Hilda Spellman
Sabrina: The Teenage Witch Sabrina: The Teenage Witch

Hilda Spellman

Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Hilda Spellman with sound clips and images.
Franchise: Sabrina: The Teenage Witch

One of Sabrina's aunts that takes care of her. Originally Hilda was the typical witch, ugly and liked doing bad things and was disgusted by Sabrina's good deeds and was the more serious one between the two aunts. However, starting with the 1996 sitcom, she was blonde and pretty and was the eccentric yet somewhat scattered brain and was the "fun one" of the two aunts. In the animated series to Secret Life, she became a brunette and her skin color became tanner (which oddly caused some to wonder if Hilda was suppose to be Hispanic in the said series) however her personality is much like her sitcom counter part but her "party girl" personality is shown a bit more.
Created by Music Meister on Sep 25 2013
Special thanks to CatsTuxedo for additional sound clips.
Sabrina the Teenage Witch (1971)
Hilda SpellmanJane Webb
Jane Webb
Sabrina: The Animated Series (1999)
Hilda SpellmanMelissa Joan Hart
Melissa Joan Hart
Sabrina, the Teenage Witch: Spellbound (1999)
Hilda SpellmanCaroline Rhea
Caroline Rhea
Sabrina: Friends Forever (2002)
Hilda SpellmanMoneca Stori
Moneca Stori
Sabrina: Secrets of a Teenage Witch (2013)
Hilda SpellmanTabitha St Germain
Tabitha St Germain


Ladies and gentlemen we know look at the other aunt, Hilda!

Jane Webb: Jane gives a good "typical witch" kind of voice but she did well to give Hilda a sense of humor and did sound like she was enjoying herself.

Caroline Rhea: Comedian and actor, Caroline Rhea was another actor from the original sitcom to reprise their role in this game. Caroline has had plenty of energy and comedic timing to really make this version of Hilda sound like the scattered brain that she is and sound like she's having fun. This is a good example of Caroline's voice acting.

Melissa Joan Hart: Melissa does a higher voice for Hilda (to contrast with the lower voice she gave Zelda) and does fit for the more party girl version of Hilda. However, sometimes her voice didn't come off as natural and (like I mentioned in the Zelda compare) she would slip in and out of her Hilda and Zelda voices and this would be confusing when the two argued. Still, it is an enjoyable performance and is a good example of Melissa Joan Hart's voice acting.

Moneca Stori: Much like all of the cast from the animated series, Hilda was recasted after DiC was no longer apart of Disney. That said, Meneca was a natural in the role. She also gave a pretty high voice for Hilda but she came off as more natural and had a good amount of energy. This is a good example of Moneca's voice work and Friends Forever (and Secret Life's) casting .

In the end each of these ladies did a very good job but my personal favorites are Moneca and Carline but Melissa and Jane are very close seconds.

Music Meister


Add a Comment

said at 7:15 PM on Thu Jan 5 2017
Wile I grew up on the others, Jane Webb sounds the most stereotypically witchy.
said at 1:38 PM on Tue Jul 7 2015
 1 Shout Out!
1) Jane Webb
2) Tabitha St. Germain
3) Caroline Rhea
4) Melissa Joan Hart
5) Moneca Stori
said at 11:38 AM on Thu Sep 25 2014
Tabitha's sounds a lot like when she did Scary Godmother.
said at 3:40 AM on Thu Sep 25 2014
1 Caroline
2 Jane
3 Tabitha
4 Melissa
5 Moneca
said at 3:39 AM on Thu Sep 25 2014
The only one I really like is Caroline 'Linda Flynn/Fletcher' Rhea
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 7:55 PM on Tue Oct 8 2013
In case anyone was wondering, it was Jane's clip that was updated
said at 12:22 PM on Thu Sep 26 2013
Went with Melissa on the other two but I'll pick Caroline here and Melissa and Moneca are tied for 2nd. Jane is as good as the original.
said at 10:26 AM on Thu Sep 26 2013
Jane Webb was great, but her version is an entirely different character than the others. She did great portraying the original version of this character, and she really showed her range in this show (Jane is definitely an underrated voice actress).

Caroline Rhea basically carries over her sitcom performance. Nothing wrong with that, but it isn't as distinct as the others.

Melissa Joan Hart is alright, but a little clumsy in places.

Moneca Stori sounded like an improved version of Melissa's, and was great in this role.

Overall, I like Moneca the best of the newer version of the character, and Jane was good as the original.
said at 3:44 AM on Thu Sep 26 2013
I've gotta go with Caroline Rhea here. & riding in second place, as always, Melissa Joan Hart.
said at 11:47 PM on Wed Sep 25 2013
Again going with Melissa Joan Hart
She really distinguished both sisters' personalities
Zelda is a hippie-esque type of character, and Hilda is more of a scatterbrain
Faved by 3 BTVA Members

Support Behind The Voice Actors on Patreon
What is Patreon?
Who do you think has been the best from these Hilda Spellman voice actors?
Jane Webb
Caroline Rhea
Melissa Joan Hart
Moneca Stori
Tabitha St Germain