Voice Compare » Captain America » Captain America
Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Captain America with sound clips and images.
Captain America is the result of Steve Rogers being injected with the experimental super-soldier serum during World War II. A frail soldier then became human physical perfection after the transformation.
During the final days of the war Captain America was put into suspended animation after falling into Arctic waters. When unfrozen he woke up in the modern age and became leader of The Avengers.
During the final days of the war Captain America was put into suspended animation after falling into Arctic waters. When unfrozen he woke up in the modern age and became leader of The Avengers.
Created by Jackson_H on Wed Feb 10 2010, 78 Comments, Add Comment
Special thanks to Foxwolf, Pokejedservo for additional sound clips.
EDITOR'S OPINION
I liked most of the voices these voice actors gave for Captain America. My personal favorite voice from the group is Justin Gross.Jackson_H
Latest Comments
Add a Comment
pokemastanumba1 said at 10:40 PM on Wed Apr 17 2013
Roger Craig Smith, Justin Gross, Trev Broudy, and David Kaye.
Reply
VctrBnsn said at 11:17 PM on Fri Mar 15 2013
Too bad Justin Gross isn't doing much anymore. I would listen to him again as Captain America.
Reply
VctrBnsn said at 3:25 PM on Wed Apr 3 2013
@VctrBnsn You know, I haven't done a detailed analysis on each of these actors, so I'll go ahead and give you my rankings.
Arthur Pierce - 5/10
George DiCenzo - 4.9/10
Lawrence Bayne - 5.9/10
David Hayter - 6.2/10
Dan Chameroy - 5.8/10
Daran Norris - 4.9/10
Justin Gross - 8/10
Trev Broudy - 6.9/10
David Kaye - 7/10
Tom Kenny - 6.5/10
Cal Dodd - 6/10
Adrian Pasdar - 3/10
Brian Bloom - 8/10
Jeffrey Hedquist - 5.5/10
Chris Evens - 7.8/10
Sandy Becker - 7.9/10
Roger Craig Smith - 8.2/10
ReplyArthur Pierce - 5/10
George DiCenzo - 4.9/10
Lawrence Bayne - 5.9/10
David Hayter - 6.2/10
Dan Chameroy - 5.8/10
Daran Norris - 4.9/10
Justin Gross - 8/10
Trev Broudy - 6.9/10
David Kaye - 7/10
Tom Kenny - 6.5/10
Cal Dodd - 6/10
Adrian Pasdar - 3/10
Brian Bloom - 8/10
Jeffrey Hedquist - 5.5/10
Chris Evens - 7.8/10
Sandy Becker - 7.9/10
Roger Craig Smith - 8.2/10
pete said at 10:56 PM on Fri Mar 15 2013
Jumping on the Avengers EMH bandwagon but I also like Sandy Becker's voice. David Hayter wasn't too bad either.
ReplyVctrBnsn said at 11:41 PM on Sat Feb 23 2013
I remember using Roger in my fan casts, but stopped because I didn't think he was right. I was wrong. He's perfect. I also really like Sandy Beckers, who I get a Brian Bloom feel from. Brians awesome too. Along with Roger, I think Justin Gross sounds the most natural. Adrian is obviously the weakest.
Reply
thomwim said at 12:10 PM on Thu Jan 10 2013
On behalf of someone I knew from high school, I vote for Chris Evans because he's the only voiced captain I've hear so far.
Reply
TheAtticus said at 8:45 AM on Mon Dec 17 2012
I chose Brian Bloom, since he's the one who sounds the most like an American war hero.
P.S. Solid Snake voiced him? Christ, how did that not turn out to be the best thing ever?
ReplyP.S. Solid Snake voiced him? Christ, how did that not turn out to be the best thing ever?
Nightmare Crusher said at 9:34 PM on Sat Dec 1 2012
I'm having a hard time choosing between Brian Bloom and Roger Craig Smith now.
Reply
Music Meister said at 9:07 PM on Fri Oct 19 2012
No matter how many times I hear Pasdar's voice for Cap I just wonder what the casting director was thinking
Reply
TheVengeanceKnight said at 5:15 AM on Sat Nov 24 2012
@Music Meister He was probably high that day. :-P
Reply
TheAtticus said at 8:49 AM on Mon Dec 17 2012
@Music Meister I don't tink it was the casting director's fault; Pasdar could have done a good job. I think the voicing director was more to blame. It seems like he wanted him to be less like Cap and more like Wolverine and it failed.
Reply
pete said at 10:58 PM on Fri Mar 15 2013
@Music Meister He would work for Nick Fury I think not Cap, Iron Man or any Avenger for that matter.
ReplyTheVengeanceKnight said at 8:08 AM on Tue May 14 2013
@TheAtticus I think both are to blame. :-P
Reply
coolgeek176 said at 8:32 PM on Sat Oct 13 2012
Brian Bloom is easily the best for Cap. Roger Craig Smith was good too.
Reply
Spider-Fox said at 3:58 PM on Fri Oct 12 2012
Ok I'm changing my vote. While Brad Swaile is always my Cap voice, Roger Craig Smith was just AWESOME!
Reply
ConfusedPhantom said at 6:16 PM on Wed Oct 17 2012
@Spider-Fox Brad Swaile voiced Rogers? ...I can't really see that working. *scratches head*
Reply
Pokejedservo (Moderator) said at 5:35 PM on Thu Oct 18 2012
@ConfusedPhantom Neither do I but to be fair Swaile could make a potentially good Bucky though...
Reply
Spider-Fox said at 12:39 AM on Sun Oct 21 2012
@ConfusedPhantom I'm honestly using his Setsuna F. Seiei (Gundam 00) and Jin (Street FighterXTekken) performances as Cap's voice if it helps. But yeah, I have a strange Voice Cast for the Marvel U.
Replypete said at 3:56 PM on Thu Oct 11 2012
I'm gonna guess but I'm assuming 1. Roger's voice is similarto how his Havok would have sounded but lighter. 2. Roger is voicing Cap in Avengers Assemble along with Adrian Pasdar and Travis Willingham reprising Iron Man and Thor from USM with the possibility of Chris Cox reprising Hawkeye and of course most likely unless he has other obligations or personal issues or something Fred Testasciore is reprising Hulk.
Reply
SLEDGERAID said at 3:33 PM on Fri Oct 12 2012
@pete Wait so your assuming all that or just the Havok thing?
Reply
TylerMirage (Admin) said at 12:47 PM on Thu Oct 11 2012
My top picks are Justin Gross, Brian Bloom and Roger Craig Smith. None of the others really captured that authoritative, strong, commanding presence, in my opinion.
Reply
pete said at 3:50 PM on Thu Oct 11 2012
@TylerMirage I thik Sandy Becker did pretty well especially for his time. Most VA's didn't nail characters back then like they would today mainly because they didn't have any/much material to base their takes on. Some are younger as well I think.
Reply
TylerMirage (Admin) said at 3:55 PM on Thu Oct 11 2012
@pete True, I re-listened to Sandy's and I will admit it's pretty good, especially for the time.
Reply
Lion's Edge said at 7:33 AM on Thu Oct 11 2012
...Holy heck! I always used to say I wanted to see Roger Craig Smith voice Captain America! And now, he is?!?! And he is JUST as great, possibly better, than I thought.
A tie between him and Brian Bloom for me.
ReplyA tie between him and Brian Bloom for me.
TheVengeanceKnight said at 4:26 AM on Thu Oct 11 2012
I'm gonna go with Brian Bloom for Cap, though Trev Broudy, Justin Gross, David Hayter, Roger Craig Smith and Chris Evans were good too.
Reply
Mickwhitefire28 said at 10:44 PM on Wed Oct 10 2012
Hey, I'm a big roger fan, and I love his reindition of Cap, but I still keep my vote for 'the best' Brian Bloom.
ReplyMusic Meister said at 5:52 PM on Wed Oct 10 2012
I actully think Rodger is the best.
He sounded brave, strong and smart while sounding natural. It's a good example of his work.
While Brian is the favorite I never thought it was good. To me it's not "the voice of Captain AMerica" but more of someone doing a voice for cap, it sounded like a cliche 'big macho hero'. He's not bad, his performance is great but I never thought the voice was natural.
David Kaye is my second, he had an 'old war vet' feel to his voice and sounded strong yet caring.
While I don't hate the others they just didn't do a remeberable voice or performance
Reply
He sounded brave, strong and smart while sounding natural. It's a good example of his work.
While Brian is the favorite I never thought it was good. To me it's not "the voice of Captain AMerica" but more of someone doing a voice for cap, it sounded like a cliche 'big macho hero'. He's not bad, his performance is great but I never thought the voice was natural.
David Kaye is my second, he had an 'old war vet' feel to his voice and sounded strong yet caring.
While I don't hate the others they just didn't do a remeberable voice or performance
pete said at 3:52 PM on Thu Oct 11 2012
@Music Meister I think his voice would have been great for Civil War. It's too bad they never got a chance to adapt it on EMH.
Reply
Torak said at 4:44 AM on Sun Oct 7 2012
I'll go with Brian Bloom, he sounds just right for the role. Others sound too high pitched, low pitched or just don't fit IMO.
1. Bloom
2. Gross
3. Evans
4. Kaye
5. Broudy
Reply
1. Bloom
2. Gross
3. Evans
4. Kaye
5. Broudy
Torak said at 3:14 AM on Thu Oct 11 2012
@Torak Changing my vote to Roger Craig Smith, he sounds strong and smart like a captain should do, plus he is a good actor. :D
My new ranking:
1. Smith
2. Bloom
3. Gross
4. Kaye (Moved him up because he sounds like a strong and experianced soldier also what a captain should have.)
5. Evans
ReplyMy new ranking:
1. Smith
2. Bloom
3. Gross
4. Kaye (Moved him up because he sounds like a strong and experianced soldier also what a captain should have.)
5. Evans
pokemastanumba1 said at 10:08 PM on Fri Jul 6 2012
Ok seriously, how does Brian have such a huge lead? He was barely winning about a month ago, but now he's dominating by a majority. Where on Earth are all his votes coming from?
Reply
TheVengeanceKnight said at 2:46 AM on Sat Jul 7 2012
@pokemastanumba1 Really? I remembered him dominating the poll for a long time.
Reply
NCZ (Admin) said at 11:17 AM on Sat Jul 7 2012
@pokemastanumba1 Yeah, I remember he was winning at the time when user accounts were created. That was over a year ago. So, all of the votes are coming from people who legitimately like his performance.
Reply
pokemastanumba1 said at 5:39 PM on Sat Jul 7 2012
I've been a member for over a year now, and I never remembered him having such a huge lead. He has been winning for a while, just not by such a wide margin. It's just weird to me, especially since the Marvel fandom is pretty split between the Captain America voice(s) they prefer.
Reply
shadowvegeta said at 3:02 PM on Sun May 20 2012
1. Brian Bloom
2. Trev Broudy
3. David Hayter
4. Justin Gross
5. Chris Evans
Reply2. Trev Broudy
3. David Hayter
4. Justin Gross
5. Chris Evans
Spider-Fox said at 5:56 PM on Mon May 14 2012
Brad Swaile is my usual Cap actor (ha ha, Captain America played by a Canadian, oh the irony) of the people who have played Cap my picks are
1. Brian Bloom
2. Chris Evans
3. David Kaye
4. Daran Noris
5. Trev Broudy
Reply1. Brian Bloom
2. Chris Evans
3. David Kaye
4. Daran Noris
5. Trev Broudy
SparklyShake12 said at 2:42 AM on Fri Apr 13 2012
Brian Bloom is my favorite, but Chris Evans and David Kaye are tied for a close second.
Reply
SparklyShake12 said at 7:43 PM on Wed Oct 10 2012
@SparklyShake12
Changing my vote to Roger Craig Smith. He was fantastic!
New rankings:
1. Roger Craig Smith
2. Brian Bloom
3. Chris Evans
4. David Kaye
5. Trev Bundy
ReplyChanging my vote to Roger Craig Smith. He was fantastic!
New rankings:
1. Roger Craig Smith
2. Brian Bloom
3. Chris Evans
4. David Kaye
5. Trev Bundy
scarletarachknight said at 9:36 PM on Thu Apr 5 2012
I dunno, while I love Brian Bloom's take on Cap I think I'll go with Chris's portrayal (probably because I love how he played him in the film)
Reply
Anicomicgeek said at 7:39 AM on Fri Feb 17 2012
I'm gonna go odd man out here, but I'm going with David Kaye for Captain America. That said, I also liked Justin Gross, Chris Evans, Brian Bloom, and Trev Broudy in the role.
Reply
Anicomicgeek said at 9:19 AM on Wed Feb 22 2012
@Anicomicgeek Upon listening to them again, yeah, I'm gonna change my mind and side with the majority and agree on Brain Bloom on this one. That said, David Kaye was still good in the role.
ReplyAnicomicgeek said at 10:56 PM on Wed Oct 10 2012
@Anicomicgeek
Sticking with Bloom as he's better, but Roger Craig Smith was pretty good in the role, too.
ReplySticking with Bloom as he's better, but Roger Craig Smith was pretty good in the role, too.
plasman1029 said at 9:56 AM on Wed Sep 21 2011
Adrian Pasdar is my fave... He's not a very good Captain America, but he was in Heroes... so... ya... he wins
Reply
Nightmare Crusher said at 1:38 PM on Sat Apr 6 2013
@plasman1029 I know this comment is old and the user will probably never be here again, but seeing it fills me with so much rage.
Reply
RedHumanJared15 said at 5:02 PM on Tue Feb 8 2011
I like Brian for some odd reason... Justin may seem to be a bit better, but hearing Bloom voice the Cap in MvC3 is more subtle opinion-wise. Hopefully people will start using him in that game since the last two installments had rarely anybody use him... Just a couple of noobish players using Storm, Sentinel, and Magneto. Ehh, what can you do?
Replygabe (Guest)
said at 3:39 AM on Wed Feb 2 2011
said at 3:39 AM on Wed Feb 2 2011
Trev Broudy got the ultimate Cap voice.
anonymous (Guest)
said at 2:27 AM on Sat Jan 29 2011
said at 2:27 AM on Sat Jan 29 2011
Personally, I think Trev Broudy epitomizes him the best.
anonymous (Guest)
said at 3:05 PM on Fri Jan 21 2011
said at 3:05 PM on Fri Jan 21 2011
They're all pretty decent, but I'll have to go with Justin.
dmxx116 (Guest)
said at 4:35 AM on Mon Dec 20 2010
said at 4:35 AM on Mon Dec 20 2010
David Hayter,Brian Bloom, Justin Gross are the best.
jakob997 (Guest)
said at 1:20 PM on Sat Nov 6 2010
said at 1:20 PM on Sat Nov 6 2010
David Kaye's way alright, but Trev Broudy is my favorite. His Captain America is much more military like than anyone else, and anyone who knows Cap's origin should agree.
capnbarfy (Guest)
said at 1:28 PM on Thu Nov 4 2010
said at 1:28 PM on Thu Nov 4 2010
I know this'll sound odd, but Cathal J Dodd will always be Captain America to me.
*plays too many fighting games*
*plays too many fighting games*
bryon (Guest)
said at 12:09 AM on Sun Oct 17 2010
said at 12:09 AM on Sun Oct 17 2010
Me, I gotta go with David Kaye, Brian Bloom, and Justin Gross.
kojj (Guest)
said at 3:48 AM on Sun Jun 6 2010
said at 3:48 AM on Sun Jun 6 2010
david hayter also did his appearances in xmen evolution too
dtemplar said at 9:28 PM on Sun Feb 14 2010
George also voices Cap on 2 episodes of Spider-Man & His Amazing Friends
Reply
Jackson_H (Admin) said at 3:44 PM on Wed Feb 10 2010
I'm not sure.
I know I'm missing
Robin Atkin Downes (Spider-Man: Battle for New York)
and
Cathal J Dodd from the Marvel vs. games
(vs. Street fighter, vs. Capcom)
ReplyI know I'm missing
Robin Atkin Downes (Spider-Man: Battle for New York)
and
Cathal J Dodd from the Marvel vs. games
(vs. Street fighter, vs. Capcom)
john (Guest)
said at 3:23 PM on Wed Feb 10 2010
said at 3:23 PM on Wed Feb 10 2010
Didn't Cam Clarke voice him in one game?
said at 5:51 PM on Fri Apr 26 2013
said at 2:13 PM on Tue Apr 30 2013
said at 10:50 PM on Tue Apr 30 2013
said at 11:30 PM on Tue Apr 30 2013
said at 12:25 AM on Wed May 8 2013
said at 1:36 AM on Wed May 8 2013
said at 9:51 AM on Wed May 8 2013