Created by CatsTuxedo on Jul 9 2010
Special thanks to NCZ, DaveS for additional sound clips.
EDITOR'S OPINIONBrother Theodore's rendition is very convincing, not to mention fun to listen to.
Peter Woodthrope's acting is pretty solid, but his voice lacks the creaturesque quality that makes the character.
Andy Serkis does a good job at making Gollum sound vicious and ill-tempered and Smeagol sound pitiful and benign, but what is more impressive is that both voices never sound like they're coming from completely different people, which captures the duality of the character nicely.
Quinton Flynn sounds like he has potential, but he has too minor of a role to really show the audience what he can do.
Daran Norris, while having the voice down-pat, isn't quite strong enough ("My riiing" is particularly weak).
In the end, I'm going with Serkis, with Brother Theodore a close second.