Browse VOICE COMPARE
#ABCDEF
GHIJKLM
NOPQRST
UVWXYZ
OTHER CARDCAPTOR SAKURA COMPARES
Cardcaptor Sakura

Voice Compare » Cardcaptor Sakura » Sakura Avalon/Sakura Kinomoto

Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Sakura Avalon/Sakura Kinomoto with sound clips and images.


Created by Pokejedservo on Mon Oct 19 2009, 19 Comments, Add Comment
Special thanks to Satoshi for additional sound clips.
Share/Save/Bookmark
CardCaptor Sakura (2000)
Sakura Avalon / Sakura KinomotoCarly McKillip
Carly McKillip
CardCaptor Sakura (2000)
Sakura Avalon / Sakura KinomotoKari Wahlgren
Kari Wahlgren
CardCaptor Sakura (2000)
Sakura Avalon / Sakura KinomotoAndrea Kwan
Andrea Kwan

EDITOR'S OPINION

Well folks time to start off the Cardcaptor Sakura Voice Compare section with the main character of the show SAKURA!

In the English dub of the series she was voiced by then child actress Carly McKillip. Now I know, I know about how many fans hated the dub of the TV series (though I heard what went wrong with the American showing is more Kids WB's fault IIRC) but still I never thought Carly was a bad choice for her. It's not the first time Ocean ever used a Child to do voice work, Carly may be no Andrea Libman but she is not that bad.

In the English dub of the 2nd movie done by Pioneer she was voiced by VA Kari Wahlgren. Now Kari is well known for doing cutesy higher voices well and this is no exception at all as she was definitely a perfectly suitable alternative.

Overall I am not too sure, I like them both.

Pokejedservo

Latest Comments

Add a Comment

HienFan
said at 4:34 AM on Sat Jan 11 2014
Carly sounds too old

Andrea and Kari are better

Prefer Kari so she wins
JSD
said at 3:55 PM on Thu Aug 9 2012
All of them are fine as far as dubbing goes...but I went with Carly.
dreamer
said at 12:14 PM on Fri May 11 2012
why didn't Carly voice her in the second movie anyway?
thomwim
said at 2:48 PM on Thu Jul 26 2012
@dreamer This is because the second movie was recorded in Los Angeles instead of Vancouer, Canada.
dreamer
said at 12:54 AM on Fri Aug 31 2012
@thomwim did not know that! Thanks for the info!
dreamer
said at 12:14 PM on Fri May 11 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Kari was so awkward for me to listen to in the second cardcaptors movie...Carly was perfect for me. I first heard her when I was only 9 and I'm 20 now. That voice will forever be 'Sakura' to me. I don't recall Andrea at all??
PurpleWarrior13
said at 1:05 AM on Wed Feb 13 2013
@dreamer Andrea voiced Sakura in the English dub produced in Hong Kong for Animax stations in South-East Asia.
immblueversion
said at 12:54 AM on Tue Mar 6 2012
This remains for me to be one of those situations where the character really is like two entirely different people depending on the scripting. So it's less the voices and more like the personalities that I feel compelled to compare.

On one hand, we have the cute, naive Sakura Kinomoto who appears in the original Japanese dub and the more by-the-book English dubs that Kari Wahlgren and Andrea Kwan appear in. Then there's the more tomboyish, spunky Sakura Avalon played by Carly McKillip in Nelvana's Americanized incarnation of the show known as "Cardcaptors."

Naturally, the voice actors play their roles well enough under the direction they were given. But "Avalon" seems a tad too bratty for me to enjoy as a main character. Then again, it appears that "Li Showron" was meant to be the main character of "Cardcaptors." So "Kinomoto" takes the cake as the more interesting character to watch. When she's happy, we're smile. When she's sad, we cry. When she kicks ass, we totally root for her to kick ass.

Of course, considering the "Kinomoto" character (or so to speak) is played by two different people, I'd pick Kari over Andrea. There's just something about her presence that really sticks out. Of course, I must wonder how she'd do if her role extended beyond just a single movie.
MaryKosmos
said at 7:41 PM on Fri Dec 23 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Carly McKillip. I grew up listening to that voice, and besides. The other two voices were just too cutesy and squeaky...
akkijake
said at 11:18 AM on Wed Nov 16 2011
Best voice is Andrea Kwan....awesumly Cute and sweet which suits Sakura's character....^_^
shadee88
said at 11:46 AM on Wed Oct 5 2011
Kari Wahlgren>Andrea Kwan>Carly Mckillip
kn (Guest)
said at 5:13 AM on Mon Nov 15 2010
Kari is much better. Sure, she's not "Age Appropriate" but Carly felt far to old for such a young girl anyway.
shadee88 (Guest)
said at 11:06 AM on Tue Oct 26 2010
Because Carly's voice sounded too mature for a little girl. Her personality didn't quite match what Sakura really is (cute innocent). I think picking carly was a form of censorship to mask down the cutesyness of the show.
diehardfan (Guest)
said at 4:55 PM on Thu Oct 21 2010
so how come they didnt keep Carly McKillip and her co stars for the second film? That was kind of a shame.
Dont get me wrong, her sucessors did well, but... they sound too unrealistic to have a kid voice.
Id rather have voiceactors with proper age than voiceactors faking their age.
satoshi
said at 7:14 PM on Sat Oct 9 2010
Andrea Kwan from the Animax dub added
shadee88 (Guest)
said at 9:14 AM on Mon Jun 21 2010
They cut off when Sakura says HOEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!! because Carly McKillip can't do that part. Only Kari Wahlgren can do it.
satoshi
said at 10:03 PM on Mon Jun 14 2010
I know this may sound weird but Carly McKillip's voice sounds too old. I mean I know she was like 12 when she voice Sakura, but the voice for some reason sounds way too old for Sakura. Kari on the other hand is perfect. Like Shadee88 said she sounds like a cute and innocent girl which is what Sakura is.
shadee88 (Guest)
said at 8:58 AM on Tue May 25 2010
Kari Wahlgren makes Sakura sound like a cute innocent girl.

But Carly McKilip makes her sound like a bratty teenager. She is also not a good voice actor and shows little emotion.

Kids can only do their own voice but adults can do more voices.
pw13 (Guest)
said at 8:29 PM on Thu Dec 3 2009
Kari Wahlgren was perfect as Sakura! It's a shame she couldn't perform the role as much.


A favorite Voice Compare
for 4 members.
BTVA POLL
Who do you think has been the best from these Sakura Avalon/Kinomoto voice actors?
Carly McKillip
Kari Wahlgren
Andrea Kwan