Batman Batman


Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Scarecrow with sound clips and images.
Franchise: Batman

(Note: While Jeff Bennett did voice Scarecrow in the episode "Over the Edge" Scarecrow did not actually have any lines in that episode as Jeff only did an evil laugh.)

Scarecrow is one of Batman's various enemies and has been in the Batman comics since the 3rd issue of Worlds Finest Comics that came out in the Fall of 1941. Scarecrow was formerly known as Jonathan Crane whom was quite fixated on fear due to his terrible childhood and was once a physician at Arkham Asylum until he was fired for testing his fear gas on his patients. Soon afterwards Jonathan Crane became the Scarecrow in which unlike most of Batman's Rogues Gallery his physical capabilities are lacking but is still very dangerous on how he more goes for psychological damage with his fear gas.
Created by Pokejedservo on Jul 19 2011
Special thanks to Music Meister for additional sound clips.
The LEGO Batman Movie (2017)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneJason Mantzoukas
Jason Mantzoukas
Injustice 2 (2017)
ScarecrowRobert Englund
Robert Englund
Batman (2013)
ScarecrowBrian Silva
Brian Silva
Batman Unlimited: Monster Mayhem (2015)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneBrian T Delaney
Brian T Delaney
Batman: Arkham Knight (2015)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneJohn Noble
John Noble
DC Universe Online (2011)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneChristopher S Field
Christopher S Field
Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneDino Andrade
Dino Andrade
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2008)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneDee Bradley Baker
Dee Bradley Baker
Batman: Gotham Knight (2008)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneCorey Burton
Corey Burton
The New Batman Adventures (1997)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneJeffrey Combs
Jeffrey Combs
Batman Begins (2005)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneCillian Murphy
Cillian Murphy
Batman: The Animated Series (1992)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneHenry Polic II
Henry Polic II
Super Powers Team: Galactic Guardians (1985)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneAndre Stojka
Andre Stojka
Challenge of the Super Friends (1978)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneDon Messick
Don Messick
Batman with Robin the Boy Wonder (1968)
Scarecrow / Jonathan CraneTed Knight
Ted Knight


Today on the Batman VC section we have a big VC for this Fear gas loving fiend from Gothan... THE SCARECROW! The Scarecrow has a rather large VC here so I will keep this brief by saying that I am not sure who to pick as there is plenty of quality material here. The weakest of the Scarecrow voices here would probably be Ted Knight's work as Scarecrow here as I suppose its kind of okay by its own merits but seems rather generic compared to the others. Cillian Murphy and Don Messick were okay though (in retrospection Don's voice for the role wasn't bad but its a shame that Super Friends series didn't give him much material to work with.) However I was pleasantly surprised with Andre Stojka (whom is easily the best of the "Old" Scarecrow voices) and Dee Bradley Baker though.) But still most of these guys did some awesome work for Scarecrow in their own way.



Add a Comment

said at 8:41 PM on Sun Sep 10 2017
 3 Shout Outs!
1. Robert Englund
2. John noble
3. Jeffrey Combs
4. Henry Polic II
5. Dino Andrade
said at 4:17 PM on Sat Aug 26 2017
 2 Shout Outs!
I'm in the minority here, but I honestly like almost all of these guys as Scarecrow. To be honest, I don't mind a few of them focusing on the creepy aspect, as some incarnations don't focus on Scarecrow's cowardice unless he gets fear-gassed himself.

Robert Englund is the definitive Scarecrow for me. I had trouble deciding between three of the actors here, but when Englund got added, I thought he had the best qualities of all three. I really enjoy his smug, full-of-himself performance, and his dialogue mixed with the design creates a terrifying incarnation of Scarecrow. His performance as Crane is very great too: cold and calculating, just how I prefer him. The voice itself is just how I imagined Scarecrow: light, but imposing, not too deep or high.

The three I was torn between previously were Jeffrey Combs, John Noble, and Dino Andrade. Jeffrey has a very creepy, whispery performance, but I thought he was a little too reserved in TNBA. He's much better in Sin Tzu, with a chilling evil laugh and some great delivery but I still think he could've added just a tad more oomph. John Noble has a very creepy voice, with some fantastic delivery and it's a perfect fit for Knight Scarecrow...but I honestly couldn't picture this deep, threatening voice fitting the comics Scarecrow at all, which makes it difficult for him to be my favorite. Dino is a fan favorite and I understand why as he is the most balanced Scarecrow, able to be creepy, smug, and cowardly, but I feel the voice is just too high-pitched for me.

Corey Burton and Dee Bradley Baker pull off really great performances, which I'd like to hear more of. Corey's over-the-top performance is rather frightening, and the same could be said of Dee's under-the-top one.

Cillian Murphy was awesome in the movies, and he's fairly good in the game, unlike many other of the reprising actors, but I wish they had kept the effects from the movie.

Henry Polic II (RIP), while a tad deep like Noble, still fits pretty well with some good delivery, but I always found the pre-TNBA version of the character in the DCAU to be rather bland.

I prefer Don Messick (RIP) for having a creepier tone over Andre Stojka, who is a tad too hammy but still enjoyably smug. They both sound a bit too high-pitched IMO.

Christopher S. Field had a really nice intimidating delivery reminding me of Anthony Ingruber's Joker...but those last couple lines kinda ruined the performance for me by sounded forced and hammy.

Brian T. Delaney has a nice voice, but he focuses too much on being cold. I think if he added more variety in the delivery he'd be great.

I can't really hear Brian Silva. I'm not sure if he's filtered or if that's just the quality of the clip.

Jason Mantzoukas sounds rather unfitting and distracting. I can tell it's him because of Regular Show.

Ted Knight sounds like Jeff Bennett. He'd fit Joker or Penguin much more.

1. Robert Englund
2. Jeffrey Combs/John Noble/Dino Andrade
3. Corey Burton/Dee Bradley Baker
4. Cillian Murphy/Henry Polic II
5. Brian T. Delaney/Don Messick
6. Christopher S. Field
7. Andre Stojka
8. Brian Silva
9. Jason Mantzoukas
10. Ted Knight
said at 6:52 PM on Sat Sep 9 2017
@GreenGoblin75 Brian Silva is saying "I did a little redecorating around town Batman, I do hope you'll approve"
said at 8:15 PM on Sat Sep 9 2017
Thanks. I kinda feel like he has potential in the role. He kinda reminds me of Cillian Murphy.
Shaun Ince
said at 2:10 PM on Sat Aug 26 2017
The issues I have with John Noble as Scarecrow, are the same problems I had with Jim Cummings as Dr Eggman. Just sounding menacing & imposing, just isn't enough & the performance comes across as "very one note" and lacking any personality. Arkham Knight's voice work feels like a downgrade compared to the Arkham games that preceeded it. And Noble as Scarecrow was one of the performances that I'm not extremely fond of.
Shaun Ince
said at 1:52 PM on Sat Aug 26 2017
There's something I've noticed with some if these actors for Scarecrow. The ones that don't fit al that we'll, are better as Braniac. And vise versa.
said at 5:41 PM on Wed Jul 5 2017
 4 Shout Outs!
Jason Mantzoukas sounds like John Kassir.

Speaking of, he should totally play Scarecrow. He could nail the wimpy toady side, and the nightmarish fear gas side.
said at 11:19 AM on Sun Jul 2 2017
 2 Shout Outs!
As someone who wanted Robert Englund as Scarecrow, finally getting it was not satisfying at all. As an Elm Street fan I wanted a Freddy Krueger esque Scarecow so and this is the opposite and not in a good way.

His Crane voice is bland, generic, and even thuggish to the point where I actually thought he was one of Scarecrow's minions instead at first. It pretty close to the complaints about John Noble but worse. This is from someone who actually liked John Noble.

His Scarecrow voice should have been his Crane voice, and Scarecrow should sound like Freddy. I don't know if they just misdirected him, or they were trying to avoid typecasting, but Robert can still pull off Freddy in animation if he can't do the role physically anymore, and with Elm Street animated adaptions happening, and the chances of them diinishing year after year after year, this was a major opportunity they missed to have him play Freddy without getting casted as him techincally.

IMO Injustice 2 had a really inspired casting choice and then just blew it. Hopefully he'll get a chance to reprise the role and do it properly and not be wasted again.
said at 1:16 PM on Sun Jul 2 2017
@SupremeTarantulas Well I still prefer Robert's voice as Crane, it sounds better than what I heard in the game. I had no access to the clip before due to needing headphones.

It's just not the intimidating or over the top voice Scarecrow should have IMO, and sounds too mud like a regular psychologist, that only fits Crane, and not even Hugo Strange.

The slow delivery also fits Felix Faust better, or even Robert's Riddler. Compared to Robert's Crane, John Noble fits better, and compared to his Scarecrow Dino Andrade is better.
said at 9:33 PM on Thu Jun 29 2017
 1 Shout Out!
1. Jeffrey Combs
2. Dino Andrade
3. John Noble
4. Robert Englund
5. Henry Polic II
6. Dee Bradley Baker
7. Corey Burton
8. Don Messick
said at 11:51 AM on Tue Jun 27 2017
 4 Shout Outs!
I can't help it. I'm a huge Freddy Krueger fanboy. I know it's not totally in line with the character but I really like it.
said at 10:15 AM on Tue Jun 27 2017
 2 Shout Outs!
Sticking with Dino Andrade, but Robert Englund also worked.
Shaun Ince
said at 10:41 PM on Mon Jun 26 2017
 3 Shout Outs!
Robert Englund does work pretty well as Scarecrow when it comes to his scarier side, but that's it really. I'll say this, he's much better than John Noble in this role.
CatsTuxedo (Moderator)
said at 9:47 PM on Mon Jun 26 2017
 4 Shout Outs!
Englund's a nice voice when it comes to Scarecrow being scary and intimidating, but there's nothing suggesting that Crane the coward is hiding behind it. Sticking with Andrade.
said at 12:58 PM on Thu Jun 22 2017
 1 Shout Out!
1. Dino Andrade
2. Jeffrey Combs
3. John Noble
4. Henry Polic II
5. Dee Bradley Baker
6. Corey Burton
7. Don Messick
said at 5:03 PM on Mon Jun 19 2017
 3 Shout Outs!
I'm going to be changing my vote to Robert Englund once he gets added. He's exactly how I always imagined Scarecrow sounding.
said at 5:56 PM on Tue Jun 13 2017
 4 Shout Outs!
I think Robert Englund perfectly encapsulates the sadistic sophisticate within Scarecrow. His voice sounds like what happens when you put Hannibal Lecter through a fear gas filter, which is more or less perfect for the character.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 6:50 PM on Tue Jun 6 2017
 3 Shout Outs!
Honestly, Robert Englund just doesn't quite do it for me. I think it has to do with when you hear him outside of the monster hallucination. How scary Crane is without his toxin varies from interpretation to interpretation, but the grittiness of that voice is just too on the nose for me.
said at 4:47 PM on Tue Jun 6 2017
 3 Shout Outs!
I still need to play the game, but I'm probably going to change my vote to Robert Englund.

He takes the best traits of everyone else, with none of their drawbacks.
said at 12:26 PM on Tue Jun 6 2017
 5 Shout Outs!
Saw some clips of Englund. I'm not getting the hype. Sure, I think he does the cold, creepy thing considerably better than Jeffrey Combs did, but it's still kinda bland, and he sounds a little too old.
EPA Deane
said at 2:03 PM on Wed Jun 7 2017
@PsychicVoiceSpy Honestly? I Much Prefer Robert Englund as The Riddler....
said at 5:30 AM on Mon Jun 5 2017
I see the appeal on Arkham Asylum and Injustice 2 portrayals on Scarecrow. But I personally prefer Arkham Knight with John Noble. I mean he sounds intelligent while also being intimidating. I can't get enough. Although Dino Andrade sounds perfect for Crane himself not Scarecrow.

As for Injustice 2's version he does sound incredible but I think he sounds a bit too old for Scarecrow but the personality and sense of fear is phenomenal.
EPA Deane
said at 2:07 PM on Wed Jun 7 2017
@4xNicholas I genuinely found the Scarecrow's interview tapes to be more frightening than the Nightmare sequences.

The Effects for when Crane is in his costume take away from the power from Andrade's performance IMO.
said at 4:54 AM on Thu Jun 8 2017
@EPA Deane I agree, and that is what I meant. Dino Andrade sounds perfect as Crane, but when he tries Scarecrow, it doesn't have that power.
Stare at the Sun
said at 4:10 PM on Sun May 21 2017
 5 Shout Outs!
I'll change my vote to Robert Englun. He nails it.
said at 2:03 AM on Sat May 20 2017
 5 Shout Outs!
Englund is just as fantastic as I had hoped he would be. His incredibly cold delivery is fantastically creepy and I like that he's able to nail the more calm and intelligent sound of Crane while still sounding incredibly threatening. I'd put him right up there with Combs.
said at 8:20 AM on Mon May 15 2017
 6 Shout Outs!
After seeing Injustice 2, my vote is immediately going to go to Robert Englund. He nails Crane's intelligence, his sick malice towards his victims.

One thing I also like is that while Scarecrow is meant to be scary, that's only when the gas is being used. He's meant to be that kid that got bullied at school that's now grown up with all that bitterness and hate, which is why I think someone like John Noble doesn't really suit him because he sounds very threatening and very much like a supervillain. Englund has a much lighter tone, but his acting really makes you feel all that hate Crane should have. Crane is a monster hiding inside a feeble man and Englund captures that perfectly.
said at 11:07 AM on Sun Jul 2 2017
@Fairfieldfencer Crane sounds too similar to John Noble honestly, rather generic and even thuuggish.

His Scarecrow is more high pitched and is how his Crane should sound, NOT his Scarecrow. which should've been his Freddy.
said at 7:07 AM on Thu Mar 30 2017
 6 Shout Outs!
I just watched the Injustice 2 "It's Good To Be Bad" trailer and I think Robert Englund is voicing Scarecrow. I'm actually surprised no one thought about this casting decision
said at 6:43 AM on Mon Feb 20 2017
And the original Bubsy is here- wait he's still voice acting? Last I know of any role from him is his Atelier Iris role(which was terrible), I can't really understand what he is saying at all
said at 6:23 PM on Sun Feb 12 2017
VC thoughts update

I must say that whenever I see the Scarecrow design in the Batman comic books (especially in comics drawn by Neal Adams and Jim Aparo), I always imagine the Scarecrow being quite creepy yet hammy enough to be fun and the only ones that manage to find the balance are Henry Polic II and Andre Stojka.

Henry Polic II has a really great voice and his hammy delivery really works well in the role. He can be quite threatening and foreboding yet he also made Professor Crane quite the pathetic weasel deep down.

Andre Stojka has a great raspy voice and a fantastic delivery as well. He also has a really great mischievous laugh. I really liked how well the Scarecrow was used in this episode and it was the very first time we got a Scarecrow that could be a credible threat to Batman. I also like how Stojka made Crane a very intellectual and cool headed man who really is a cowardly weasel deep down.

Jeffrey Combs does sound quite creepy and whispery, but he lacks ham. His Rise of Sin Tzu performance is a little bit better, but I still feel he lacks a little bit of an over-the-top edge.

Don Messick has a great whispery voice, and he is tons of fun in the role, but I never felt threatened by his version. So yeah, it's a great hammy performance, but not creepy enough.

I have the same case with John Noble as I have with Jeffrey Combs. He does sound fittingly creepy and foreboding, but he needs more energy.

I like Dee Bradley Baker, Corey Burton and Dino Andrade in the role, but their attempts at trying to balance ham and creepiness just don't sit right with me. I still like their takes, though.

Cillian Murphy, Christopher S. Field, Brian Silva and Brian T. Delaney really don't leave a big impression on me.

Honorable mention: James Goode (BBC DC radio dramas)
said at 6:37 PM on Sun Feb 12 2017
Oh, and I forgot about this, but despite limited material, Jason Mantzoukas does a pretty fantastic job in making the Scarecrow a fun creepy character. He's third place for me. Also, switching Don Messick and Jeffrey Combs around.

I also forgot to talk about Ted Knight. His voice would fit the Joker really well, but it doesn't work for the Scarecrow.
said at 5:27 AM on Sat May 20 2017
Honestly, Robert Englund disappointed me. I expected him to go full-on Freddy Krueger and do something closer to Henry Polic II and Andre Stojka. But instead, he just plays him too subdued for my taste.

It's not a bad performance, but like John, Dee, Corey and Dino, he just doesn't balance it well.

If he played him more like Freddy, Henry and Andre would have some serious competition in my book.
said at 5:52 PM on Sun Feb 12 2017
Brian Silvawas alright from what I could make out.
said at 5:50 PM on Sun Feb 12 2017
I can't really hear Brian Silva.
said at 7:22 PM on Sun Feb 12 2017
@Zillah That's a risk with recording arcade games, sometimes dialogue gets interrupted by yelling kids.
said at 3:08 AM on Sat Jan 28 2017
 2 Shout Outs!
Dino Andrade works best to me as Scarecrow, but I like Jeffrey Combs and Dee Bradley Baker's performances as alternatives to it.
said at 10:31 PM on Mon Dec 26 2016
 1 Shout Out!
I'm changing my vote back to Jeffrey Combs.
said at 9:10 PM on Fri Oct 28 2016
 3 Shout Outs!
When it comes to Scarecrow, he needs to sound scary. For me, it's a tie between Jeffrey Combs and Dino Andrade. The former because his raspy whisper sends chills up my spine, and the latter for how he makes Crane sound so much like an unpredictable sociopath. Recasting him in Arkham Knight was a mistake. He didn't sound scary, just another deep menacing villain voice. Yawn.

I feel Combs could've done better. It's scary at first, but then you realize he says everything the same way. He was only in two episodes, so I wish he could've done more to have time to improve.
EPA Deane
said at 5:00 AM on Tue Oct 11 2016
 1 Shout Out!
My Top 5 Scarecrow Voices:

5.Corey Burton/ Cillian Murphy
4. Dino Andrade
3. Dee Bradley Baker
2. John Noble
1. Jeffrey Combs
said at 5:44 PM on Tue Aug 30 2016
1. Dino Andrade
2. John Noble
3. Henry Polic II
4. Dee Bradley Baker
5. Corey Burton
Shaun Ince
said at 1:05 PM on Sun Jul 31 2016
 2 Shout Outs!
This compare has some pretty interesting takes on Scarecrow. Dino Andrade really embodies Scarecrow through his performance alone. The demonic effects give off a really creepy vibe and like people have saids, masks the facade that he is.

Dee Bradley Baker balances the creepy & campy side of Scarecrow, in a way that doesn't sound too forced. Arguably one of his best performances in Brave & The Bold.

Heny Pollic II is more or less on par with Dee in this role. Not much else to say. It's a good performance

Jeffery Combs while decent, just sounds way too whispery in this role. A more refined version of his Rat King voice would be perfect.

John Noble doesn't work as a traditional Scarecrow voice. It sounds like Unicron from Transformers trying to be Scarecrow. And I can't get that image out of my head. I can't fault people for liking the performance, I just don't think it fits. Noble would fit perfectly as Hugo Strange with that voice however.

Of all the classic ones. Andre Strokja has the stronger performance. Ted Knight sounds too hammy & Don Messick sounds too feeble.

Corey Burton's take to some extent fits, but the overuse of effects ruins the performance. Sounds way too demonic & distorted & you can't even understand it half the time.

Cillian Murphy, Christopher S Field & Brian T Delaney all come across as bland & forgettable.

Dino is my personal favorite, Dee is second & Henry at a worthy third place.
said at 2:14 PM on Thu Jul 7 2016
 3 Shout Outs!
After playing Arkham Knight, I'm changing my vote to John Noble. He was fantastic in the role.
said at 12:45 AM on Tue May 24 2016
 2 Shout Outs!
Comparing them again and listening to his performance in Rise of Sin Tzu, I'm going to change my vote back to Jeffrey Combs.
said at 4:05 PM on Sun May 29 2016

On second thought, comparing the clips and listening to the interview for Arkham Underworld, I'm gonna change my vote to Dino Andrade, as he was pretty creepy.
said at 6:07 PM on Fri Jul 8 2016
@Anicomicgeek That's awesome to hear Dino back as Scarecrow in Arkham Underworld!
said at 3:19 PM on Wed Apr 13 2016
 8 Shout Outs!
After playing through Arkham Knight a few times, I think I was perhaps too harsh on John Noble's performance.

I think his voice works perfectly with the Scarecrow's redesign in Knight, and the scene where he tells Oracle it's ok to be afraid is pretty damn creepy. He voices a version of Crane that is borderline Narcissistic, and is done screwing around. The whispery voice is a good fit, in my opinion.

I probably would vote for him, but Dino came first and thus my vote sticks with Dino. I think the cowardice in his voice just embodies Crane better, until he's more in control as Scarecrow, hence the demonic effects that work perfectly.
said at 3:41 PM on Wed Apr 13 2016
IMO, John works amazingly well for the AK version, but I couldn't really see him as a traditional Scarecrow.
said at 4:16 PM on Wed Apr 13 2016
@GreenGoblin75 Indeed, and that is why Dino is my favorite.
said at 8:26 AM on Sun Mar 20 2016
 6 Shout Outs!
Oh man this voice compare is one of the harder ones for me to analyze. I feel many of the voices here are good but not the ideal perfect voice for me.

My top three favs are Dino Andrade, Henry Polic and Dee Bradley Baker.

Dino's really creepy and light sounding voice fits rather well and works even better since he's ultimately a pathetic weaselly coward.

Henry Polic I think is rather enjoyable and fun, he has his fair share of creepy and comical moments and gives the most well rounded performance overall.

Dee Bradley Baker is quite fun in the role, he's creepy and campy. With more material maybe he could become my favourite.

The rest work and yet don't.

Jeffrey Combs, honestly he'd be perfect if it wasn't for the way he was directed. He speaks too fast is a bit too dry which is shame since based on his Herbert West and Rat King (which is really how his Scarecrow should have been like) I know he'd nail it. I hope he gets another shot, I know he could nail it.

Corey Burton's creepy distorted voice and delivery fits well but sounds too unintelligible.

Cillian Murphy his voice acting is rather stiff but I did always like his portrayal of the character.

Andre Stojka is the best of the older voices for Scarecrow, his Carlos Alazraqui esque inspired voice and delivery actually works well for a campy yet diabolical version of the character.

John me this is honestly Hugo Strange and not the Scarecrow. It's a shame really, much like the game itself, this seemed promising but ended up being a major let down.

Ted Knight is too overacted.

Don Messick is too light and raspy.

Brian T. Delaney and Christopher S. Field are honestly forgettable sounding.

I think I'll go with Dino Andrade for the time being.

BONUS: I think someone like Crispin Freeman, Chuck Huber, Robert Englund or Alec Willows would be perfect as The Scarecrow.
said at 2:42 PM on Tue Mar 8 2016
 1 Shout Out!
1. Jeffrey Combs (Rise of Sin Tzu)
2. John Noble
3. Corey Burton
4. Dino Andrade/DBB
5. Cillian Murphy- he was better in the movie
6.Henry (RIP)
said at 2:44 PM on Tue Mar 8 2016
Jeff sounds much better here than in TNBA:
said at 8:33 AM on Fri Feb 5 2016
 7 Shout Outs!
Having played Knight, I actually like John Noble. The problem was that Scarecrow's role was greatly reduced to AK's version of Hugo Strange.

A pity that the game (IMO) has a lack of character development/personality going for the cast. I could go on, but that would be better for the forums.

I still stand by Dino Andrade as well as the Asylum rendition of the character.
said at 3:46 AM on Sun Jan 31 2016
 1 Shout Out!
John Noble: scary and crazy like Screcrow should always sound
said at 12:28 PM on Mon Nov 16 2015
After reading the YMMV page of TV Tropes, I'm beginning to think Dino Andrade might've chosen to come back, as it's possible one part of the game's plot might've hit a little too close to home for him.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 1:01 PM on Mon Nov 16 2015
@Anicomicgeek I know what you're talking about, but that is basically impossible. Actors don't usually get those kinds of details until they're actually recording. Besides, Scarecrow was completely redesigned and they certainly wouldn't have done this simply because a single voice actor wanted out. They recast Scarecrow because they wanted to, not because of anything involving Dino Andrade.
said at 11:07 PM on Mon Nov 16 2015

I meant to say "chosen not to come back".
said at 11:07 PM on Mon Nov 16 2015
@Nightmare Crusher

That's a good point; I didn't think of that.^^;
said at 5:19 PM on Sun Aug 30 2015
 12 Shout Outs!
People seem to erroneously think of John Noble's monotone as being indicative of a lack of effort in his performance and not, as it actually is, a large part of said performance.

This is a Scarecrow numbed by heavy exposure to his own fear toxin, all but dead inside. He feels nothing. He fears nothing. Heonly lives to try and recapture the fear Batman once made him feel.

That soulless, empty monotone suits him perfectly.
said at 1:25 PM on Mon Aug 17 2015
 15 Shout Outs!
John Noble. For a few simple reasons, he's scary without needing digital enhancements to sound scary. The monotone voice, the religious obsession with fear, the slow but calculating delivery. Sure, it's not original or unique. It's basically stock villain. But at least I'm hooked on what he's saying and believe he is a danger.

When I listen to Dino Andrade, Henry Polick, or pretty much anyone who isn't John Noble and Jeffrey Combs....I'm not scared. They sound more like a weak man, compensating by using drugs. Which isn't scary, it's pathetic.

John Noble 's portrayal is still a weak man, he's not a fighter. But he's still a danger. He's intelligent, he's obsessive, and borderline sadistic. He's almost like a preacher with all his speeches and you can see some of the logic. There's nothing more terrifying than understanding a person you know to be crazy, because what does that say about yourself.

Scarecrow may be a weak man, but many voice actors emphasize this too much. Scarecrow is bottom-line, supposed to be scary. John Noble although stock and simple, is scary. And scary without digital enhancements. So bonus points awarded for that.

John Noble get's my vote.
CatsTuxedo (Moderator)
said at 2:55 PM on Mon Aug 17 2015
@DeadpoolFool "Scary" is not a character that comes out organically, it's an image to be artificially engineered. The Scarecrow uses his fear gas to generate a scary facade, because the character behind it, Jonathan Crane, is organically not scary; he's a weak, over-educated blowhard and a dirty coward.

It occurs to me that the Arkham Knight writers may've had to conjure up this shallow, fake persona for the Scarecrow themselves to cover up the fact that they don't know the character at all.
said at 4:39 PM on Mon Aug 17 2015
@CatsTuxedo I've read my fair share of comics and Doctor Crane started off as a weak, over-educated, blowhard, and coward. This is true. But after he adopted the Scarecrow persona, he became a threat and more a force than a character. The comics always plays him off as like a Hannibal Lecter kind of threat. He may look weak, but he's always thinking four or five steps ahead. I recall he once drove two Arkham inmates to suicide, and pretty much had the whole asylum scared without once using his fear gas.

Scarecrow may look like a weak, cowardly, dweeb. But in reality, he's a dangerous psychopath and that's something I don't think many adaptions have gotten right because they exaggerated his more dweebish tendencies and made him more dependent on his fear gas.

At least the Arkham Knight version of Scarecrow made him a danger even when he's not using the fear gas. He's manipulative, cunning, sadistic, and obsessive.

The Scarecrow I know, doesn't need fear gas to be a bad guy. John Noble's is the closest to that.
CatsTuxedo (Moderator)
said at 7:02 PM on Mon Aug 17 2015
@DeadpoolFool Jonathan Crane's Scarecrow persona is just that: a persona. The reason the Scarecrow comes off as such a smug, power-tripping evil genius is because Crane knows he can get away with it holding the kind of power he has. When that power is cut through and the potency of his outward persona dissipates, more likely than not his true colors are exposed.

The issue with Noble's Scarecrow is that he's all persona and no character; there's no extra layers that give nuance to why he acts and behaves the way he does.
said at 7:23 PM on Mon Aug 17 2015
@CatsTuxedo If you follow the Arkham games (or listen to mook dialogue in Arkham Knight), you'll find that Scarecrow's the way he is because of what happened ALLLLLL the way in Arkham Asylum, particularly when his body was mangled by Killer Croc thanks to Batman activating his shock collar. So it's no exaggeration to say that he's doing everything in his power to make Batman's last night a living nightmare. And since it took him the better part of about two years (Arkham City=one year after Asylum, Arkham Knight=nine months after City) to recollect himself, his obvious obsession with outing Batman and the fact that he was willing to nuke Gotham with fear definitely shows that he's gone off the deep end.
said at 12:13 PM on Mon Aug 24 2015
@CatsTuxedo Isn't saying that casting John Noble means you don't understand the character essentially the same as fans who like him don't? These guys came up with pretty good defenses for the voice, and if you can come up with reasoning like that, then you do understand the character somewhat, not sure what the writers said if anything, but Scarecrow or any comic book villain doesn't have to be a copy/paste from the comics to work.
said at 12:14 PM on Mon Aug 24 2015
@DeadpoolFool congrats dude you worded your defense way better than I could.
CatsTuxedo (Moderator)
said at 12:33 PM on Mon Aug 24 2015
@pete Most of the praise/defense I've seen of Noble's Scarecrow goes solely toward how "creepy" and "menacing" he is, with the occasional "intelligent" here and there. I've hardly seen any note of his personality, of which there is minimal, as other detractors have brought up.
said at 3:29 PM on Mon Aug 24 2015
@CatsTuxedo I think that's more the voice direction than anything else. Not of the others are my ideal Scarecrow though, and others I've mention, can probably be as creepy and menacing as Noble but have personality.
Shaun Ince
said at 12:34 PM on Mon Aug 17 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
You know, after listening to Noble as Unicron, I think I understand why people would consider his Scarecrow to be uninspired. It sounds almost exactly like Unicron.
said at 8:17 AM on Fri Aug 14 2015
 6 Shout Outs!
At last, John Noble has popped up here, AND Brian T. Delaney. Permit me the opportunity to go over my top 5!

1) Jeffrey Combs- Combs' revamp of the Scarecrow on B:TAS (or TNBA) was definitely for the better. All respect to Henry Polic II, but as one of the producers said, Scarecrow should live up to his name, as in "scary." And his performance really fits the new zombie look. Combs' performance with the whispery and raspy tone really gives the character new life and while not up there with Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill, definitely was one of the better performances in the show. In fact, I would've liked to have seen Combs come back as Scarecrow in Arkham Knight had they not cast John Noble (as another "BRING BACK ACTORS FROM THE ANIMATED SERIES" like they did with Conroy, Hamill, and Sorkin for the first game). I'll get more to him later, but Combs is easily my favorite Scarecrow performance since it can be scary even without the ghostly effect (refer to Rise of Sin Tzu).

2) John Noble- Ah, easily one of the most divisive performances of Arkham Knight. Personally, I think it served its purpose. While everyone says that Dino should have come back for the role, sometimes there comes along a character design that can only go with one voice, like with Jeffrey Combs. As for me, when I look at the Arkham Knight version of Scarecrow, I don't immediately hear Dino's voice coming out of that zombified, walking corpse. In fact, I rarely ever do. John's "monster" voice (or his "Unicron" voice, as I like to put it) really fits the character this time around. He doesn't sound as frightening to me as Combs, but he still brings an ambience of intelligence, spitefulness, and an overall sinister personality. Also bear in mind that the Noble/Dino Scarecrow's character evolved over the course of the games, so the voice could logically follow. Speaking of Dino...

3) Dino Andrade- One of Arkham Asylum's most memorable performances, period. Dino isn't the perfect Scarecrow, but as John Noble served the "mastermind" Scarecrow design, Dino's voice fit the "recently escaped Joker lackey" part. It would have been interesting to see Dino return, as while his normal voice (without the modulation) brought out the intelligent and analytic part of Scarecrow, he sounded like a bit of a wimp when going up against Batman in his final scene before he was mauled by Croc. I can't really imagine Dino's Scarecrow to sound menacing without the effects, which now that it occurs to me was probably the intention. Still, as I mentioned, he was definitely one of the more memorable performances of Arkham Asylum, and I give him credit for at least that.

4) Dee Bradley Baker- I know what you're thinking. "Why are you putting a performance from TBATB here?" Simple: it works. No, seriously, out of the voices here for the Silver Age Scarecrow, Dee's probably works the best. He speaks in a soft and whispery tone similar to Combs'. Of course, to most of us it doesn't sound creepy but it definitely fit that version of Scarecrow. And besides, Dee's one of those actors who doesn't really need voice modulation all that often, he played almost every alien in Ben 10: Alien Force! As for a more modern Scarecrow, I think he could do an alright job. In fact, yeah! Why don't we do some trial and error with him to see if he makes a good modern Scarecrow? It's worth a try, danggit!

5) Cillian Murphy- Carrying his performance from live action, Cillian really gives the Scarecrow a creepy vibe. Not entirely scary, mind you, but still creepy. Every time he talks, he almost sounds like he's about to get off his rocker each time, with that subtle trembling tone. I don't know about you guys, but as an aside note I think Cillian's Scarecrow was the Loki of the Dark Knight Trilogy. Seriously, did he have to show up in every single movie? Sure, he was entertaining as hell, but was it necessary for him to be the hanging judge in The Dark Knight Rises? Regardless, though he's at the bottom of my top 5, I still enjoy his performance.

Now for the runner-ups:
Corey Burton- I genuinely wonder what kind of voice Corey put on under all that modulation. I think he's the most modulated voice in this comparison! The weirder thing is, this is supposed to be Cillian's Scarecrow. Why does he sound demonic? Is there fear gas running through his sewer lair, too? And if so, why is his mouth FULLY VISIBLE? Noble's Scarecrow at least has the excuse of the gas tubes. But a demonic performance is still a demonic performance, and Corey Burton never fails to impress.
Brian T. Delaney- Since the film was meant for kids, I don't think this portrayal was meant to be too scary for the younger viewers. With that aside, it was...alright for me.
Christopher S. Field- I honestly lost my composure when I got to the part where he yelled. I don't think I could take this Scarecrow seriously after that line.
Henry Polic II- While there's no doubt that Polic was going for the "professor" approach with Scarecrow, he didn't seem all that scary to me. Intelligent? Of course. Scary? Not so much. Still, wouldn't consider it a bad prototype performance, even though it's a voice that went with a character that underwent four designs (counting Combs, who was the apex).
said at 10:17 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015

Regarding Corey Burton's Crane and your theory about fear gas, maybe, but also Batman was somehow infected with fear toxin when got bitten by Croc. There's also the fact that the closest anyone got to sounding in Gotham Knight is KMR as Lucius Fox.
said at 11:04 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@Anicomicgeek Yeah, I only watched Gotham Knight in passing, so please pardon me if I didn't get a few details right anywhere else :P
said at 8:14 PM on Tue Aug 11 2015
 5 Shout Outs!
Anyone who thought John Noble was a great Scarecrow clearly doesn't get the character.

Actually, a LOT of voices from Knight seem to have this problem: they're terrible performances that don't capture what made these characters so distinct to begin with.

So yeah, sticking with Dino
said at 9:57 PM on Tue Aug 11 2015

That's actually pretty rude to people who liked the performace.
said at 11:52 AM on Wed Aug 12 2015
@Anicomicgeek Thanks fir saving me the trouble of ranting about it.
said at 1:18 PM on Thu Aug 13 2015
@pete for
said at 5:36 PM on Thu Aug 13 2015
@Anicomicgeek - I guess it just bugs me when people praise the more generic run-of-the-mill voices just because it came from something they liked.

I'm not saying Noble's performance was bad by any means. I'm just saying it's a voice that could be slapped on any generic villain. It doesn't scream "Scarecrow" no matter how many fear analogies he makes. It makes me feel that people want Scarecrow to be a very generic main baddie instead of the unique and interesting character he is.
said at 5:46 PM on Thu Aug 13 2015
@Anicomicgeek - BTW I am aware my statement contradicts my saying "terrible performances" earlier. I kind of jumped the gun with that. Greene's Barbara is the only real terrible performance IMO. Everyone else who was recast was fine, but still generic
The Doctor
said at 3:40 AM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@Anicomicgeek Guy was just telling his opinion on Noble's performance. He didn't say anything about people who liked the performance, so in my eyes he wasn't rude at all.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 10:10 AM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@The Doctor "He didn't say anything about people who liked the performance"

But he did.

"Anyone who thought John Noble was a great Scarecrow clearly doesn't get the character."

I don't even like John Noble's Scarecrow, but this is kind of rude.
The Doctor
said at 12:09 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@Nightmare Crusher My bad. Tired after school and just little time for myself before going to work, so my mind wasn't at its sharpest. Sorry.
said at 2:45 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@HyperVoiceActing Well from what I understand when he was badly mauled by Killer Croc, his mask was damaged so there was no reason to use that voice so Scarecrow created a new one.
said at 2:45 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@HyperVoiceActing Kinda guessed the second part though.
said at 2:59 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@pete - What does that have to do with what I just said?
said at 3:03 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@HyperVoiceActing It's all your comments as a whole, not saying that's why it's generic, but the whole "not getting the character" thing, IMO he changed the voice for those reasons.
said at 3:07 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@pete - But I never even brought up how he sounded different from Asylum.

That has nothing to do with how one note he was
said at 3:13 PM on Fri Aug 14 2015
@HyperVoiceActing It's a theory I had, just my way of defending the voice.
said at 4:38 PM on Fri Sep 18 2015
@HyperVoiceActing So according to you, people are morons for having an opinion you don't like? Nice.
said at 5:44 PM on Sat Sep 19 2015
@GF93 - It's not that I think they're morons. It's that they seem to prefer a version with zero personality outside of "fear metaphor fear metaphor fear metaphor" instead of a version that captures how unique and interesting the character is. Sure, Noble sounds intimidating, but should that really be the only thing the character needs?

I'll concede that I was pretty harsh with my word choices though, and I apologize for that.
said at 10:30 AM on Thu Mar 10 2016
said at 1:09 PM on Tue Aug 11 2015
Regarding John Noble, he doesn't have his mask anymore as it wore out and fell apart, and I'm guessing the voice Dino Andrade used is just a voice Crane created to sound more scary and frightening, and without the mask, Crane will altered his natural voice voice in this game. I honestly found it more frightening then most voices here and am going with him.

skeletonking1234 said it better than me, so I'm going quote him, so one has to scan through.

"Dino...oh Dino...I never understood. I really never did. this is a role that everyone adores in the Arkham games, but to be honest, is probably one the most overrated supervillain performance I've ever seen. I never thought it sounded that fitting, it sounds way too young, the vocal effects don't sound all that good, and to be honest, from playing AA, he always sounded really bored in his portrayal".

I quoted it because aside from the bored part, I agree. My ideal voices are Peter Macnicol, Robert Englund, Tobin Bell, and Brian Drummond.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 2:03 PM on Tue Aug 11 2015
@pete The problem with Noble isn't just the voice. All of the other Scarecrow voices can be described in ways that set them apart.

Dino Andrade sounds more like "the coward who tries to act tough". Henry Polic puts more of a pompous sneer into it. Corey Burton is buried by weird vocal effects.

Cillian Murphy's is interesting because he actually sounds creepy in a way that's unexpected. The tone of his voice and the rhythms of his lines are unusual and off-putting. Jeffrey Combs' tone is pretty straightforward, but his naturally creepy voice manages to make him stand out.

John Noble's just a straightforward "villain" performance that's been done so many times.
said at 11:50 AM on Sun Aug 16 2015
@pete the whole "this is what Crane sounds like without the mask" defense used to justify Dino Andrade's recasting with John Noble really doesn't hold water for two reasons, though.

1: You actually get to hear Crane's normal voice in Arkham Asylum on numerous occasions, whether it be in patient interview tapes or certain cutscenes, and he couldn't sound further from John Noble as possible.

2: does it really make sense for a person who has John Noble's voice make themself sound radically different and high pitched with the mask on? Much as I don't like his voice for Scarecrow, John Noble's voice is still pretty cool.

There really isn't much of a way to justify the voice change in-universe, just to retcon in your head Scarecrow had John Noble's voice in Asylum, just like how Oracle sounds 10 years younger going from Kim Brooks to Ashley Greene, haha.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 12:31 PM on Sun Aug 16 2015
Or how Gordon has had four very different voices.
TylerMirage (Admin)
said at 12:35 PM on Sun Aug 16 2015
@Music Meister I think Gordon's constant changing of VAs is the one that gets me rustled the most, ha ha. They're all great VAs who all make great Gordons...but...all four to portray a single version of Gordon? I can let Gough slide since he was an "origins" Commish, and they re-cast both Batman and Joker to portray their younger selves, too.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 12:44 PM on Sun Aug 16 2015
I joke about it being just tradition that Gordon gets a new VA every game but yeah, no real good reason that they got VAs who almost sound nothing alike.
said at 1:39 PM on Sun Aug 16 2015

Yeah, the fact Gordon keeps getting recast is ridiculous, especially considering in City, Tom Kane did come back as Sharp. They should've just picked one voice and kept it as best as they can.
said at 3:30 PM on Sun Aug 16 2015
@TylerMirage It's a shame too, because while I don't agree all of them were great Gordon's, most of them were or had the potential to be.

Tom Kane was probably one of the worst Gordons due to how gravelly and forced his voice was, so I was totally fine with David Kaye taking over in Arkham City. Sadly, he barely got much to do in that game despite being a huge step up from Kane.

Gough was totally fine in Origins, but it'd be nice if they could pick a change and stick with it. By the time Rocksteady announced Jonathan Banks taking over for Arkham Knight, I just threw my hands up in the air and said screw it. Banks is a good enough performance anyways, probably the only recast in Arkham Knight I could honestly get behind.

Trying to reconcile voice recasting in canon is pretty stupid. You can't really justify in-universe how Scarecrow goes from Dino Andrade to Jonathan Banks, Oracle from Kim Brooks to Ashley Greene, or Michael Gough all the way to Jonathan Banks, haha.
said at 9:03 AM on Mon Aug 17 2015
@chaosincarnate Dino Andrade to Jonathan Banks?
said at 4:04 PM on Mon Aug 17 2015
@Zillah Typo, obviously meant John Noble.
said at 4:25 PM on Mon Aug 17 2015
@chaosincarnate I know, I was just being silly :p
said at 12:24 PM on Thu Aug 20 2015
@chaosincarnate Faur enough was trying to say that without the mask, he changed his regular voice to be more threatening, but I guess Yeah going from high to deep to be threatening doesn't work, but that's from the original trailer. A mic in the mask is a another guess but I just like this because I always enjoy John Noble, and have trouble picking a definitive Scarecrow out of these guys.
said at 11:56 AM on Mon Aug 24 2015
@pete Fair
said at 10:45 AM on Thu May 26 2016

No offense, but what is more probable is that what Croc did to him might've also affected his vocal cords.
said at 10:08 AM on Tue Aug 11 2015
 6 Shout Outs!
Well I guess I'm gonna be on the unpopular opinion side and say John Noble was fantastic in this role. And yes, he gets my vote.
Shaun Ince
said at 6:57 AM on Tue Aug 11 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
Listening to a couple of people's thoughts on this compare & I feel inclined to agree with Music Meister & CatsTuxedo. And I've decided to change my vote back to Dino.
said at 7:06 PM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 5 Shout Outs!
i feel John would have been better as Jeremiah Arkham. That guy should have been the main villain in Arkham Knight.
said at 1:03 PM on Mon Aug 31 2015
@Troodon2 Hinedtly I think the Court Of Owls was the best choice, and their leader was the Arkham Knight in this version.
said at 1:32 PM on Mon Aug 31 2015
@pete Or Hush. You know, since his appearance in City was practically pointless if they don't do anything with him or the League of Assassins.
said at 6:02 PM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
John Noble and Brian T Delaney are simply okay. I'm sticking with Dino Andrade.
said at 4:21 PM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 7 Shout Outs!
I agree with Music Meister and CatsTuxedo, John Noble is a disappointment. It's not that he was even a bad choice, and I understand the recast since Scarecrow is the big bad of Arkham Knight, but I'm sorry... his take is just boring to me, with hardly any presence to his performance. You could literally take that voice and put it onto plenty of Batman villains. Take away "Fear" from his ramblings and you basically get Hugo Strange.

It's a shame, because he actually sounded pretty damn creepy in the E3 2014 Scarecrow reveal, but he leaves no impact whatsoever at all in the actual game.

Dino Andrade seemed to just get this character better. Jonathan Crane is a character who is a complete and utter wimp, while the Scarecrow persona is one giant power trip, complemented by the demonic vocal effects. Thus, my vote stays with him.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 2:16 PM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 7 Shout Outs!
People already kinda said my opinion but I'll say mine anyways, John Noble is a good villain performance but that's all he has. No personality or anything special. It's menacing but really, that's it.

I still prefer Dino, he sounds scary but under it all he is a coward.
said at 12:48 PM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 5 Shout Outs!
I'm giving it to John Noble. I love the methodical, creepy, mastermind characteristics he gave to Scarecrow.
said at 11:08 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 8 Shout Outs!
Let's be honest, some of these are only "great" because of the filters and effects.
TylerMirage (Admin)
said at 1:57 PM on Mon Aug 10 2015
@Weirdperson31 Not that I disagree with your point, but your comment sort of opens up a big ol' can of worms regarding the oft-debated "voice vs. performance"-thing.

What matters in a voice-over role? Is it the original, unedited voice? Or is it the final performance/end result?

While it's mostly subjective, some characters are better without alterations, and some are better *with* alterations. Frank Welker's Soundwave is one of the most iconic voices in the franchise, yet all it is is his Dr. Claw growl with a vocoder effect thrown on top. The original voice is nothing special as Soundwave, but you put that vocoder effect on it and BAM you've got something that fans instantly fell in love with.

Is it really that big of a deal if someone's voice needs some artificial tinkering to make it a little deeper or growlier? Or lighter? Or most ghostly? Or whatever? If they can achieve the end result naturally, good on them - but needing some help in post isn't necessarily a *bad* thing. Fiddling with a voice in post in like putting an actor into make-up on a live-action shoot. It can enhance or inhibit the performance, but it's just one part that goes into making that final result of "the character". The concept of gestalt, if you will.

You can have great ingredients that go into making a cake (the voice actor's original, unedited performance), but sometimes you still need to put a cherry on top and display it on a nice platter (add filters or effects). Doesn't mean the cake was bad, that just means they chose/needed/wanted to do a little bit more with it. So I think it all depends on the character, the voice actor, the voice director and overall direction that they wish to go with the character.
NCZ (Admin)
said at 11:05 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 9 Shout Outs!
John Noble's just a one-note villain performance. Dino Andrade's putting some actual oomph into it.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 10:33 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 8 Shout Outs!
Honestly, Arkham Knight Scarecrow just felt like a generic bad guy to me. The great thing about Scarecrow in Asylum was that he stayed in the background and came up when you least expected it. Dino's performance gels with that potrayal very well and my vote stays with him.
said at 5:27 PM on Mon Aug 31 2015
@Nightmare Crusher To be fair to John Noble, his Scarecrow didn't get the lion's share of screentime compared to the Arkham Knight, and yet this time he was elevated to non-action big bad. He stayed in the background and never confronted Batman unless he had to (ACE Chemicals?) because of his broken bum leg. I'm just saying, Scarecrow in AK probably got as much screentime as he did in AA, if you're judging performance by appearance.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 6:14 PM on Mon Aug 31 2015
@loredragonmaster It isn't just acreentime though. Scarecrow's actual role in AK is much larger than in AA, even if he isn't directly confronting you, he is a much greater presence.
CatsTuxedo (Moderator)
said at 10:19 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 8 Shout Outs!
Noble as Scarecrow just feels kinda meh. It's a decent villain performance, but there's hardly anything about it that stands out as specifically Scarecrow.

Meanwhile, Polic is too deep and Combs' delivery is rather monotonous; all his lines feel the same as each other and the voice itself isn't even that formidable. It almost feels like the favor for his version is based more on the superficial design than the actual voice or personality.

From my point of view, Scarecrow is a character who should be plenty intelligent and might seem intimidating in particular circumstances, but is ultimately a dirty coward who lets his fear gas do the heavy lifting. Since Dino fits that character the most, I put my vote on him.
said at 1:43 PM on Mon Aug 10 2015
@CatsTuxedo Yippie we agree on something for once! Happy day! :D
said at 2:51 AM on Mon Sep 7 2015
@CatsTuxedo Henry Polic's voice is the right blend of unique presence and Shakespearean flare acting that creates the most ideal and memorable performance to date for this character. I don't find the voice to be that deep to begin with it considering it barely deepened at times.
said at 4:25 AM on Mon Sep 7 2015
@IAMTHEVASTUNIVERSE My thoughts exactly.
Shaun Ince
said at 10:03 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
John Noble as Scarecrow is perhaps one of the best performances I've seen in a Batman game. I think I'll be retracting my vote from Dino & voting for John instead.
said at 9:33 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 4 Shout Outs!
Finally I've been planning to change my vote to John for awhile.
said at 9:30 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 3 Shout Outs!
Yes! John sounds like a force to be reckoned with. This sounds like someone to actually be afraid of!
said at 3:58 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 5 Shout Outs!
................ WHOA John Noble is creepy!
said at 3:45 AM on Mon Aug 10 2015
 4 Shout Outs!
I'm gonna change my vote to John Noble as he was very creepy as Scarecrow. That said, Brian T Delaney was kinda meh in the role.
said at 10:17 PM on Sun Aug 9 2015
Brian T Delaney was... meh! Not bad, but not very good either just... meh! Kind'a generic, though I don't really blame the casting itself.
said at 5:46 PM on Thu Jul 9 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
I'm gonna vote for John Noble when he comes up
said at 12:18 AM on Sun Jun 28 2015
 1 Shout Out!
I gotta go with Dino Andrade. I found the Arkham Asylum version of the character to be interesting. He comes off as quite wimpy compared to the other super villains, but under the fear gas, he becomes really, really menacing.
Shaun Ince
said at 7:53 PM on Sat Jun 27 2015
 1 Shout Out!
Bit late to the party, but I'll be voting for Dino Andrade. Most of the other performances are pretty solid as well. Dee Bradley Baker's especially.

I have seen gameplay of Arkham Knight & John Noble as Scarecrow is awesome.
said at 1:08 AM on Thu Jun 25 2015
 4 Shout Outs!
Gimme dat John Noble, ANYday of the week. He is always what I imagined Scarecrow would sound like.
said at 8:52 PM on Wed Jun 24 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
10.Cillian Murphy: He sounds too normal, too calm and too human.
9.Ted Knight: He's more fit to voice Joker over Scarecrow in my opinion.
8.Don Messick: Sounds a bit creepy, but also really childish, which makes it less creepy, therefore a not very good voice for Scarecrow.
7.Corey Burton: Burton... Why the hell aren't you trying here?
6.Andre Stojka: Not a very fitting one, but still good voice for the Batman villain.
5.Christopher S Field: Kinda corny but still alright for Scarecrow.
4.Jeffrey Combs: Not a very interesting voice. Creepy, but also really boring.
3.Dee Bradley Baker: Pretty fitting overall, and it suits him even if this is a parody of the character.
2.Dino Andrade: An upgraded version of Combs' performance.
1.Henry Polic II: Such an awesome voice. Given how Scarecrow was portrayed in that series, this voice commands more respect, and the appearance gives enough spooks to anyone.
said at 10:54 AM on Sat May 30 2015
 2 Shout Outs!
I haven't even played the game, and I know that John Noble is going to be my vote. Even just listening to the guy in casual interviews creeps me out. The dude just naturally has a creepy tone in his voice. But it's also intelligent, and suave. It's the perfect Scarecrow voice.

In a close second place is Jeffery Combs, it's a bit more intelligent than creepy. If it wasn't for the echo sound they added in post, it probably wouldn't have been as scary. Where-as John Noble doesn't need any post production work done to naturally sound scary.
said at 8:09 AM on Wed Apr 29 2015
 4 Shout Outs!
No Matter If John Noble Comes, Dino Will Always Be Scarecrow To Be.
said at 1:49 PM on Thu Feb 26 2015
1. Jeffrey Combs
2. Dino Andrade
3. Corey Burton
4. Dee Bradley Baker
5. Cillian Murphy
6. Henry Polic II
7. Don Messick
8. Christopher S Field
9. Andre Stojka
10. Ted Knight
said at 7:28 PM on Thu Feb 12 2015
 1 Shout Out!
I think Cillian Murphy is a fantastic actor and I loved his take on Crane, but I don't think it translated as well to voice over. Jeffrey Combs has a similar portrayal but works better with the medium, so my votes goes to him.

The rest of them sound either "cartoon crazy" or demonic, which doesn't mesh with how I see Crane's character –- as an emotionally detached intellectual who took his research way too far.
said at 10:31 PM on Tue Feb 10 2015
 8 Shout Outs!
1. Currently Unknown (John Noble?): Yeah, he's not listed here at the moment. Yet, just going off of the Arkham Knight trailers alone I can already place this guy as my favorite. The way he delivered his "How many more bones will you crush? How many lives will you destroy in pursuit of what you call justice?" speech was absolutely perfect, and I love how his voice is equal parts gravely, menacing, raspy, and intellectual. I can tell that when Arkham Knight releases, I'm going to love this guy.

2. Dino Andrade: Out of the many great performances put on in the Arkham series, Dino's is among my favorites from Asylum. His slimy, high pitched voice never fails to send shivers down my spine, and the added filter enhances the creepy factor rather than takes away from it. He did good at making Scarecrow a fearsome adversary, and while I do like John Noble(?) even better, I'm still a bit sad that Dino isn't reprising his role.

3. Dee Bradley Baker: Dee's is another fantastic take, I can see him doing fantastic as Scarecrow in a more serious adaptation since his voice is fantastically quiet yet fearsome.

4. Corey Burton: The effects added to his voice make him a bit hard to understand at times, but I like it nonetheless, mainly because this is the way I picture Scarecrow sounding whenever the person listening to him is under the influence of fear gas. The demonic reverberation added to his hoarse and rough voice make him sound absolutely nightmarish.

5. Cillian Murphy: He's not my favorite take on Jonathon Crane, but Cillian was good nonetheless. I like that he has more of a sleazy, slimy tone that is laced with a hint of subdued menace, it's very fitting for the movie's amoral scumbag version of the Scarecrow.

6. Henry Pollic II: I'm not too big on either him or Combs, but I do prefer him at the end of the day. I don't know if I consider him scary, but the deep voice and arrogant tone are pretty fun to listen to. His performance isn't one of the DCAU's best, but it's still a good one regardless.

7. Christopher S. Field: His delivery sounds a bit off, but I feel that he has a ton of potential to sound great. His tone while inconsistent does sound genuinely intimidating at times, and the gruffness of his tone reminds me almost of a slasher movie villain.

8. Don Messick: I kind of wish that Don had more material, because his Scarecrow I feel is actually pretty decent for an earlier adaptation. Not that it's perfect mind you, but I like that whispery tone he used.

9. Jeffery Combs: I hate to say it, but I agree with the user who finds Jeffery incredibly overrated. He sounds a bit creepy during the clip used on this site, but outside of a few lines he sounds absolutely boring and lifeless.

10. Ted Knight and Andre Stojka: I feel Andre edges Ted out, but neither are all that good. Especially Ted who sounds incredibly screechy and way too high pitched.

I personally want to hear Robert Englund take on the role some day. It's a bit of an easy casting choice to make, but he'd make it suitably creepy and sinister.
said at 8:07 AM on Sat Jan 10 2015
Is it me or does the clip from DCUO remind me of the Dr. Destiny arc from Sandman (those who read ti might know what I'm talking about)?
said at 9:47 AM on Wed Jan 7 2015
 4 Shout Outs!
I'm not sure if that really is John Noble as Scarecrow in Arkham Knight. But whoever it is, once they are added, they get my vote.
It is, to a "t" what I've always imagined Scarecrow sounding like.
said at 8:52 PM on Mon Dec 29 2014
Who is playing Crane in Arkham Knight? I know it's not Dino Andrade.
said at 9:21 PM on Mon Dec 29 2014
@allthingsuper I'm pretty sure it's John Noble.
said at 10:55 PM on Sat Dec 27 2014
 8 Shout Outs!
So, a couple of months ago I finally watched the episode of TNBA with Jeffrey Combs in it... and to be honest, I found him incredibly dry and boring. I don't see how he's so scary, AT ALL. The only scene in the entire episode where I thought he sounded kinda creepy and intimidating was the part in this clip, and even then, it didn't do much for me. In the other scenes where he wasn't in a position of power over Batman and trying to psychologically toy with him he sounded even more bland. When Robin and Batman were foiling his plans and he needed to express more desperation and emotion... he fell flat. His take was a real downgrade in comparison to Henry Polic II, IMO. Henry wasn't very scary, but at least his performance was passionate and emotive and helped make Scarecrow an interesting character.

Sorry, I hope I don't sound like a jerk. I loved Jeffrey as Ratchet and Question, and I think he could have been a lot better if the character hadn't been so stinking bland in that episode, but I had to say something after watching his whole performance.
Axem Red
said at 3:37 PM on Sun Oct 12 2014
Corey Burton gets my vote!
said at 9:47 AM on Thu Oct 2 2014
 5 Shout Outs!
Armin Shimerman for Scarecrow?
said at 12:51 PM on Tue Jun 17 2014
 3 Shout Outs!
1: Dino Andrade- Holy hell was this guy just absolutely terrifying in every way. The effects on his voice in the dream sequences really hammer home the point that you're in an insane fantasy, and his true natural voice for the character sounds like he's truly enjoying his work, albeit still capturing Crane's wimpy persona under the surface. Without a doubt the best voice actor to come out of the Arkham series, it's a shame he won't be returning to the role.
2-: Corey Burton: I'm kinda conflicted ranking him above Jeffrey Combs, but in the end, he captures the insanity and frightening persona of the character a little more.
3-: Jeffrey Combs: A very spooky version of the character he pulled off well that goes perfectly with the new design. Very chilling and subdued while still making Crane sound like he's the one in control. So yes, a very intimidating voice for the role.
4-: Henry Polic: A fine take on the character that works well. Over confident yet wimpy sounding, and I found the British accent to be a nice touch that worked well.
5-: Cillian Murphy: The effects are cool, and while I enjoy him for what little screen time he had in the films, the guy just sounds too young to make it entirely believable.
6-: Dee Bradley Baker: He plays Scarecrow more tongue in cheek, but he works well for his version. I think he could do even better in a more serious portrayal.
7: Christopher S Field: Not bad in the slightest, and he sounds fitting enough. I just think the delivery was a little off, and he didn't capture the intimidating nature enough.
8-: Don Messick: His take hasn't aged well, but I still sense that he could've done a pretty bang up job with that whispery voice, if he deepened up a bit.
9-: Ted Knight and Andre Stojka: Don't fit the role in the slightest.
said at 8:24 PM on Mon Jun 9 2014
 1 Shout Out!
Well then, it appears that Dino Andrade has been recasted for Batman: Arkham Knight, going by the E3 footage. It's a real shame, as I thought he was a perfect fit, but the new VA isn't bad. The significantly deeper voice compared to Dino's does fit the new design well, and while I find the change jarring, I'm sure I'll get used to it eventually.
said at 2:40 PM on Wed Jun 11 2014
@chaosincarnate And now it appears that John Noble is Scarecrow's new VA in Arkham Knight... that's a damn good casting choice, I have to say.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 2:47 PM on Wed Jun 11 2014
@chaosincarnate Has there been proof of that
said at 2:55 PM on Wed Jun 11 2014
@Music Meister Well, since my only real sites to provide crecedence are IMDB and Wikipedia... at the moment, no. But hearing him in the E3 footage is a dead ringer for him, I'm almost positive.
said at 1:44 PM on Tue Sep 2 2014
@chaosincarnate - The new voice is good, but I'm still a bit startled by him sounding completely different than he did in Asylum
said at 12:37 PM on Tue May 27 2014
 5 Shout Outs!
Robert Englund, Tobin Bell, and Brian Drummond are my ideal Scarecrow voices.
said at 12:46 PM on Tue May 27 2014
@pete Oh and Peter Macnicol.
said at 11:06 AM on Tue May 6 2014
 1 Shout Out!
Dino is my favourite with my other favourites being Dee, Corey, Jeffrey and Christopher in that order.

Ted, Don & Andre are not scary, just annoying really.

Henry is decent as is Cillian.
said at 11:08 AM on Tue May 6 2014
I wonder who will be voicing Scarecrow in Arkham Knight. I would like Dino to reprise the role but I really doubt that.
Polyester Funk
said at 11:42 PM on Thu May 1 2014
 1 Shout Out!
I like Jeffrey Combs the best. His voice is so very eerie and I love the design Scarecrow had in that series. It was suitability eerie for the character and the voice. Dino sounds pretty good, but I've never played the game so my knowledge is limited.

Henry Polic II was pretty good and I think he sounds like Rene Auberjonois. Rewatching that series on the Hub I thought it was Rene.

I would like to hear Corey Burton take a crack at him without the effects added.
said at 5:19 PM on Sun Apr 20 2014
 2 Shout Outs!
You know there's one person I think would be both fitting as Johnathan Cranes normal voice, and a great scarecrow.

I know this would be a bit weird since he usually on guest stars on other Batman shows since he is most well known as a certain Clown, but I think Mark Hamill would be a pitch perfect Scarecrow when I think about it.

He has the right calm yet sinister tone which could fit Johnathan when he talks normally (Muska is a great example of this), and we all know he can do great creepy, and raspy voices which would fit the scarecrow just perfectly.
said at 5:25 PM on Mon Apr 7 2014
 3 Shout Outs!
Ted Knight sounds much more like he should've been the Joker using a voice like this than the Scarecrow. I mean it's a good voice, it's just completely unfitting for Scarecrow. 3/10 for a scarecrow voice, but a 6 out of 10 for being different.

Don sounds very fitting here but he has barely anything to go off of here which is very sad because his high pitched kind of sound could work very well if given more material. 6/10

Andre sounds...okay, it's nothing spectacular but I just think it sounds bizarre and, some of his delivery does feel a bit awkward. 4.5/10

Henry works extremely well with the role here, and sounds creepy, while it sounds weird hearing the scarecrow that deep it oddly works and didn't come off as a generic thug which I do like. RIP 7.5/10

Cilian sounds fantastic here, as he was in the film as well, though I do wish he was able to use this voice more in the film, but I'm happy to see him use it here, and is given a decent amount of dialogue. 7/10

Jeffrey...oh GOD Jeffrey how I love thee. Jeffrey is not only extremely fitting in the role, but is downright CHILLING. The voice matches the design perfectly, and is hands down one of Jeffry's best performances, if not his best. 9.5/10

Corey is bit too heavily vocally effected, and is a bit hard to understand at points, but he does sound good, but a bit too demonic with all those effects. and is it me or at a couple lines does he sounds like Dwight Schultz? 7.5/10

Dee was a natural choice for Scarecrow in Brave and the Bold, and he works very well with the role, being much more quiet and reserved in the role, but the rasp he adds to the role works very well, and the vocal effects add this fantastic creep factor to the performance. 8.5/10

Dino...oh Dino...I never understood. I really never did. this is a role that everyone adores in the Arkham games, but to be honest, is probably one the most overrated supervillain performance I've ever seen. I never thought it sounded that fitting, it sounds way too young, the vocal effects don't sound all that good, and to be honest, from playing AA, he always sounded really bored in his portrayal. 5/10

Christopher sounds decent at first, but the further he goes, it starts to sound a bit awkward. He starts slwoly adding this rasp to his voice, which to be honest sounds a bit odd in general, not really what I picture when I see the scarecrow. It's a better performance than many of the other DCUO performances, but that's not saying much. 6/10

1. Jeffrey
2. Dee
3. Henry
4. Corey
5. Cilian
6. Don
7. Christopher
8. Dino
9. Andre
10. Ted
facundo guerra 4
said at 5:23 PM on Wed Jul 23 2014
@skeletonking1234 Did you already heard John Noble,if you did what do you think of him?
said at 4:44 PM on Tue Dec 24 2013
Dee Bradley Baker
Jeffrey Combs
Henry Polic II
Don Messick
said at 8:57 AM on Fri Oct 25 2013
 4 Shout Outs!
Dammit, I know Dino is perfect as the scarecrow, but.... Jeffrey is just so frigging terrifying in his role, I begin to doubt my own sanity.

....Yeah, I think I prefer Combs. Andrade comes a VERY close 2nd. Cillian and Corey would be my other choices.
said at 10:45 AM on Mon Oct 14 2013
 1 Shout Out!
I really liked Dee Bradley and Dino Andrade Scarecrow voices.

And of course, Cillian Murphy is the perfect live action Scarecrow.
said at 5:46 PM on Mon Oct 7 2013
 3 Shout Outs!
Dee Bradley Baker, Jeffrey Combs, Cillian Murphy, Dino Andrade, and Christopher S Field all nail this part. The rest of them just don't work.
said at 8:32 PM on Mon Jun 9 2014
@Galactic_Cyrus I'm curious as to what your issues with Corey Burton and Henry Polic are. I'm so used to seeing them held in such high regard, and while I disagree with you, your comment does feel like an admitted breath of fresh air.
said at 2:50 PM on Wed Dec 10 2014
@chaosincarnate Corey Burton is actually pretty good in the role now that I listen again. But Polic I just think was a miscast. He sounds way too stereotypically "professor-like" but not at all scary.
said at 10:18 AM on Tue Aug 27 2013
 2 Shout Outs!
Henry Polic II, you were the Master of Fear.
said at 8:46 PM on Wed Aug 14 2013
 5 Shout Outs!
RIP Henry Polic II.
said at 9:06 AM on Tue Jul 16 2013
 1 Shout Out!
Ted Knight: 3/10
Don Messick: 4.5/10
Andre Stojka: 4/10
Henry Polic II: 6/10
Cillian Murphy: 8/10
Jeffrey Combs: 10/10
Corey Burton: 9.5/10
Dee Bradley Baker: 8.5/10
Dino Andrade: 10/10
Christopher S Field: 7/10
Both Combs and Andrade are fantastic and creepy, I have to give my vote for Andrade, as I felt he had more range.
said at 9:04 PM on Mon Jun 17 2013
 4 Shout Outs!
I like Jeffrey combs best because he manages to sound creepy and chilling without having any added effects. The calm tone actually sounds MORE scary to me.
said at 3:40 PM on Sat Mar 23 2013
 2 Shout Outs!
Jeffrey and Dino FTW. I really wish in BGK they got a guy emulating Cillian Murphy instead of Corey Burton, but he still did a good job.
said at 11:18 AM on Sun Mar 3 2013
 5 Shout Outs!
I don't like how dry and nonchalant Jeffrey Combs sounded. Sometimes sounding nonchalant and dry works, but I don't think it does with this character and that voice. Dee Bradley Baker worked well too, my second favorite. However, I am indeed going with Dino Andrade.

I would like to see him reprise the role in the next Arkham game. I like how arrogant yet small he sounds in the interview tapes and how creepy he sounds when he's scarecrow and they throw the filters on.

I don't think he's perfect, at least not yet, but he is my favorite for the time being.
said at 3:38 PM on Thu Jan 10 2013
 1 Shout Out!
In my opinion, I would say that Dino Andrade is the best with Jeffrey Coombs as a very close second. Likewise, Dee Bradley Baker would be a very close third.
said at 3:55 PM on Tue Feb 26 2013
Please disregard the previous post, in the intervening month since I posted that comment, I have chosen instead to cast my vote for Mr. Jeffrey Coombs in lieu of Dino Andrade.
Nightmare Crusher
said at 12:49 PM on Thu Nov 22 2012
 2 Shout Outs!
Lot's of good choices here. I think I'll go with Dino Andrade with Dee Bradley Baker as a close second.
said at 9:00 PM on Sat Nov 17 2012
 3 Shout Outs!
I'm gonna go with Dino Andrade. He was pretty creepy in Arkham Asylum.
said at 8:56 AM on Mon Oct 29 2012
 3 Shout Outs!
I'm going to give this one to Dee Bradley Baker. He made the Scarecrow sound creepy and menacing . . . especially when he does that crackle.
said at 9:00 AM on Mon Jul 30 2012
 3 Shout Outs!
1. Dino Andrade - After hearing his performance in AA, I must say he did a very good job: his Scarecrow really crept me out especially with the voice modulator, and even sounded threatening too at some points.

2. Jeffery Combs - An interesting take, but very effective: sounds creepy and unpredictable. The reason he isn't my number one is because he sounds a little too soft and quiet making him seem less threatening as a villain.

3. Corey Burton - Granted of course it was a little too modulated but it still had a creepy feel to it, it still fits though.

4. Cillian Murphy - Another interesting take, he really nails that maniacal and threatening side of Scarecrow which is what he needs IMO.

Others I'm afraid don't fit the bill for Scarecrow personally.
said at 2:41 AM on Mon Jul 16 2012
 1 Shout Out!
Jeffery Combs has that sadistic, calm tone in his voice. THAT is scary.
said at 12:49 AM on Sat Jun 30 2012
 3 Shout Outs!
1 . Dino Andrade - Soft , creepy , raspy and yet wimpy . The perfect blend of Jeffrey and Cillian`s equally brilliant performances .
2 . Jeffrey Combs - Raspy , creepy , intellectual . The only real complaint I have is he sometimes spoke almost too softly to hear .
3 . Cillian Murphy - Brilliant , subdued and complex as Crane and a total maniac as Scarecrow . Of course , you can occasionally hear Cillian`s Irish origins subtly slip through when he emotes and his American accent sounds more New York ( Specifically Christopher Walken-style Queens ) than New England but as he`s portraying a Nolanized reimagining of Crane he may be a native Gothamite in this version so I`d hardly count that against him .
4 . Corey Burton - Basically Cillian`s performance in The Film with more of a New England/Mid-Western accent . Impressive if a bit overly modulated .
5 . Dee Bradley Baker - Creepy , raspy . Truly one of BTAB`s stand-out performances .
6 . Henry Polic II - Underrated performance , IMHO . His Crane was creepy when he needed to be while not forgetting what a coward at heart the man was . He also gave a very convincing New England intellectual accent .
7 . Christopher S. Feild - Pretty damn creepy if average overall .
8 . Andre Stojka - Probably the best of the older Scarecrow performances and the first to actually sound creepy rather than campy .
9 . Don Messick - Not bad though his attempt to sound creepy comes off as more campy . Still a valiant effort . But meh , I`ve seen better .
10 . Ted Knight - Okay , I know Crane`s supposed to be from New England and all but really ?
said at 1:56 AM on Fri May 4 2012
Dino Andrade Was just damn Scary, but terrific. Now if they Get John Kassir to voice him in the Arkham Sequel, That would magnificent.
said at 8:58 PM on Sun May 27 2012
@Mr.Fennoy93 I thot I was the ONLY one who thought John Kassir would be a GREAT Scarecrow!
said at 3:13 AM on Thu Jun 7 2012
It's a win win.
said at 1:21 PM on Sat Apr 21 2012
 1 Shout Out!
Jeffrey Combs is pretty much the perfect Scarecrow although it largely depends on how Scarecrow is being portrayed. If you want a genuinely creepy Scarecrow, Combs all the way. Subtle, not forced, but chilling. However if you want Scarecrow to be slightly ridiculous but obviously educated then I'd go with Henry Polic II.
said at 2:22 AM on Sat Jan 28 2012
 2 Shout Outs!
1. Jeffery Combs
2. Dino Andrade
3. Corey Burton
4. Henry Polic II
5. Dee Bradley Baker
6. Cillian Murphy
said at 12:00 AM on Mon Oct 24 2011
 1 Shout Out!
I'm giving this one to Jeffery Combs as I felt the raspy whisper was pretty creepy. That said, Dino Andrade, Henry Polic II, Corey Burton, Dee Bradley Baker, and Cillian Murphy were good, too.
said at 7:47 PM on Thu Sep 15 2011
 3 Shout Outs!
Ted Knight - ...
Don Messick - He's okay, I guess. But he's still definitely much better than... THAT...
Andre Stojka - I agree, he's definitely best of the classic voices. It is a bit high, but it's not bad.
Henry Polic II - Finally a deeper voice. And he does a great job too. Now's when we're getting to the good stuff...
Cillian Murphy - Very nice, especially for a movie-liscensed game.
Jeffrey Combs - I know most everybody likes him, but to me, it sounded more like he was just speaking quietly rather than being scary.
Corey Burton - HOLY CRAP THAT IS SCARY. Really good!
Dee Bradley Baker - Like poke said, this is a pleasant surprise. It's hard to imagine Dee doing a menacing voice... but here we are. XD
Dino Andrade - He does a great job of sounding both scary and meek when he needs to. Probably my favorite out of them.
Christopher S. Field - Eh...
Blue Paratroopa
said at 11:32 PM on Sun Aug 14 2011
 2 Shout Outs!
I'd say Jeffrey Coombs. His voice reminds us that despite the Scarecrow's frightening appearance, he's still a human behind the mask. That's important to remember.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 5:03 PM on Tue Aug 9 2011
 1 Shout Out!
Scarecrow is number three on my top 5 favorite Batman villains

Ted Knight's version was annoying, way too high for my taste.
Messick was pretty generic just nothing outstanding about it.
Stojka was, like what Pokejedservo said, best of the golden age voices. Is still a little high but not too high I guess.
I grew up with Henry Polic's version of Scarecrow and he does do a very good job. He gives Scarecrow a sinister and creepy sound to it and can easily show off his cowardly side.
Normally actors in video games are pretty bad (Toby from SPiderman is a good example) so I was very surpirzed with Murphy's performance. A good creepy voice that fits the character very well.
Although I like Scarecrow's design in Gothan Knights I thought Combs wasn't so perfect in the role. Don't get me wrong, he does a good sinister and intellgent voice but not all that creepy. I just think he could have been a little better.
I know it wasn't 100% Burton on the voice but wow was it scarey. I know it was Batman under his scare gas so it was suppose to sound disfigured but still a nice creepy voice.
Now I know Dee Bradley Baker is a man of many voices but damn was this unexpected. Creepy and a nice touch of voice modulator (or whatever it's called). A nice unexpected change for Baker.
Dino Andrade is the winner. Terrorfying, sinister, good amount of voice modulator, can go to a cowardly and sound threatening. A great example of the voice work in the game.
Christopher S Field is...well pretty generic. Nothing really standing out in it. However his delivery of the lines are outstanding, so he gets a pass just for that.
So my ranking is
1. Dino Andrade
2. Cillian Murphy
3. Henry Polic
4. Corey Burton
5. Dee Baker
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 2:01 PM on Sun Aug 14 2011
@Music Meister On second thought I switch Burton and Polic
said at 7:31 AM on Sat Jul 23 2011
Combs for sure? Effortlessly creepy.
said at 11:29 PM on Fri Jul 22 2011
Jeffery all the way!
said at 1:31 PM on Thu Jul 21 2011
 2 Shout Outs!
Jeffery Combs, it's a shame Scarecrow didn't appear more in that series/season
said at 4:02 PM on Wed Jul 20 2011
I'm not a big fan of the Batman Begins film, and I'm not usually a sucker for big screen actors performances in video games, but I think Cillian Murphy gives such a unique sound to the Scarecrow. That makes him the first batman character voice that, in my eyes, surpasses the Batman: TAS voice.
said at 2:17 AM on Wed Jul 20 2011
Dino Andrade for me. Managed to sound both like the wimp Crane is, and the creepiness he wants to emit as the Scarecrow. Cillian Murphy in second.
Faved by 26 BTVA Members

6th Annual BTVA Voice Acting Awards 2016
Who do you think has been the best from these Scarecrow voice actors?
Ted Knight
Don Messick
Andre Stojka
Henry Polic II
Cillian Murphy
Jeffrey Combs
Corey Burton
Dee Bradley Baker
Dino Andrade
Christopher S Field
John Noble
Brian T Delaney
Brian Silva
Robert Englund
Jason Mantzoukas