Created by CatsTuxedo on Aug 18 2011
EDITOR'S OPINIONIn a shocking turn of events in terms of My Little Pony voice compares thus far, this two incarnations of Scootaloo are actually similar to each other in that both are sports-favoring ponies with an infatuation for "coolness". However, given the tame nature of the G3.5 series, Germain's Scootaloo hardly sounds any tougher than the other ponies despite supposedly being the tomboy of the group. Since Friendship is Magic is not bound by the same air of saccharinity as the Generation 3 works were, Peters is much more free to perform as the brash tomboy that Scootaloo was intended to be, and she pulls it off while sounding authentically like a child quite nicely. My vote goes to Peters.