3rd Annual BTVA Anime Awards

Voice Compare » Batman » Mad Hatter

Comparision of the voice over actors who have been the voice of Mad Hatter with sound clips and images.

Created by Pokejedservo on Sun Jan 30 2011, 39 Comments, Add Comment
Special thanks to Cypo, Music Meister for additional sound clips.
Batman with Robin the Boy Wonder (1968)
Mad Hatter / Jervis TetchTed Knight
Ted Knight
Batman: The Animated Series (1992)
Mad Hatter / Jervis TetchRoddy McDowall
Roddy McDowall
Batman: Arkham City (2011)
Mad Hatter / Jervis TetchPeter MacNicol
Peter MacNicol
DC Universe Online (2011)
Mad HatterMatt Hislope
Matt Hislope


In this Batman VC we have another member of Batman's Rogues Gallery and this time its for this Alice in Wonderland-themed villain generally known as Jervis Tetch... THE MAD HATTER! In the late 60's the Mad Hatter had his VA debut in Batman with Robin the Boy Wonder in which he was voiced by the late Ted Knight. Unlike the 2nd clip that we will go over later this take on the Mad Hatter is a simple good old fashioned silly comic book villain with a gimmicky theme. Is this take on the Mad Hatter a generic gimmicky comic book super-villain? Perhaps but Ted Knight's performance does help ensure that this take on the Mad Hatter does suit this show's light-hearten nature.

In the Batman Animated Series (and the DCAU) the Mad Hatter was voiced by the also late Roddy McDowall in which this take on the Mad Hatter is another example of why Paul Dini is known for making sympathetic villains. Granted the Mad Hatter did become a bit more of a conventional villain later on in his appearances in the DCAU but in his debut he was a fine example of a sympathetic antagonist in which Roddy's performance definitely captured the Mad Hatter's persona in the DCAU quite well. Roddy's performance worked very well for the Mad Hatter as it has a good sense of sympathetic shyness to increasing insanity in which to be honest I always found it to be one of my favorite performances from Roddy and it is another fine example of the voice work in the DCAU. Overall while Ted Knight's performance does work for the more simplistic take on the Mad Hatter but I am clearly going with Roddy McDowall here.


Latest Comments

Add a Comment

said at 5:38 AM on Thu Mar 5 2015
1) Roddy McDowall
2) Ted Knight
3) Peter MacNicol
4) Matt Hislope
said at 3:34 PM on Mon Oct 20 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Alan Tudyk should voice the Mad Hatter in Batman: Arkham Knight.
Axem Red
said at 11:55 AM on Tue Nov 4 2014
@Slick Yes!
said at 5:21 PM on Wed Oct 15 2014
This might sound ironic, but I bet Mark Hamill would be great as the Mad Hatter!
said at 2:30 PM on Thu Sep 11 2014
I bet Keith Ferguson, Chris Edgerly and Corey Burton would be great successors for Roddy McDowall!
said at 1:49 AM on Wed May 7 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
1. Peter MacNicol/Roddy McDowall: Both performances are quite different, yet they're both so good that I can't really say one is better than the other! Roddy is ridiculously passionate and all around fun to listen to, a great performance from an awesome actor in a superb cartoon! Roddy's Hatter is a better fit for a more traditional take on him! However, I also loved Peter as he was ridiculously creepy and really captured the feel of a guy consumed with an obsession with a book to the point of insanity. The way he channels Lewis Carol's Mad Hatter in the way he acts and speaks, the horrified anguish and sorrow he shows in Dr. Strange's interview tapes... he's just all around great for a much darker, twisted take on the Hatter. Both get a 9 respectively, both sound awesome for their different takes on the character.

2. Ted Knight: There's not a whole lot that can be said. He lacks the energy of Roddy and the eccentricity of Peter, but he's not bad either. He's just more of a generic silly villain with this performance, so I think it's fair that he gets a 5/10.

3. Matt Hislope: Eesh... I really can't say anything about this performance that's good. His delivery sounds forced beyond belief, and it's done quite awkwardly too. Really, it's just not good at all and I have to give it a 3/10.
said at 3:45 AM on Mon Mar 17 2014
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Going with Peter MacNicol, particularly for Arkham Origins.

"Blast you, Mr Wilson! Would you leave some for the party?!"
said at 3:26 PM on Tue Mar 11 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Ted Knight- Ted sounds fitting for the mood and time period of when the show was made, but it's just a below average performance when looking at it nowadays that doesn't leave all that much of an impact. 3.5/10

Roddy McDowall- Being one of the best actors ever IMO, and he definitely shows it here. He has the emotional energy when playing the role and when he gets mad he legitimately sounds mad, and he's just as good at sounding evil and mean as he is sounding emotional as he shows before he becomes the Mad Hatter, and at the end of the episode when he is captured, and its not only one of Batman TAS best performances, it's one of Roddy's greatest. R.I.P. 9.5/10

Peter MacNicol- Peter is going for much more of the mentally unstable Hatter, which acts somewhat like a little more stable version of the Joker, and MacNicol like many other roles, does fantastically here. Peters high pitched voice works very well in the role and he gets the unstableness of the hatter down very well and the creepy lines come out very creepy with his voice. 9/10

Matt Hislope- Do I even need to say anything about this performance? Hislope sounds completely unfitting in the role. He sounds excited yet extremely bored at the exact same time, and his line delivery is just awkward at a lot of points. And as some people have said, he does sound like he would've fit the Joker better in that game than the Hatter. 3/10

1. Roddy
2. Peter
3. Ted
4. Matt
said at 11:39 AM on Sun Feb 2 2014
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Tom Kenny for Mad Hatter
said at 7:31 AM on Sun Oct 26 2014
Maybe. I'm not sure which voice he should use for that character.
said at 6:50 AM on Tue Jan 7 2014
 3 Shout Outs! [?]
I wonder if Alan Tudyk would make a good Mad Hatter?
said at 7:12 AM on Sun Aug 31 2014
He would! It would be quite coincidental, because Alan Tudyk voices King Candy who bears a striking resemblance to Disney's Mad Hatter!
said at 1:57 PM on Wed Jan 1 2014
Matt Hislope's pretty bad... He sounds too goofy and like everyone has said, it'd be better for the Riddler. Sticking with Roddy McDowall.
said at 12:01 PM on Wed Jan 1 2014
It's pretty obvious by the fact he starts with a riddle(and even sounding a bit Jim Carrey ish) that he'd be better for Riddler, so my thoughts on him are the same as others below.
said at 9:25 AM on Wed Jan 1 2014
 3 Shout Outs! [?]
Matt sounds like he'd be better at voicing Riddler than Hatter. My vote stays with Peter.
said at 7:12 AM on Wed Jan 1 2014
 5 Shout Outs! [?]
I think Matt did terrible.
said at 7:02 AM on Wed Jan 1 2014
 4 Shout Outs! [?]
Peter for sure, but Roddy was great as well. Ted Knight was pretty good too, but I think Matt's voice would suit the Riddler more.
said at 3:44 PM on Tue Dec 24 2013
Roddy Mdowall was amazing as Mad Hatter
said at 3:45 PM on Tue Dec 24 2013
@Archerboy58 i mean Mcdowall
said at 5:25 PM on Wed Oct 15 2014
He was. May he rest in peace. I bet Keith Ferguson, Chris Edgerly and Corey Burton would be perfect successors.
said at 10:04 AM on Thu Nov 28 2013
Peter wins this one for sounding the most creepy and making the Mad Hatter sound distinctive. Roddy was also good, while Ted isn't anything special.
said at 8:37 AM on Sun Nov 17 2013
Peter really makes the role as he makes Hatter sound as crazy as he should be.

Roddy was pretty good by making an intelligent version of Hatter.

Ted wasn't so great.
said at 4:39 PM on Mon Oct 7 2013
 5 Shout Outs! [?]
Roddy McDowell really made this character an interesting and entertaining member of Batman's rogue gallery. Peter MacNicol does a perfect job too: very creepy and deranged. Ted Knight...generic and forgettable.
said at 6:21 PM on Sat Sep 14 2013
I'm going with Roddy McDowell. Peter MacNicol is good too.
said at 5:23 PM on Wed Oct 15 2014
Don't you think Keith Ferguson, Chris Edgerly and Corey Burton Will be good successors for Roddy McDowell?
said at 1:33 PM on Mon Jul 22 2013
 1 Shout Out! [?]
I like Roddy McDowall the best. He gave a great performance, but I actually thought Hatter's story in TAS was a little melodramatic and corny. Peter MacNicol is perfect for making him sound creepy though. I would have liked Roddy McDowall even better if he got a chance to be full-blown creepy and psychotic, but instead he was more of just a "misunderstood awkward guy" who had an unrequited crush (and an obsession with a book), and it didn't allow him to be as psychotic and funny as he could have been.
said at 6:49 PM on Mon May 27 2013
 2 Shout Outs! [?]
Ted is very forgettable villain performance in my mind and almost nothing really sticks out about it.

Roddy Mcdowall is one of my favorite actors as with Peter Macnicol and both make the character a delusional lunatic but make him sympathetic at some points but I feel Macnicol did it a little better and that high pitched voice fits Mad Hatters personality a little more.
said at 9:14 AM on Tue Jul 31 2012
 1 Shout Out! [?]
The thing about Roddy is that he's playing a very different Hatter from the comics. It's a much more sympathetic take, and Roddy absolutely rocks it. Both "Mad as a Hatter" and "Perchance to Dream" have insanely great acting from him. He's still good in Hatter's later episodes (there are a couple priceless bits in "Knight Time" and "Over the Edge"), but the humanity had been drained from the character by then.

Peter, by contrast, is playing a much creepier Hatter closer to the comics; you definitely get more of a "child molester" vibe from him, and he does that excellently.
said at 6:33 AM on Fri Sep 28 2012

I totally agree with you a 100%, Roddy captured the humanity of the Hatter portrayed in the early BTAS. Which ended up being my favorite depiction of him through the series. I had issues with half the villain character development in Season Three of BTAS. Even Bruce seemed to fall flat at times. Maybe it's just me but there has to be a bit of humanity in each villain to relate or even like the character.

Now Peter MacNicol really got that "Holy ****" this guy is a creeper Mad Hatter aspect. The total this guy is a crazy pedo-bear! Which I like too. :P I like both depictions of the Mad Hatter maybe one day they can somehow intertwine both. Though Peter does and excellent job and should continue portraying him.
said at 10:22 AM on Fri Jul 27 2012
roddy and peter.
said at 12:09 PM on Sat Apr 21 2012
Roddy McDowall was able to cover the all the different sides of Hatter from Jervis to his costumed persona. MacNicol was good but can only really do the creepy side. And unfortunately his voice gets a tiny bit irritating.
said at 9:39 AM on Fri Mar 9 2012
Roddy McDowall
said at 5:22 PM on Wed Oct 15 2014
Keith Ferguson, Chris Edgerly and Corey would be good successors.
Music Meister (Moderator)
said at 3:45 PM on Tue Jan 17 2012
I feel, given the character's bio, needs a creepy element which Peter delivers. Roddy was better in Gotham Knights where he was a little creepy. Ted is fine just not very rememberable
said at 11:33 PM on Sun Oct 23 2011
I'm gonna give this one to Peter MacNicol as I felt his Mad Hatter was really creepy. Roddy McDowall was good, too, but I just think MacNicol was creepier.
said at 6:10 PM on Thu Jan 19 2012
@Anicomicgeek Actually, considering the events. Why not say that Peter MacNicol does a good job of honoring Roddy McDowall's memory? It satisfies both aspects.
said at 3:50 PM on Sat Oct 22 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Peter MacNiol's Doc Ock voice fits Mad Hatter more. Makes him sound just creepy and is great replacement for Mcdowall.
said at 9:34 PM on Wed May 15 2013
@pete Oh and to clarify I mean it's Mad Hatter WAY more than it suits Doc Ock.
Blue Paratroopa
said at 11:40 PM on Sun Aug 14 2011
 1 Shout Out! [?]
Anyone else think Ted Knight sounds A LOT like Jim Backus?

A favorite Voice Compare
for 7 members.
Latest Reason:

"Underrated villain and a favorite of mine!"

- NoxiousSludge
Who do you think has been the best from these Mad Hatter voice actors?
Ted Knight
Roddy McDowall
Peter MacNicol
Matt Hislope