that THIS IS AMY ROSE, NOT MINNIE MOUSE! Sorry, but Cindy's was just beyond ear-raping horrendous, and the only one of the new cast that I just can't stand.

You want to know what the really sad and disappointing part is? A GUY can imitate Cindy's voice. Sad, just sad.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwl7d11X32I

If this is so, they might as well hire a guy to do the voice in future installments...

said at 12:01 AM on Tue Jul 12 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I definately do not like the minnie mouse voice lol
pokemastanumba1
said at 10:07 PM on Tue Jul 19 2011
@Sonic I don't think anyone else does either...
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 1:54 PM on Fri Jul 22 2011
@pokemastanumba1 I think so, too.
Ninjaman15
said at 2:36 PM on Fri Jul 8 2011
While I singlehandingly hate 4Kids's own soul, the one thing I won't nerd rage on are the company's own voice cast; most have talent, others are a bit mediocre at times... Therefore I will say that Lisa Ortiz was no doubt the best Amy voice I have heard, right next to Taeko Kawata, that's for sure. Then again, I grew up with hearing Jennifer Douillard's performance more, considering I used to own both Sonic Adventure and Sonic Adventure 2: Battle on the Gamecube... All I can say for that is: She could pull off emotion, even if it sounded too dry at times.

Perhaps that leaves only Cindy Robinson: why, yes, she can get the emotion down, but the problem is in the tone... It sounds too similar to Minnie Mouse almost all the time, and it can even make my ears bleed. In fact, I am tempted to say she has down better roles for, say, Kukaku Shiba for the english dub of Bleach and then Makoto Nanaya from Blazblue: Continuum Shift... Unless if the latter role was done by someone other than Robinson, I dunno. Overall, it's not that I detested Cindy's performance, but she could've improved a bit more on the tone and then some.
Ninjaman15
said at 6:39 PM on Sat Jul 9 2011
@Ninjaman15 "done, not 'down'
SmartyBoyboy
said at 4:35 PM on Mon Jun 27 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1. Lisa - She was okay in Sonic X, but man did she get that "crazy-yet-sweet girl who wants to be Sonic's boyfriend no matter how much he resists her" role down as time went by.
2. JenJen - She really went for that cutesy girl type role and pulled it off.
3. Cindy - Really sounds much too much like a young Minnie Mouse; doesn't really fit with the mannerisms of the character herself. (But she'll get better over time, okay?)
Sonic_Blaze
said at 12:51 AM on Sun Jun 26 2011
Jenny Jen is my fave though I'm starting to like Cindy even though it sound Minnie Mousish. I know she can improve on that .

Lisa had an okay one but when I looked over some of the old Sonic x Episodes and some of hte games I kinda found her version of Amy somewhat Annoying. Especially with scenes when she cries out Sonic. But then again it's just a recent nitpick. Also her voice is Kinda overrated as well. so Jenny for my fave.
Truesonic
said at 12:11 PM on Wed Jul 6 2011
@Sonic_Blaze

I find Cindy a lot worser than Jennifer XD
Truesonic
said at 12:11 PM on Wed Jul 6 2011
But I still think Lisa is the best IMO
Sonic_Blaze
said at 3:13 PM on Sat Jul 9 2011
@Truesonicn at this point I'm tired of Lisa's though. I find her to be alot more annoying. Cindy spunds like Minnie mousish but she's starting out so I'm sure that tone will be adjusted. but Lisa has experience and at this point I finally gotten tired of Lisa's version. It;s like she took her voice as Serenity from Yu-Gi-Oh! and just cut and pasted it to Sonic which I didn't like .
I hold on to Jen as my favorite. Cindy will improve . I'm sure of that
Truesonic
said at 7:59 AM on Sun Jul 10 2011
@Sonic_Blaze

I disagree but I respect your opinion :)....I just really don't like Cindy's Amy vocie but Im giving her a chance to improve because I think she can do a lot better than this :/
Truesonic
said at 11:43 AM on Mon Jul 11 2011
But like you said I hope Cindy improves too....I respect your opinion in many ways
TheBlackHawk
said at 12:38 PM on Sun May 15 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1. Jennifer Douillard - I think Jen-Jen gave Amy the best "There you are, my Sonic~!" voice.
2. Lisa Ortiz - Hmm, I'm not really sure why I love her voice so much. Maybe it's because I always heard it so often when I watched Pokemon.
3. Cindy Robinson - Her voice for Amy is very good, and I look forward to hearing her improve throughout her years voicing Amy.
pokemastanumba1
said at 10:06 PM on Tue Jul 19 2011
@TheBlackHawk Great order and nicely put!
TheBlackHawk
said at 11:55 AM on Thu Jul 21 2011
@pokemastanumba1Thanks! =D
NintendoNate25
said at 2:55 PM on Fri Apr 8 2011
1. Lisa Ortiz - I think she had the best voice for Amy.
2. Jennifer Douillard - She was okay, but her acting could have been better. Her voice was a little too pinchy in my opinion.
3. Cindy Robinson - Probably the only one of the new voices that I don't really care for. She sounds too much like Minnie Mouse. However, it WAS her first time voicing Amy, so I'll give her a chance to improve in the next game the character appears.
jonhardwick
said at 9:20 PM on Wed Apr 6 2011
i wonder why most people hate douidlard. amy is supposed to be an annoying brat who follows sonic all the time. oh well it dipends on how you look at the character
pokemastanumba1
said at 10:03 PM on Tue Jul 19 2011
@jonhardwick No, that's exactly the way Amy is. A Sonic-lovestruck annoyance who constantly gets on the blue blur's case. But yeah, I do wonder why most fans don't care about Douillard anymore, as she was fantastic in the Adventure series and Heroes.
BlueSkySlash
said at 7:37 PM on Tue Mar 29 2011
My list:

1. Lisa Ortiz

Out of all the 4kids cast, Lisa was one of the few voices actors that I thought was properly casted. Ever since Sonic X, she did a good job as Amy. At first I thought she sounded annoying when shouting in Amy's voice, but this is the script writer and voice director's fault and not Lisa's, I think. When she doesn't show Amy's extremely hot tempered side (which I can't stand), she otherwise did great with showcasting Amy's other emotions. I noticed she does make Amy a bit squeaky, which could be a nuisance to a few people. But I got used to it after a while, and think it suits her.

Overall, I liked Lisa's voice, and this may be the only 4kids voice I might miss, and I'll explain why later...


2. Jennifer Douillard

Jennifer comes close to Lisa in terms good quality and tone for Amy. I noticed that she makes Amy sound somewhat natural compared to Lisa. It's a high pitched voice, no doubt, but it didn't sound slightly squeaky like Lisa's does. I think that tone suits Amy fine as well, really. The only reason why I rank Jenny below Lisa is because her acting was mediocre, but mostly in the Sonic Adventure games. But when voice directed properly, she's very good with the role.


3. Cindy Robinson

I'll try to be as respectful as possible. Cindy was not a good choice for Amy's voice. I'm not sure what the casting directers were thinking in hiring her as Amy. It's too Minnie Mouse-like for my liking, and I think it's very unfitting for the character. I seriously hope they replace her, but that probably won't happen anytime soon. Lisa and Jennifer were much more fitting for the job than Cindy is.
TheUltimatePhantom1
said at 2:00 PM on Fri Jul 22 2011
@BlueSkySlash Not only that. There's another issue: Amy is supposed to be 17 years old! Does Cindy Robinson SOUND 17 YEARS OLD TO YOU!!!
NintendoNate25
said at 10:56 PM on Tue Jul 26 2011
@TheUltimatePhantom1 Actually, Amy is 12, not 17.
Sonic_Blaze
said at 5:52 PM on Tue Mar 29 2011
I can't really like them , I mean with Jenny she did good in the 3D games since I grew up with them and at least Amy could stand on her own with a homing attack.. to mean that's Amy. Lisa kinda made her sound a little more mature but during Sonic x Amy was everywhere that I sort found it annoying to here her, but it toned down a notch to where I liked it in unleashed. It's just time, they improve over time. I'm hoping Cindy does step up her A game though. She sounds like Minnie mouse and I hope she does get better so these pointless VA wars can like start to die down a bit
akmaldanish
said at 12:30 AM on Thu Mar 17 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I prefer Lisa Ortiz. She makes Amy sound more mature.
666Halen
said at 6:22 PM on Sat Feb 12 2011
Lisa is pefect at giving Amy that personality that combines sweetness and spunkiness with ferocity and aggression
Sonic_Blaze
said at 6:11 PM on Wed Feb 9 2011
Jenny sounded great as Amy for games.she makes Amy sound like she's close or around 12 which was nice. Lisa Sounds good for the anime plus she brings in drama and stuff. Cindy sounds like a minnie mouse sound alike but If she improves and starts sounding better then maybe just maybe
pokemastanumba1
said at 9:52 PM on Tue Jul 19 2011
@Sonic_Blaze Completely agreed.
AMT
said at 5:15 PM on Mon Feb 7 2011
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
I love lisa! She's a sweetheart! I think no one will ever play Amy like she did! =D
niawhite (Guest)
said at 8:24 AM on Sun Feb 6 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I want Lisa to play Amy again why did they pick Cindy this is Amy Rose not Minnie Mouse
victini (Guest)
said at 1:59 AM on Sun Feb 6 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Really 78 for Cindy? there is A poll on segas blog about how much they dislike her as Amy and over 300 people agree she bombs. Jennifer may not have had emotion but at least she isn't so cringing like Cindy
Truesonic
said at 7:02 PM on Thu Feb 3 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Lisa Oritz was the best Amy voice for me it fitted most than others

She gave Amy a strong,quite high pitched and mature voice which Amy should have it too connected to the character's personality it was more sweet sounding and rage sounding when angry XD those bits were funny futhermore Lisa made Amy somewhat Kinds,sweet,caring, natural brave,angry,funny and smart at the same time I like Amy's character more in Sonic X that way she was able to express her feelings deeply and solefully and Lisa nailed those perfomrances capturing every bit,presense,emotion,behavior and texture in the character and The scenes with Sonic are just laughable XD

I feel Amy didn't get much spotlight in the games and Lisa didn't either well she kinda did though Amy appeared in most games but mainly a supporting character and a battle player or cameo in the storybook series It's a shame the character didn't get much serious dialogue but I liked her in all peformances the best ones are...

Sonic X, Zero Gravity, 06, Unleashed and Black Knight also as the Lady Of The Lake and lol the ending I am disappointed 4Kids didn't voice the characters in Chronicles the lines were funny and the story was laughable especially Amy I wish lisa would have voiced her back then but looks like they didn't sigh If only

Lisa Oritz is the best Amy vocie for me :)

Jennifer Douillard comes second in my list she definately gave the Amy voice though she was a bit less high ptiched but still a little bit high though she sounds more natural too Her best peformance was uh.....actually let me scrape that part out the thing She lacked for Amy was in early performances most lines sounded fake mainly Shuffle and she sorta made a her a bit annoying when she appeared in scenes but she did a fine job though she still needed more time to develop just like all the people in the Original cast cept for Deem Bristow he was already good (R.I.P)

Best lines/perfomrances - SA2, Some in Adventure

Uhh Cindy Robinson O_O....

Okay I'll be honest she's doing a terrible job at the moment

The voice is more high pitched it is as high as Cream but a bit worser, The acting is okay but not good enough at the moment I've heard her in Both Free Riders and The DS Version of Colours I'm afraid I don't like her yet perhaps in time she will improve but to improve she needs to get rid of that high voice lower it down like Lisa and Jen did I'm not too keen on any of the voices yet but surely they will improve in the future but for now I think I will leave Cindy out It's just the voice that's the problem the lines and acting don't really make it better

1)Lisa Oritz
2) Jennifer Douillard
3) Cindy Robinson

Cindy is last for now....but hopefully she will improve in time It's just not working out for me at the moment...

Lisa definately gets my vote
gemma (Guest)
said at 6:26 PM on Thu Feb 3 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Sorry typo I meant Cindy makes a terrible Amy voice lol sorry :P
gemma (Guest)
said at 6:25 PM on Thu Feb 3 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
@Sonic1984

Not everyone is fond or Roger it's just her/his opinion for now

@Samantha

I understand you don't like the compliants but Wow you can't just say and act like that not everyone likes the new voices everyone is entitled to their own opinion that's just plain rude lashing out like that next time have a little respect please I do noot lyke dat attitude >:|

I like Jen and Lisa only

Cindy makes a terrible Lisa
Sarge Ray
said at 2:30 PM on Thu Feb 3 2011
Douillard: I'm not gonna say she's great, but she's FAR from terrible. My genuine complaint is her "put me down" line; not a lot of practice here.

Ortiz: Lise here is kind of hit-and-miss. She's had her bad moments, but she also has a few good moments with Amy.

Robinson: I'm HURT. This actress played the protagonist of Moribito. HOW can she mess up and sound like CREAM?!
sonfan1984 (Guest)
said at 1:41 AM on Mon Jan 31 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
@silverrose92
What do you mean that Roger Craig Smith doesn't give Sonic chemistry? I like how he portrayed Sonic in Colors and thinks he brings new life into the character.

But yeah, I agree with Amy's voice actor though. Hopefully Cindy will get better at the role
sonfan1984 (Guest)
said at 1:23 AM on Mon Jan 31 2011
I actually perfer Amy's old voice actors over her new one in Free Riders. Her new voice actor lefted a bad first impression for me. I was hoping that they give her a voice that made Amy sound LIKEABLE. I'm alright with everybody else, though. Amy's the only voice actor I didn't like out of the new cast.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 2:55 PM on Sun Jan 30 2011
Also, AMT, I got that image from her LinkedIn profile, so it is definitely her (lives in San Diego and everything, data matches up with her blog and other such sources, etc).
http://www.linkedin.com/in/jdouillard
NCZ (Admin)
said at 2:53 PM on Sun Jan 30 2011
Guess I was wrong. I read a more official source and apparently Jennifer Douillard went to high school from 1986-1990. So the Sonic Retro stuff about her being 11 when recording Amy and her real name being Erica Connery is untrue. So, disregard my previous comment.
perfect7en (Guest)
said at 8:20 PM on Sat Jan 29 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I liked Lisa Ortiz the best. All three of Amy's voices took some getting used too (I feel it's going to take longer for the third one) but I feel that Lisa has done the best job. Let's hope Cindy gets better in later games/media. She is a good VA in some of the anime she does so hopefully that will lead to improval.
s1lv3rblaz3 (Guest)
said at 5:19 PM on Wed Jan 26 2011
jennifer made amy sound older and cooler. Lisa's sounded more whinier
miriam (Guest)
said at 12:14 AM on Sun Jan 16 2011
forget that i said you should stop playing k but i still think cindy does a great voice for amy
miriam (Guest)
said at 9:36 PM on Mon Jan 10 2011
I think cindy lisa and jennifer made amy sound great so stop hating on the actresses and amy that much u act as if all the sonic characters were really people. people who think like that might deserve to be called mental. also i totally agree with samantha u guys should stop playing the sonic games if u hate their voices that much also u should stop arguing so get a life and deal with it also dont hate appreciate
NCZ (Admin)
said at 9:40 AM on Mon Jan 10 2011
Completely agreed, Samantha.
samantha (Guest)
said at 12:26 AM on Mon Jan 10 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I think cindy lisa and jennifer sounded all right so stop arguing on who is better and deal with it or get a life or stop playing the future sobic games and live with it man people these days
AMT
said at 10:46 PM on Thu Jan 6 2011
@nzc 11? Where'd you read that? Sonic Retro or something? She sounds way to old for an 11 year old girl

But even so, if that's true, then Jennifer's gotta be like 23 by now and in that picture she looks pretty old for a woman of that age. So are you sure that's the right picture? ._.
mitcheta21 (Guest)
said at 7:44 PM on Tue Jan 4 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
lisa describes amy the most. jennifer sounds okay, but not anything interesting, and cindy sounds like minnie mouse.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 11:15 AM on Sun Jan 2 2011
@blackrose

Actually, Jennifer Douillard was 11 or 12 when she first voiced Amy. So the two were just about the same age.

Also, I think Lisa sounding more aggressive has something to do with the writing. Sonic Heroes was goofy, Amy was on the sidelines in SA2, so she only got to show off her "independent fighting" side in Sonic Adventure. Whereas when Lisa voiced the character, Amy seemed to get mad all the time.
Truesonic
said at 9:30 AM on Sun Jan 2 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1) Lisa Oritz
2) Jennifer Douillard
3) Cindy Robinson

Lisa was the best Amy voice for me she gave Amy emotion and passion for how she feels and gave her mores strength she was great on every game but her best performances were Sonic X and Black Knight she did one of the most eventful performances She should be proud of her work she has done well these last 7 years good Luck for future roles Lisa I will really miss her as Amy

Jen was good but some perofmrances were a bit out of place but she was listenable and good unlike Cindy shes too squeaky almost as sqeuaky as Cream's last V/As O_o she has to tone it down in future games

@HuskyDreams

Don't be shocked not everyone hates 4Kids
MarioSonic
said at 7:11 PM on Tue Jul 26 2011
@Truesonic true dat
blackrose (Guest)
said at 6:17 AM on Sun Jan 2 2011
Why don't SEGA just get a 12 year old child actress to voice Amy?!

All three of them are middle aged women trying to portray a preteen with a crush; and they make Amy sound too stereotypical all the time. Same with Cream, how often do you get a 6 year old sounding like they're on helium?

Out of all of them, Lisa's is the least 'OMG! I love you Sonniku!', and gives Amy the edge she has; her character isn't just a lovesick Sonic fangirl, she's an independant fighter too.
diggy (Guest)
said at 12:01 PM on Fri Dec 31 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
it seems as though sega tried replace the 4kids cast with people who try to sound like the sonic adventure cast and they dont seem to nail it
anonymous (Guest)
said at 9:53 PM on Fri Dec 24 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
@huskydreams You took those words right out of my mouth...4Kids normally does so much worse at casting VAs for the English dubs of anything.

But yeah, I forgot to mention earlier that it would have been for the best if SEGA kept Lisa, it's just that I suggested Tara, Kate or Michele in case SEGA felt like they just HAD to recast the role for God-knows-what reason.
huskydreams (Guest)
said at 7:30 PM on Fri Dec 17 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Lisa's voice fits the best....wow, I can't believe I'm saying that about a 4Kids VA.
qtstar (Guest)
said at 2:09 AM on Sun Dec 12 2010
scratch that it's working now. ^^;
qtstar (Guest)
said at 2:05 AM on Sun Dec 12 2010
A Lisa Ortiz voice doesn't work and she's my favorite voice for Amy! I don't really like Cindy's version. D8 Jennifer Douillard was awesome too.
anonymous (Guest)
said at 7:58 PM on Sat Dec 11 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
@purplewarrior I agree with you...except for your last statement. No offense, but Cindy is TERRIBLE. I mean, SEGA could've gotten someone who can actually sound like a 12-year-old, like Tara Strong, Kate Higgins or Michele Knotz. Or they could have at least brought back Jennifer, since she had a decent performance in Sonic Heroes.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 3:23 PM on Thu Dec 9 2010
I think Jennifer is a little better than Lisa, but it is close. As I stated previously, I think Cindy's isn't that bad.
purplewarrior (Guest)
said at 10:13 PM on Sun Dec 5 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1. Lisa Ortiz
2. Jennifer Douillard
3. Cindy Robinson

But they were all good!
austinguy (Guest)
said at 4:52 PM on Sat Dec 4 2010
Well, turns out that Amy's lines in Sonic Adventure were recorded when she was 11. Guess she just sounded old for her age :P
austinguy (Guest)
said at 6:17 PM on Tue Nov 30 2010
Jennifer's is best, even if it's too old sounding to an extent. Now, the 4Kids one...too young and high-pitched, but the acting's pretty good. The newest one also has really good acting, but the voice is even HIGHER.
silverrose92 (Guest)
said at 10:02 PM on Sun Nov 28 2010
Yuck. I really hate Cindy Robinson's voice. Mostly because her and Roger Craig Smith's voice do NOT match at all. At least with Jason Griffith and Lisa Ortiz, and even Ryan Drummond and Jennifer Douillard, there was some chemistry. But these new voices, NO CHEMISTRY AT ALL!

I mean, these new voices of Sonic and Amy have totally ruined my Sonamy fangirlness. I'm starting to loose interest in seeing Sonic and Amy ever getting together, and its been my biggest wish forever.

At least I can always watch those sonamy episodes in Sonic X *sigh*

So yeah, bring back Lisa Ortiz! Or at least get Cindy Roinson to improve.

But its better to bring back Lisa Ortiz. And bring back the rest of the 4kids cast aswell.
AMT
said at 11:41 PM on Tue Nov 23 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
@david thats exactly how I feel... And its even worse now that we have to listen to her voice this character from now on T.T""
pokemastanumba1
said at 9:49 PM on Tue Jul 19 2011
@AMT Maybe not. I heard from Mike Pollock that Generations might hold reauditions for all the main characters, so hopefully there'll be a change here.
david (Guest)
said at 12:47 PM on Mon Nov 22 2010
I don't like the way the Sonic Free Riders voice sounds. Amy's my favourite character too :(
dan (Guest)
said at 2:32 AM on Sat Nov 20 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Lisa Ortiz is easily the best one.

Cindy sounds like Minnie Mouse... >_>
AMT
said at 12:44 AM on Fri Nov 19 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Well SEGA, you officially began the destruction of one of my most favorite sonic characters by giving her this new voice... Let's just sit back and watch her popularity go down the toilet now, shall we?

Oh and p.s., Bring. Back. Lisa.
pokemastanumba1
said at 9:34 PM on Tue Jul 19 2011
@AMT After seeing the comments on YouTube videos of Sonic Free Riders, I think this was already done now...
4kidssonic (Guest)
said at 9:38 PM on Mon Nov 15 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Agreed jared WTH SEGA Lisa was Gold
jared (Guest)
said at 8:07 PM on Thu Nov 11 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Cindy is TERRIBLE!! At least bring back Lisa 'cuz in my opinion, she and Douillard are the only two that could fit the character better... I'm sorry that only Amy had the most annoying voice in Free Riders... What was Sega thinkin'?
chaddy (Guest)
said at 1:38 PM on Thu Nov 11 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I don't understand how they could axe Lisa like that. Cindy's voice is terrible at Amy. Jennifer's good though! But, Lisa should totally return.
Truesonic
said at 5:03 PM on Tue Nov 9 2010
Cindy sounds a bit squeaky but not bad still prefer Lisa Oritz but as of course we will see how it goes

(Almost sounds like Cream's last voice actor Rebecca Sol )
SSSSSSSSSSSSSS (Guest)
said at 3:38 PM on Tue Nov 9 2010
didn't cindy sound like minne moouse witch is unisseapable
NCZ (Admin)
said at 12:54 PM on Tue Nov 9 2010
Cindy Robinson added.
AMT
said at 5:33 PM on Fri Nov 5 2010
Wendee Lee is NOT the voice of Amy Rose! Cindy Robinson is confirmed! Go the Sonic Free Riders page and look at my comment for the Game credits in the youtube vid link I posted!
pokemastanumba1
said at 9:28 PM on Tue Jul 19 2011
@AMT After hearing Amy in Sonic Free Riders, I really wish it was Wendee Lee...
michael (Guest)
said at 5:24 PM on Fri Nov 5 2010
Wendee is better than Lisa, but worse than Jennifer.

Wendee makes her sound like Minnie Mouse. I was hoping that Kate Higgins would voice Amy using her Sakura voice, but it turns out that she used that voice for Wave the Swallow, and it fits her better anyway.
omg (Guest)
said at 8:59 PM on Thu Oct 21 2010
Amy's voice is really adorable and I'm a fan of her because she has my favorite color, PINK!
My Favorite Quote, "AMY ROSE IS HERE!"
Truesonic
said at 11:26 AM on Sun Sep 5 2010
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
@purplewarrior
I AGREE DEFINATELY I LIKED HER ALOT IN FACT I LIKE THE WHOLE CAST

THE 4KIDS VOICE CAST IN MY OPINION WERE FAR SUPERIOR THAN THE ORIGINAL CAST
THE ACTING WAS AWESOME AND OUTSTANDING

THEY GOT EVEN BETTER
IN UNLEASHED AND BLACK KNIGHT
ALSO RIVALS 2
purplewarrior (Guest)
said at 5:30 PM on Thu Sep 2 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Lisa FTW!! May she be retained for future Sonic Games like Mike Pollock! She had the best voice of all the 4Kids Sonic performances!
mp40 (Guest)
said at 12:43 PM on Thu Aug 19 2010
Neither is terrible, but Lisa is better.
satoshi
said at 11:27 AM on Thu Aug 19 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Man shame Jennifer had a perfect voice for Amy, but her delivery was so monotone, and didn't really show any emotion at all. Liza eh I hear here voice a little too often, but shes a good fit for Amy and tries to turn in a decent performance despite some of the lines she had to work with.
Truesonic
said at 7:46 PM on Wed Aug 18 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Lisa deffo :D she has more emotion thats what jen lacked :|
sonicluver (Guest)
said at 1:06 AM on Wed Aug 18 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Lisa fits Amy. Nuff said.
driuco (Guest)
said at 6:46 AM on Fri Aug 13 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
The both sound so similar, i dont know which one to pick.
takiyah (Guest)
said at 9:40 AM on Sun May 2 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I love Lisa Ortiz . Jennifer Douillard is just as good but, I love Lisa Ortiz alot.
jack (Guest)
said at 6:14 PM on Mon Apr 26 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Even though i'm biased (I went to highschool with her!) I have to go with Jennifer...very pure voice!
al (Guest)
said at 11:45 AM on Sat Mar 13 2010
I have to go with Jennifer, since I'm sick of hearing Lisa's "teenager with an attitude problem" voice on every single one of the 500 characters she's played.
anonymous (Guest)
said at 3:03 AM on Mon Feb 8 2010
 1 Shout Out! [?]
lisa sounds better imo

then again they didnt choose very good clips for the other girl. but i remember her voice being pretty annoying in the adventure games
gaijinotaku (Guest)
said at 10:51 PM on Sat Jan 16 2010
I know a lot of people will disagree with me, but Lisa is FAR superior IMO. I absolutely cannot STAND Jennifer's voice. Lisa's voice is perfect for the character.
marcello (Guest)
said at 7:59 AM on Sun Nov 22 2009
I chose Jennifer, but Lisa has gotten better latley. Still I like Jennifer more
jeff (Guest)
said at 4:38 PM on Tue Oct 6 2009
This is the only time I'll go with the new cast. They both were great, and the Sonic Adventure games had a better overall voice cast, I do like Lisa Ortiz as Amy a lot!
Foxwolf (Admin)
said at 1:16 AM on Tue Oct 6 2009
the sounds fixed now
Pokejedservo (Moderator)
said at 10:01 PM on Mon Oct 5 2009
I know, I told the owner of the site about it and hopefully he will fix this soon.
jeff (Guest)
said at 3:32 PM on Mon Oct 5 2009
The sound doesn't work!


A favorite Voice Compare
for 22 members.
Latest Reason:

"Jennifer was good!Lisa Ortiz was PERFECT!Cindy Robinson is...Ahh!"

- Blaze
BTVA POLL
Who do you think has been the best from these Amy Rose voice actors?
Jennifer Douillard
Lisa Ortiz
Cindy Robinson