Created by Pokejedservo on Jul 28 2009
EDITOR'S OPINION
Misty, quite possibly one of the most known Tsunderes in all of modern anime. (Well in the US at least of course.) But still she is well known as the Gym Leader of Cerulean City and the original "Girl traveling in Ash's little group".Ever since Misty's debut in the anime back in the late 90's she has been voiced by Rachel Lillis, and Rachel is very well known for this role (and quite understandably so). And yes I too am one of the plenty whom always did enjoy Rachel Lillis' handiwork as Misty and its always been some of her best handiwork.
Though in the rather infamous Pokemon The Mastermind of Mirage Pokemon (and occasionally afterwards) she was voiced by Michele Knotz whom also voiced a certain other familiar Rachel Lillis role. And Michele Knotz always went for the sound-a-like route for her known Pokemon Female Human roles (except for May... at first, but that's a different story.) But still Michele does do a pretty good sound-a-like and overall does a fairly satisfactory performance as Misty. (But then again by the time Michele got to voice Misty it was at the time when Misty only very occasionally ever appeared at all in the Pokemon anime so its not like Michele had that much time to voice Misty.)
Overall neither one are bad but I am going with Rachel Lillis here.
Pokejedservo
Comments
Add a Comment
said at 9:33 PM on Sun Feb 7 2016
Once again Michele manages to do a perfect impression one of Rachel Lillis' voices, but since Rachel originated the role (in English) my vote goes to her, Misty is my favorite Rachel Lillis character after all.
Replysaid at 3:02 PM on Sat Jan 2 2016
Rachel Lillis really shined and brought out the best as Misty, both her kind-hearted sweet moments and also her angrier and snarkier moments. She just fits The Tomboyish Mermaid perfectly.
Michele Knotz didn't have much time to work with in the role like Rachel, she's fine I suppose? Though I rather would have had Lillis return.
ReplyMichele Knotz didn't have much time to work with in the role like Rachel, she's fine I suppose? Though I rather would have had Lillis return.
said at 2:10 PM on Fri Jan 1 2016
1) Rachael Lillis- Perfect fit, not much I can really say, she nailed it sounding genuinely like a tomboyish girl.
2) Michele Knotz- What user HeroRises143 said, it's spot on, really.
Reply2) Michele Knotz- What user HeroRises143 said, it's spot on, really.
said at 4:17 PM on Fri May 1 2015
Rachael is better because she sounds more tomboyish and natural in the role.
Michele sounds a bit forced and unnatural but was still good in the Mastermind Special, but in the Unova flashback her performance degenerated and now sounds too much like dub Iris.
ReplyMichele sounds a bit forced and unnatural but was still good in the Mastermind Special, but in the Unova flashback her performance degenerated and now sounds too much like dub Iris.
said at 8:51 PM on Mon Oct 13 2014
I think I'll go with Michelle, she didn't have much but she was as good as Rachael despite the limited material and to be fair the degrading on BW was from lack of practice, not sure if Rachael would be much better if she had years of hiatus
Replysaid at 9:26 AM on Sun Jun 22 2014
#1) Rachael Lillis (EP001-EP276 = AG/Hoenn 3-Part Cameo = Early BF/AG132-AG134)- Perfect. She was so awesome in this role, that she even outdoes her ORG JPN Seiyu Mayumi Iizuka to me, who was also quite excellent. She managed to get the fiery temper down well, but also the sweet and caring side as well-- she nailed it. 10/10
#2) Michele Knotz (Pokemon: Learning League > MoMP > BW116)- Good. Michele did a great job with Misty in MoMP, doing an almost spot on imitation of Rachael's Misty, but the only thing that she was lacking in comparison was proper delivery of her lines/the acting, which was awkward, like "WHAT in the world brought YOU here?" She improved in the Pokemon: Learning League Shorts, and was an equal to Rachael as Misty there. However, in BW116, she sounded completely off in ther ole, and more like Eileen Stevens' Iris than Rachael Lillis' Misty. 8/10
Reply#2) Michele Knotz (Pokemon: Learning League > MoMP > BW116)- Good. Michele did a great job with Misty in MoMP, doing an almost spot on imitation of Rachael's Misty, but the only thing that she was lacking in comparison was proper delivery of her lines/the acting, which was awkward, like "WHAT in the world brought YOU here?" She improved in the Pokemon: Learning League Shorts, and was an equal to Rachael as Misty there. However, in BW116, she sounded completely off in ther ole, and more like Eileen Stevens' Iris than Rachael Lillis' Misty. 8/10
said at 1:57 PM on Sat Jun 7 2014
Rachael Lillis was perfect in this role! Though Michele Knotz wasn't bad.
Replysaid at 12:58 PM on Tue Oct 1 2013
They're both so similar sounding. Eerily similar. Michelle Knotz' Rachael Lillis impression for Misty, as with Jessie, is simply perfect. However, you still can't beat the real, original Rachael Lillis. Her Misty was absolute perfection, to the point where many (myself included) prefer it over the character's original Japanese voice. She gets my vote every time.
Replysaid at 10:15 PM on Mon Aug 19 2013
Rachael Lillis. Michele Knotz was just doing a cheap imitation of Lillis in the Mastermind Special, but she did improve greatly in the "Pokemon Learning League" Shorts online for a time. However, with the recent flashback in BW, it seems Michele Knotz has completely lost her touch with Misty.
In BW116, Misty said "Charmander looks funny," and I swear she sounded just like Eileen Stevens does as Iris. I know it's only one line, but it seems like Michele has actually gotten worse at Misty in the recent era episodes.
Rachael Lillis is the best voice actor for Misty. Hot-tempered, fiery, passionate...Lillis had it all down pat for Misty. She was very well cast in this role.
Michele Knotz is pretty average...she's not good or bad. She's just okay in this role, and she's gotten worse in BW116. Rachael Lillis wins this one.
ReplyIn BW116, Misty said "Charmander looks funny," and I swear she sounded just like Eileen Stevens does as Iris. I know it's only one line, but it seems like Michele has actually gotten worse at Misty in the recent era episodes.
Rachael Lillis is the best voice actor for Misty. Hot-tempered, fiery, passionate...Lillis had it all down pat for Misty. She was very well cast in this role.
Michele Knotz is pretty average...she's not good or bad. She's just okay in this role, and she's gotten worse in BW116. Rachael Lillis wins this one.
said at 1:00 PM on Tue Oct 1 2013
@OldSchoolFTW To be fair, Misty hadn't been seen in a loooong time, so Michele was WAY out of practice for that part.
Replysaid at 12:51 AM on Sat Oct 5 2013
@Galactic_Cyrus
Agreed. Michele could probably do a great job as Misty again, if she had the time to get comfortable in the role.
ReplyAgreed. Michele could probably do a great job as Misty again, if she had the time to get comfortable in the role.
said at 6:57 PM on Sat Oct 5 2013
@OldSchoolFTW If not, then they ought to just have Rachael voice Misty again if the character makes a future appearance. They had her to voice Maylene after all.
Replysaid at 12:28 PM on Fri Aug 16 2013
Misty is no pushover. Rachael Lillis proves that fact a million times. Michele Knotz, on the other hand, makes Misty look like a pushover. I speak for all Pokemon fans when I say everyone prefers Rachael Lillis more than Michele Knotz, am I right?
Replysaid at 6:07 AM on Mon Sep 30 2013
@Legacyman You realise there are 5 people who prefer Michele, don't you?
Replysaid at 12:59 PM on Tue Oct 1 2013
@Legacyman Most everyone prefers Rachael Lillis, but Michelle was a very close second in her earliest days as Misty. She only made her sound like a pushover in the BW Charizard episode.
Replysaid at 10:40 AM on Thu Oct 3 2013
@Galactic_Cyrus Rachael's Misty is too memorable, and those scenes that show the firey red-head temper are proof
Replysaid at 5:48 PM on Thu Oct 3 2013
@MatthewC17 Agreed. Rachael just OWNED the role they way nobody else can.
Replysaid at 10:28 PM on Sat Jul 27 2013
Like I said about Jessie, Rachael Lillis makes the perfect voice for Misty. She knows how to make the character more interesting than any other female. Michele Knotz botched it badly when she took over.
Replysaid at 1:02 PM on Tue Oct 1 2013
@Legacyman Michele actually sounded alot better in the Mastermind of Mirages special than just that one clip would lead you to believe. She was at least good at sounding like how Rachael was voicing Misty by late Johto.
Replysaid at 12:24 AM on Wed Nov 21 2012
Misty/Kasumi, the tomboyish mermaid.
1) Rachael Lillis- Phenomenal. It's rare that an English dub performance supercedes even its Japanese counterpart to most people, but I must say Lillis did to me. She just sound like she has this fiery intensity in her voice that is absolutely perfect for Misty.
2) Mayumi Iizuka- Great performance. Fits Kasumi very well, but a bit too sweet-sounding. Still can pull off the tomboyish side of her well enough, and is a pleasure to hear.
3) Michele Knotz- Decent performance. Rather generic and forced, but a good voice for the character. Not the worst performance in TPCi English but not the best one either.
Reply1) Rachael Lillis- Phenomenal. It's rare that an English dub performance supercedes even its Japanese counterpart to most people, but I must say Lillis did to me. She just sound like she has this fiery intensity in her voice that is absolutely perfect for Misty.
2) Mayumi Iizuka- Great performance. Fits Kasumi very well, but a bit too sweet-sounding. Still can pull off the tomboyish side of her well enough, and is a pleasure to hear.
3) Michele Knotz- Decent performance. Rather generic and forced, but a good voice for the character. Not the worst performance in TPCi English but not the best one either.
said at 5:24 PM on Sun Dec 30 2012
@Dra12as I agree with you all the way
Knotz is a decent replacement but Lillis is Misty
ReplyKnotz is a decent replacement but Lillis is Misty
said at 9:27 PM on Wed Oct 17 2012
Though Rachel Lillis may be working on stage and broadway at the moment but I did read on Save Our Voice Actors, that she's willing to come back on Pokemon. She's been allowed back before to do minor roles but I feel she's about ready to regain her rightful place as Jessie. Whatever happens, it's time that Pokemon got revolutionized, starting with bringing Lillis and the others back.
Replysaid at 4:49 PM on Thu Dec 6 2012
@Revolution9 Yeah I miss that charm Lillis would put in when she voiced her characters
Replysaid at 4:00 PM on Sun Sep 2 2012
I really am not a big fan of Michele Knotz being in recast roles. Sometimes it works (like here), but other times (May), she just miserably fails. I'll have to go with Rachael Lillis here, however. Michele is a bit bland.
Replysaid at 8:37 AM on Wed Aug 15 2012
Rachael was amazing in this role! She completely nailed the character, and sounded very natural.
Not to be rude, but I dislike Micheal to complete hell, but I guess she was the best VA that TPCI had to voice Misty. To be honest she isn't so bad in this role, still Rachael by a landslide.
ReplyNot to be rude, but I dislike Micheal to complete hell, but I guess she was the best VA that TPCI had to voice Misty. To be honest she isn't so bad in this role, still Rachael by a landslide.
said at 1:23 AM on Sun Jul 8 2012
I couldn't really tell the difference...OK, fine, Rachel
Replysaid at 2:59 PM on Mon May 14 2012
Always Racheal. No doubt about it. First voice I ever heard, loved and brought happiness to my life when I was little. Always love her voice
Replysaid at 9:33 PM on Mon Apr 2 2012
Ah the memories... I really wish they hadn't cut Misty... I pretty much stopped watching the show after the 2 season, like for instance I heard the new theme song and was thinking (literally) "WHAT IN THE HELL IS THAT" I just feel like they have made so so many bad decisions, like while I was writing this I could hear the season 1 theme song (in my mind) and I just feel they need to fall back on the things that they did that were good. Any waus for all this rambling I haven't gotten very far. Out of Rachael Lillis and Michele Knotz I definitly prefer Lillis, and seriously you older gen people like me, remember those cool "little" pikachu shorts/adventures they did with the movies (I miss them so much). T_T
Replysaid at 9:49 PM on Tue Aug 23 2011
I'm for Rachel's voice. :) She sounds more pure and innocent than Michelle does.
Replysaid at 5:26 PM on Mon Aug 15 2011
I love Rachael's Misty she sounds cute
Michele's Misty sounds too much like her May voice
ReplyMichele's Misty sounds too much like her May voice
said at 11:26 PM on Fri May 6 2011
This is absolutely no contest. Rachael for the win!
Replysaid at 1:01 AM on Sat Apr 16 2011
They sound almost exactly the same! Michelle Knotz did a REALLY good imitation of Rachel Lillis' Misty.
Still, can't quite beat the original so Rachel gets my vote.
ReplyStill, can't quite beat the original so Rachel gets my vote.
said at 12:55 AM on Fri Feb 11 2011
Racheal is amazing in the role. She creates such a geniune feeling. But Michele is decent, even if she is doing an impression.
Replysaid at 10:24 PM on Fri Oct 22 2010
not sure if you're joking or not but if you're serious and actually want to know, Misty was Ash's original traveling partner for Kanto, Orange Islands and Johto (original series).
After she left May replaced her in Hoenn and Battle Frontier. Then Dawn replaced May in Sinnoh.
If you haven't watched the old episodes you probably wouldn't know of Misty since he rarely appears anymore.
ReplyAfter she left May replaced her in Hoenn and Battle Frontier. Then Dawn replaced May in Sinnoh.
If you haven't watched the old episodes you probably wouldn't know of Misty since he rarely appears anymore.
Search for "
" on Amazon.com.
said at 9:13 PM on Tue Apr 19 2016
2. Michele Knotz: Once again Knotz tries to imitate Lillis, she sounds decent here but in BW116 her Misty sounded atrocious. Given the fact that she didn't voice the character as long as Lillis so I honestly can't say this ranking is fair.