Captain America Captain America

Voice Compare » Captain America » Winter Soldier

Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Winter Soldier with sound clips and images.
Winter Soldier is initially a foe now Anti-hero ally of Captain America whose comic book debut was in Captain America Volume 5 #1 in January of 2005. Winter Soldier is one of the various fates that have happened to Captain America's sidekick Bucky in which Bucky was captured and brainwashed into a cold-blooded assassin by the Soviets (or in one story the Red Skull). Back when Winter Soldier was a villain his persona somewhat differed (he is either a violent amnesiac or hates Captain America and blames him for his predicament here) but when he becomes a Anti-Hero he makes amends to Cap and wishes to atone for his past as Winter Soldier. As Winter Soldier Bucky is a lot stronger with his new cybernetic arm and while he is still well known as Cap's old partner he has worked with the Black Widow before as well.

Created by Pokejedservo on Jul 5 2012, 69 Comments, Add Comment
Special thanks to Music Meister, solidejake for additional sound clips.
Marvel: Ultimate Alliance (2006)
Winter SoldierCrispin Freeman
Crispin Freeman
The Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes (2010)
Winter SoldierJon Curry
Jon Curry
Marvel Super Hero Squad Online (2011)
Winter SoldierYuri Lowenthal
Yuri Lowenthal
Avengers Assemble (2013)
Winter SoldierBob Bergen
Bob Bergen
Marvel Heroes (2013)
Winter SoldierDavid Hayter
David Hayter
Avengers Assemble (2013)
Winter SoldierRoger Craig Smith
Roger Craig Smith


Alright folks today in the Captain America VC section we take a look at this new version of Bucky... WINTER SOLDIER! Lets begin...

Crispin Freeman- First of all one can tell that his voice and performance for the role is very similar to what he has done for Albedo Piazzola (well namely when he is speaking to Cap). But to be fair all things considered it is rather understandable. But still Crispin's voice is pretty good as his performance as he can go from serious minded soldier to someone who has a bit too much issues with his old partner. Its a pretty good example of Crispin's work and of the voice work in the game.

Jon Curry-  At first I thought that Jon's voice was perhaps a little too high but I did start to like it more as I have realized that Jon was playing Winter Soldier as Scott Menville's Bucky all grown up and kind of bitter about his life. While Jon's voice and performance for the role was okay at first but he did get considerably better later on when the show did more focus on Winter Soldier's past. It was a good example of Jon's work and of the voice work in the show nevertheless.

Yuri Lowenthal- First of all I have noticed on how unlike the others Yuri seems to be playing this role as more of an Anti-Hero instead of a Villain (well a far lighter Anti-Hero consdiering what kind of game this is but still). Anyways Yuri has a fairly good voice for the role and his performance is pretty good (though limited due to lack of lines) as Yuri tries to play up the fact that Winter Soldier is... well... a Soldier. But still while this is an okay example of Yuri's work in general its one of his better performances in this game at least.

Bob Bergen- I too must agree that this is a very interesting change of pace for Bob here as his voice and performance work very well with the role here. But still Bob was a natural fit for the role here as he does a fine job in playing the Winter Soldier as a resentful yet tragic Anti-Villain character.I also liked on how Bob made Winter Soldier sound threatening and hateful but also made him sympathetic in a way as well and its a very good example of his work.

Overall both all of them are pretty good for the role in their own way but I think I am going with Bob Bergen the most here.



Add a Comment

Nightmare Crusher
said at 7:40 PM on Fri Nov 6 2015
 1 Shout Out!
I've been playing Marvel Heroes recently because I have no life and since I decided to pick Winter Solider as my starter I figured I would rank his compare too.

1. David Hayter: I'm probably just biased because of how much I like David Hayter's voice, but he's awesome. His voice is stern, charismatic and commanding and he really conveys that this is a guy who has been through hell. None of the others have that same feel to them. David easily gets my vote.

2. Bob Bergen: His voice is a little too light and forced sounding. Aside from that he does a pretty good job of conveying Winter Soldier's lust for revenge.* It's a pretty good performance.

3. Roger Craig Smith: Considering his role in the episode Roger does a pretty good job. His voice fits well and I would like to hear him get a real shot at it. How was he in that mobile game?

4. Crispin Freeman: I really think Crispin Freeman is a natural choice and his voice is a great fit. The problem I have is how the character is written in UA. He just acts like some smug jerk with none of the actual depth of Winter Soldier's character. Would love to see him get another shot at it.

5. Jon Curry: Oh boy. I know I said Bob sounded kind of forced, but he's got nothing on Jon here. That rasp comes and goes and sometimes is way too forced. He sounds like he's kind of overacting too.

6. Yuri Lowenthal: He's just kind of there. I really don't have much to say. Especially since Yuri already plays a few other characters in that game and it all blends a bit.

*Couldn't make it through this without one Metal Gear reference. Not where I expected it to end up though.
said at 2:05 PM on Sat Oct 3 2015
 4 Shout Outs!
Hayter is how I imagined the character sounding, and we know from the past he can do the Cap voice as well. He has the right of amount f ruggedness, but you can imagine him being as nicer guy like Bucky can be. The others were fine, but leaned too much toward gruffness or intense for my liking.
Dark Kuja
said at 9:28 PM on Fri Oct 2 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
Holy crap. David Hayter did the war weary grizzled veteran RIGHT for once?
solidejake (Moderator)
said at 11:28 AM on Sat Oct 3 2015
@Dark Kuja Oh really? I lost count after ten!
said at 2:14 PM on Fri Oct 2 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
Two Cap VA's have played Winter Soldier now,as David was him in Spider-Man TAS.
said at 10:57 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
Roger is actually pretty cool
1 Bob Bergen
2 Roger C Smith
3 Jon Curry
4 David Hayter
5 Crispin Freeman
6 Yuri Lowenthal
Polyester Funk
said at 10:36 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
David Hayter and his Winter Soldier have similar hair and facial hair.

Also, casting Roger there was for convenience and since Bucky there was a manifestation of Cap's guilty conscience it makes sense that it would sound somewhat like him, too.
said at 4:38 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
Sticking with Jon Curry, though Rgoer Craig Smith was also good.
Shaun Ince
said at 4:37 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
Roger's take sounds similar to his Batman voice. It's sounds brooding. However I find Bob Bergen to be much better in this role.
said at 4:30 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
All of them did an amazing job, but Hayter is my favorite.

1) David Hayter
2) Jon Curry
3) Crispin Freeman
4) Yuri Lowenthal
5) Roger Craig Smith
6) Bob Bergen
said at 2:28 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
 1 Shout Out!
Roger is kinda meh, but why did they replace Bob Bergan he was amazing, sometimes I still have trouble deciding between him and David. Though if Sebastian Stan came along my vote would definitely go to him.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 2:33 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
It was probably for convince, Winter Soldier had a small part so it wasn't worth getting another actor.
said at 2:42 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
@Music Meister You're probably right, I just hope Bob gets to come back as this character at some point since Sebastian Stan is such a low possibility.
said at 11:50 AM on Thu May 21 2015
1. Crispin Freeman
2. David Hayter
3. Yuri Lowenthal
4. Bob Bergen
5. Jon Curry
said at 8:24 PM on Tue Apr 28 2015
 1 Shout Out!
I voted for David Hayter. I personally wasn't a fan of Jon Curry's but that's probably because I was first introduced to his voice in Marvel Ultimate Alliance with Crispin Freeman, so I wasn't used to him sounding growly.
Shaun Ince
said at 7:16 PM on Fri Apr 17 2015
I like Bob Bergen the best in this role. It's all sorts of good. It's also a good showcase of his range.
said at 10:38 AM on Tue Mar 17 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
After hearing David Hayter as the Winter Soldier part of me wants to hear Robert McCollum take a crack at him at some point simply to make the compare more interesting
said at 8:21 AM on Sat Mar 14 2015
David is alright. He's just way too bland here, even makes Bob sound better in my opinion.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 6:20 AM on Mon Mar 9 2015
 11 Shout Outs!
David Hayter is the best. I don't mind the Snake influence because I'm pretty sure casting Hayter to begin with was a deliberate Metal Gear homage, and it makes him a lot nicer to listen to.
said at 7:02 AM on Mon Mar 9 2015
@NCZ I knew I wasn't the only one who thought so. LOL
said at 2:57 AM on Mon Mar 9 2015
David Hayter is average here
said at 11:56 PM on Sun Mar 8 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
David Hayter sounds closest to how I imagined Winter Soldier to sound, so I'll go with him. I also like Crispin Freeman, Bob Bergen and Jon Curry.
Shaun Ince
said at 10:34 PM on Sun Mar 8 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
Hayter is alright but it kinda throws you off guard when you hear bits of Solid Snake in his performance.
said at 10:32 PM on Sun Mar 8 2015
I do like Hayter in the role, though he does slip into snake quite a few times, which is very noticeable. It's not that it's bad, he does good for what he had, it's just the voice sticks out like a sore thumb at points.
solidejake (Moderator)
said at 10:30 PM on Sun Mar 8 2015
I really like Hayter, but it might mainly be because I miss hearing his voice so much. Even so, I didn't really feel any of the current portrayals were too memorable, so I changed my vote to Hayter. Although the writing almost seemed like they were trying to include Solid Snake into the Marvel Universe.
said at 4:49 PM on Fri Mar 6 2015
1) Jon Curry
2) Crispin Freeman
3) Yuri Lowenthal
4) Bob Bergen
said at 6:59 AM on Mon Mar 9 2015
1) David Hayter
2) Jon Curry
3) Crispin Freeman
4) Yuri Lowenthal
5) Bob Bergen
Dark Kuja
said at 7:52 AM on Tue Feb 24 2015
 1 Shout Out!
Maybe it's just because the Winter Soldier movie was more or less my first real taste of the character, but all these guys seem to talk too much.

When I picture the Winter Soldier, I picture him not speaking unless ABSOLUTELY necessary.
said at 12:26 PM on Tue Jan 27 2015
Sticking with Curry, but Bob Bergen was pretty good and Yuri Lowenthal was all right as Bucky
said at 3:08 PM on Sat Dec 6 2014
I'm going with Jon Curry because he makes the Winter Soldier sound sinister and heartless.

Crispin is 2nd because I like the kind of smug attitude he gives off.

Bob was good but kinda bland in a sense.

Yuri was all punk & in the zone. He wasn't bad, just decent.
said at 10:49 PM on Sun Nov 30 2014
1 Bob
2 Jon
3 Crispin
4 Yuri
said at 3:45 PM on Wed Nov 26 2014
Bob Bergen, he sounds a LOT more fitting as Winter Soldier!
said at 5:03 PM on Sat Nov 22 2014
 3 Shout Outs!
According to this forum
David Hayter is going to voice Winter Soldier.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 5:49 PM on Sat Nov 22 2014
@coolies Holy ****! That's just too good to be true.
said at 6:34 AM on Tue Jan 27 2015
@Nightmare Crusher
Nightmare Crusher
said at 6:53 AM on Tue Jan 27 2015
@coolies Yes! It is everything I hoped for.
said at 6:10 PM on Fri Nov 7 2014
None of them are my ideal Winter Soldier, but that may be for the best. A lot of these voice casting choices are out of the box, and my ideal winter Soldier would probably be a typecast actor, like Troy Baker. Can't always trust my judgement.
said at 6:20 PM on Fri Nov 7 2014
@VctrBnsn Funny, I actually thought Troy Baker would voice him in Avengers Assemble.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 6:51 PM on Thu Nov 6 2014
If Crispin had more material he would be my absolute favorite. For now I'm going with Bob.
TylerMirage (Admin)
said at 6:38 PM on Thu Nov 6 2014
 8 Shout Outs!
Bob seriously impressed me. I was very pleased to hear of his casting. He has so much range and deserves to spread his wings past Looney Tunes*.

*I know he's done more than just LT, but that's a huge bulk of his work these days.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 6:18 PM on Thu Nov 6 2014
 7 Shout Outs!
1. Crispin Freeman: Though recently Winter has been portrayed as being calmer, I enjoyed Crispin's crazy take. He sounds threatening and evil but I can see the voice transition into Winter Soldier's anti-hero side.

2. Bob Bergen: While a little bland in some lines, I liked when he talked calmly. He was threatening but not to an evil degree. It's not a stand out of the show but a nice change of pace for Bob.

3. Yuri Lowenthal: I think he could have worked but he sounds a bit too heroic. I think he deserves a second shot but for now he's just okay.

4. Jon Curry: I don't get the love, he's rather awkward in some lines, he's too high, he's a bit too sinister, and he just seems off for Winter. Yet people love it, I dunno maybe I'm missing something.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 5:02 PM on Fri Nov 7 2014
I know I've brought him up before in fan casts but how about Eric Bauza as a future Winter Soldier.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 4:05 PM on Sun Sep 27 2015
I'd put Roger under Bob and David under Roger.

Roger is a little too sinister but he's playing a nightmare version of the character. Still, he sounds similar to Bob.

David sounds alright but is rather bland.
said at 3:41 PM on Fri May 30 2014
It's real funny to see Itachi and Sasuke in this VC. And they both do very well with Winter Soldier.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 7:38 PM on Fri Jun 6 2014
@Fulgore2005 Same with the Loki compare
said at 8:24 AM on Tue May 13 2014
 2 Shout Outs!
1. Itachi
2. Sasuke
3. Jon.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 1:24 PM on Mon May 12 2014
 4 Shout Outs!
My ranking:
1. Crispin
2. Yuri
3. Jon
said at 2:16 PM on Mon May 12 2014
@Music Meister I agree 100%
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 2:20 PM on Mon May 12 2014
@Archerboy58 Thanks man
said at 6:44 PM on Mon Mar 3 2014
 2 Shout Outs!
Jon Curry sounds a bit to high but his acting is fine. Crispin Freeman sounds more natural and I also like how he sounds like a sane Albedo Piazzola. Vote goes to Freeman.
said at 10:36 PM on Fri Jan 24 2014
 4 Shout Outs!
Crispin Freeman for me. I'm not really a fan of Jon Curry's voice. I don't think the raspiness works, the voice is a bit too high and to be honest, the voice is very dull while Crispin sounds more entertaining and interesting IMO.
said at 9:46 AM on Thu Aug 8 2013
 1 Shout Out!
Crispin Freeman for me.
said at 12:50 PM on Fri Jul 26 2013
 1 Shout Out!
I'm going with Crispin Freeman, Curry sounds a bit too raspy for me.
said at 4:42 PM on Thu Dec 13 2012
 3 Shout Outs!
I'll go with Crispin.

Is it just me or does Curry sound slightly like Solid Snake? (At least to me)
solidejake (Moderator)
said at 2:20 PM on Sat Dec 22 2012
@BlackWolf219 I was thinking the same thing, but I was thinking more like a very bad impression of Snake.
said at 9:50 PM on Mon Mar 9 2015
@BlackWolf219 Y'know, funny you say that...
said at 2:57 PM on Thu Dec 13 2012
I'm going with Jon Curry. Crispin Freeman is good too.
said at 4:18 PM on Fri Jul 6 2012
I thought for a moment that he in A:EMH, was voiced by Adrian Pasdar.
said at 9:27 PM on Fri Jul 6 2012
@Dodgibishi You were thinking of that politician the Red Skull disguised himself as. He sounded a lot like Adrian but was really Steve Blum who also played Red Skull on the show.
said at 9:28 PM on Fri Jul 6 2012
@Dodgibishi scratch that he sound like Adrian as well but the other dude did as well.
said at 2:54 AM on Fri Aug 24 2012
@pete I dunno, Dell Rusk only sounded like Steve to me, maybe it's just cause I'm used to hearing him.
said at 2:56 AM on Fri Aug 24 2012
@GothamRed Same.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 10:24 AM on Fri Jul 6 2012
 1 Shout Out!
Crispin Freeman gave a more interesting performance
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 10:39 AM on Sun Jul 8 2012
On top of that Curry sounds a bit forced and a bit too high. Crispin fits for Winter's crazy moments and his normal villain moments plus I can see him in heroic moments.
said at 4:30 AM on Fri Jul 6 2012
Both are good, but I'm gonna go with Jon Curry for Winter Soldier.
said at 2:03 AM on Fri Jul 6 2012
 1 Shout Out!
To be fair, Jon's take does sound slightly higher due to the fact that these were taken from an Australian airing, where they are slightly sped up.
said at 1:49 AM on Fri Jul 6 2012
 3 Shout Outs!
Jon Curry, though I was disappointed they didn't get Scott Menville to play Winter Soldier; he could've used his Nightwing voice.
said at 9:57 PM on Wed Nov 27 2013
@TheVengeanceKnight I think they might have and changed their minds, in one of the previously on segments (I think in Code Red) they play the scene where winter soldier injects Ross with the Hulk serum and he sounds like Scott's voice instead of Jon's, as well as sounding different than it did in the episode it appeared.
said at 11:43 PM on Thu Jul 5 2012
Giving it to Jon Curry. It's more unique. I do think Crispin's take works though.
Faved by 4 BTVA Members
Who do you think has been the best from these Winter Soldier voice actors?
Crispin Freeman
Jon Curry
Yuri Lowenthal
Bob Bergen
David Hayter
Roger Craig Smith