Lord of the Rings Voice Compares
Browse VOICE COMPARE
#ABCDEF
GHIJKLM
NOPQRST
UVWXYZ
OTHER LION KING COMPARES
Lion King

Voice Compare » Lion King » Scar

Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Scar with sound clips and images.
(Note: While some clips claimed that James Avery voiced Scar in the 1995 CD-Rom game "Disney's Animated Storybook The Lion King", after finding a couple of vids on it online this is confirmed to be false.)
Created by Pokejedservo on Sun Jul 11 2010, 68 Comments, Add Comment
Share/Save/Bookmark
The Lion King (1994)
ScarJeremy Irons
Jeremy Irons
The Lion King (1994)
ScarJim Cummings
Jim Cummings
Kingdom Hearts II (2006)
ScarJames Horan
James Horan

EDITOR'S OPINION

Ah yes Scar, one of Disney's most renowned villains whom is often considered to be a classic example of a sinister manipulator (with an more than occasional troublesome ego).

In the classic 1994 film "The Lion King" he was voiced by known British actor Jeremy Irons. Jeremy is fairly well known for being a character actor and this is a fairly good reason why and lets just say I can understand why its one of Jeremy Irons' most renowned performances as it was a perfectly suitable for Scar's personality.

Though for a little bit of trivial info, Jeremy Irons temporarily damaged his vocal cords so at least for the latter portion of the highly renowned Villain song "Be Prepared", VA Jim Cummings took over and lets just say he was a definitely suitable replacement even if it is only brief. (Oh yes and Jim also voiced Scar in his cameo in the Lion King II, heck some people couldn't even tell that Jim Cummings did the last part of the song "Be Prepared".)

A little over a decade later in Kingdom Hearts II, while there were role reprisals in that game for Disney Characters Scar wasn't one of them in which he was voiced by James Horan. I will say this much that James did certainly try to sound like Jeremy Irons' Scar voice but it came off as an average at best impression. (And KH2 probably should have just used Jim Cummings I mean he was definitely already in the game.)

 I am going with Jeremy Irons and Jim Cummings the most and James Horan at a semi-distant 2nd place.

Pokejedservo

Latest Comments

Add a Comment

Bauglir100
said at 3:04 PM on Tue Dec 9 2014
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
What if Maurice LaMarche voiced Scar?
Slick
said at 3:37 PM on Tue Dec 9 2014
He would be great!
Metabad
said at 5:01 PM on Tue Dec 9 2014
@Bauglir100 Sorry, he's a great actor, but I can't see it working all that well.
Bauglir100
said at 4:26 PM on Wed Dec 10 2014
@Metabad I guess it would depend on what kind of voice he gives him. I think I could see Maurice using a rough, but not too gravelly or guttural, version of his voice for The Brain.
Metabad
said at 8:48 PM on Wed Dec 10 2014
@Bauglir100 Ehhh...that's the one voice I think really wouldn't work at all for Scar.

I could see maybe something like his Dr. Doom working if he deepened it a bit, but I'm still not really crazy over the idea.
Zillah
said at 7:21 PM on Sun Dec 7 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Jeremy Irons IS Scar to me, but Jim did a pretty spot on impression. Seriously, I could never tell it was 2 people playing the role at once as a kid, and it took me until doing the research myself to find out.

James Horan isn't bad, but I'm honestly confused as to why they didn't have Jim voice him in the Kingdom Hearts games, I mean he already had a few roles in there (Winnie the Pooh, Tigger and Pete), so it just confuses me as to why he didn't get that role as well.
CuriousUserX90
said at 1:30 AM on Sun Nov 16 2014
Surprised that Tony Jay never voiced Scar, having a Similar Sort of Voice to Shere Khan the Tiger.
Jacob M. Keene
said at 6:56 PM on Sun Nov 16 2014
@CuriousUserX90 And if he did, then that probably would've been the only time where James Earl Jones and Tony Jay (my two most favorite actors/voice actors ever [Tony Jay at #01 and James Earl Jones at #02]) are in some of the same scenes together! But the closest they ever came to being in the same media was the show "The Greatest Adventure: Stories From the Bible" (in separate episodes, but still).
CuriousUserX90
said at 12:29 AM on Mon Nov 17 2014
@Jacob M. Keene Do you Consider Scar and Shere Khan having Similar Sorts of Voices.
CuriousUserX90
said at 12:32 AM on Mon Nov 17 2014
@Jacob M. Keene Whose Voice Exactly does Scar's Voice Remind you of that has the Same Voice Actor as him?
Jacob M. Keene
said at 7:47 PM on Mon Nov 17 2014
@CuriousUserX90 I don't think of them having similar voices, and I haven't seen anything else with Jeremy Irons in it besides The Lion King.
Joker123
said at 3:45 PM on Wed Sep 17 2014
Jeremey all the way.

Jim was good here and could have easily reprised his role in kh2, even if it was just his robotik voice.

James Horan...I dunno, when he's not doing the lines from the film and using the game dialogue as scars ghost, it was alright, but it just sounds like he's rushing it and lacks the energy and roughness Jeremy had. He's improved a bit on magical kingdom, but as a different character and not scar, I'd like to hear more of that voice
Ikrani
said at 10:09 PM on Sat Aug 30 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Tie between Jeremy and Jim, mainly because I didn't notice the difference until I learned that there WAS a difference.
Slick
said at 5:49 PM on Tue Aug 5 2014
 4 Shout Outs! [?]
I bet Ron Perlman would make a great Scar. He has a good creepy, haunting voice.
Zillah
said at 7:14 PM on Tue Aug 5 2014
@Slick Oh man, that was be amazing.
Zillah
said at 7:14 PM on Tue Aug 5 2014
@Zillah *would be*

damn typos
Bookman230
said at 6:44 PM on Sun Jun 1 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I'm almost disappointed Avery voicing Scar is false. /That/ sounds interesting.
HienFan
said at 2:29 AM on Wed May 21 2014
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
They should have hired Jim in Kingdom Hearts, James sounds terrible here.

Pity since Jim is good in the PS1 game
DVJ
said at 6:27 PM on Mon Apr 7 2014
Jeremy Irons,of course,that guy has the perfect voice for sneering,manipulative villains.

Jim Cummings does a dam good impressiom

James Horan is somewhere between meh and barely lukeworm at best,and i find him to sound way to whimsy and foopish
Hero of Legend
said at 6:55 PM on Wed Oct 23 2013
In the PS1 game, Jim completely redubbed Jeremy in the cutscenes, here's a good one:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCldA0SCoHw

@10:29 is the cutscene after the final fight in the movie, if spoilers are allowed, this is a great one.
JTurner
said at 10:47 PM on Fri Aug 23 2013
 4 Shout Outs! [?]
Jeremy Irons. No doubt. He simply IS Scar. I honestly didn't realize Jim Cummings did the second half of his song until after the fact. I DID recognize him slightly in the sequel thoguh. Horan, sorry to say, isn't very good. He lacks both the menace and the bite that Jeremy had. Jim did a good job, but Jeremy gets my vote. It's easily one of his best roles ever.
Ross123
said at 4:31 PM on Wed Jul 17 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Jim doesn't count as he does the singing.

Jeremy is the best though James was a good voice double.
GothamRed
said at 9:01 PM on Sun Mar 16 2014
@Ross123 Jim also voiced him in the Lion King 2
Ross123
said at 1:29 PM on Mon Mar 17 2014
@GothamRed When I posted that comment I forgot about that. Mainly because Scar's appearance was pretty brief in that movie. I haven't seen The Lion King 2 in ages. Thanks for reminding me of that performance as it has brought back some childhood memories.
HienFan
said at 12:21 AM on Sat Jul 26 2014
@Ross123 Jim also voiced Scar in a PS1 game I have called Simba's Pride

I have to wonder why did they hire someone else for Scar in KH2 instead of using Jim
Ross123
said at 4:41 AM on Sat Jul 26 2014
@HienFan I wondered the same thing. The only answer that I can think of is Square Enix wanted to try something new with some of the Disney characters.

I also question Tress MacNeille as Kanga in KH 2 as well. Like Jim, Kath was also voicing characters in the game.
HienFan
said at 12:53 AM on Sun Jul 27 2014
@Ross123 Or Square's history of choosing the worst possible voice actors/giving really weird directions
Monotone Aerith and Ansem/Xehanort heartless in 2, Terra and Aqua in Birth by sleep, Mickey in the remakes of Chain of memory and Coded(not like those two got much storywise anyway), Cloud's voice period(yeah I don't like his dub voice haw haw...)
Ross123
said at 11:18 AM on Mon Jul 28 2014
@HienFan Disagree with Mickey & Ansem/Xehanort as I enjoy Bret & Richard's performances. If you don't like them more power to you.

As for the rest you just mentioned, I couldn't agree more.

Although, critics praise Square for their casting choices in the 2 main games. Critics do agree with Terra being terrible BBS.
HienFan
said at 9:07 PM on Mon Jul 28 2014
@Ross123 I meant their voices in those games(I voted for Richard as Ansem/Xehanort) they sound okay in the other games
Ross123
said at 9:23 AM on Tue Jul 29 2014
@HienFan I know what you meant. I'm just disagreeing with you. If you don't like their performances in those games, fine.
HienFan
said at 8:58 AM on Wed Jul 30 2014
@Ross123 I'm surprised you agree about Cloud, I thought I was the only person who never liked his English voice
Ross123
said at 9:38 AM on Thu Jul 31 2014
@HienFan Steve Burton I felt was a bit wooden on most of his lines. Also, the voice he gave Cloud I find to be very forgettable unlike the other characters. Guess he doesn't leave that much of an impression on me, huh?
HienFan
said at 9:44 AM on Thu Jul 31 2014
@Ross123 Yeah I find it very forgettable and generic(and too monotone) but I guess that's what people like(considering I find some no.1 to be really generic maybe I'm onto something)
PsychicVoiceSpy
said at 9:21 PM on Sun Mar 24 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Yes everyone, Jeremy Irons was really good in this movie and Jim Cummings is a boss for singing the second half of this song while doing a great job of emulating Jeremy... but why is this such a popular compare? I know it's some cool trivia and it's one of the coolest things about the movie... but why does this make it continuously a top ten compare? :P

Oh yeah, James Horan gives a passable impression, but it's lacking.
VctrBnsn
said at 11:41 AM on Wed Mar 27 2013
@PsychicVoiceSpy I've always wondered that too, but the bigger question is, WHY IS FINN ALWAYS AT NUMBER 1!?

BTW, Jeremy Irons wins.
VctrBnsn
said at 11:43 AM on Wed Mar 27 2013
@PsychicVoiceSpy Not that I don't like Adventure Time, it's just, come on guys, theres only two compares, and the winner is obvious.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 1:12 AM on Sun Mar 31 2013
@VctrBnsn I believe Foxwolf already explained that on the actual compare.
VctrBnsn
said at 9:57 AM on Mon Apr 1 2013
@Nightmare Crusher Thanks, you're right, but now Scar is on top. Why? Maybe it doesn't help that I'm viewing it right now..........


inception
VctrBnsn
said at 10:06 PM on Mon Apr 1 2013
@VctrBnsn OK, Finns back on top. All is right in the world.
HienFan
said at 2:30 AM on Wed May 21 2014
@VctrBnsn It's a bit irritating Finn is ALWAYS at no.1 at all time, there's only two VA

I don't like Adventure time but still
madax
said at 9:55 AM on Thu Mar 21 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Jim Cummings did an amazing job covering the end of that song, I've known for a few years now about that and I still can't hear it change. It's kinda creepy to think the finale of the villain song to the most successful 2D animated film of all time is also the voice of the worlds most famous teddy bear.
But, let's be honest, Jeremy Irons wins, this doesn't even really count as a comparison when the others don't even have a dozen lines between them.
jonhardwick
said at 8:16 PM on Fri Feb 1 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
I feel like i was the only one to hear the diffrences between Irons and Cummings.
tlemmens10
said at 1:28 AM on Sat Oct 6 2012
James Horan did a good job at imitating Jeremy Irons' voice! And I think his voice wasn't bad! It sounds bad because they basicly just translate what was said in Japanese!
Zylphia
said at 12:45 PM on Wed Aug 29 2012
I love Jim Cummings! I don't think I can find a difference between his voice and Irons though. They're both amazing! James Horan's performance, I'm not quite feeling, but it's a good attempt nonetheless!
Anthonyiscool64
said at 12:41 PM on Sat Jul 28 2012
I would have to say my number one favorite voice actor, Jim Cummings!!!!!
Blue Paratroopa
said at 1:14 PM on Mon May 28 2012
 5 Shout Outs! [?]
You just can't beat the original.
DeepC
said at 6:29 PM on Tue May 1 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
James Horan is better off voicing Wheeljack in TFP.

said at 1:59 PM on Mon Apr 9 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
My vote goes to Irons. He's a classic :D Besides, Scar is visually based off of him. However, Cummings does a fantstic singing voice for him. So it was a little bit difficult to decide.
Torak
said at 6:04 AM on Sun Feb 12 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Ah Scar, my favorite Disney villain. :)

Anyway, Jeremy Irons definitely nailed it, but MAN if Jim Cummings did Scar's speaking voice he would nail it too!

James Horan was OK, but can't compare to Jeremy or Jim.
jonhardwick
said at 7:35 PM on Thu Mar 7 2013
@Torak Cummings actually dubbed Scars voice in the movie clips that were used in The Lion King: Simba's Mighty Adventure for PS1.
Torak
said at 3:22 AM on Fri Mar 8 2013
@jonhardwick Ah yes, I remember! Heres where I found it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lion_King:_Simba's_Mighty_Adventure

It's amazing how close he sounded to Jeremy!
Aurora
said at 10:39 AM on Sun Jan 1 2012
I actually believe that both voices for Scar are sinister sounding and aggressive. I was born in 1994 which is the year this movie was released. Must be ironic........
Galactic_Cyrus
said at 4:43 PM on Fri Dec 16 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Jeremy Irons easily but Cummings does great too. James Horan was an awful miscast.
ninjinister
said at 1:15 AM on Mon Oct 31 2011
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
What does it say about me, that as soon as I had been told that Cummings took over briefly during "Be Prepared", that I was able to pinpoint in my head the exact moment? For a film I'd not seen in three years?
Xneu
said at 1:34 PM on Sat Oct 15 2011
Jim Cummings gets my vote irons was in a second place but he was missing that threating voice scar would have and same for their musical voices JIM CUMMINGS HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MatthewC17
said at 9:43 PM on Wed Aug 31 2011
If it helps Jim Cummings is also Scar at Disneyland's Fantasmic
Aurora
said at 10:48 PM on Sat Aug 13 2011
jermy really nailed it and same with jim cummings, but his voice is agressive than james horon
Metabad
said at 10:14 PM on Thu Jul 14 2011
Jeremy Irons gets my vote, with Jim Cummings as a REALLY close second, the man can imitate anyone's voice perfectly.
MatthewC17
said at 9:43 PM on Wed Aug 31 2011
@Metabad Yeah Cummings is excellent
pete
said at 12:02 AM on Tue Jul 5 2011
I'm giving it Horan my vote because I heard some Tony Jay in his voice.
pete
said at 9:10 PM on Wed Oct 17 2012
@pete Scratch that going with Cummings.
LadyRose
said at 3:36 PM on Sat Feb 12 2011
I voted for Irons. I did not now until recently that Jim did that song. Its my favorite song from the movie.
zebra (Guest)
said at 11:03 AM on Sun Jan 23 2011
cummings rocks
jonhardwick (Guest)
said at 12:57 PM on Tue Jul 13 2010
cummings famous rasp gave him away.
jonhardwick (Guest)
said at 12:46 AM on Tue Jul 13 2010
i sung be prepared in irons voice and i didnt damage my voice.
jonhardwick (Guest)
said at 12:37 AM on Tue Jul 13 2010
irons for me.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 2:20 PM on Sun Jul 11 2010
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Jim Cummings has an awesome singing voice.
Torak
said at 3:46 PM on Mon Jul 30 2012
@NCZ I agree. :) Oh and Tom Kane voices Scar in sorcerers of the magic kingdom: an interactive game attraction in Disneyworld.


#1 favorite Voice Compare
for 1 member.

A favorite Voice Compare
for 18 members.
Latest Reason:

"#1 Disney Villain ever! ... for me ^^"

- RJManatsu
BTVA POLL
Who do you think has been the best from these Scar voice actors?
Jeremy Irons
Jim Cummings
James Horan